Close
 


Dapat na bumalik ang Pilipinas sa ICC?
Hide Subtitles
Click any subtitle word to view Tagalog.com dictionary results.
Computer Shortcuts: Left / Right arrows to jump 2 seconds back or forward. +Enter or Space to toggle Play/Pause button. Full Screen Mode
Nagbabago na ba ang ihip ng hangin at tila bukas na si Pangulong Marcos Jr. na bumalik ang Pilipinas sa International Criminal Court?
Christian Esguerra
  Mute  
Run time: 19:24
Has AI Subtitles



Video Transcript / Subtitles:( AI generated. About AI subtitles » )
00:00.0
Thank you for watching!
00:30.0
Thank you for watching!
01:00.0
Thank you for watching!
01:30.0
Thank you for watching!
02:00.0
Thank you for watching!
02:30.0
Thank you for watching!
03:00.0
Thank you for watching!
03:30.0
Thank you for watching!
04:00.0
Thank you for watching!
04:30.0
Thank you for watching!
05:00.0
Thank you for watching!
05:30.0
Thank you for watching!
06:00.0
Thank you for watching!
06:30.0
Thank you for watching!
07:00.0
Thank you for watching!
07:30.0
Thank you for watching!
08:00.0
dito sa mga patayin
08:02.2
under President Ocerto.
08:04.4
Paliwarin niyo nga ulit yung rule,
08:05.7
yung applicable Rome Statute
08:08.2
during the time when the State
08:10.1
Party was still a member of the Rome Statute.
08:13.0
Oo. Kasi yung
08:14.0
naging party tayo sa Rome Statute,
08:16.5
parang kasal din yan eh. Kahit na
08:18.1
naghiwalayan na, naging
08:19.7
kasal pa rin. So mayroon time talaga
08:22.1
na naging party tayo. Kailan yan?
08:23.8
November 1, 2011, hanggang
08:25.8
March 16,
08:27.8
2019. So I mean to say,
08:30.7
nung period na yun,
08:32.2
eh, in effect yung Rome Statute
08:34.0
sa Pilipinas. Kaya kung ano mang mga
08:35.7
international crimes na nangyari nung period na yun,
08:38.4
eh, within the jurisdiction of
08:40.1
the Rome Statute. So yun lang actually
08:42.0
yung ine-exercise ng ICC.
08:44.8
Yung period na yun.
08:46.1
Anything earlier than that is outside
08:48.0
of the jurisdiction. Anything
08:49.6
later than that is outside of the jurisdiction
08:52.2
of the ICC.
08:54.8
Ngayon,
08:55.7
dapat ba bumalik na tayo?
08:57.8
Sa Rome Statute?
08:59.7
I think yes. There's
09:01.3
good reasons for us to
09:03.9
enter. First, it's really
09:05.9
giving the signal
09:09.2
that we're adhering
09:10.7
to a rules-based
09:13.7
international legal order.
09:15.8
Kasi kung yun yung argument natin
09:17.9
with respect to the West Philippine Sea,
09:20.2
eh, para mas maging consistent pa
09:21.7
at talagang para mas maging
09:24.2
malalim pa at talagang
09:25.8
talagang very strong
09:27.7
ang ating position. So
09:29.4
malaking impact yun sa international
09:31.6
community if we go back to the ICC
09:33.8
Rome Statute. Secondly,
09:36.3
yung theme na
09:37.7
ni BBM na pagbabago
09:39.7
and in fact, hindi siya
09:42.2
kopya ng kanyang
09:43.7
father na
09:44.7
naging dictator. So
09:47.6
malaking sinialis din to sa history,
09:49.9
diba, na iba ako. So
09:51.7
ibahin mo ako. So I want to
09:53.6
really respect and protect
09:55.7
human rights. Yun yung sinasabi.
09:57.7
Sabi sa EU, yun yung sinasabi ng
09:59.6
Pilipinas sa US. So this
10:01.6
is a strong signal that indeed we're
10:03.6
adhering to our international law
10:05.4
obligations, especially on human rights.
