Close
 


I NEED TO SEE RAFFY TULFO vs. CYNTHIA VILLAR
Hide Subtitles
Click any subtitle word to view Tagalog.com dictionary results.
Computer Shortcuts: Left / Right arrows to jump 2 seconds back or forward. +Enter or Space to toggle Play/Pause button. Full Screen Mode
TELL IT TO THE MARINES RAFFY TULFO!- CYNTHIA VILLAR Eto po bagong FB natin para sa videos: https://www.facebook.com/BATASnatin-107860591437195 https://www.facebook.com/Atty-Ranny-Randolf-B-Libayan-154012243457531 Alternate YT channel po for livestreams: https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCskZGSV52krMvXgb8OXXx1g WEBSITE: https://batasnatin.com/ LAW FIRM: https://firm.batasnatin.com/ FACEBOOK PAGE: https://www.facebook.com/BATASnatin/ INSTAGRAM: https://www.instagram.com/batasnatin/ YOUTUBE CHANNEL: https://youtube.com/BATASnatinLive TWITTER: https://twitter.com/BATASnatin LAWYERS: Atty. Kristina Louise Magalong Atty. Ranny Randolf B. Libayan FIRM ADDRESS: #31 Gen. Luna St., Tuktukan, Taguig City, NCR (Across Taguig City Hall) Email: BATASnatin@gmail.com Telephone nos: +63915-954-6080 (+632)359-4203 We are a full-service Law Firm We handle and are experienced in litigating many kinds of cases. Please do not hesitate to contact us. We will be happy to ass
Atty. Ranny Randolf B. Libayan
  Mute  
Run time: 34:06
Has AI Subtitles



Video Transcript / Subtitles:( AI generated. About AI subtitles » )
00:00.0
All right, yan. Magandang araw mga kabatas natin at welcome sa isa namang live stream.
00:06.7
Mga kabatas natin, recap lang dun sa nangyari sa kabila.
00:09.9
Itong si Rafi Tulfo, meron siyang claim.
00:13.3
Sinasabi niya na doon sa protected area, mga kabatas natin,
00:17.2
e merong nagtayo ng windmills.
00:21.8
May structure na daw.
00:23.2
So, sinabi ng DNR, yung mga structure na nakita nyo, sa ibang lugar yan.
00:31.7
Ngayon, sinabi niya, kapag meron structure nga doon,
00:36.5
kasi nga ang binigay lang na na-permit sa kanila ay mag-conduct ng study
00:41.4
at hindi mag-build ng windmills.
00:44.8
Sinasabi ni Rafi Tulfo, may nag-build na daw ng windmills.
00:47.6
So, ngayon, hiningi nila.
00:49.1
Patingin nga yung mga investigation mo, yung data mo,
00:53.2
yung pagkakaalam mo na yan, kung saan mo man nalaman para imbestigahan namin.
00:58.7
Sabi niya.
00:59.6
Ngayon, mga kabatas natin, itong si Rafi Tulfo, linabas na yung section 26.
01:04.0
Doon sa NIPAS.
01:05.4
Ngayon, mga kabatas natin, protected areas ang pinag-uusapan nila.
01:10.4
At sinabi, merong strictly protected area, tapos merong multi-use.
01:16.6
Pinaliwanag sa kanya yun.
01:18.1
Ngayon, mga kabatas natin, I don't even have to explain.
01:21.2
You know why? These people are the experts.
01:23.7
Alam nila yan.
01:25.5
Ngayon, tingnan natin kung bakit mas expert si Rafi Tulfo.
01:28.6
At tingnan nyo kung paano paiba-iba na yung kanyang kwento.
01:33.0
Ngayon, kung may other complaints na pinaalis yung mga tao, ganun-ganun.
01:37.9
Isa pa pala yan, mga kabatas natin.
01:39.6
Kino-complain niya daw na pinaalis yung mga tao.
01:42.0
Sinipa daw yung mga indigenous peoples doon.
01:45.3
Dahil daw sa pagpapatayo nila ng mga windmills.
01:49.2
Let's go.
01:49.6
And then, let's have the complaint and we will investigate.
01:53.2
Exactly.
01:54.8
Exactly.
01:55.8
Thank you very much for that answer, Madam Sponsor.
01:57.9
That's exactly what I want you to say.
02:00.9
That's exactly what I want you to say.
02:04.3
Nakita nyo kung paano niya na naman ipalabas na tama siya
02:10.8
at kinontrol niya yung usapan nila when in the first place,
02:14.8
ang unang claim niya, windmill.
02:18.6
Na may structure sa windmill.
02:21.1
Ngayon, may claim siya na may principle.
02:23.2
May pinatalsik o sinipa
02:25.2
ng mga indigenous peoples.
02:30.1
Wala naman siyang pinapakita na ebidensya.
02:39.2
Diba?
02:44.1
Huwag ganyan, araw-ay-dross.
02:45.9
Okay lang yan.
02:47.4
Attorney-Mayor Conspiracy Service,
02:48.5
tsuri ako lalabas na yung disciplinary decision sa Senate League.
02:52.0
Kaya, merong nag-upload,
02:53.0
merong nag-upload,
02:53.2
merong nag-upload,
02:53.2
I don't know which war against the Senate.
02:54.8
Lahat na lang kinokontra.
