TALAKAYAN PARA SA BAYAN (Culex Soliman at Patrick Aguirre): PAGKAKATALAGA KINA GIBO AT HERBOSA
Video Transcript / Subtitles:
About AI Subtitles »
* AI ("Artificial Intelligence") subtitles on Tagalog.com are generated using "Whisper" by OpenAI (the same company that created ChatGPT and DallE2). Results and accuracy may vary.
* The subtitles do include errors occasionally and should only be used as a tool to help with your listening practice.
* You can request this website to create a transcript for a video if one doesn't already exist by clicking the "Request AI Subtitles" button below a video. Transcribing usually takes 30-40% of the length of a video to complete if there are no other videos in
the queue. For example, a 21 minute video will take 7-8 minutes to transcribe.
* Running a super fast cloud GPU server to do these transcriptions does cost money. If you have the desire and financial ability, consider
becoming a patron
to support these video transcriptions, and the other tools and apps built by Tagalog.com
00:00.0
PLEASE SUBSCRIBE, LIKE, COMMENT, SHARE at SHARE this video with your friends.
00:30.0
PLEASE SUBSCRIBE, LIKE, COMMENT, SHARE at SHARE this video with your friends.
01:00.0
PLEASE SUBSCRIBE, LIKE, COMMENT, SHARE at SHARE this video with your friends.
01:20.0
PLEASE SUBSCRIBE, LIKE, COMMENT, SHARE at SHARE this video with your friends.
01:50.0
Thank you Patrick. So this will be our topic in our discussion with Patrick, my fellow countrymen.
02:00.0
We will talk about the reaction of Patrick as a young man in his appointment as Secretary of the Department of National Defense.
02:15.0
Second, what is Patrick's reaction as a young man in his appointment as Dr. Ted Herbosa in the Department of Health.
02:29.0
So we will remember, as a background, my fellow countrymen. This Department of Health has not had a secretary for a long time.
02:40.0
This is just OIC, Dr. Belgeri. That was during the time of Duque during COVID.
02:48.0
So for a long time, Marcos Jr. has been appointed as the Secretary of the Department of Health.
02:58.0
Now, he appointed Ted Herbosa. There are many issues with Ted Herbosa.
03:07.0
In the Department of National Defense, it's the same. It happened that they appointed, I think, Galvez, right?
03:17.0
The replacement of Chudoro. Chudoro ran last election. But of course, you will wait for a year.
03:26.0
If you are a politician or a candidate, you ran last election. Before you are appointed, you will wait for a year.
03:33.0
After a year, he was appointed to the Department of National Defense under Marcos Jr.
03:43.0
This is Gilbo Chudoro. We know him. He ran during the time of Gloria, the opponent of Pinoy. He also ran as president.
03:52.0
That's Gilbert Gilbo Chudoro. Now, what are the issues that are involved in these two appointments of Marcos?
04:03.0
By the way, before we start, let's greet the viewers, Patrick. Mila B. Anino, good evening Atty. Enzo Salat ng Kabunyog. Thank you.
04:16.0
Viewers, just comment and we will read your comments.
04:22.0
For Enzo Recto, let me check. We will greet the viewers of Enzo Recto.
04:31.0
Good evening Atty. Enzo Salat ng Kabunyog. Edgar A. Santojo.
04:36.0
Temporarily, Kulex Suleiman will be Atty. Enzo's reliever because there's a very important walk of our chairman of Kabunyog.
04:45.0
Christopher Villan, wow, a new haircut of my idol, Kulex. Good evening. Am I handsome? Thank you.
04:54.0
Anyway, I will greet you later. Let's start with Patrick Gilbo Chudoro.
05:03.0
We know that Gilbo Chudoro is highly educated. He was a former congressman, a man of Gloria Arroyo who ran as president.
05:16.0
Now he was appointed to the Department of National Defense. He was asked, because you're a student Patrick,
05:24.0
he was asked if he's in favor of returning the UP DND Accord. What is that?
05:32.0
That is the agreement of the University of the Philippines and the Department of National Defense,
05:37.0
wherein the police and military should not be allowed inside the UP campus without the permission of the school.
05:45.0
That agreement was removed during the time of Duterte, during the time of DND Secretary Lorenzana.
