Close
 


HARRY ROQUE, SARA, BBM…
Hide Subtitles
Click any subtitle word to view Tagalog.com dictionary results.
Computer Shortcuts: Left / Right arrows to jump 2 seconds back or forward. +Enter or Space to toggle Play/Pause button. Full Screen Mode

Richard Heydarian VLOGS
  Mute  
Run time: 27:41
Has AI Subtitles



English Summary of Video (AI):
Here is a summary of the topics discussed in the video based on the provided transcript:

- Senator Leila de Lima's case and its implications:
* Hope for resolution of cases believed to be politically motivated, carryovers from the previous administration.
* Senator de Lima's potential actions against her alleged tormentors, including President Rodrigo Duterte and former Justice Secretary Aguirre.

- President Marcos Jr.'s visit to the United States:
* Meetings with Filipino communities in San Francisco and Hawaii.
* Big meetings with top defense officials at the Pentagon and discussions about American investments in the Philippines.

- The former spokesman of President Duterte and human rights law:
* Controversy over a former Duterte spokesman and his connection to an international human rights group.
* Allegations of being apologetic about questionable court cases from the previous administration and difficulty in portraying a human rights advocate.

- Issues with cyber libel and libel laws:
* A concerning case of a private school teacher (Janus Monar) facing complaints after sharing a video about police preparations for a VIP's commute (implied to be VP Sara Duterte).
* Critiques of the weaponization of cyber libel and other laws to silence or intimidate citizens, with a chilling effect on freedom of speech.

- The case involving former Congressman Walden Belio:
* Details of the legal proceedings, including mediation ordered by a Davao court regarding a cyber libel case between Belio and an aide of VP Sara Duterte.
* Discussion of potentially decriminalizing libel to prevent its misuse as a tool for silencing dissent.

- Collaboration and initiatives by the creator of the video:
* Plans for engaging with legal experts, progressive influencers, and journalists for in-depth discussions on law, politics, and public policy.
* Promotion of an upcoming show, "The View from Manila" on One News TV 5, featuring interviews with public figures such as Ambassador Eduardo de Vega and Undersecretary Jonathan Malaya.


Video Transcript / Subtitles:( AI generated. About AI subtitles » )
00:00.0
Alawa na yan and yeah, let's see. I mean, you know, of course, those two are very good friends.
00:05.6
Those two have been in touch throughout the years through thick and thin and mutual admirers.
00:12.2
And of course, as we see mga positive developments dito sa kaso ni Senator de Lima,
00:17.1
of course, there's a hope that other similar cases or cases that are believed to be politically motivated
00:22.7
and, you know, yung mga hangovers, yung mga, you know, questionable court cases in the view of some
00:32.4
na essentially a carryover from the previous administration na many are hoping na medyo magkakaroon ng resolution at maayos din yan.
00:39.9
President Marcos Jr. is also, of course, back from the United States, mga kameta.
00:44.1
He had a very, very productive meeting at this in terms of traveling sa San Francisco, sa Hawaii,
00:50.8
na meet niya yung mga kababayan.
00:52.7
Natan yung mga kapsad natin na Ilocano, nagadumadjay Hawaii, no?
00:56.9
Talagang pagdapan kay Jay Hawaii, pag sinabi mo Ilocano ka, wala na, philatome ka na, diba?
01:02.9
And of course, mga kamets, mga kamets, there were some big, big, big meetings between President Marcos Jr.
01:09.7
and top defense officials in the Pentagon.
01:12.9
There have been also discussions about American investments in the Philippines.
01:16.3
But yun nga, sabi natin, sana hindi magiging pledge diplomacy lang, hindi lang magiging pledge diplomacy.
01:22.1
So, having said all of that, all of that, let's go one by one.
01:25.5
Okay.
01:26.4
Una-una, of course, nagtetrending kanina, eto si former spokesman of Rodrigo Duterte.
01:35.5
Someone who's supposed to be a human rights lawyer na hindi nakapasok dun sa international, ano,
01:41.0
something for international human rights and law people.
01:44.0
Alam nyo na bakit, of course.
01:45.3
I mean, once you're a spokesman of Duterte and trying to, at least in the view of critics, apologizing
01:50.2
dun sa mga...
01:52.1
dun sa mga, alam nyo na, mga kababalagan sa ilalim na nakaraan na administration,
01:58.6
you know, it's hard to, you know, it's hard to convince the world na ikaw ay isang bastion of human rights, etc.
02:05.0
But having said that, that hasn't stopped this former presidential spokesman from kind of injecting himself in the conversation
02:13.1
and saying, base dito sa Philippine Star Report, na yung judge na who oversaw yung grant,
02:20.9
yung nag-grant,
02:22.1
ng bail, former President Senator Dalima,
02:25.7
ay kanyang dating paboritong estudyante at San Beda College.
02:31.4
Ano, nagturo ba sa San Beda to?
02:32.8
Di ba taga-UP yan?
02:34.1
Nagturo sa UP yan.
02:34.9
Anyway, so, of course, naturally, maraming nagtaas ng kilay,
02:40.5
to put it mildly, like, wait lang.
02:42.3
First of all, okay, like, so what are you implying here?
02:46.1
And pangalawa, of course, many people remember that one of the persons, right,
02:52.1
or one of the group of people na sobrang daming sinabi kay Senator Dalima back in the day,
02:59.3
alam nyo na yung who, di ba?
03:00.4
So, connect the dots, no?
03:01.9
And, of course, as you know, Senator Dalima has also implied that she will go after her tormentors,
03:07.7
beginning with former President Rodrigo Duterte,
03:10.1
potentially also former Justice Secretary Aguirre,
03:12.8
but we know that hindi lang itong dalawa ay behind yung mga very, you know,
03:18.4
very, someone would say, very politically motivated,
03:21.0
critics would say,
03:22.1
very, very vicious, barbaric, vulgar attacks against the former Senator Leila Dalima
03:27.3
who's now enjoying a semblance of freedom,
03:30.3
enjoying some time with her family and loved ones,
03:31.9
and now looking at taking the fight back to her tormentors
03:35.4
and making the most out of the complete transformation dito sa political dynamics sa Pilipinas.