02:56.7
Eh, pang dagdag sa piyansa ni Rikul.
03:00.2
Yan, Rikul, pang dagdag daw sa piyansa mo.
03:02.6
Sabi ni Teacher Mark,
03:04.0
Am I creating monsters ba kung grade 4 pa lang tinuturoan ko na
03:07.8
ng basic algebra?
03:10.5
Well, kung naiintindihan naman nila, di okay lang.
03:14.9
Pero syempre, pag titignan mo naman,
03:17.3
usapang algebra, basic pa rin yung alam nila.
03:22.1
And if they,
03:23.1
if they go toe-to-toe against a college student,
03:26.5
panalo pa rin yung college student.
03:28.8
Diba?
03:29.5
Kasi after all,
03:31.6
it's still knowledge that we are talking about.
03:36.8
Exactly daw.
03:37.8
Yun daw yung gusto niyang sabihin niya.
03:40.1
Samantalang nung umpisa,
03:42.0
yung structure,
03:45.8
ngayon yung pinatalsik na,
03:47.9
walang resolution.
03:50.5
Now,
03:53.1
ang nangyari kasi,
03:55.2
nagkaroon po ng multi-use zone
03:56.8
klinasify po ng DNR
03:58.5
using...
03:59.3
Tignan niya, magbabago na siya.
04:01.7
Magbabago na siya.
04:03.3
Nagkaroon daw ng multi-use zone.
04:05.8
Illegal ba yung pagkakaroon ng multi-use zone?
04:08.8
Kasi nga, yung DNR mismo ang nagsabi.
04:11.5
Pwede ang multi-use zone.
04:13.9
Section 25 of the E-NIPAS law as amended
04:19.1
2018 from Republic Act 7586.
04:23.1
of the E-NIPAS Act of 1992.
04:25.8
Now,
04:26.7
yan po, hindi ko na pwede
04:28.3
contest yung dalbatas po yan.
04:30.2
Okay?
04:31.5
Then what are you freaking doing?
04:37.2
Then what are you doing?
04:40.4
I will not contest.
04:41.6
However,
04:42.9
nakasaad dito,
04:44.3
para ang PAMBI
04:45.9
ay payagan na mag-classify
04:48.6
ng multi-use sa isa.
04:50.2
Iba na naman!
04:53.1
Nakita niyo kung anong nangyari dito?
05:01.4
Nagsimula sa structure.
05:09.2
Tapos, napunta doon sa mga sinisipa.
05:16.8
Ngayon itong PAMBI.
05:18.3
Oh, let's go.
05:18.8
Isang strictly protected area.
05:21.7
Kailangan,
05:23.1
ito na po yung iminensyon niyo kanina,
05:24.4
Madam Sponsor.
05:26.6
Members of the PAMBI Board,
05:28.6
which consists of
05:29.3
DNR Regional Director,
05:31.1
Governor,
05:32.7
Senator of the Republic of the Philippines
05:34.3
who is dual registered resident of the province,
05:37.3
District Representative of the Congressional District,
05:46.9
Mayors,
05:47.7
Chairperson of Barangay,
05:48.8
Regional Directors,
05:49.8
D.A. Neda,
05:51.3
D.O.S.T.,
05:51.8
D.N.D.,
05:52.0
D.N.D.,
05:52.2
D.N.D., D.N.D., D.N.D., D.N.D., D.N.D.
05:53.1
Representative from NGO or PO.
05:55.8
One, but not more than three.
05:57.3
Representative from IPs,
05:59.2
ICCs.
06:01.0
Sigaw pa siya.
06:03.7
IPs or ICCs.
06:05.3
Ano ba yung ICC?
06:06.9
Indigenous Cultural Communities.
06:09.7
Three representatives.
06:11.5
And then one representative from the academic institution.
06:14.3
And finally,
06:15.2
one representative from the private sector.
06:17.2
Now, gusto ko pong malaman
06:18.2
kung nasunod po ba ito
06:20.0
na itong lahat ng nakasulat dito
06:21.9
sa Section 11,
06:23.1
ng Republic Act 11-038
06:26.5
2018 as amended
06:27.9
ng INIPAS
06:29.0
kung nasunod po ito
06:30.3
nung pagbigay po ng multi-use
06:32.2
ng...
06:34.7
There is...
06:36.7
Alam niyo mga kapatid natin,
06:38.0
binabanggit din natin lagi ito.
06:39.5
Yung regularity in the...
06:41.0
presumption in the regularity of performance
06:43.7
of public officers.
06:46.2
So, kung ikaw, Rafi Tulfo,
06:48.1
sinasabi mo na may irregularity,
06:51.4
dapat ikaw ang maglabas ng evidence
06:53.1
siya na may irregularity.
06:55.8
Kasi ang presumption
06:57.1
ay regular yung nangyari.
07:02.0
Ang tignan natin siya.
07:03.9
DNR sa...
07:06.4
Paul Lukban,
07:09.4
Protected Interest of Meralco.
07:12.2
Hala ka.
07:13.6
Hala ka dyan.
07:14.8
Mapriso ka.
07:18.3
Farm na
07:20.0
Burnas Energy.
07:22.0
Pena.
07:22.3
Pena.
07:23.1
Energy.
07:24.5
Kung nasunod po.
07:25.6
Itong 11 members...