05:57.0
That means anytime, the police and military can enter the UP.
06:03.0
So Patrick, what is your reaction to what Gilberto Chudoro is saying that he's not in favor of renewing the UP DND Accord as a student?
06:16.0
That's right, Secretary. First of all, our stand as a student, especially here in UP Los Banos,
06:24.0
during the last administration, it was not allowed, actually, correct me if I'm mistaken, 15 meters distance along the campus.
06:37.0
So the police and military are really prohibited inside the University of the Philippines.
06:47.0
Our stand there, as a young person who is in charge, is in charge in a way that the freedom of speech inside the university
07:01.0
cannot be mixed, maybe fear and anxiety can be mixed between the police and the youth,
07:07.0
especially the UP, actually, the UP has become a common hot spot,
07:13.0
a hot spot ground for many policemen who are protesting and fighting for the country.
07:23.0
So the only thing I can say about this issue, if the policemen are allowed to enter the university,
07:33.0
the fear and anxiety will be mixed between the students and not just the students,
07:41.0
but also the people who are inside the university.
07:48.0
Because to be honest, there is no sense for them to be allowed to enter,
07:56.0
the policemen are allowed to enter, not just the students or the people who are wearing high-caliber guns.
08:07.0
So this is worrying in a way, but at the same time, the freedom of speech or the freedom of speech of the youth,
08:19.0
that is our safe place to express our feelings of being safe,
08:27.0
but at the same time, we are not afraid of ourselves, if we allow our policemen to enter,
08:34.0
the fear and anxiety will be mixed, that's all.
08:46.0
We are not afraid of ourselves,
08:49.0
if we allow our policemen to enter, the fear and anxiety will be mixed, that's all.
08:57.0
Okay. Thank you very much Patrick. I don't know why there's a delay on my laptop.
09:04.0
Yes, because we have seen the scrapping of the UP DND Accord,
09:13.0
because of the police of Duterte during the time of Lorenzana, right Patrick?
09:23.0
As a student, if you're not free,
09:27.0
it's because of such a simple thing that students are threatened if there are police and military there.
09:34.0
Of course, all the suspects, let's say it directly, they did it because they are Duterte,
09:42.0
all of them are suspects of being NPA, rebel.
09:46.0
If it's critical to the government, NPA, rebel. It's always like that.
09:52.0
And that's the anti-terror law. You Patrick, the anti-terror law.
10:00.0
It's clear that when we are conducting protests inside our universities,
10:08.0
we are holding our placards.
10:11.0
We are holding placards and a megaphone or microphone that will serve as our voice.
10:20.0
The placards will serve as our call.
10:24.0
So, what's wrong with this?
10:26.0
Why can't we hold our placards?
10:32.0
What we want to say is, we just want to shout our calls so that our democratic people can have a voice.
10:42.0
As a young person, it's really worrisome if the police are allowed to enter the university.
10:50.0
So, aside from causing fear to the youth,
10:55.0
I think this will also increase the freedom when it comes to free speech.
11:12.0
I think this will increase the freedom when it comes to free speech.
11:26.0
Okay. Thank you Patrick.
11:30.0
That's the problem with the Duterte administration.
11:36.0
He's not going to allow it.
11:40.0
I don't know. He also said, because there's a law in the Congress and the Senate,
11:46.0
he's urging to return the UP DND Accord so that the schools will be free, especially the UP.
11:56.0
But that's not in favor of Duterte.
12:01.0
Do you think Patrick, because this is his premise, if he's the Secretary of National Defense,
12:10.0
he's not in favor of the resumption of peace talks.
12:20.0
He doesn't want that.
12:22.0
Because it's national security, it's one of the problems of the Philippines.
12:27.0
We want the rebellion to be solved.
12:32.0
We want it to end.
12:34.0
I hope the Filipinos will stop rebelling.
12:38.0
They're holding arms.
12:40.0
But Gilbert Chidoro is not in favor of the resumption of peace talks.
12:48.0
As a youth, what is your reaction to that?
12:52.0
Thank you for the question.
12:54.0
Actually, that's one of the hot topics of discussion right now.
12:59.0
Our stand as a youth, we are always looking forward when it comes to peace talks.