03:42.5
So, let's look at, mga kamay, ito, what's gonna happen there,
03:46.1
what are gonna be the developments there.
03:48.5
Kausapin natin si Senator Leila Dalima later this week.
03:52.1
Piling tignan natin ano yung mga plano niya or anong pwede niya i-share na plan.
03:55.5
Of course, pagdating sa batas, kailangan ma-diskarte,
03:58.5
kailangan readyng-ready yung kanyang team, hindi pwede talang-talan lang.
04:01.8
So, let's see what's happening here.
04:04.0
Now, this brings me, of course, to the other issue,
04:08.1
you know, this concern that, you know, cyber libel, libel-related laws
04:12.4
or laws that were passed during pandemic, among others, ay naweponize.
04:17.7
And one thing weird that it's happened right now is,
04:21.0
meron tayong itong report,
04:22.1
by Michael Navallo, si Atty. Navallo, from mga kaibigan natin sa ABS-CBN.
04:27.5
So, may pinost siya kanina, mga kameta,
04:30.8
na isang private school teacher na nag-post ng video of a police officer
04:34.2
identifying the vice president as the VIP who will pass by Commonwealth,
04:39.6
uy, mali naman ka,
04:41.1
who passed by the Commonwealth Avenue is now facing complaints for sharing false news
04:46.3
and child abuse before the QC prosecutor's office.
04:49.7
So, medyo malangkot yan, mga kameta.
04:52.1
So, of course, people are saying,
04:53.3
what? Bakit napunta sa ganitong usapan, diba?
04:56.0
So, what's happening here, alright?
04:58.1
I-post natin, mga kameta, dito yung video
05:00.9
para makita nyo naman yung pinag-usapan natin.
05:05.0
Wait lang.
05:06.1
Anaman natin.
05:07.2
Kailangan tignan dito.
05:08.1
Wait lang, ha.
05:10.0
Let's check this out, mga kameta.
05:13.9
One second lang.
05:17.0
Okay.
05:17.8
I hope it's this one, no?
05:20.7
Ay, hindi pala.
05:21.6
One second.
05:23.4
Gano'n naman tayo, eh.
05:24.8
Mga kamets.
05:26.5
Mga kamets.
05:30.4
Yan.
05:31.1
Okay, ganun pala yung style.
05:32.7
Ito, mga kameta, oh.
05:34.0
So, ito yung pinost ni
05:35.1
bossing
05:36.8
si Atty. Navalo
05:39.5
of ABS-CBN.
05:42.2
Mausay po na journalist yan.
05:43.8
At, of course, abogado rin.
05:45.2
So, ito, ito, ito.
05:47.1
So, ito po yung video na nakita natin nyo na
05:49.2
itong, ito po yung private school teacher.
05:51.4
Ito po yung private school teacher.
05:51.5
Na nag-share ng video
05:54.9
about dun sa
05:55.9
police officer identifying
05:58.9
VP Sara Duterte as the VIP
06:00.3
will pass by convolute na, of course,
06:02.4
maraming nag-complain.
06:04.3
Pero later on, ang nangyari bigla dito
06:06.6
is inakusan pa siya ng
06:08.0
spreading fake news
06:10.9
and child abuse, etc.
06:12.6
So, Janus Monar
06:14.7
says he's baffled.
06:16.0
I-post din natin ito, mga kameta,
06:17.5
para makita niyo yung defense
06:18.6
ng itong
06:20.7
ah,
06:21.5
active citizen na nag-share
06:23.2
out of just genuine concern.
06:25.0
Hindi naman hater siguro yan.
06:26.8
Si kuya naman, just sharing,
06:29.2
di ba, na yung VIP culture
06:30.9
sa Pilipinas, medyo
06:32.8
siguro kailangan review. Now, of course,
06:36.1
hindi pa natin na-confirm
06:37.3
sino ba talaga nandun.
06:38.6
All he did was just to share
06:40.5
you know, a video that
06:43.1
implied that, you know, certain
06:44.5
influential person was
06:47.0
somehow, ano,
06:50.4
perhaps the reason
06:51.3
why Sinera
06:51.9
yung Commonwealth.
06:52.6
Yung kampo naman ni
06:53.9
Sen. Vice President
06:55.5
Sao Duterte, of course,
06:56.7
clearly denied this.
06:58.8
But, the concern right now
07:00.7
is bakit ganito?
07:01.2
I-post ko yung
07:01.8
ah, yung
07:02.8
nung
07:03.7
Sinera ko yung video.
07:05.2
O, eto po.
07:06.3
O, eto po.
07:06.7
Si Sir,
07:07.3
si Sir Janus Monar.
07:09.5
Kaya nagbulat po kami
07:10.3
kasi akala namin
07:11.3
yung Station Commander
07:13.1
ay makay.
07:14.5
Pero,
07:15.4
kasi
07:15.7
Police Antonia
07:17.1
yung nag-file
07:17.7
sabi ko, bakit?
07:19.1
Eh, siya mismo yung
07:20.2
nagsabi na,
07:20.8
oo, oo, dadaan siya.
07:22.7
And then, siya pa yung
07:23.9
nagreklamo.
07:25.5
At magulat din po ako
07:26.5
with the filing of
07:28.2
child abuse.
07:29.1
No, parang
07:29.6
ang dali-daling
07:31.3
manira ng pangalan.
07:32.9
Kasi,
07:33.4
I filled up my reputation
07:35.0
for 18 years already
07:36.2
as a teacher.
07:37.8
Eh, wala akong
07:38.5
inabusong bata.
07:40.4
Pero,
07:40.9
ngayon sinasampahan ako
07:42.0
ng child abuse.
07:43.0
Kaya nagbulat ako.
07:43.8
Siguro,
07:44.7
I feel,
07:45.5
kung totoo man yun,
07:46.8
I feel the reaction
07:47.9
ng bata.
07:48.8
Pero,
07:49.7
parang ang layo.
07:50.5
Kasi,
07:50.8
hindi ko siniraan.
07:52.5
Wala akong ginawang
07:53.1
paninira doon sa police.
07:54.6
No,
07:55.3
pinost ko yung...