07:26.7
Nandyan daw po lahat yan
07:27.2
nung magbigay ng permit.
07:29.1
Well, can I see the...
07:30.4
Nandyan daw lahat yan
07:32.7
kung nagbigay ng permit.
07:34.0
List.
07:34.7
Kung sino itong 11 na ito
07:36.1
na pumayag naman
07:36.7
to ito yung ating environment
07:38.4
doon po sa...
07:39.2
Diba?
07:40.2
Magpapahid siya na naman.
07:41.4
Mga kapatid,
07:42.2
ganyan siya magaling eh.
07:43.9
Magpapahid siya ng irregularidad
07:45.5
na wala namang irregularidad
07:47.8
siyang nakita.
07:49.7
Mag-aakusa lang siya.
07:50.6
Pero meron niyang
07:53.5
presumption ng regularity.
07:55.2
Kung irregular,
07:55.9
you're supposed to be
07:56.7
the person
07:57.4
who will provide the evidence
08:00.6
that something irregular happened.
08:03.2
Bakit ang presumption sa'yo,
08:04.5
Rafi Tulfo,
08:05.2
ay irregular?
08:06.8
O iproprovide na sa'yo?
08:08.9
Okay na.
08:09.6
Nasagot, diba?
08:10.8
Iproprovide na sa kanya.
08:11.8
Ano na naman
08:12.3
ang sasabihin niya?
08:13.4
Sa masungi.
08:15.3
Yun nga mga local,
08:16.7
mahilig.
08:17.2
I need the list of those people
08:18.6
na pumayag
08:19.8
sa mga local.
08:20.6
Na i-exploit natin
08:22.0
itong tinatawag nating
08:25.9
masungi conservation area
08:29.5
na which is declared as
08:31.3
a strictly protected area.
08:34.4
So itong 11 members
08:35.8
Hindi naman.
08:37.3
Hindi naman.
08:38.5
Kasi nga multi-use na.
08:50.6
Hanggang dyan ka na lang,
08:53.0
Alfredo Palita.
08:54.3
Kunwari may alam
08:56.0
tong attorney na to
08:57.0
kung makakontra
08:57.8
kay Rafi Tulfo.
08:58.6
Kala mo talaga may alam.
08:59.8
Toxic talaga,
09:00.8
sabi niya.
09:03.3
Ayan, okay ka na.
09:08.6
At least ako.
09:11.5
Environmental scientist
09:13.0
tapos lawyer.
09:16.1
Kung walang alam yun sa'yo,
09:19.0
eh,
09:20.6
you're the man.
09:24.8
You're the man,
09:25.6
Alfredo Palita.
09:28.4
Si Rafi Tulfo,
09:30.4
ano nangyayari sa kanya?
09:33.0
Panuuri natin.
09:34.7
Na nag-sign
09:36.1
members of the board
09:37.5
sa Pambi
09:39.3
allowing
09:40.3
exploitation
09:41.7
of Masungi.
09:43.7
I need a list
09:44.4
of those people.
09:46.2
Ganyan na lang eh.
09:47.4
I need a list
09:48.1
of those people.
09:49.5
Pero dahil pa
09:50.2
gusto mo ng list na yun,
09:51.4
ibig sabihin ba
09:52.1
may irregularidad na nangyari?
09:53.8
Wala, di ba?
09:54.7
Because you did not point
09:55.8
any irregularity.
09:57.3
You just need the list
09:58.2
of the people.
10:00.8
Nagka-grandstand ka dyan
10:01.9
na parang
10:02.5
meron kang
10:03.3
pasabog.
10:05.8
Meron kang
10:06.2
expose.
10:10.0
But none.
10:12.8
You're just talking nonsense.
10:16.2
Humihingi ka lang
10:16.9
ng listahan.
10:19.0
So ano ngayon?
10:19.7
Ibibigay yung listahan sa'yo.
10:21.9
Paano ka naging bida?
10:25.1
Their signatures.
10:29.3
Very important to me is
10:31.2
yung
10:32.1
pagsalitay mo.
10:34.7
IPs.
10:36.0
Meron po bang pumirma
10:37.1
na IPs?
10:39.3
Meron ba?
10:40.5
Meron.
10:41.1
I need a list.
10:43.2
They will submit to you
10:44.8
those who signed.
10:46.2
O, isasabit nga sa'yo.
10:49.7
Ay, sasabit nga sa'yo.
10:56.8
Pareho kayo
10:57.6
ni Alfredo Palita na ito.
10:59.9
Walang malasakit
11:00.8
sa katutubo
11:01.5
ang mga kabutas.
11:02.7
May kilala ka bang
11:03.4
katutubo,
11:04.2
Alfredo Palita?
11:06.2
Yun ang tanong ko sa'yo.
11:10.3
Pareho kayo
11:11.1
nung idol mo.
11:12.6
Wala kayong alam
11:13.5
pero nagdudunong-dunungan ka.
11:16.2
What?
11:16.6
But right now?
11:17.3
Kasi pero yan,
11:18.6
I'm warning you.
11:19.7
That yan,
11:21.1
majority wins.
11:22.7
Diba?
11:23.6
Kahit na hindi pumirman lahat,
11:25.4
kung majority pumirma,
11:27.4
panalo yun.
11:28.5
I know.
11:29.3
Pero ang selection.
11:30.6
I know.