13:05.0
In our opinion, that's the answer to the root of the problem of the system.
13:15.0
The peace talks, in our opinion, need to be continued or started.
13:23.0
That way, there will be a solution to all the problems.
13:29.0
There will be talks between the revolutionaries until now,
13:37.0
between the CPPN, NDF, NPA, between the government and the NPA or the communists.
13:47.0
In our opinion, what Gilbert Chidoro is saying is that terrorism cannot be resolved
13:55.0
if it disagrees with the peace talks.
13:59.0
That's what we see.
14:05.0
That's what we see as the answer to the root of the problem of the system.
14:10.0
If a DND secretary disagrees with that, it's very sad.
14:18.0
Aside from the risky life of the youth, the activists,
14:27.0
or the youth who are shouting their calls,
14:31.0
those who are holding placards and calling themselves terrorists,
14:37.0
and in the end, they can still use force.
14:40.0
So, our side as a youth, I consider myself as an activist
14:47.0
because we are not terrorists, we are not holding arms.
14:53.0
We are not holding arms because we are holding placards and a microphone.
15:03.0
It will be a thing for us to shout inside for the government.
15:13.0
So, at a story short, or at least saying short,
15:16.0
what we see there is very sad and angry
15:21.0
that the mind of a DND secretary is not open to this issue of peace talks
15:27.0
that will bring true peace to our country.
15:32.0
So, the peace talks need to be continued through the government
15:36.0
and through armed groups.
15:38.0
That way, that's what we see as the solution to the problem of the system.
15:44.0
So, if Dbo will not disagree, it will be very sad
15:47.0
because the government will be forced to act.
15:57.0
So, the peace talks need to be continued through the government
16:01.0
and through armed groups.
16:04.0
That way, that's what we see as the solution to the problem of the system.
16:11.0
So, if Dbo will not disagree, it will be very sad
16:14.0
because the government will be forced to act.
16:20.0
Okay. What you said is good Patrick.
16:23.0
I just don't know if I have a delay here or not.
16:27.0
Anyway, that's right.
16:29.0
That's why they are saying to us in Boniog, you are NPA, you are rebels.
16:37.0
This is precisely our point.
16:40.0
We in Boniog, we don't want a rebellion.
16:44.0
We don't want people to rebel.
16:48.0
But we always say in Boniog, we root out, why are people rebelling?
16:55.0
That's always the question.
16:57.0
What is the reason?
16:59.0
Why are there people who are angry with the government?
17:04.0
We can see that the system is really corrupt.
17:08.0
And you, young people, they are saying that you are always the target.
17:14.0
They say you are brainwashed.
17:16.0
They say you are brainwashed to rebel.
17:19.0
Do you believe that Patrick?
17:21.0
That's why you are rebelling because you are brainwashed?
17:24.0
You know, that's one of the saddest things.
17:29.0
As a young person, that's the saddest thing we hear from those who are older than us.
17:36.0
And usually, from people who are not aware of the reality and the system of our society.
17:41.0
So, it's clear to us that that's why we are fighting, or going to the streets,
17:50.0
to try to call for the help of the government.
17:57.0
So that they can listen.
18:01.0
Because in this time, that's what we believe is the most crucial.
18:07.0
There is no longer a system of our society.
18:10.0
So, if we look at how biased our government is,
18:20.0
we can see that as a young person, we are going to the streets to fight
18:26.0
to call for the help of the government.
18:30.0
So that those who are older than us can listen to us
18:34.0
and understand what the problem is that we are trying to solve.
18:39.0
So, that's saddening to us.
18:42.0
We will be told that we are terrorists, communists,
18:48.0
or that we are the ones who are confronting the armed groups.
18:54.0
That's why we will be confronted or rented as being brainwashed,
19:00.0
or whatever else.
19:03.0
That's what is saddening to us, or to people like us who are young.
19:10.0
Usually, that's why we are fighting and going to the streets to call for the help of the government.
19:18.0
So that we can listen to the issues that need to be resolved
19:22.0
and the government should pay attention or give clarity.
19:27.0
So, that's saddening.
19:33.0
Okay, thank you Patrick.
19:35.0
Yes, as you can see,
19:37.0
from a young person, they say that they are not being brainwashed.
