00:52.7
Doon sa mga hindi alam, yung farmali na ito,
00:57.3
naging issue yan noon nung panahon ni Senator Dick Gordon.
01:01.2
Si Dick Gordon, mga kabatas natin, isa rin siyang abogado.
01:05.6
Okay? Tignan natin kung ano nangyari.
01:08.6
Tatagalog ko na lang sa inyo, mga kabatas natin.
01:12.5
Noong 2021 kasi, doon sa Blue Ribbon Committee,
01:17.8
ang chairman noon, si Richard Gordon, si Ong at si Yang,
01:22.7
na farmali executive, mga kabatas natin, ay sinight nila for contempt.
01:28.2
Bakit? Kasi nga, nagbigay sila daw ng false and evasive answers during the hearing.
01:35.1
September 10, 2021.
01:37.7
Ito ay tungkol sa kontrata ng farmali sa gobyerno sa pagbili ng COVID-19 medical supplies.
01:46.5
Okay? Kasama dyan yung mga, yung mga, anong tawag doon? Yung mga face mask.
01:51.7
Tapos yung mga, ha, basta. Yung sinusuot, anong tawag sa sinusuot na yun?
02:00.5
Basta yun, basta yun. Alam nyo na yun.
02:03.8
O ano ba nangyari, mga kabatas natin? Nag-rule na yung Supreme Court.
02:09.4
Meron daw grave abuse of discretion when incited in contempt and ordered the arrest of farmali,
02:16.3
farmaceutical executives, Lincoln Ong and Michael Yang Hong.
02:21.7
Yung, thank you. PPE nga. PPE.
02:26.0
O tsaka mga face shields. Tama. Okay. PPE.
02:29.6
Thank you, thank you mga kabatas natin.
02:34.0
Familiar? Familiar. Ginagawa din yan lagi.
02:39.2
Especially ngayon, ginagawa yan lagi ni Rafi Tulfo, lalong-lalo na sa mga pulis.
02:48.5
Hindi ko talaga maintindihan kung may galit talaga si Rafi Tulfo.
02:51.7
Hindi ko talaga maintindihan kung may galit talaga si Rafi Tulfo.
02:52.0
Hindi ko talaga maintindihan kung may galit talaga si Rafi Tulfo.
02:52.1
Hindi ko talaga maintindihan kung may galit talaga si Rafi Tulfo.
02:52.1
Ito yung nangyari. Nang 2022, mga kabatas natin,
02:59.0
sinayit sila in contempt dahil doon sa COVID-19 medical supplies.
03:03.8
Ang ginawa ni Ong, nagpetisyon siya sa Supreme Court.
03:07.2
Sinabi niya, mga kabatas natin, na iligal yung ginawa ng Senado.
03:14.7
Kasi nga, exclusive constitutional domain of the judiciary yun.
03:20.0
Ibig sabihin, mga kabatas natin,
03:21.7
hindi kayo yung gumagawa niyan.
03:24.4
Ang gumagawa niyan yung korte.
03:28.3
Bakit? Bakit kayo ginagawa niyo na yan lahat?
03:33.6
Mga kabatas natin, this is vindication for us.
03:39.6
Makailang beses ko nang sinasabing, hindi nyo pwedeng gawin yan.
03:45.0
Anong sinasabi sa akin ng mga 100 lawyers?
03:48.6
Anong sinasabi sa akin ng mga Tulfonatics?
03:52.9
Pwede yan. Ginagawa nga nila eh.
03:54.5
Anong sinabi ng Supreme Court?
04:01.9
Anong ngayon, Raffi Tulfo?
04:05.1
Anong ngayon, Tulfonatics?
04:09.6
Super DM, tulungan mo ako.
04:13.1
May baho na naman tayong naaamoy dito.
04:23.3
Protect nyo pa yung idol nyo.
04:29.1
When it found him guilty of giving false testimony,
04:33.0
adding that the Senate proceeding against Ong under an erroneous concept
04:36.9
and gravely abusive exercise of contempt powers.
04:42.7
Mga kabatas natin, isa pa yung sinasabi ko sa inyo.
04:44.8
May contempt power sila, diba?
04:46.6
Pero mga kabatas natin, yung contempt power nila kailangan nang botohan eh.
04:50.2
Nang two-thirds eh.