07:56.4
So,
07:58.6
eh, ito,
07:59.2
of course,
07:59.7
may maintain
08:01.0
ng si Sir,
08:02.8
si teacher
08:03.5
Monar,
08:04.8
na walang basihan
08:06.6
itong accusation
08:07.8
ng child abuse,
08:08.6
et cetera.
08:09.1
And, you know,
08:09.4
he's wondering
08:10.6
if this has to do
08:11.8
something about
08:12.5
yung post ng video
08:14.3
na yan,
08:14.7
or this was a way
08:15.9
of trying to silence him
08:17.2
or intimidating,
08:18.3
et cetera.
08:18.8
So,
08:19.4
ito po,
08:19.8
of course,
08:20.8
big issue yan.
08:22.2
Hindi ito nga yung dadaan.
08:23.5
So,
08:24.3
I put it in the
08:25.5
comment or in the
08:27.0
comment.
08:28.9
Kasi,
08:30.0
gaya po nang sabi
08:30.7
ni Atorne,
08:31.9
it's our expression
08:33.9
of freedom of speech pa.
08:37.4
So, parang,
08:38.4
ako kasi gusto ko lang
08:39.4
magpapalabas
08:41.4
sa social media
08:42.5
na parang
08:43.0
too much din naman
08:44.4
yung patigilin mo
08:45.6
yung buong
08:46.2
world
08:47.0
para ikaw ay dadaan.
08:48.9
And, with the
08:49.4
pronouncement of
08:50.5
police
08:51.7
Antoliano naman na
08:53.0
si
08:53.3
Diti nga yung dadaan.
08:55.4
So,
08:56.1
I put it in the
08:57.3
comment or in the
08:58.7
caption
09:00.3
na
09:01.3
dadaan daw.
09:03.3
Which,
09:04.1
I refer to
09:05.2
what
09:05.7
Antoliano said,
09:07.6
dadaan na.
09:08.4
So, ako,
09:09.2
dadaan daw
09:10.0
si Diti Sara.
09:11.5
So,
09:12.5
bigyan ang daan yan
09:13.4
sa atin.
09:14.0
Pero,
09:15.2
I also quote there
09:16.5
the confidential
09:17.3
queen.
09:18.0
Siguro doon sila
09:18.8
nainis.
09:19.6
Kasi,
09:20.5
well,
09:21.2
I am only following
09:22.5
kasi yung issue
09:23.2
noon ng confidential
09:24.1
issue with regards
09:25.5
to the vice president.
09:27.4
Kasi ngayon,
09:27.9
paggastaan,
09:28.5
parang excessive
09:29.4
din naman yung 11 days
09:30.6
na gastis yung
09:31.2
lahat yung
09:32.2
budget na yun.
09:35.3
And,
09:35.8
I really want
09:36.3
my students also
09:37.0
to see na
09:37.7
ito parang
09:38.5
abuse of power
09:39.3
na hindi
09:39.6
ginagawin.
09:41.1
Kaya,
09:41.7
ako,
09:42.3
with all those
09:43.7
contemporary issues ko,
09:44.9
nagbibigay daw
09:45.5
ako ng comment.
09:46.5
Sir,
09:47.1
so you think
09:47.7
ang nag-file talaga nito
09:48.8
ay yung
09:49.4
police,
09:50.5
officer,
09:51.3
or somebody else
09:52.0
is behind this?
09:53.8
Um,
09:54.4
hindi ko po alam
09:55.3
ano kaya
09:55.8
somebody's behind this.
09:59.3
Kaya nagulat ko
09:59.9
tamang...
10:00.5
Wait lang,
10:01.4
si Atty. Jokno pala
10:02.6
yung abagado niya.
10:03.7
Wait lang,
10:04.6
sabi ko,
10:05.0
sino yung abagado niya?
10:06.1
Yung pala si Atty. Jokno,
10:07.2
of course.
10:07.8
So, you know,
10:08.2
alam niyo naman,
10:09.3
si Senator Candidate,
10:11.8
former Senator Candidate,
10:12.8
and of course,
10:13.8
Dean and Atty. Jokno,
10:15.5
isa sa mga
10:16.0
leading human rights
10:16.9
lawyers ng bansa.
10:17.9
At nakikita nyo naman
10:18.5
na talagang tumutulong
10:19.6
siya dito.
10:20.5
Sa mga...
10:21.7
Alam natin,
10:22.5
nung pandemic time pa lang,
10:23.7
actually way before that,
10:25.0
pero pandemic time pa lang,
10:26.6
you know,
10:27.0
Atty. Jokno,
10:28.5
who we also interviewed
10:29.5
dito sa podcast natin
10:30.5
during election period,
10:31.8
really took up the cudgels
10:32.9
dun sa mga citizens
10:34.2
na sinishot down
10:35.1
at minuweaponize
10:36.0
ang cyber libel law
10:37.9
sa mga others
10:38.4
para ma-intimidate
10:39.3
sa mga kametan.
10:41.1
So, eto po,
10:42.6
just be...
10:44.3
So, eto po,
10:45.1
kasama niya si
10:46.1
Atty. Chell Jokno,
10:47.6
eto yung magagaling
10:48.5
ng mga Atty.
10:49.1
Eto mga Atty.
10:50.1
talaga,
10:50.5
na alam nyo naman,
10:52.1
they're fighting
10:52.9
for human rights,
10:54.2
they're fighting
10:54.5
for the concerns of people,
10:55.5
and speaking of which,
10:56.6
eto, eto,
10:57.8
tignan naman natin
10:58.8
yung sinabi ni Atty. Jokno,
11:01.1
din Jokno,
11:02.6
kasi ano e,
11:05.1
guys, mahalaga yung
11:06.0
mga ganitong cases.
11:07.2
Kung ikaw yung
11:08.1
simpleng mamayan,
11:09.4
tapos may
11:09.8
nakuha kang video
11:11.7
na sinishare mo lang
11:13.1
yung potential
11:14.2
abuse of power
11:15.1
or allegedly,
11:15.9
tapos biglang maganyan ka,
11:17.3
anong gusto natin
11:19.1
mangyari dito?
11:20.1
Diba?