19:42.0
People can see the corruption of the system, the advantages, the disadvantages,
19:49.0
the extreme poverty.
19:51.0
Usually, young people learn that in school,
19:55.0
especially when they are studying in schools like UP or PUP.
20:01.0
They can see the truth in society.
20:05.0
That is the fruit of their education, not because they are being brainwashed.
20:11.0
That's why, Patrick, that's why the UP DND Accord is being taught.
20:18.0
Because the government is always saying that NPAs and activists are being brainwashed,
20:25.0
those who are in UP, those who are being brainwashed.
20:29.0
Which is, why would you blame those who are being brainwashed?
20:33.0
For example, those who are being brainwashed are being convinced.
20:38.0
Why would you ask that?
20:40.0
Is it because someone is being convinced or because of the reality of society?
20:45.0
Yes, and young people feel the lack and the incompetence of the government
20:54.0
that instead of resolving the problems of the system,
20:58.0
they remain trapped and there is no justice in the law.
21:04.0
Yes, that's right.
21:06.0
That is what we are saying.
21:10.0
You, young people, who are being brainwashed,
21:15.0
you are not the ones who are being brainwashed, not because you are being brainwashed.
21:22.0
But they see the truth, they are being brainwashed and they feel sad.
21:28.0
They even held arms.
21:32.0
Even though we are dead, we are sad that this is what is happening.
21:36.0
But we are trying to understand the roots.
21:39.0
And the rebellion, it will not be achieved by force.
21:44.0
It will be stopped by force, by killing Filipinos and fellow Filipinos.
21:50.0
But why don't we...
21:52.0
Just to be clear, just to be shared to you.
21:56.0
Most of me, I consider myself as an activist but not a terrorist.
22:02.0
So, as a young person who grew up in the reality of society,
22:08.0
I am not stupid to hold...
22:13.0
I am not like that.
22:15.0
So, my question is,
22:19.0
if you think about it, why are there people who are rebelling?
22:24.0
Why are there people who are forced to hold arms?
22:28.0
Or why are there people who are fighting the government and are forced to use force?
22:34.0
If you are a decent person and you are from the reality of society,
22:39.0
you will not look at them as rivals.
22:42.0
The CPPA and the NDF-NPA, you will not look at them in a way that they are rivals.
22:49.0
The answer to this will be the violence of the police.
22:54.0
But in a deep perspective, you will look at those people and why they are fighting.
23:01.0
So, meaning to say, what you said is right, Sek,
23:05.0
that as a Filipino with a deep perspective,
23:09.0
you always look at the four sides of a square, not just the top or the bottom,
23:14.0
but you are always neutral.
23:16.0
If you will notice, why are there people like that?
23:19.0
First of all, because of the lack of justice,
23:22.0
there are many who do not experience fair justice under the law
23:27.0
and those who are in power favor them.
23:34.0
Second, aside from the lack of justice,
23:38.0
there are people who continue to be oppressed by poverty.
23:44.0
There are people who continue to lose hope.
23:51.0
So, to cut my saying short,
23:56.0
if you are a deep Filipino and you are like the reality of society,
24:01.0
when it comes to neutrality,
24:03.0
in thinking like this, there is a question mark.
24:06.0
Shouldn't the government have compassion for the people,
24:11.0
so that the country will be peaceful?
24:13.0
Or maybe the government is the one who is oppressing the people
24:17.0
so that it will rise up and use force.
24:21.0
That's very good, Patrick.
24:23.0
What you said is very good.
24:26.0
Because we are talking here about Gibo Tsundoro
24:31.0
as the Department DND Secretary, National Security.
24:36.0
So, our problem with the rebellion is really touched by that.
24:40.0
What we are saying, we in Bunyog,
24:43.0
even though we do not agree with the unification and armament of our fellow Filipinos,
24:51.0
we understand the reason.
24:54.0
We are not saying that this is why they rebelled,
24:58.0
because these are terrorists, these are evil people.
25:01.0
They are troublemakers.
25:03.0
The government is wrong, right Patrick?
25:06.0
Yes, that's right.
25:08.0
In fact, they are the countrymen.
25:11.0
They love their countrymen,
25:13.0
that's why when they saw the corruption of the society,
25:16.0
the corruption of the...