04:52.6
Two-thirds of the members of the committee.
04:55.1
Ginagawa ba nila yun? Hindi.
04:56.7
Anong ginagawa nila?
05:03.2
Sergeant at Arms.
05:04.1
Eskortan sa babayan.
05:05.4
Tanggalin yung kama.
05:14.8
P.P.E. yung isusuot ni Bayad Bay bago humarap sa babae.
05:24.5
Oo. Para katanggat.
05:34.7
Supreme Court yan!
05:38.6
Meanwhile, in Yang's petition, he argued that the Senate committed grave abuse of power
05:42.9
when it issued arrest orders.
05:44.8
Despite a lack of legal basis, and compelled him to answer questions and submit documents
05:51.7
and information that were beyond the scope of the legislative inquiry in violation of
05:57.3
his rights to privacy.
06:04.8
Vinayulate yung kanyang karapatan bilang isang pribadong tao.
06:14.8
Sabi niya, mga kabatas natin,
06:19.0
High-handed and oppressive conduct of proceedings.
06:23.7
Yung nangyari daw doon, mga kabatas natin,
06:33.2
Claiming that the Senate treated resource persons before it worse than an accused in a criminal proceeding.
06:44.8
Ilang ulit ko nang sinasabi yan.
06:50.8
Ayaw nyong maniwala sa akin.
06:53.7
Gusto nyong makipagsuntukan, ikulong.
06:59.7
Sumabog sa puso. Ay, iba pala yun.
07:02.6
Tumaob. Ay, iba pala yun.
07:05.8
Ay, iba pala yung padala flowers.
07:10.9
In its decision promulgated March 28,
07:13.8
the SC said the order of arrest and contempt case against the two formerly executives
07:18.3
violated their rights to due process.
07:29.4
I've said that before.
07:39.0
sobrang familiar yung eksena.
07:43.8
Ang daming senador na nagagalit sa akin.
07:46.6
Kapag pinupunako sila, kapag gumagawa sila ng ganyan.
07:50.4
Sinasabi nila sa akin na ikaw kasi kampi ka doon sa mga kriminal.
07:57.6
Yan ang nakikita ko sa comment section.
08:02.5
Kampi ka doon sa mga kriminal.
08:06.0
Well, wait. Hindi pa kriminal yan mga yan.
08:13.8
Kasi nga, may right to due process na ayaw ni Rafi Tulfo.
08:22.1
Kaya uulit-ulitin ko kung bakit binabatikos ko si Rafi Tulfo
08:28.4
dahil ayaw ko yung pagkaayaw niya sa due process.
08:34.6
Hanggang ganyan siya, hindi kami magkakasundo.
08:43.8
Sabi ni Torvix Torvix,
08:45.5
Attorney, now that the Supreme Court ruled it,
08:47.9
what do you think is the implications nito sa hearing sa Senado?
08:53.9
Sana, magpakabait na sila.
08:57.0
Sumunod sa batas.
08:58.6
After all, mambabatas kayo.
09:02.5
Ayaw nating maging mambabatas na walang alam sa batas.
09:21.7
Kung makakontemp at makapagpakulong ng mga tao, mashinggan.
09:30.0
Akala mo automatic yung rifle niya?
09:34.3
Anong sinabi ng Supreme Court?
09:37.1
Anong sinabi ng Supreme Court?
09:40.1
Violation sa rights to due process.
09:47.1
Oh, tahimik ngayon.
09:49.8
Yung mga promo-protecta kay idol nila.
09:54.8
Silent kayo ngayon.
09:59.5
Di ba? Promote niyo siya.
10:01.3
Tama yung ginagawa mo, Rafi Tulfo.
10:03.7
Pakulong ka lang ng pakulong.
10:07.1
Sige, gawin mong panakot yan, Rafi Tulfo, sa Rafi Tulfo in action.
10:11.8
Pakulong ka lang ng pakulong.
10:23.8
Ngayon, tahimik ang mga Tulfonatics.
10:28.1
Rafi Tulfo, ano na?
10:32.1
Magsasorry ka ba?
10:37.1
Anong sinabi ng Supreme Court?
11:07.1
The ruling noted the observation of Senior Associate Justice Marvick Leonen
11:13.2
who observed that inconsistent answers were equated by Senate
11:16.8
with testifying evasively.