11:20.5
Kung buro,
11:21.5
ang tinutukoy nila,
11:22.8
malamang,
11:23.4
although we don't really know,
11:25.1
ay yung spreading
11:25.9
of false news.
11:26.8
Pero wala naman
11:27.5
false doon sa
11:28.8
sa na-share na video.
11:30.9
Dahil yun ay
11:32.0
talagang,
11:33.8
hindi,
11:34.1
pati si Pantaleano
11:35.3
sinabi naman yun,
11:36.2
na yun din
11:36.7
ang talagang
11:37.3
binanggit niya
11:38.3
nung in-interview siya
11:39.4
ng hindi na kilalang
11:40.8
na videographer.
11:42.3
R.A.
11:43.1
Article 154,
11:44.8
na nagpatakaling kami
11:45.8
ng spreading
11:46.4
of false news,
11:47.9
publishing of
11:48.7
printed material
11:49.9
without
11:50.3
attribution,
11:51.6
fusilio and author,
11:53.1
may mga ganon.
11:54.2
Pero doon sa complaint,
11:55.3
hindi naman nakalagay
11:56.2
kung alin doon
11:57.1
ang kinomit na offense
11:58.7
ng complaint ko.
12:01.0
Siguro,
12:01.7
ang tinutukoy nila,
12:03.0
malamang,
12:03.5
although we don't really know,
12:05.3
ay yung spreading
12:06.1
of false news.
12:07.0
Pero wala naman
12:07.7
false doon sa
12:08.9
sa na-share na video.
12:11.1
Dahil yun ay
12:12.2
talagang,
12:14.0
hindi,
12:14.3
pati si Pantaleano
12:15.4
sinabi naman yun,
12:16.4
na yun din
12:16.9
ang talagang
12:17.5
binanggit niya
12:18.5
nung in-interview siya
12:19.6
ng video.
12:20.0
So,
12:20.0
hindi,
12:20.1
hindi,
12:20.1
hindi,
12:20.1
hindi,
12:20.2
hindi na kilala
12:20.9
ng videographer.
12:22.4
So, yun po.
12:25.1
So, nangita natin
12:25.9
yung explanation
12:26.8
from Atty. Jokno,
12:28.1
at ang concern niya dito
12:29.6
is how on earth
12:31.2
the Article 154
12:32.9
of the Revised Penal Code
12:34.0
ay applicable dito
12:34.9
sa case na
12:35.3
because yung video na
12:36.9
was essentially
12:38.0
quoting,
12:38.9
right,
12:39.4
a policeman
12:40.0
on the record
12:41.0
saying that
12:42.1
a certain high-level
12:43.4
official,
12:44.1
blah, blah, blah.
12:44.8
So,
12:45.4
bakit siya yung
12:46.7
sinisisiya?
12:47.4
He's just
12:48.5
transmitting the
12:49.4
information
12:50.2
that is being
12:51.1
publicly
12:51.6
shared by
12:53.2
isang
12:53.6
essentially,
12:54.8
you know,
12:55.2
public official,
12:57.1
diba?
12:57.4
So, at,
12:58.3
of course,
12:59.1
the other more
12:59.7
concerning dito,
13:00.6
mga kameta,
13:01.2
is hindi lang dito sa
13:02.4
potential libel aspect
13:04.8
dito,
13:05.3
yung cyber libel aspect
13:06.3
dito,
13:06.7
but there's also
13:07.6
this aspect,
13:08.3
no,
13:08.6
na inakusa
13:09.4
ng other
13:11.7
criminal charges
13:12.6
na very,
13:13.5
very serious
13:14.1
and, you know,
13:14.8
very unfair
13:16.4
para sa
13:17.1
itong inakusa
13:18.0
na tiyo.
13:18.3
Hindi namin ma-gets
13:19.5
kung ba,
13:20.0
bakit may charge
13:21.6
na gano'n?
13:22.5
Ano explanation
13:23.5
niya?
13:23.8
Bakit may charge?
13:24.6
In what sense
13:25.2
may child abuse?
13:26.1
Well,
13:26.3
ang nakamitin sa
13:26.9
complaint,
13:27.5
sa piningi-complaint
13:28.4
ng Pantuliano,
13:29.4
na nakita daw
13:30.9
ng anak niya
13:31.6
na minor
13:32.3
yung video
13:33.6
at na trauma
13:34.4
daw siya.
13:36.7
Pero,
13:37.3
sa tingin namin,
13:38.0
talaga naman
13:38.6
unfounded
13:39.3
yung charge
13:40.5
na yun
13:40.9
dahil
13:41.7
ang ginawa
13:42.6
naman ng
13:43.1
kliyente ko
13:43.6
ay tulad
13:44.6
ng ginagawa
13:45.2
ng mga
13:45.5
million na
13:46.0
Pilipino
13:46.4
na sinare
13:47.1
niya ng
13:47.6
video
13:48.4
ng isang
13:50.0
public official
13:50.8
performing
13:51.5
public function
13:52.5
sa isang
13:53.4
public place.
13:54.5
Dahil,
13:54.7
ang nasa video
13:55.5
naman,
13:56.4
si Sergeant Pantuliano
13:58.0
na nag-geta-traffic
13:59.3
at sa
14:00.9
Commonwealth Avenue.
14:02.0
Kaya,
14:02.2
sa tingin namin,
14:03.0
wala naman
14:03.4
masama
14:05.6
at walang
14:06.0
iligal
14:06.5
doon yung ginawa niya.
14:07.9
Hindi namin
14:08.4
ma-gets
14:09.3
kung...
14:09.4
Yes, so,
14:09.9
medyo parang
14:10.8
na-weird
14:11.6
na natitweet.
14:12.2
Parang,
14:12.6
what?
14:13.0
Parang naging
14:13.3
child abuse
14:14.0
yung case na yan.
14:15.0
But,
14:15.5
but this is
14:15.9
what's very important
14:16.7
mga kameta.
14:17.4
This is the most
14:17.9
important part dito.
14:19.5
Because,
14:19.8
dito,
14:20.0
makikita nyo talaga
14:20.6
what is the broader
14:21.6
political impact
14:22.6
ng ganitong
14:23.3
situation
14:23.9
and how this is
14:24.6
potentially very unhealthy
14:26.3
if not destructive
14:27.7
para sa ating
14:28.3
demokrasya.