25:18.0
They did not even touch the government.
25:24.0
If that is not what we agree with,
25:27.0
or that is what we think is wrong,
25:29.0
let us understand why it happened.
25:32.0
And resolve by then, once and for all,
25:35.0
the root of the rebellion of the people,
25:39.0
they will say it's poverty.
25:41.0
What is the root of poverty?
25:42.0
But what the government is doing,
25:44.0
Marcos is just continuing the policy of Duterte,
25:50.0
as if Marcos is kind,
25:53.0
but in a way, his policy, his dissent, his criticism,
26:01.0
And that reflects in the positions of the new DND Secretary,
26:09.0
That's why it's not good...
26:12.0
Can you say that Gibo Chudoro is a red tagger, Patrick?
26:19.0
This is clear, this is common sense,
26:24.0
that Gibo Chudoro is not only a red tagger,
26:27.0
but he also has his own thoughts,
26:30.0
and it really affects his desire to be a system,
26:38.0
even though he is the DND Secretary.
26:43.0
So it is only right that he should not be the one in the position,
26:48.0
because as a young man, I disagree,
26:51.0
because it is clear that if the thoughts of a government official
26:56.0
will be the front of the government,
26:59.0
when it comes to defense,
27:01.0
it will be the Filipinos and their fellow Filipinos who will be the last to die,
27:09.0
and in the end, it will be the fate of the people of our country.
27:14.0
So the peace talk,
27:15.0
that's what we think,
27:16.0
I know that there is a lot of controversy there,
27:19.0
we disagree to the point that our fellow Filipinos are dying,
27:24.0
and at the same time, they are holding arms,
27:27.0
but that will not be the reason to close our eyes,
27:32.0
that why are they doing this?
27:35.0
So we are always neutral to those views,
27:39.0
that we may not consider,
27:42.0
that's why they are doing this,
27:44.0
because of the corruption of the system,
27:46.0
and secondly, we really want peace,
27:48.0
through the government and armed groups,
27:53.0
but how will that happen?
27:57.0
we need to reach out,
27:59.0
or have help through the government and armed groups,
28:05.0
first, the will of the armed groups,
28:08.0
and give it to the government,
28:13.0
because it's simple,
28:16.0
I know that their will is simple,
28:19.0
a good government,
28:21.0
and a good government,
28:27.0
we all want peace,
28:29.0
we all want peace,
28:30.0
we all want peace,
28:35.0
should be based on responsibility,
28:38.0
there is no peace if there is no responsibility,
28:41.0
you can't say it's peaceful,
28:43.0
but there is still an advantage,
28:47.0
and there is an advantage to the poor,
28:49.0
we are not saying that there is no rich or poor,
28:52.0
what we are saying is,
28:53.0
there should be no advantage,
28:54.0
the society should be responsible,
28:56.0
the law is being violated,
28:58.0
there are opportunities for people to prosper,
29:02.0
peace is based on responsibility,
29:05.0
if there is no justice,
29:07.0
there is no peace,
29:10.0
if a person sees that the system is still the same,
29:14.0
it's still corrupt,
29:15.0
the corrupt politicians,
29:17.0
they steal billions,
29:18.0
they don't get jailed,
29:19.0
and those who get jailed are the ones who steal sardines,
29:23.0
That's not allowed.
29:27.0
but we get jailed.
29:30.0
if the politicians are rich,
29:32.0
they are corrupt,
29:34.0
they are even arrogant,
29:42.0
That's not allowed,
29:43.0
if there is no peace,
29:44.0
there is no advantage,
29:45.0
but if there is an advantage,
29:51.0
there will be peace,
29:52.0
maybe the rebels will give up,
29:55.0
the land of the farmers,
29:58.0
those who don't have land,
30:03.0
industrialization,
30:04.0
people will have jobs,
30:07.0
then there is a correct salary,
30:09.0
not just the rich who are rich,
30:13.0
the oligarchs who say
30:16.0
the workers are left in poverty,
30:19.0
can such a society survive?
30:21.0
So if those things are addressed,
30:27.0
we will have peace,
30:29.0
based on survival,
30:32.0
maybe they will think,
30:33.0
we will lower our arms,
30:35.0
because the government is okay,
30:37.0
even if the government is not perfect,
30:39.0
at least it's okay,
30:41.0
that's what we're saying.