11:33.7
Yung process ninyo,
11:35.3
kailangan,
11:36.1
meron pong
11:36.8
IPs.
11:37.3
Ay, yung pina-follow.
11:38.9
Kaya nga,
11:39.2
paano po sinelect you?
11:40.5
Kaya nga,
11:41.0
sinunod nga yun.
11:42.0
Di ba sinabi na rin sa'yo?
11:43.6
Isasabit sa'yo.
11:45.9
Yung IPs.
11:47.2
May I know?
11:47.6
Oo.
11:48.5
From the experts?
11:49.7
Baka hindi naman po.
11:51.3
Diba?
11:52.2
Siya mismo nagsabi.
11:53.3
From the experts.
11:57.4
Pero mas magaling ka sa expert.
11:59.8
So, anong tawag sa'yo?
12:02.2
BS in everything.
12:04.9
Diba?
12:06.8
Isipin mo,
12:08.3
aawahin mo
12:09.4
yung expert
12:10.6
tungkol sa protected areas,
12:14.3
sa multi-use,
12:15.8
tsaka sa strictly protected areas.
12:18.0
Tapos mag-a-I know ka sa kanila.
12:19.6
BS in everything.
12:25.3
Ay, naku.
12:27.6
Galing din, no?
12:30.3
Anong tawag sa kanya?
12:31.3
Expertist.
12:33.1
Experter.
12:35.8
God mode on.
12:38.3
How dare you call them an expert?
12:43.2
Tapos you challenge them with what they know
12:45.8
and you are not an expert.
12:47.9
You are not.
12:49.6
Co-equal.
12:52.1
Pumirma yung IPIS.
12:53.5
Alam nyo,
12:54.5
miski IPIS,
12:55.9
naano din yan eh.
12:57.5
Nai-influence din yan eh.
12:59.7
Ay, dapat hindi.
13:01.0
Ay, naku.
13:02.9
Ay, dapat hindi.
13:04.4
Sabi.
13:05.9
Ano sila?
13:06.6
Hindi sila tao.
13:08.3
Tignan natin.
13:09.3
Tell it to the Marines.
13:10.6
Sorry.
13:12.3
Semperfi!
13:13.4
Tell it to the Marines na,
13:14.7
Rafi Tuto.
13:17.4
Eh, ewan ko ba dito?
13:18.9
Kay Rafi Tuto.
13:19.6
Rafi Tufo.
13:20.4
Dapat hindi.
13:22.8
Well, everyone.
13:24.8
You.
13:25.4
You.
13:25.9
You are also being influenced
13:27.9
by the people around you, Rafi Tufo.
13:31.7
Kaya nga nagkanda leche-leche
13:33.0
yung mga strategy mo dito sa social media eh.
13:37.8
Sinong tawang hindi na-influence?
13:40.8
Bakit may mga advertisements tayo nakikita all over?
13:44.0
Because people,
13:48.7
people,
13:49.6
are being influenced.
13:51.9
Hindi ba tao
13:52.8
ang mga indigenous people,
13:55.0
Sir Rafi?
14:03.0
Bakit yung nag-a-advertise ng Robust?
14:07.0
Because you want to influence people.
14:09.5
You want to influence people to buy Robust.
14:11.8
Bakit?
14:11.8
Because you want to influence people to buy Robust.
14:11.9
Because you want to influence people to buy Robust.
14:19.1
Oh, my goodness.
14:24.2
Ay, dapat hindi.
14:26.0
Ay, nako.
14:27.4
Tell it to the Marines.
14:28.6
Sorry.
14:29.5
Tell it to the Marines.
14:30.4
Dapat hindi po.
14:31.7
Kasi,
14:32.0
kawalan naman po yung mga IPs.
14:33.4
Sa aking
14:33.7
legislated protected area,
14:36.1
nangyayari yan.
14:37.1
Yung mga barangay na i-influence eh.
14:39.7
Kawawan naman po yung mga IPs.
14:41.2
Eh,
14:41.4
kulang nga po.
14:41.7
Kulang nga po.
14:41.7
Kulang nga po.
14:41.8
Kulang nga po.
14:41.8
Kulang nga po.
14:41.9
Kulang po sa pinag-aralan.
14:43.0
Kulang po sa kaalaman.
14:49.1
Ngayon,
14:49.6
ang tanong dyan,
14:51.5
is it a good influence
14:52.9
or a bad influence?
14:56.8
Pero,
14:57.4
na-influence yan lahat ng tao.
15:02.4
Yung mga IPs,
15:03.4
tao din yan.
15:04.6
And mind you,
15:05.3
marami ng IPs
15:06.2
ang edukado.
15:10.8
Then,
15:11.2
i-exploit ko na.
15:11.8
I-exploit natin.
15:12.2
Because we're saying na
15:13.8
madali silang ma-influence siya.
15:15.6
Dapat,
15:16.1
we try to help them
15:17.4
to make sure that
15:18.0
they will not be easily influenced.
15:20.0
So that...
15:22.8
Verbal diarrhea na naman ito.
15:29.7
In the first place,
15:31.2
ano bang influence
15:32.2
yung pinag-uusapan?
15:33.1
Ano bang influence yung pinag-uusapan?
15:39.7
Gagawin po nila kung anong tama
15:41.2
para sa kanilang proteksyon.
15:42.8
Oo nga.
