00:47.9
Pero bago tayo tumungo dyan, tignan natin kasi kung anong ginagawa nila
00:52.1
Especially itong si Rafi Tulfo mga kabatas natin
00:54.6
Alam naman natin ang kanyang laging panakot sa mga tao
00:59.0
Especially sa mga resource persons na pumupunta
01:01.7
Doon sa Senado, ipapakontempt niya at ikukulong
01:05.2
Doon sa baba, kung saan, tinanggal na daw yung kama, no? At banig na lang
01:12.6
At tignan nyo mga kabatas natin
01:13.9
Ito rin taong ito mga kabatas natin
01:17.2
Yung magfafile daw ng cyber libel complaint laban sa mga small vloggers
01:22.8
Gagawin niya daw yun para hindi ako tularan
01:26.5
At ako daw, finailan na ng cyber libel complaint
01:29.0
Tignan natin yung tabil ng dila nito mga kabatas natin
01:32.5
Kung bakit ang lakas ng loob niyang magfile ng cyber libel complaint sa mga small vloggers
01:40.5
Now, dalawa lang, mamili ka
01:44.0
Ikaw ay bupo o ikaw ay tiwali?
01:49.2
Grabe, ang galing no?
01:51.9
Tapos siya ayaw pa ba tikos, lalo na sa mga small vloggers?
01:57.0
Dalawa lang, mamili ka
01:58.5
Ikaw ay bupo o ikaw ay tiwali?
02:00.9
Pagkatapos nito kasi mga kabatas natin
02:03.0
Magsasight siya in contempt
02:09.6
Minimum bupo ka at hindi ka karabat dapat sa PNP
02:13.5
Dapat masipa ka na sapagkat
02:16.7
Isipin mo pag sinabi sa'yo yung Rafi Tulfo
02:18.6
Sinabi sa'yo yan ng mga small vloggers
02:21.4
Anong gagawin mo?
02:24.4
Ng cyber libel complaint?
02:25.6
Kasi sinabi hanggang bupo?
02:28.5
Minimum bupo ka at hindi ka karabat dapat sa PNP
02:31.6
Dapat masipa ka na sapagkat
02:32.6
At hindi ka karabat dapat sa Senado
02:34.9
At dapat masipa ka?
02:38.6
At makulong pa sapagkat
02:40.4
Hindi mo alam ang pinaggagawa ng bag
02:43.0
Sapagkat hindi mo alam ang pinaggagawa mo
02:46.0
Binabalik ko lang sa'yo yung mga sinasabi mo ha
02:51.6
Binabalik ko lang sa'yo
02:58.5
Let's make an example out of you
03:00.5
Kung yun ay sasabihin sa'yo
03:07.6
Kapalmoks mo eh, no?
03:10.1
Na magfile ng cyber libel sa mga small vloggers eh
03:24.0
na itong bata mo,
03:28.5
Ay gumagawin ng kalukuhan
03:29.5
At kinukonsinti mo
03:30.5
Mamili ka lang, dalawa lang
03:33.5
Mamili ka lang, bobo o kaya tiwali?
03:36.5
Ginaganyan niya yung mga tao
03:38.5
Tapos siya yung malakas ng loob
03:40.5
Siya ay yung anlakas ng loob
03:46.5
Magfile ng cyber libel sa mga small vloggers
03:50.0
Porke small vloggers sila?
03:55.5
Wala akong mapili eh, owner
03:57.5
Ganon yung bobo na laks
03:59.5
O, tinawanan niya eh
04:03.5
Your owner pa ang tawag sa kanya dyan ha
04:06.5
Ah, so kung wala ka mapili, tanga
04:10.5
Kung wala ka mapili, tanga
04:14.5
Cyber libel pa more sa mga small vloggers
04:21.5
Honestly, I'm serious
04:24.5
Sirius pa siya dyan
04:25.5
Dyan, I need to whisper something
04:27.5
Exactly, you have to do something there
04:29.5
No, I just need to whisper something
04:37.5
Go to mommy, go to mommy, not here
04:41.5
I hope you haven't used Lice Shrieve!
04:46.5
Make sure that I didn't subscribe!
04:51.5
Tama ba yan na pinaggagagawa ng isang senador?