14:29.1
So,
14:29.3
tignan natin
14:29.6
ang explanation
14:30.1
ni Atty. Chokno dito.
14:31.9
Diba?
14:32.5
And he has been
14:33.1
consistent about this
14:34.0
throughout the years.
14:34.9
Please check this again.
14:36.2
So,
14:36.4
ito ah.
14:37.7
Ito yung concern niya.
14:38.7
So,
14:39.0
following the logic
14:42.6
ng pag-file ng
14:43.9
complaint
14:44.4
laban kay Janus,
14:45.6
ang ibig sabihin nun
14:46.5
ay kahit sino
14:47.5
ay pwede rin
14:48.2
kasungan
14:48.7
kung sila
14:49.4
ay nag-share.
14:50.0
At doon din kami
14:51.2
nababaaga
14:52.0
dahil
14:52.9
may chilling effect
14:54.5
yung mga ganitong
14:55.3
pag-amit ng batas eh.
14:57.5
Ano nakita natin
14:58.5
kahit ng pandemia
14:59.4
na
14:59.8
pag meron
15:00.7
nagpupus
15:01.3
na
15:02.5
hindi nagugustuhan
15:03.8
ng mga nasa
15:04.7
pwesto
15:05.2
ay
15:06.0
nakakasuhan
15:07.1
minsan.
15:07.4
Ito yung exciting
15:07.9
decision bang
15:08.9
pinapayag na
15:10.0
pinapasuhan naman
15:11.4
at that is
15:12.0
support.
15:12.8
Kaya
15:13.3
nakakababag
15:14.5
yung chilling effect
15:15.4
ng pag-file.
15:16.7
May nakakasuhan.
15:18.3
So, ito ah.
15:19.0
Yung chilling effect
15:19.8
ma,
15:20.0
mga kameta,
15:20.5
yun yung concern
15:21.3
talaga dito.
15:22.5
Aside from the
15:23.5
distressed
15:25.2
and troubles
15:26.2
caused dito
15:26.9
sa isang private
15:27.6
citizen,
15:28.4
isang simpleng guro.
15:30.9
Interesting disaster
15:31.7
or something,
15:32.6
you know.
15:33.4
Secretary of
15:33.9
Security.
15:34.2
Anyway,
15:34.9
so,
15:35.5
ang sinasabi niya
15:36.2
ato rin,
15:36.4
joke na,
15:36.8
is that
15:37.0
is warning of
15:37.6
a chilling effect
15:38.2
dito sa
15:38.6
finding of
15:39.0
this kind of
15:39.4
cases when
15:39.9
laws are used
15:40.6
against critics
15:41.2
of the government
15:41.8
citing similar
15:42.6
cases filed
15:43.2
during the
15:43.5
pandemic
15:44.0
against those
15:44.7
who expressed
15:45.2
their criticisms
15:45.9
online.
15:46.5
Diba,
15:46.6
yun ang minensyon
15:47.1
natin mga kameta
15:47.8
noong 2021-2022.
15:49.6
Ang dami
15:50.0
mga ordinaryong
15:51.5
mga mga mayan
15:52.2
ay nag-complain
15:53.2
lang doon sa
15:53.7
government handling
15:54.6
or kapalpakan
15:55.4
doon sa handling
15:56.1
ng pandemic
15:56.7
na alam naman
15:57.3
natin daming
15:57.9
kapalpakan.
15:58.6
Diba,
15:58.8
I mean,
15:59.4
my goodness,
15:60.0
diba?
16:00.6
And then the next
16:01.1
thing yun,
16:01.4
na sinisiber
16:02.7
libel sila,
16:04.0
mga kung ano,
16:04.5
ganyan-ganyan.
16:05.6
When,
16:05.9
you know,
16:06.1
anyone who
16:07.0
bothers to check
16:07.8
all of the
16:08.6
comparative studies,
16:11.2
all of the studies,
16:11.9
rankings,
16:12.4
parating kulala
16:13.0
ng Pilipinas
16:13.6
through the
16:14.4
thick of the
16:15.4
pandemic,
16:16.1
2021,
16:17.3
2020,
16:18.1
et cetera.
16:18.7
And then,
16:19.2
bandang dulo na,
16:19.9
medyo naging
16:20.4
okay na ba
16:21.0
ng aid?
16:21.8
You get what I'm saying?
16:22.9
So,
16:23.1
this is the problem.
16:23.9
So,
16:24.0
ito ulit ha.
16:24.8
So,
16:25.0
ito yung,
16:25.7
ang complainant po
16:26.6
ay PMS
16:27.4
Verdo
16:28.0
Pantoliano
16:29.4
na nag-claim po siya
16:30.6
na hindi siya
16:31.3
intentionally
16:32.2
pronounced
16:33.4
ng word
16:33.8
ng VP.
16:37.4
Okay,
16:38.2
alright.
16:38.7
Ito,
16:39.0
ito,
16:39.1
post natin dito
16:39.9
mga kameta.
16:43.2
So,
16:43.7
ito po yung mga kameta.
16:45.0
So,
16:45.1
ito,
16:45.4
ito.
16:49.9
Ah,
16:54.3
yung pala yung
16:54.7
counter-affidabit.
16:55.7
One second,
16:56.1
labas ko lang tong
16:56.8
original complaint
16:58.4
para naman makita nyo
16:59.4
on your own,
17:00.0
mga kameta.
17:02.9
Talagang Pilipinas,
17:04.4
talagang minamahal
17:05.3
natin bayan.
17:06.7
Diba?
17:07.1
Talagang ibang klase
17:07.9
ng demokrasya natin.
17:13.4
Ang hirap
17:14.1
maging mabait
17:14.8
ng mga mayan,
17:15.6
matinong mga mayan.
17:16.5
So,
17:16.6
ito po ha.
17:18.0
So,
17:18.6
yung complainant po,
17:19.9
ay yung si
17:20.5
Verdo Pantoliano
17:22.0
na sinabi niya
17:22.9
na hindi niya
17:23.7
intentionally na-pronounce
17:24.7
the word VP.
17:25.7
So,
17:26.0
anong gusto niya
17:26.4
i-pronounce?