11:21.7
Ito yung sinabi ni Justice Marvick Leonen.
11:27.6
Whether a witness genuinely did not know or did not recall the answer
11:31.6
or was evasive in answering a question
11:34.0
is largely a matter of judgment or opinion.
11:43.5
Kasi si Rafi Tulfo, anong ginagawa niya?
11:49.0
Pag ayaw niya yung sagot.
11:50.5
Contempt ka, sir.
11:53.1
Mali ang sagot mo, sir.
11:54.1
Contempt ka, sir.
11:58.6
Ano pa yung sinabi niya sa mga polis?
12:00.2
Itong mga polis na ito,
12:03.3
sabi ni Rafi Tulfo,
12:05.0
nagkukulong ng walang dahilan.
12:07.1
O kaya konti lang yung dahilan.
12:12.0
hindi yung verbatim, pero parang ganun.
12:15.0
Gawin din natin yung ginagawa nila
12:27.9
Ano na, Rafi Tulfo?
12:32.6
Ilan na yung vinaulate mong batas dyan
12:34.5
sa Senate hearing?
12:42.6
Taste your own medicine.
12:47.7
Sabi ni si Generis,
12:49.1
ikaw ba counsel ni Ong and Yang?
12:50.6
Bakit saktong-sakto arguments pattern?
12:52.3
Hindi ako yung counsel nila.
12:54.4
Baka sabihin na naman nila,
13:01.2
Basic lang kasi yan.
13:07.1
Yung mga tamad lang mag-aaral
13:15.6
ang hindi alam yan.
13:29.2
Kaya bakit parang alam na alam ko
13:31.2
yung kalalabasan?
13:33.4
That is provided for by law.
13:37.1
Sabi nila Orans Dino,
13:43.2
Sir Rick Gultawa.
13:45.0
Because that is due process.
13:50.8
Bakit saktong-sakto yung mga sinabi ko sa inyo?
14:05.0
Kahit nabalutan ng ginto,
14:10.2
kung hindi mo ginagamit ng maayos,
14:14.9
hindi pa rin maayos.
14:20.3
Kahit yung revised penal code mo
14:22.3
or rules of court mo
14:23.5
ay limited edition one of one,
14:28.4
kung hindi mo ginagamit ng maayos,
14:30.4
hindi pa rin maayos.
14:36.3
This determination requires an assessment
14:38.5
of the totality of the evidence presented
14:41.4
to determine whether a witness speaks truthfully
14:44.5
or merely trying to evade
14:46.4
answering the questions directly.
14:51.8
Totality of the evidence.
14:57.2
Yung pangkalatan.
14:59.5
Hindi yung gusto mo lang.
15:03.5
That doesn't work.
15:06.3
You're not the boss of everyone.
15:11.2
Kung ayaw mo sa due process, Rafi Tulfo,
15:13.9
huwag mong idamay ang ibang tao.
15:23.1
Sabi ni No Nonsense,
15:24.4
collectible lang daw.
15:28.3
Meron akong collectible dito.
15:30.4
Marami akong collectible.
15:36.3
It added that the determination
15:41.4
could not have been made
15:42.8
based on the testimony alone.
15:54.9
Magkocross-examine.
15:56.5
Tapos, titignan kung guilty or not guilty
16:06.3
Sabi rin dito sa SC Decision,
16:08.5
mga kabatas natin,
16:09.5
sinabi rin ni Chief Justice Jasmundo.
16:13.5
Na, yung mga witnesses daw na charged
16:15.8
giving false or evasive testimony
16:18.0
must be at least given a chance to explain
16:20.1
why his or her testimony
16:22.2
is not false or evasive.
16:25.1
Anong ibig sabihin yan?
16:26.1
Hindi man lang sila binagbigyan ng pagkakataon
16:28.8
na ipaliwanag yung kanilang sarili
16:30.4
kung bakit hindi dapat sila makulong.
16:34.8
Sergeant at Arms,
16:41.0
Tanggalin yung kutyon
16:42.5
at bigyan ng banig.
16:51.4
Due process wins.
16:54.9
Alam mo pati dun kay Banat Bayan,
16:57.4
ito, si attorney,
17:00.5
si vlogger li ba yan?