04:53.5
Pili ka, bobo o tiwale?
04:55.5
Tapos file ng cyber libel?
04:58.5
Pagkatapos dyang bobo, tiwale at gawing tanga ang isang tao, mga kabatas natin
05:06.5
Ikokontent pa niya
05:08.5
At ito nga yung pinaka content natin ngayon
05:13.5
Because kung kayo po, kasi hindi ka abot sa colonel
05:17.5
My father was a colonel
05:22.5
My father was a colonel
05:24.5
Matalinong tatay ko
05:27.5
Ano nangyari sa'yo?
05:29.5
Anong colonel para sa'kin matatalinong?
05:31.5
Hindi nyo mamabot yung ganong ranggo, colonel, kung kayo ay bobo
05:35.5
Buhuhan lang kayo para pali
05:37.5
Or frustrated, kuwera
05:40.5
Paala na kayong mga bugado
05:42.5
Mga kabatas natin
05:44.5
Pagkatapos nun, nasa in-contempt yung mga ngayon
05:47.5
Si Lieutenant Colonel Rodolfo Mayo
05:49.5
Ay, Lieutenant Colonel Ibanez at Rodolfo Mayo
05:51.5
Si Knight in Contempt, yan mga kabatas natin
05:56.5
Nakakapikon itong si Captain Arabejo eh
05:58.5
Sarap ipakulong sa baba eh
06:01.5
Sarap ipakulong sa baba
06:02.5
Bakit siya ipapakulong sa baba?
06:08.5
Anong sabi ng Supreme Court?
06:14.5
Porke hindi mo nagustuhan yung sagot?
06:23.5
Ganon ang pag-abuso dito sa contempt powers ng Senado
06:28.5
Tapos nag-rule na nga yung Supreme Court
06:32.5
Anong sinabi dito mga kabatas natin?
06:40.5
Nagsisave face siya dito eh
06:42.5
Hindi niya man lang recognize mga kabatas natin
06:45.5
Yung tunay na gist
06:47.5
O laman nung desisyon ng Supreme Court
06:50.5
SP Subiri Statement on the SC Decision Concerning the Farmalli Case
06:55.5
We in the Senate recognize the decision of the Supreme Court
06:58.5
On the case involving Farmalli Executive
07:00.5
And at the same time welcome the decision of the Highest Court
07:03.5
Affirming the Senate's power to hold witnesses in contempt during hearings in aid of legislation
07:09.5
So dito makikita nyo na mga kabatas natin
07:11.5
Iniiwasan nyo na yung tunay na issue
07:13.5
Ano yung tunay na issue dito?
07:16.5
Puntahan natin ulit yung balita ha
07:19.5
Simpleng-simple na nga yung balita mga kabatas natin eh
07:29.5
The arrest of Farmalli Executives
07:35.5
Yun yung issue dito
07:44.5
Nung pinasa ko ito parang
07:46.5
Actually sinandito ni I.M. Shanwain sa akin
07:48.5
Binasa ko wait sandali
07:51.5
Well you're missing the point
07:55.5
Meron nga kayong power
07:58.5
To hold witnesses in contempt
08:00.5
Kaya lang because of abuse
08:04.5
It was declared void
08:07.5
And the pattern is the same with what you are doing right now
08:15.5
In today's deliberation of the judiciary's budget
08:18.5
I acknowledge the court's decision
08:20.5
Appreciating its guidance on how the Senate should handle contempt cases moving forward
08:26.5
The court did not invalidate the Senate's power to cite witnesses in contempt
08:31.5
As well as all the grounds for contempt under our rules
08:39.5
You are exercising it
08:41.5
In an abusive and wrongful manner
08:45.5
Kaya nga sinabing merong grave abuse of discretion
08:51.5
The court merely said
08:57.5
The court merely said that considering the broad definition of giving false or evasive testimony
09:02.5
The witness must be given a chance to explain why his or her testimony is not false or evasive
09:07.5
The court merely said
09:09.5
Balikan na naman natin ha
09:15.5
Balikan na naman natin
09:17.5
Balikan na naman natin
09:19.5
SC Void's Arrest of Farmer Executives
09:25.5
Sinabi ng Supreme Court iligal yung ginawa nyo
09:31.5
Ano ang malabo doon?