17:27.8
If not VP,
17:28.5
then what?
17:30.4
VIP?
17:31.7
VIP?
17:32.7
VP?
17:33.2
VIP?
17:34.1
Maybe?
17:34.6
I don't know.
17:35.3
When answering yung,
17:36.7
ito si teacher
17:38.4
na,
17:39.9
you know,
17:41.2
anong drama dito?
17:43.1
Bakit sinasara yung
17:43.8
Commonwealth
17:44.2
or something like that?
17:45.2
At itong complainant,
17:46.8
sinasabi niya,
17:47.4
yung kanyang
17:47.7
13-year-old daughter
17:48.7
ay experience
17:49.4
overwhelming trauma,
17:51.3
psychological
17:51.9
and emotional stress
17:53.1
dahil dito sa video
17:54.4
na yan.
17:54.8
So,
17:55.2
okay.
17:56.7
So,
17:57.1
ito po.
17:58.4
So,
17:59.0
ang sinasabi dito,
18:00.0
yung complaint po,
18:00.9
ay violation of
18:01.6
Article 154
18:02.6
of the Revised Penal Code
18:03.9
or unlawful use
18:05.2
of means of publication
18:06.3
on lawful
18:06.9
utterances
18:07.9
and violation of
18:08.8
RA 7610
18:10.2
Special Protection
18:11.2
of Children
18:11.6
Against Children Abuse
18:12.5
Exploitation Discrimination Act
18:13.9
all in relation
18:15.0
to violation of
18:15.8
RA 10175.
18:17.9
Ito,
18:18.0
importante mga kameta.
18:19.4
Cybercrime Prevention Act
18:20.8
of 2012
18:21.7
against
18:22.7
here in person
18:23.8
yung nag-upload
18:24.9
ng viral video na
18:25.8
oh yeah,
18:26.7
tatawid si
18:27.4
VIP Sarah
18:28.5
the Confidential Queen
18:29.6
bigyan daw
18:31.8
daan yan.
18:33.5
Yan,
18:33.8
si Sir Janus M.
18:35.4
Monar.
18:35.9
So,
18:36.1
please check it out.
18:37.5
Ito po yung
18:37.9
nagkita nyo dyan
18:39.1
yung copy ng complaint.
18:40.4
So,
18:41.2
of course,
18:42.9
aside from the
18:43.4
personal distress
18:44.3
that is also causing
18:45.3
the
18:46.3
Sir Teacher Janus,
18:48.4
because these are
18:50.4
very grave charges,
18:51.7
the other concern
18:52.5
also here is
18:53.3
you're creating
18:54.0
a lot of chilling effect.
18:55.1
Very, very troubling
18:56.1
chilling effect.
18:56.7
So, ito po yung concern
18:57.4
dito
18:57.8
ng
18:58.9
ni Atty. Jock
19:00.6
among other
19:01.4
civil rights
19:03.3
and human rights
19:04.1
activists.
19:04.9
Now, of course,
19:05.5
let's see how the court
19:06.3
will handle this issue
19:07.3
if madismiss
19:08.1
itong case na to,
19:08.9
if this is gonna prosper
19:09.9
in any way.
19:10.4
Now,
19:11.2
obviously,
19:11.6
in one way or another,
19:12.3
this is,
19:13.4
we mentioned already
19:14.0
the Delima case,
19:14.8
we're mentioning this case.
19:16.2
Now,
19:16.5
we have to also mention
19:17.8
another important,
19:18.4
important case
19:19.7
which is still pending
19:21.3
and this could go
19:22.1
all the way to the
19:22.7
highest court of the land.
19:24.7
At ito po yung case
19:25.5
ni former congressman
19:27.1
Professor Walden Belio.
19:30.5
So, most recently,
19:31.8
ito po yung development niya,
19:32.9
yung korte po,
19:33.8
sa Davao yata to,
19:34.7
called for mediation
19:36.6
dito sa case na yan,
19:39.1
dun sa case ni
19:40.5
former congressman Belio
19:41.8
at saka yung isang
19:43.5
top aide
19:44.4
ni vice president ngayon.
19:47.5
So, ito po,
19:48.4
the trial is supposed
19:52.8
to proceed
19:53.9
unless, you know,
19:55.4
Congressman Belio
19:56.2
and Jeffrey Tupas
19:57.4
reach an out-of-court settlement.
19:58.9
Now, I'm not in position
20:00.0
to share details about this.
20:01.2
Maybe later on,
20:02.1
we can interview the people
20:02.9
involved here
20:03.4
so that they can tell us.
20:04.1
So, just to give you
20:05.0
a latest update,
20:05.9
the original court in Davao
20:07.5
has ordered Vice President
20:08.4
Saed Duterte's
20:09.0
Media and Public Relations
20:10.0
Chief and 2022
20:11.5
Vice President
20:12.3
General Kenny Walden
20:13.1
Belio to go to a mediator
20:14.1
and explore the possibility
20:15.1
of out-of-court settlement
20:16.4
in connection to
20:17.5
sa cyber-like
20:18.4
libel case.
20:19.8
Si Belio has been charged
20:20.9
with maligning
20:21.4
former Davao City
20:22.5
Information Officer
20:23.4
when he made yung isang
20:24.5
reference to
20:25.2
criticism of Duterte
20:26.9
during the election period
20:28.1
according to the
20:28.8
November 16, 2020
20:29.8
court order.
20:31.9
Yung complainant
20:33.5
is currently
20:33.9
Duterte's Media and Public
20:34.9
Relations Division Head
20:35.9
on Facebook.
20:36.7
Belio alleged that
20:38.2
this person was
20:39.8
So, ito.
