SECOND MOTION FOR RECONSIDERATION- TAGUIG VS. MAKATI
* AI ("Artificial Intelligence") subtitles on Tagalog.com are generated using "Whisper" by OpenAI (the same company that created ChatGPT and DallE2). Results and accuracy may vary.
* The subtitles do include errors occasionally and should only be used as a tool to help with your listening practice.
* You can request this website to create a transcript for a video if one doesn't already exist by clicking the "Request AI Subtitles" button below a video. Transcribing usually takes 30-40% of the length of a video to complete if there are no other videos in
the queue. For example, a 21 minute video will take 7-8 minutes to transcribe.
* Running a super fast cloud GPU server to do these transcriptions does cost money. If you have the desire and financial ability, consider
becoming a patron
to support these video transcriptions, and the other tools and apps built by Tagalog.com
00:00.0
Alright yan magandang araw mga kapatid natin at welcome sa isa namang live stream.
00:05.7
Mga kapatid natin I think you will find it interesting kapag ikukwento ko sa inyo yung history ng 2nd motion for reconsideration.
00:16.2
Ito kasi yung nangyari. Ito yung sinabi dito sa judiciary.gov.ph
00:23.2
This is the official website of the Supreme Court of the Philippines mga kapatid natin.
00:27.7
Ito sinabi dito SC denies Makati's motion for leave to admit 2nd motion for reconsideration in Makati-Tagig territorial dispute.
00:36.7
Okay mga kapatid natin. Pagtitignan nyo kasi dito this is not actually a 2nd motion for reconsideration.
00:44.7
This is only a motion for leave to admit. Yan yung unang una dyan.
00:49.7
Ano ba yung motion for leave to admit? Yan ay yung humihingi ka ng permiso sa korte na sana tanggapin nyo po yung aming 2nd motion for reconsideration.
00:59.7
So kapag hindi niya pinayagan o hindi niya tinanggap yung motion for leave mo o yung paghingi mo ng permiso para magfile ng 2nd motion for reconsideration,
01:10.7
eh wala nang visa. Hindi na babasahin yung 2nd motion for reconsideration mo.
01:16.7
Anong nangyari dito kung bakit motion for leave to admit 2nd motion for reconsideration kasama doon sa motion for leave to admit
01:24.7
o motion for leave nila o paghingi nila ng permiso para magfile ng motion for reconsideration, sinama na nila doon yung kanilang 2nd motion for reconsideration.
01:36.7
Ito ang sinabi. Sa isang resolution daw, yung date niya June 26, 2023, the Supreme Court Special Third Division resolved to deny the City of Makati's 2nd omnibus motion.
01:49.7
Pag omnibus motion yan, ibig sabihin halo-halong motion. Magkakasama na. So dalawa kasi dito.
01:57.7
Meron yung motion to admit tapos yung motion for reconsideration or 2nd motion for reconsideration. Kaya naging omnibus motion kasi dalawang motion ito.
02:06.7
Which among others sought the court's leave to file and admit its 2nd motion for reconsideration.
02:11.7
Anong sinabi dito? Sinabing ganyan na a 2nd motion for reconsideration is generally prohibited under the rules of court.
02:21.7
Ikikwento ko sa inyo mga kapatas natin. At kung tayo ay manunood, ay manunood, mag-aaral ng lumang-lumang desisyon ng Supreme Court, hindi pa sila stricto masyado.
02:32.7
At pwede ka pang mag-file ng 2nd, 3rd, 4th motion for reconsideration sa Supreme Court.
02:41.7
Nangyayari yan noon. Ngayon mga kapatas natin, nung naramdaman ng Supreme Court na bakit parang inaabuso itong motion for reconsideration na yan.
02:52.7
Eh ginawa na nila na prohibited motion ang 2nd motion for reconsideration. Kaya pag titignan nyo, kahit naman kasi sa lower courts ngayon, hindi na nagkakaroon ng 2nd motion for reconsideration.
03:06.7
Hindi lalong lalo na pa sa Supreme Court. Dito nyo lang makikita kasi syempre yung desperation din na mag-file sila ng 2nd motion for reconsideration kasi kapag pinagbigyan yan, at least may chance ka.
03:20.7
Tulad ng sinasabi ko sa inyo, nung nag-file ako ng kaso na certiorari, I think it's under Rule 64, yung kay Raffy Tulfo, yung desisyon ng Comelec kay Raffy Tulfo.
03:38.7
Kaya sinasabi ko sa inyo mga kapatas natin na it's already successful. Yung petition mo ay successful na kapag ito ay binasa, pinakinggan ng Supreme Court, hindi ito dinismissed o denied outright tapos pinag-comment yung kabila.
03:55.7
Kasi pag titignan nyo dito mga kapatas natin, the court just noted without action the City Makati 2nd motion for reconsideration. So ninote lang nila tapos hindi sila gumawa ng action.