15:44.0
Okay,
15:44.7
kung hindi nila ginawa yung tama
15:46.2
sa kanilang proteksyon,
15:47.4
magpakita ka kasi
15:48.3
ng ebidensya.
15:51.5
Kasi you already
15:52.7
accusing
15:53.6
na merong
15:56.2
hindi maganda
15:57.5
na nangyari.
15:59.9
Eh,
16:00.1
wala ka namang ebidensya pa.
16:03.2
Kumukuha ka pa nga lang
16:04.3
ng ebidensya,
16:05.2
di ba?
16:07.2
Kumukuha ka pa lang
16:08.1
ng listahan.
16:10.8
Pero,
16:11.2
ang nangyayari dito,
16:12.2
you're accusing the DNR already
16:14.2
of...
16:15.8
Siguro,
16:16.4
kasi you talk about influence,
16:18.5
bad influencing.
16:20.2
Bad influencing
16:21.5
yung mga
16:22.5
IPs.
16:26.9
Pero wala ka naman nasabi.
16:29.8
Wala ka pa nga ebidensya
16:32.5
kasi nga kukunin mo nga
16:33.6
kung titignan mo pa lang
16:34.7
yung listahan
16:35.4
kung kompleto,
16:36.6
di ba?
16:39.5
Then why is the default
16:41.0
na
16:41.2
now
16:41.5
corrupt
16:43.4
ang DNR?
16:46.0
Na pera
16:46.6
ang dahilan.
16:47.9
Katulad nga na
16:48.5
binanggit mo kanina.
16:52.9
Fishing.
16:54.0
Fishing expedition.
16:56.9
Hindi siya maniwala
16:58.4
na yung IPs
16:59.2
pumirma.
17:01.9
Narinig nyo yun.
17:02.9
Hindi siya maniwala
17:04.0
na yung mga IPs
17:05.1
pumirma.
17:07.8
Wala naman siyang ebidensya.
17:09.7
Paniwala lang.
17:11.2
Sabi ni Maria,
17:21.1
hindi mga mga IPs
17:22.5
may mga graduate sa college.
17:23.9
Hindi lang graduate sa college.
17:25.5
Lawyers pa.
17:26.8
Marami akong kaibigan.
17:27.9
Sabi ko nga sa inyo.
17:28.8
Kung nasabihin sa akin,
17:30.1
ako alam kong pwede yun.
17:31.8
Pero siya,
17:32.5
ayaw niya.
17:33.2
Kaya isigay din na lang
17:34.4
kung sino yung bumi
17:35.3
ng patent.
17:36.1
Wala.
17:39.5
Ayaw niyang
17:40.2
ayaw niya.
17:41.2
Maniwala eh.
17:44.7
Ayaw niyang maniwala eh.
17:47.7
Presumption of irregularity,
17:49.4
di ba?
17:50.1
John King Suleiman.
17:54.4
I'll help you.
17:56.0
Would you?
17:56.5
Oh, oh, oh.
17:57.1
Wow, wow.
17:57.8
Matulungin pala si Rafi Tulfo.
17:59.4
Okay, I'll help you.
18:00.2
I'll help you.
18:01.1
We need that help.
18:02.0
Okay, let's go, Rafi Tulfo.
18:03.7
Actually, you're helping yourself here.
18:07.6
You're helping yourself here.
18:09.4
Napapahiya ka na ng sobra.
18:11.2
Tignan mo,
18:12.3
nakangiti na sila dun sa likod.
18:13.6
Tignan mo si Madam Jan, oh.
18:20.1
I'll help you.
18:21.7
Would you mind
18:22.5
if I help you?
18:23.6
Yeah, you're very welcome.
18:25.1
Would you mind
18:26.8
daw if I help you?
18:28.0
Okay, okay, okay.
18:29.4
Ang mag-help pa yung
18:31.6
hindi expert.
18:34.1
Yung BS in everything.
18:36.2
Let's go.
18:36.9
Mr. President.
18:38.3
Kasi,
18:38.5
bago po
18:39.6
mapili,
18:41.2
ang isa o dalawa o tatlong IPs
18:43.7
na sumama po sa PAMBI
18:45.2
sa selection process.
18:47.8
Number one,
18:49.4
dumadaan yan sa
18:50.3
Indigenous Political Structure
18:52.3
or IPS.
18:55.3
Okay?
18:56.1
Ano po yun?
18:57.1
It consists of tribal leaders
18:58.7
that have exclusive right
19:00.9
na pa-
19:01.8
Given na yan.
19:06.4
Alam nyo,
19:07.4
mga kabatas natin, no?
19:08.9
I'll tell you this.
19:11.2
I have
19:12.2
parang
19:13.6
constant communications
19:15.6
especially in Baguio
19:17.7
and in Binggit
19:18.7
with
19:19.2
certain tribal leaders.
19:22.8
Kasi,
19:23.9
we help them
19:25.0
with several
19:25.7
matters
19:26.9
in relation to
19:28.5
to
19:29.7
talking with the local governments.
19:33.4
Siyempre, tungkol sa batas din.
19:35.9
A huge part of it
19:37.6
is because
19:38.6
kaibigan ko sila.
19:41.2
At, no,
19:45.5
they don't have me on retainer.
19:47.4
Hindi ako nagpapabayad.