20:42.5
So, ang konteksto yung
20:43.6
isang pinost niya
20:44.6
ng 2021
20:48.4
So, what the camp
20:50.6
of Walden Belio
20:51.3
is saying that
20:52.0
the allegedly
20:54.8
libelous statements
20:56.6
against yung sa kabila
20:58.1
this was just a reflection
21:00.2
what was already
21:01.3
out there in the news
21:03.2
that this was not a claim
21:04.6
out of thin air
21:05.5
but this was already
21:06.5
openly being mentioned
21:09.5
dun sa mainstream media
21:10.8
you can check the article
21:11.5
on yourself
21:11.9
for all of the details
21:13.3
Now, the other camp
21:16.7
is saying
21:17.0
that was directly
21:18.1
libelous
21:18.6
kaya ngayon
21:19.2
some are wondering
21:20.2
just to
21:21.7
just to make sure
21:24.5
na
21:24.9
you know
21:27.4
hindi potentially
21:28.2
ma-weaponize
21:29.8
ang mga ganitong
21:30.7
situations
21:31.7
is that
21:32.9
why not just
21:33.7
decriminalize libel
21:34.8
but make it a civil case
21:36.2
so if in case
21:37.4
we have this
21:38.3
for instance
21:38.8
in other places
21:40.0
like the United States
21:40.7
so kung baka
21:41.2
kung may
21:41.5
there's someone
21:42.5
who spread
21:43.0
really maliciously
21:44.0
intentionally malicious
21:44.9
thing against you
21:46.3
then you know
21:46.8
you can go for
21:47.7
a civil case
21:48.0
and go for
21:49.6
for damages
21:50.9
in that case
21:52.1
but once you criminalize
21:54.1
libel
21:54.7
and now with the new
21:55.9
cyber libel laws
21:56.9
among others
21:57.8
hmm
21:58.6
suddenly people are wondering
21:59.9
madali na i-weaponize yan
22:02.0
because ayaw mo
22:02.6
yung sinabi ni ganito
22:03.5
immediately
22:04.3
i-accusan mo ng cyber libel
22:05.7
then because the charge
22:06.6
is very big
22:07.4
then next thing you know
22:08.2
my goodness
22:08.8
everything is gonna change
22:09.8
for the worse
22:10.3
so this is a very serious issue
22:12.1
mga kamila
22:12.5
this is a very serious issue
22:13.6
and unfortunately
22:14.7
lahat ng mga tao
22:15.6
na involved sa public
22:16.5
sphere discussion
22:17.3
alam mo naman
22:17.7
lahat ng mga tao
22:18.0
in one way or another
22:19.0
we've had to deal
22:20.1
with the shadow
22:20.6
of potential weaponization
22:23.2
of
22:23.8
of
22:24.6
libel suits
22:26.1
now of course
22:26.6
the Duterte camp
22:27.4
maintains that
22:28.3
you know
22:28.6
there has to be
22:29.8
you know
22:30.7
a proper reassessment
22:32.4
of itong cyber law
22:33.8
natin
22:34.8
and making sure
22:36.2
na hindi siya maweaponize
22:37.2
of course the other
22:37.8
camp is naman saying
22:38.5
libel is yung sinabi
22:39.6
so let's see
22:40.1
how the courts
22:40.8
are gonna
22:41.2
proceed with this
22:43.3
or whether this is
22:44.0
gonna move to a higher court
22:45.4
let's see what's gonna
22:46.2
happen on this
22:46.8
as you know
22:47.8
right now
22:48.5
Supreme Court of the Philippines
22:49.5
is also about
22:50.5
to check a number
22:51.7
of other petitions
22:52.7
petitions that have to do
22:54.5
with the
22:55.7
another legacy
22:56.5
of the Duterte
22:57.0
administration
22:57.6
which is yung
22:58.3
free of information
22:60.0
act
23:02.3
executive order
23:03.2
which in some way
23:04.9
paradoxical
23:05.7
or perhaps
23:06.3
not so paradoxically
23:07.3
enabled
23:09.1
itong proliferation
23:10.8
ng confidential funds
23:11.8
so that's another
23:12.5
legal issue
23:13.0
that we can discuss
23:13.8
later on
23:14.2
so we're
23:14.6
I'm hoping to
23:16.6
do a couple of
23:17.7
collaborations
23:18.4
so one of the other
23:19.4
collaborations we're
23:20.1
looking at is also
23:20.8
to do a
23:21.8
kind of a joint podcast
23:23.2
with the legal expert
23:24.4
top legal expert
23:25.8
para naman may
23:26.3
pagka law and order
23:27.5
tulfo style din tayo
23:28.8
but you know
23:29.2
like really
23:30.0
law and order discussion
23:31.3
of course the other
23:31.9
thing we're also
23:32.4
looking at mga
23:32.9
kamender right now
23:33.6
is collaboration
23:34.7
with also some other
23:35.5
like-minded
23:36.2
or some other
23:37.2
progressive
23:38.3
youtubers
23:39.0
influencers
23:39.7
and journalists
23:40.8
and in that context
23:41.7
of course I also
23:42.3
mentioned
23:42.9
itong potential
23:44.2
collaboration
23:44.9
with yung kaibigan natin
23:46.1
si Christian Esquerra
23:47.1
something like an
23:47.7
RRC
23:48.6
or CRR
23:49.7
or whatever
23:50.3
hindi CRR
23:50.9
doesn't sound good
23:51.8
does it
23:52.4
RRC na lang
23:53.4
so Ronaldo
23:54.4
Ricardo
23:55.0
and Cristiano
23:56.4
right
23:57.6
Cristiano Ronaldo
23:58.6
yung pala naman
23:59.2
Cristiano
23:59.8
tsaka Ronaldo
24:01.0
Cristiano Ronaldo
24:02.2
yun okay
24:03.0
so let's see
24:03.6
if we can also do
24:04.3
those kind of collaborations
24:05.4
because yung nga
24:05.9
yun
24:06.5
ang daming po nangyara
24:07.4
sa ating bansa
24:08.1
and it's always good
24:09.1
to have multiple people
24:10.4
no
24:10.8
to share their views
24:11.7
and we
24:12.8
we also look at ways
24:14.2
to make sure na
24:15.6
medyo 300
24:16.4
300
24:17.0
di 300
24:17.6
180 degrees
24:18.7
no hindi 360
24:19.6
180 degrees talaga
24:20.8
titignan natin
24:21.4
itong isya