17:02.7
Tinitira na naman yung mga senador.
17:04.5
Tinutuwid ko lang.
17:09.3
Binakaapan ako ng Supreme Court.
17:13.6
What about that, ha?
17:18.0
Iignore nyo na lang yan?
17:19.7
Naninira na lang ako?
17:23.5
No, don't do that.
17:30.1
Because you are public servants.
17:32.5
You're supposed to do the right thing.
17:35.7
And the right thing is what I said.
17:38.0
Because this is also what the Supreme Court said.
17:56.5
however the SC did not agree with the petitioner's accusation
17:59.8
that the Senate had supposedly encroached
18:01.8
on the contempt power of the judiciary
18:03.9
saying the legislative's power of attorney is not enough.
18:05.6
The power of content is inherent and arises by implication.
18:08.6
Yan, meron naman silang contempt powers.
18:10.6
Binasa naman natin yun.
18:12.6
Kaya nga may two thirds na votes pa, di ba?
18:15.6
wag namang kulong agad.
18:29.6
Pinaliwanag ko din sa inyo.
18:31.6
Sa korte nga, kapag contempt ang usapan,
18:33.6
it is a separate issue.
18:34.9
It is a separate criminal proceeding
18:36.9
in direct contempt.
18:44.9
Pero, wag niyong kunin.
18:46.9
Yung pagpapakulong at pagsesend ng
18:48.9
warrant of arrest
18:50.9
ng walang due process.
18:54.9
Sabi niyang ganyan,
18:56.9
this coercive process is essential to the legislature's discharge of its function.
19:01.9
To legislate wisely or effectively,
19:03.9
because they have the power to compel the availability of information necessary in shaping legislation.
19:10.9
Pumarte naman sila doon sa power of contempt.
19:14.9
Wala naman akong problema dyan, sinabi ko.
19:16.9
Pero, idaan nyo lang sa due process.
19:18.9
Sana ko hindi umagri sa pagpapakulong.
19:25.9
Pareho kami nung Supreme Court.
19:32.9
Sabi dito ni Pautun.
19:34.9
Nebriha versus Revilla attorney. Ano reaction mo?
19:36.9
Hindi ko alam ha. Send nyo nga sa akin.
19:38.9
Send nyo nga sa akin.
19:46.9
is exactly the same
19:48.9
as the opinion of the Supreme Court.
19:52.9
What a coincidence!
19:54.9
No, it's not a coincidence. It's due process.
20:02.9
At talagang sabi niya.
20:04.9
The SC also noted Senate rules cannot be declared unconstitutional
20:08.9
as it has complied with the requirements set under the Constitution
20:13.9
that the rules including its amendments should be made known to the public through publication.
20:19.9
The decision which was received by the parties on November 10
20:23.9
was penned by Associate Justice Henry Imting.
20:30.9
Due process wins.
20:32.9
Nakapagtataka, no?
20:34.9
Parang lahat nung sinabi ko tumumpak doon sa desisyon ng Supreme Court.
20:44.9
I would like to thank the Supreme Court
20:47.9
for finally clarifying this.
20:49.9
Ilang beses na rin akong natawag
20:52.9
na bobo, tanga, walang kwenta.
20:56.9
Mas magaling ka pa doon sa mga abugadong ito.
20:59.9
Abugado ni ganyan.
21:01.9
Sasabihin sa akin, may abugado si Rafi Tulfo.
21:05.9
Alam nila kung ano yung ginagawa ni Rafi Tulfo.
21:08.9
Sa tingin mo ba hindi ina-advise-an ng abugado ni Rafi Tulfo yung mga yan?
21:13.9
Ang daming abugado ni Rafi Tulfo.
21:15.9
Hindi sila hampas lupa.
21:17.9
Hindi sila rotten brain.
21:19.9
Hindi sila bobo katulad mo.
21:36.9
Ito yung tunay na declaration ng Supreme Court.
21:43.9
Hindi yung sinasabi nung iba.
21:45.9
Okay. Maraming salamat mga kapatid natin.
21:47.9
At syempre tulog na lagi yung sinasabi.
21:49.9
Matulog po tayo ng mahimbing dahil alam natin
21:51.9
na yung natutulog ng mahimbing, siya yung laging panalo.
21:54.9
Paalam po. Pansa mo.