04:08.7
Kaya tulad ng sinasabi ko sa inyo mga kapatas natin, manalo o matalo tayo doon, it's still good that we fought our hardest.
04:34.7
Ito rin kasi mga kapatas natin yung pag-file nila ng 2nd motion for reconsideration, I think they know. Alam nila na it is prohibited. It is a prohibited pleading under the rules of court.
04:49.7
Kaya lang finile lang nila yun para makatulog sila ng mahimbing. Para masabi nila mga kapatas natin na ginawa natin lahat.
05:03.7
Of course I cannot blame also the lawyers of Makati. Kasi nga, there's a lot at stake. So you have to do everything that you think and hope against hope na sana matanggap yan.
05:22.7
Ang dami kasing nagsasabi din, ano ba naman yan? O boob, alam niya naman na generally prohibited pleading under the rules of court yan. Pero mga kapatas natin malay mo, malay mo gumana.
05:39.7
Yan lang, yan lang yung ginagawa nila dito. I think they know for a fact that this is a prohibited pleading under the rules of court. Kaya lang, they are desperate. Ito ay finile lang para makatulog sila ng mahimbing.
05:56.7
Sinabi rin dun sa same resolution ng ganito mga kapatas natin na noted without action din yung City of
Taguig's manifestation with motion when they prayed that the City of Makati and its mayor be required to show cause why they should not be sanctioned for making certain claims in relation to the present case.
06:15.7
So ito kasi mga kapatas natin, yung City of Taguig naman, nag-file sila ng manifestation with motion. May motion sila at nagpipray sila na show cause, ipakita ng mayor ng Makati at saka yung Makati mismo kung bakit hindi sila masight in contempt of court o maparusahan for making certain claims in relation to the present case.
06:43.7
Ang ginawa rin dito also noted without action. So parang tinanggap lang nila pero wala silang gagawin. So ngayon siguro naiintindihan nyo na kung bakit nung finile ko yung kaso na yun, eh hindi noted without action ang ginawa ng Supreme Court o kaya outright dismissal.
07:05.7
Yan ang masaya dun. That's why I'm very happy when they were asked to comment tungkol dun sa disqualification case ni Raffy Tulfo. Kasi syempre pinag-iisipan din natin na maigyan. Tandaan nyo yung mga justices natin sa Supreme Court, they are legal luminaries.
07:25.7
Big sabi niyan, sila yung mga pinakamagagaling o ilan sa mga pinakamagagaling na abugado dito sa Pilipinas. Kaya pag titignan nyo at nagfafile kayo sa Supreme Court mga kabatas natin ng mga pleadings, mga kaso, maraming dismissed outright o kaya yan, noted without action.
07:55.7
Ngayon, meron nakalagay dito. Sabi ni Christian Crisivan, Borja, di ba pwede maging grounded attorney for disbarment since prohibited? Hindi naman.
08:25.7
Saan sila humuhugot kung bakit mag-file sila ng second motion for reconsideration? This was not done in bad faith. Okay? It was not done in bad faith. If it was done in bad faith, eh doon. Baka pwede maging ground for disbarment o kaya sanction, suspension. Pwede.
08:47.7
Katulad mga kabatas natin yung pag-iimvento ng mga grounds for inhibition ng isang judge na hindi naman nag-iexist. Why? Kasi nga mga kabatas natin, tandaan nyo ito. Itong sinasabi ko na ito. Kasi this will be relevant eventually if I will be revealing cases.
09:11.7
It will be relevant eventually. So please take note of this mga kabatas natin. Yung pag-iimvento nyo ng grounds for inhibition ng isang judge na hindi naman totoo o kaya non-existent, according to the Supreme Court, that can be a ground for sanction.
09:35.7
It can be a source for contempt of court. Kasi nag-iimvento kayo. You are doing it in bad faith. You are just delaying the proceedings by asking for another judge samantalang wala namang problema doon sa judge na nakaupo.
09:55.7
Hindi mo na gusto. Ngayon mga kabatas natin, tandaan nyo yan. Kasi hindi lang natin dito gagamitin yan. Eventually, kung may mga i-reveal ako sa inyong mga kaso, in the future, you will understand why I'm emphasizing on that matter.
10:16.7
Okay? Tandaan nyo yan. Ito in-explain lang dito mga kabatas natin. 425 National Military Reservation. Basahin nyo na lang mga kabatas natin. Nandyan naman na. Pinaliwanag ko lang naman sa inyo yung mga important points dito na sa tingin ko hindi nyo paalam.
10:39.7
Okay? Yan. Maraming salamat mga kabatas natin. At syempre tulad ng laging sinasabi, matulog po tayo ng mahimbing dahil alam natin na nagtutulog ng mahimbing siya yung laging panalo. Paalam po pansamantala.