09:41.5
Iligal yung ginawa nyo
09:43.5
Kaya vinoyed nila
09:44.5
Kaya vinoyed nila
10:12.2
Is not the existence
10:14.5
existence of your contempt powers
10:18.5
discussed there, pero dito
10:21.5
it's your exercise
10:26.8
exercise of your contempt
10:30.8
abuse of discretion
10:45.6
dito nga sa headlines
10:46.9
na sinabi na nila
10:48.7
void yung ginawa nyo
11:01.2
the broad power of the senate
11:02.9
to hold witnesses in contempt as inherent
11:05.2
in its power to conduct inquiries
11:07.1
in aid of legislation
11:08.5
binasa mo ba yung
11:11.1
balita, kahit balita lang
11:23.0
abuse of discretion
11:24.2
inabuso nyo yung kapangyarihan nyo
11:30.7
the grant of that power is meant to be complete
11:32.7
meaning the senate has the power
11:34.9
to conduct inquiries in aid of legislation
11:36.9
and therefore also has the power to resort
11:38.7
to coercive mechanisms to ensure
11:40.7
that its processes are obeyed including
11:42.3
citing witnesses in contempt, yes
11:43.9
but you're not supposed to abuse it
11:46.0
kasi decision doon sinabi doon
11:48.0
na may grave abuse of discretion
11:50.0
inabuso nyo yung contempt powers nyo
12:03.4
it's essential to note that
12:04.9
contrary to misconceptions
12:06.0
the recent decision doesn't undermine
12:08.0
the senate's power
12:08.9
it does not undermine the senate's power
12:12.0
it's essential to note that
12:15.6
that you are abusing
12:17.8
or gravely abusing your discretion
12:20.2
by citing people in contempt
12:22.6
without following
12:26.3
ganito lang kasimple yan
12:32.7
yung imbes na dumaan ka sa tamang
12:36.0
proseso, sino shortcut mo
12:38.4
kaya nga due process yung issue doon
12:43.9
kasi yun ang ginagawa nyo
12:51.5
especially si Rafi Tulfo
12:53.7
grave abuse of discretion
12:59.0
bakit hindi nyo rin recognize
13:07.0
na nagkamali kayo doon
13:08.6
kaya niya binoyed
13:17.5
the court merely underscored
13:19.5
the importance of ensuring fairness
13:21.3
in contempt proceedings
13:24.2
binoyed nga yung ginawa nyo
13:27.8
at sinabing may grave abuse of discretion
13:35.8
while the senate has the authority
13:37.1
to conduct inquiries in aid of legislation
13:39.0
it also has the means to enforce compliance
13:40.8
with its processes including citing witnesses
13:43.5
there's no question about that
13:47.1
then why is it void then
13:50.5
it is void because there's grave abuse
13:56.8
lastly let be clear that all hearings
13:58.9
including those in question
14:00.2
and every senate inquiry have a primary objective
14:03.1
of uncovering the truth in aid of legislation
14:05.6
and contributing to the legislative process
14:12.3
balikan ulit natin
14:16.9
para hindi sila malito
14:26.7
of formally executives
14:29.5
in its decision promulgated March 28
14:39.0
the order of arrest and contempt case
14:41.2
against the two formally executives
14:42.3
violated their rights to due process
14:45.8
the committee's grave abuse of discretion
14:51.6
lay in its precipitate act
14:54.6
of citing petitioners
14:57.1
in contempt and ordering their arrest
14:60.0
without giving them opportunity to be heard
15:02.6
grave abuse of discretion
15:07.4
may pang-aabuso na nangyari
15:09.6
sa inyong kapangyarihan
15:11.2
yun ang iyon na nangyarihan
15:16.1
yan maraming salamat mga kabatas natin
15:18.5
siyempre tulad lang yung sinasabi
15:21.7
intindihin natin yung mga pinabasa natin
15:25.6
at siyempre matulog po tayo ng mahimbing
15:28.0
dahil alam natin na yung natutulog ng mahimbing
15:31.4
siya yung lagi panalo
15:36.4
aayo ko na magbibigay ka ng wrong information
15:39.6
you're disseminating a wrong information