19:49.7
Kapag meron silang kailangan,
19:51.7
nagme-message lang sila sa akin,
19:53.2
pumupunta kami doon,
19:54.8
pumupunta kami sa lugar nila,
19:56.5
nakakapag-meet kami doon
19:57.5
sa mga tribal leaders nila
19:58.8
para malaman
20:00.1
kung ano yung mga
20:01.4
yung mga
20:03.2
grievances nila.
20:07.2
Ano yung mga issues nila.
20:09.5
Ngayon, mga kabatas natin,
20:11.2
if you are exposed
20:13.1
to that kind of environment,
20:14.8
itong mga sinasabi ni Rafi Tulfo na ito,
20:17.2
it's just normal.
20:19.9
Okay?
20:20.7
Because that's how really they do it.
20:24.2
This actually
20:25.4
normally follows.
20:29.5
Kumbaga,
20:30.4
ganyan na yung nangyayari sa kanila noon pa,
20:33.7
sinulat na lang.
20:37.1
Gets nyo?
20:38.8
Tignan nyo yung sinabi ni Rafi Tulfo dito.
20:41.0
That,
20:41.2
actually,
20:42.7
is what is customary already.
20:48.8
Customary na yan.
20:50.3
Everything,
20:51.7
everything
20:52.2
goes through that route.
20:58.9
Sinulat na lang yan.
21:01.0
So,
21:02.1
if there are people
21:03.5
who are representatives there,
21:06.6
it is given
21:08.1
na dumaan sila sa ganyan.
21:10.3
Because,
21:10.6
that
21:11.3
is part
21:13.0
of the customs
21:14.3
of indigenous peoples.
21:17.3
Tignan nyo.
21:18.4
It consists of tribal leaders
21:20.2
that have exclusive right
21:22.3
na para magpadala po
21:24.1
ng representative nila
21:25.1
kung hindi sila mismo
21:26.0
pang sumama doon sa PAMBI.
21:29.1
Number one.
21:32.0
That's how they normally do it.
21:35.0
That's very normal to them.
21:37.5
They have high regards to the elders.
21:40.6
They're leaders.
21:47.3
Customary na yan.
21:48.5
Sinulat lang yan.
21:52.1
Number one.
21:53.3
Number two.
21:54.5
Dapat dumadaan po sa tinatawag na FPIC.
21:57.2
Free and prior informed consent.
22:00.7
Process ito
22:02.1
na ipapakita
22:03.8
na itong IPs
22:05.3
were not coerced
22:06.6
and were not influenced
22:08.2
just like what the good sponsor said
22:10.3
na madaling na-influence.
22:11.8
Kaya nga po mapasok itong proseso
22:13.5
to make sure na hindi po sila na-influence
22:15.7
hindi po sila na-coerce.
22:17.4
Ito po yung
22:18.0
Influence?
22:26.2
Yung FPIC na yun,
22:29.0
naalala nyo,
22:29.6
pinag-usapan natin yan
22:30.8
nung panahon ni Wang Od.
22:35.2
Yung issue ni Wang Od
22:37.1
kay Nas Daily.
22:40.3
Free prior and informed consent.
22:47.3
Ngayon,
22:48.6
if you think
22:49.6
that happened,
22:51.7
why don't you show evidence?
22:57.4
Kasi nga merong
22:58.9
presumption of regularity.
23:05.7
Di ba?
23:06.8
Di ba?
23:08.4
Yung FPIC
23:10.3
and finally,
23:12.2
evidence to one and two
23:13.4
I've mentioned,
23:14.5
dapat may certification precondition
23:16.6
or CP,
23:18.1
documents from NCIP
23:19.9
pirmado na nagkaroon
23:22.7
ng tamang proseso
23:23.8
at pumayagang IPs community.
23:26.7
In the absence of these three,
23:28.4
din invalid po yung pag-recruit nyo ng IPs
23:30.7
para maging member ng
23:32.1
PAMBIS board.
23:39.2
Hindi yan,
23:40.3
hindi naman sinabing absent yung tatlo.
23:41.9
Hindi naman sinabing absent yun.
23:48.8
Hindi naman sinabing absent yun.
23:52.6
Wala naman siyang pinakita
23:54.3
ng ebidensya na absent yun.
23:57.5
Parang sinabi niya lang
23:58.7
na dapat meron nito.
24:02.2
Eh di ba sinabi nila na meron nga?
24:10.3
narinig nyo yung sinabi
24:28.9
ni Cynthia Villar
24:29.9
preconditioned na yung utak kasi ni Rafi Tulfo
24:33.1
na kaya pinayagan
24:35.0
kasi nga daw may hindi magandang
24:37.2
impluensya
24:38.0
na ginamit
24:39.8
doon sa mga IPs
24:41.8
pero wala naman siyang ebidensya
24:44.7
at mga kabatas natin
24:48.7
hindi rin siya kasali
24:50.0
doon sa mga kumuha ng consent
24:51.8
hindi rin siya kasali
24:54.1
doon sa mga tao na nagpirmahan
24:56.0
hindi rin siya kasali
24:58.3
doon sa indigenous peoples na yun
25:05.0
okay, ano yung pinayagan natin?
25:08.7
ito po natin
25:09.6
ito po natin
25:11.0
kaya ano yung pinayagan natin?