24:21.9
isang isya na ito
24:22.8
we look at all of the
24:23.8
dimensions of that
24:24.7
and then of course
24:25.6
as I said mga kameta
24:26.6
we're also looking at
24:27.4
setting up some
24:28.0
other joint
24:28.7
podcasts including
24:30.3
with you know
24:31.2
one of the leading
24:31.8
legal minds in the country
24:33.8
para naman pag-usapan din natin
24:35.1
yung legal aspects
24:35.9
so there's so many things
24:36.8
that I want to discuss
24:37.6
for instance
24:38.2
yung mga petitions
24:39.2
sa Supreme Court
24:40.0
confidential funds
24:41.4
and their constitutionality
24:42.7
cyber libel
24:43.7
so maraming pwede
24:44.4
pag-usapan mga kameta
24:45.4
so don't worry about it
24:46.4
siniset up
24:47.6
at natin lahat yan
24:48.5
so thank you so much
24:49.6
sa lahat ng mga sumusuporta
24:50.7
at nagmamahal sa atin
24:51.8
your support
24:53.0
is what's encouraging us
24:54.3
your support
24:54.8
is what's allowing us
24:55.7
to keep on going
24:56.5
despite all of the harassment
24:58.0
all of the insults
24:59.0
all of the stressful things
25:00.0
so please lang
25:01.2
tuloy-tuloy sana
25:01.9
yung supportan niya
25:02.5
para lang magagawa natin yan
25:03.7
and don't worry
25:04.6
I'm looking at
25:06.0
all sorts of different
25:06.7
collaboration
25:07.3
kasi mag-isa lang naman ako
25:08.3
there's just
25:08.8
you know as magaling
25:10.3
as I may think I am
25:11.6
there's just so much
25:12.8
I can contribute
25:13.4
on my own
25:14.2
on my own alone
25:15.4
so kung sana
25:16.3
we can work with
25:17.0
other people
25:17.6
who have different expertise
25:18.7
constitutional law expertise
25:20.2
journalist expertise
25:21.6
political advice expertise
25:22.8
so Ronald
25:23.4
Christian Asguera
25:24.6
mayroon tayong kaibigan
25:27.1
na isang attorney
25:28.0
na we're also looking
25:28.7
at doing collaborations
25:29.7
so yun
25:30.5
alright
25:31.1
Cristiano Ronaldo
25:32.9
Ricardo
25:33.6
alright
25:34.3
yun po yung tinitignan natin
25:35.5
alright
25:35.8
CR2
25:36.7
hindi pa rin magandang
25:38.3
tignan eh
25:39.0
buti pa yung CR7
25:40.5
Cristiano Ronaldo
25:41.3
number 7
25:42.1
ito
25:42.4
CR squared
25:44.5
yung mga ganon
25:45.5
CR squared
25:47.3
CR squared
25:47.6
alright
25:48.1
pag-usapan natin yun
25:49.2
alright
25:49.5
so looking
25:50.5
please please
25:51.6
continue to support us
25:52.4
and don't worry
25:53.2
I'm constantly
25:54.1
ganito kasi sa
25:56.1
kultura natin sa Pilipinas
25:57.6
talagang individualistic
25:58.6
ang tao eh
25:59.2
so
25:59.6
it's so hard
26:01.2
to organize people
26:02.3
and bring them together
26:03.1
so you have no idea
26:04.4
how much effort
26:05.0
I put in to bring
26:05.9
different people together
26:06.9
and naging lucky tayo
26:08.4
dyan mga katulad ni Ronald
26:09.9
katulad ni Leloy
26:11.3
katulad ni Mark
26:12.1
and hopefully
26:12.6
God willing soon
26:13.4
katulad din ni Christian
26:14.9
para pag-usapan natin
26:16.5
ito
26:16.8
mga bagay
26:17.5
bagay and of course
26:18.2
we're also arranging
26:19.0
with legal minds
26:20.1
and experts etc
26:20.9
para may mga
26:21.6
legal analysis din tayo
26:23.3
very detailed
26:24.0
legal analysis din tayo
26:25.3
para naman mga kameta
26:26.5
ma-appreciate yun talaga
26:27.4
yung mga meta natin
26:28.5
we become really
26:29.4
the ultimate source of
26:31.0
public intellectual discussion
26:33.1
and public information
26:34.1
for that matter
26:34.8
para naman ma-empower tayo
26:36.2
as citizens
26:36.7
because we are not gonna be
26:37.5
empowered as citizens
26:38.2
if we do not know
26:39.3
the basics of our law
26:40.8
the basics of our
26:41.7
political system
26:42.9
the basics of our
26:43.8
foreign policy
26:44.5
the basics of
26:45.3
West Philippine Sea
26:46.4
issues
26:47.5
and others
26:47.8
so maraming salamat
26:48.9
thank you very much guys
26:49.9
and please also
26:50.8
ito na
26:51.4
I think this week na nag-start
26:52.7
yung show natin ulit
26:53.9
second season
26:54.9
ng The View from Manila
26:56.0
on One News TV 5
26:57.4
so yung mga may cable
26:58.5
or sa mga YouTube
26:59.3
please abangan nyo yan
27:00.8
this week
27:01.5
ang interview po natin
27:02.6
is Ambassador Eduardo de Vega
27:04.2
discussing yung
27:05.8
conflict sa Israel
27:06.9
and Gaza
27:07.5
and impact dun sa mga
27:09.0
Pilipino
27:09.5
or mga Filipino citizens
27:10.5
of course in the area
27:11.4
and also this week
27:13.4
we'll have
27:13.9
Undersecretary
27:14.8
and Spokesman
27:15.3
for the National Secret Council
27:16.4
Jonathan
27:17.5
Malaya
27:17.9
so this week pa lang
27:18.8
hopefully we'll have
27:19.2
two different shows
27:20.3
on View from Manila
27:21.1
and we also taped
27:22.1
some other ones
27:23.2
more interesting people
27:24.8
not no one more
27:26.4
just as interesting people
27:28.1
as in more of
27:29.3
interesting people
27:30.2
or also
27:30.8
we're gonna interview
27:32.2
in the coming days
27:33.0
and weeks
27:33.5
God willing
27:33.9
so please continue
27:34.7
to support us
27:35.2
mga kameta
27:35.7
thank you very much
27:36.9
God bless
27:37.4
and talk to you soon
27:38.6
maraming salamat po
27:39.5
God bless