30:44.0
our discussion is beautiful.
30:47.0
let's talk about Herbosa,
30:52.0
who is the DOH Secretary of Marcos,
30:57.0
because it's been a long time
30:58.0
since the DOH Secretary of Marcos Jr.
31:05.0
we still haven't recovered from COVID,
31:07.0
there are a lot of issues
31:09.0
revolving around Herbosa,
31:11.0
this is a red tagger in a way,
31:13.0
because this community pantry
31:15.0
seems to have a bad meaning.
31:20.0
when Angel Oxin became a community pantry,
31:23.0
there were old people who died
31:25.0
who were in line.
31:28.0
Herbosa's comment,
31:31.0
he was the UP Vice President before,
31:35.0
death by community pantry.
31:38.0
there's also a red tagging.
31:40.0
What can you say to Dr. Herbosa
31:43.0
as DOH Secretary,
31:44.0
in your view as a young person?
31:51.0
but he's also a doctor,
31:53.0
he will really be in the DOH.
31:58.0
he fits in there,
31:59.0
but if we're going to talk about
32:01.0
the issue with him,
32:08.0
is this really the choice
32:10.0
of the government
32:17.0
who are really traitors,
32:19.0
who are traitors,
32:21.0
or to lock up the people
32:23.0
who don't have a heart
32:24.0
in their mother's womb?
32:28.0
there's no progress
32:30.0
and there's no change
32:31.0
if your position,
32:38.0
doesn't have a heart
32:39.0
in his mother's womb?
32:43.0
but common sense,
32:48.0
there are a lot of good people
32:51.0
or should be more worthy
32:54.0
the people should be
32:58.0
aside from being corrupt,
33:01.0
and has no dignity
33:03.0
in his mother's womb.
33:09.0
this also happened
33:12.0
to the health workers
33:14.0
during the pandemic,
33:18.0
except for those,
33:24.0
the health workers.
33:26.0
the health workers
33:27.0
are also demanding
33:29.0
During the pandemic,
33:30.0
it's also very hard
33:35.0
even for the barangay
33:40.0
they are suffering
33:44.0
Herbosa said this,
33:51.0
What can you say about this?
33:54.0
He's the DOH Secretary
33:58.0
What can you say about that?
34:10.0
I'll just go back
34:11.0
to what I said earlier.
34:19.0
the incompetent people
34:22.0
and those who have no heart
34:23.0
for their fellowmen,
34:24.0
there will be no change
34:27.0
will remain corrupt.
34:28.0
So, meaning to say,
34:29.0
last and foremost,
34:34.0
we should look for
34:36.0
people who are really
34:40.0
the DOH Secretary.
34:41.0
You said earlier,
34:43.0
why is it still going on?
34:46.0
from the reality of society,
34:48.0
at the same time,
34:49.0
we are taxpayers.
34:54.0
or meaning to say,
34:56.0
in this kind of people,
34:57.0
our tax will go up
34:59.0
or we will make them pay
35:03.0
will happen to them.
35:05.0
if it's all about
35:08.0
and there is no solution
35:09.0
to the root of the problem
35:15.0
what we can say here is,
35:20.0
That's really it.
35:21.0
Because the anointment,
35:35.0
you're a student,
35:37.0
suddenly the class
35:46.0
How were you affected
35:51.0
this is the policy
35:52.0
of the DOA Secretary
35:54.0
What is the policy
35:55.0
of the DOA Secretary
35:57.0
What is the policy
35:58.0
of the DOA Secretary
36:01.0
the DOA Secretary
36:06.0
during the pandemic,
36:07.0
we really experienced,
36:35.0
closed their borders.
36:36.0
So meaning to say,
36:37.0
there was a chance
36:39.0
that the pandemic
36:41.0
enter our country.
36:43.0
the long story short,
36:45.0
entered our country,
36:50.0
corrupt politicians
36:51.0
would be massacred
00:00.0
40:50.120 --> 40:51.120
00:00.0
52:27.840 --> 52:57.840
00:00.0
52:57.840 --> 53:27.840
00:00.0
53:27.880 --> 53:28.880