25:13.9
ito po natin
25:14.0
ito po natin
25:14.9
ito po natin
25:16.5
ibi
25:17.1
di meron sa mga kabitsin mo
25:18.5
hindi marinig yung ibang sinabi niya
25:22.3
sinabi niya kasi
25:23.6
influence
25:25.1
sinabi niya kasi influence
25:27.9
if ano nan may
25:29.2
preconditioned na yung
25:30.9
preconditioned na yung
25:33.7
mind niya
25:34.3
sabi niya
25:34.8
ito po natin
25:37.3
ito po natin
25:38.2
ito po natin
25:38.6
kaya ano yung pinayagan natin?
25:38.7
ito po natin
25:38.7
ito po natin
25:38.8
sinabi niya kasi influence
25:38.8
ito po natin
25:38.9
ito po natin
25:39.0
ito po natin
25:39.1
ito po natin
25:39.4
Kaya nyo pinayagan
25:43.9
bla bla bla bla
25:45.0
pero yun ang sinasabi niya
25:46.0
na parang yun nga
25:47.0
may influensya na hindi maganda
25:49.4
o kaya dahil sa pera
25:51.0
katulad ng sinabi niya kanina
25:52.5
kaya pinayagan na
25:54.7
magkaroon ng conversion
25:57.2
nung parts ng protected area
26:00.8
into multi-use
26:02.0
Ipakita mo na lang
26:06.5
mga kapelis
26:07.4
para mag-configure siya
26:10.4
kasi pinayagan nyo
26:12.1
yung pre-conditioned notion na siya
26:16.9
diba?
26:20.2
Yan ang meron
26:21.7
pre-conditioned notion
26:23.6
Tama yung sinabi ni Big Daddy TV dito
26:28.7
In short
26:30.9
sarado na utak ni Idol
26:32.8
wala pa siyang ebidensya niyan ha
26:35.1
Makikita niya pa lang yung papeles
26:38.4
Pre-conditioned
26:44.0
di na tumatanggap ng ibang
26:45.4
reason
26:46.4
Wala pa siyang ebidensya
26:48.7
Ipapakita pa lang sa kanya yung papeles
26:51.5
Pero
26:52.4
meron na daw illegal na nangyari
27:02.7
Sabi ni
27:03.5
I am fake enough
27:04.7
Sabi ni
27:05.1
Sa line of work ko sa cons
27:06.7
Anong cons yan?
27:08.2
Based from my experience
27:09.4
priority ang IPs sa budget
27:11.6
and we make sure
27:12.6
na satisfied sila
27:14.8
na sila sa benefits
27:15.8
before we start the project
27:17.1
Hindi ko talaga magets
27:18.1
kung saan sila exploited
27:19.3
Pre-conditioned nga eh
27:29.2
Atunoy natin
27:29.8
Mr. President
27:33.5
We will just submit
27:34.9
all the papers available
27:37.4
to the DNR
27:39.8
about the action of the PAMBI
27:41.8
We just want to reassure you
27:43.8
that it is not yet
27:45.3
a permit to operate the windmill
27:47.7
It's just a study
27:49.4
to find out
27:51.3
the potential of the wind farm
27:54.2
here in the
27:55.5
legislated
27:56.5
Thank you Madam President
27:57.3
Thank you good sponsor
27:58.5
I will submit it to you
28:05.5
but
28:06.4
Pre-conditioned
28:11.5
na yung utak mo
28:12.2
Joke, di ba?
28:15.6
Guilty until proven innocent
28:17.4
Sabi ni DJ Byron
28:23.1
Music
28:24.5
and no topic TV
28:26.5
para hindi makulong
28:27.9
Hindi open-minded si Idol
28:29.7
hindi mo pwedeng
28:30.4
iyayaing magkape
28:31.3
At least meron siyang
28:33.0
protection
28:33.8
sa mga ganun
28:35.4
Isipin mo yun no
28:39.4
parang
28:39.9
parang
28:40.9
nangyari na
28:43.9
So
28:44.4
there is presumption
28:45.6
of regularity
28:46.5
Pero ang kondisyon
28:47.8
ng utak niya
28:48.5
hindi
28:49.2
May irregular kayong ginawa
28:52.3
Akin na yung mga papeles
28:53.9
Isipin mo
28:56.3
hindi mo pa nakita yung papeles
28:57.8
Wala kang ebidensya
28:59.3
Wala kang kahit ano
29:00.4
Pero
29:01.1
irregular na agad
29:02.9
yung nangyari
29:03.9
Sabi ni Gabsi
29:06.4
Labiktad
29:07.4
Di ba?
29:09.9
Hindi niya nga nakita
29:10.9
kung sino yung mga pumirma
29:12.1
Wala siyang nakausap
29:13.6
kung sino yung mga pumirma
29:14.9
The pre-condition
29:17.5
is grandstanding
29:18.4
Yes
29:22.0
I definitely agree with you
29:23.6
So
29:24.3
I need to see
29:26.7
the CP
29:28.3
Yes
29:29.1
I need to see
29:31.7
Gusto niya lang makita
29:32.8
Pero
29:34.1
nag-assume na siya
29:36.0
na may irregular
29:36.7
Ay nako
29:40.2
Certification of precondition
29:43.7
signed by the NCIP
29:45.5
Kahit na testing pa yan
29:47.6
kasi ang nakalagay sa batas
29:49.3
Kahit na testing
29:50.6
dapat hindi
29:51.5
doon sa mga lugar
29:52.9
na mayroong issue
29:54.2
sa ancestral domain
29:55.2
Kaya nga po
29:56.0
dumadaan doon
29:56.6
sa tatlong sinasabi kong steps
29:58.1
Without those
29:59.6
then invalid po
30:00.9
yung mga nakapirmang IPs
30:02.5
to own
30:02.9
So I need a copy
30:04.7
of the CP
30:05.7
na pirmado po
30:07.3
ng NCIP
30:08.2
May ipakita niya lang
30:09.9
na ano no
30:10.6
na supreme siya no
30:12.4
Supreme siya overall
30:14.5
Yan no
30:16.1
Gusto ko
30:18.6
I need to see
30:19.9
Because
30:22.9
kanina lang po
30:23.8
tumawag ako sa NCIP
30:25.3
wala po silang
30:26.4
pinipirmahan na CP
30:27.9
Allowing
30:29.0
the exploration
30:30.2
the testing
30:31.6
of anything
30:32.8
whatsoever
30:33.4
commercial
30:34.2
doon po
30:35.1
sa masungi
30:36.7
conservation area
30:39.2
Dignamo
30:40.8
sasagutin na naman siya dito
30:42.2
sasagutin siya na naman dito
30:44.0
experts yung mga sasagot
30:45.7
sa kanya
30:46.1
mas magaling pa siya
30:47.5
Now
30:48.1
if you cannot show me CP
30:49.6
again I will defer
30:50.9
the budget of the DNR
30:52.1
in favor of the IPs
30:54.5
and we defer
30:56.2
the budget of the DNR
30:56.4
Do we have time
30:57.8
for a different
30:58.6
question now?
31:03.9
Wait
31:04.8
Wait
31:05.2
If the sponsor has a query
31:10.4
we suspend session first
31:12.3
Madam President
31:16.4
I move to suspend the consideration
31:18.4
of budget of the department
31:19.6
I mean the
31:21.5
interpolation of our center to LVO
31:23.7
and
31:24.4
I would like to
31:26.2
recognize the next
31:29.8
interpolator
31:30.6
Senator Riza Ontiveros
31:33.0
I move that she be recognized
31:34.1
Thank you Mr. President
31:37.3
While the documents
31:39.2
are being printed
31:40.3
for the request of Senator Tulfo
31:42.9
we will hear the interpolation of
31:44.9
Senator Riza Ontiveros
31:46.0
unless Senator
31:47.5
Tulfo is willing
31:51.3
to finish his interpolation
31:53.5
pending the submission
31:55.3
of the office of the Senate
31:55.8
of the House of Representatives
31:56.1
of the House of Representatives
31:56.2
of the House of Representatives
31:56.7
of the House of Representatives
31:57.2
of the House of Representatives
31:57.7
to him
31:58.2
Okay
31:59.5
Senator Tulfo
32:00.9
still has the floor
32:02.0
Let me just clarify
32:03.6
that
32:04.6
the documents
32:06.3
Why is it not moving?
32:07.7
Ontiveros
32:08.2
unless
32:08.8
Senator
32:09.8
Just a minute
32:10.7
Unless Senator Tulfo
32:12.3
is willing
32:13.5
to finish his
32:14.9
interpolation
32:15.2
Here are our documents
32:16.0
Spoiler
32:18.7
That's tomorrow
32:19.2
We will continue tomorrow
32:20.4
He is not willing
32:21.9
He doesn't want
32:23.7
Because someone
32:25.0
has stolen
32:25.6
He has stolen
32:26.0
if he coins
32:28.2
If he finds
32:29.1
his notes
32:29.5
He has stolen
32:30.0
Then he's going to
32:30.7
go and steal
32:30.9
You know
32:31.5
Go
32:53.5
What did you say?
32:53.8
You may have to do it
32:56.0
Puro panlalait na lang.
32:58.4
Alfredo Palita.
33:00.3
Isa pang,
33:01.4
manglait ka pa ng mga ganyan, ha?
33:04.5
Manglait ka pa ng ganyan,
33:06.5
mababan ka na.
33:09.9
Goodbye, Alfredo Palita.
33:12.2
Okay?
33:13.1
Makita ko pa,
33:14.0
sunod-sunod na ganyan yung mga lait mo.
33:17.1
Okay?
33:19.6
Subukan mo lang.
33:21.2
Subukan mo lang.
33:24.1
Maraming salamat, mga kabatas natin.
33:26.0
At syempre,
33:28.5
laka.
33:29.8
Ayan, oh.
33:30.5
Sabi ni Rico, noted.
33:34.7
Maraming kaming ipapalit sa'yo,
33:36.2
Alfredo Palita.
33:37.1
Tandaan mo yan.
33:41.2
Maraming kaming ipapalit sa'yo.
33:43.0
Maraming kaming basher dito.
33:47.1
Mas maayos pa nga yung iba kesa sa'yo.
33:49.7
Maraming salamat, mga kabatas natin.
33:51.3
At syempre, tulungan lang yung sinasabi,
33:52.6
matulog po tayo ng mahimbing.
33:54.0
Dahil alam natin na
33:54.9
ay natutulog ng mahimbing.
33:56.0
Siya yung laging panalo.
33:58.1
Paalam po, pansamantala.