10:09.7
Okay. Pero dito ba?
10:12.1
Ano ba yung proseso yung inaasahan
10:13.7
natin? Kasi may mga naging sabi rito,
10:15.3
oi, baka malapit na yung
10:16.7
arrest warrant against
10:19.2
former President Duterte.
10:21.9
Pero ano ba yung nakikita yung
10:23.3
business or battle
10:25.7
ng proseso? Dahil sa
10:27.7
UK, yung reklamo,
10:29.4
makasemphasize na.
10:31.0
Oo. Alam mo, magandang
10:33.1
question and question. Kasi whether
10:35.2
the Philippines cooperates or not
10:37.4
with the Office of the Prosecutor,
10:39.2
the process of investigation still
10:41.2
continues. So
10:42.8
in fact, in the investigation,
10:45.7
yung talagang focus ng
10:46.9
Office of the Prosecutor is
10:48.9
sino ba yung mananagot? Sino yung
10:51.3
dapat panagutin? Sino ba
10:53.2
yung mga defendants dapat?
10:55.2
So i-identify yan. At ano
10:57.4
bang evidence that will show na sila
10:59.4
nga mga dapat panagutin?
11:02.1
So, kung
11:03.5
ma-ano na yun, ma-identify
11:05.7
na nila yun, yung next step dyan
11:07.2
is to actually
11:09.1
apply for an arrest warrant before
11:11.1
the pretrial chamber.
11:13.2
So, doon na natin malalaman yun actually
11:15.3
kung sino yung, kung
11:17.3
anong naging result ng investigation.
11:20.1
At I think
11:21.3
it will be good for the Philippines to
11:23.4
actually rejoin the ICC
11:25.1
even before that investigation has
11:27.1
its own results.
11:30.1
Bakit naman?
11:31.3
Mas mapapagalis ba?
11:33.0
O baka naman mas magmumikala magandaimahin
11:35.1
ng Pilipinas? I mean, what good will it do?
11:38.1
Well, ang
11:38.9
magiging magandang signal yun
11:41.4
sa international community. Kasi ibig sabihin,
11:43.8
tinunahan na natin yung
11:45.4
results
11:47.3
ng investigation.
11:49.1
So, meaning to say, we really have
11:51.3
that good faith
11:52.6
showing na we want
11:55.4
to really have a
11:57.1
that international justice mechanism
11:59.3
in the Philippines. So,
12:01.2
regardless of what will be the
12:03.5
outcome of that investigation.
12:07.3
So, sa inyo ba, mas
12:09.3
na ba? Ito lang experience ko lang bilang
12:11.2
executive director
12:13.6
ng Center for International Law.
12:15.5
So, wala ba lang pumatak-pulitin ko parang
12:17.4
mas naging, ano ba, nagkaroon ng
12:19.4
renewed interest dito sa
12:20.9
international community?
12:23.7
Ano sa mga nakakasalan niya?
12:25.2
And is that a good thing?
12:27.1
For us Pilipinas? Kasi ngayon, binabago ko
12:28.9
ng comments, sinasabi ng mga
12:31.3
loyalista, e, dapat ko
12:32.9
sumulit kayo sa ano, din lang sa
12:34.9
batas natin dito. Di ba yung narrative
12:36.7
ng iba? Parang, kagalari
12:38.9
natin yung batas dito, eh. May tayong
12:40.6
mag-subject sa mga, di ba yung
12:42.4
puti, di ba yung gano'n?
12:45.0
Actually, what's interesting,
12:46.5
what's interesting, Christian,
12:49.7
is, in fact, mayroon tayong
12:50.9
batas. It's called RA-9851.
12:54.2
It was passed
12:55.0
noong December of 2009. Ano ba yung,
12:57.1
RA-9851? This is the IHL Act.
13:00.2
At sabi po sa IHL Act,
13:01.7
sa Section 17,
13:03.1
in fact, in the interest of justice,
13:05.3
pwedeng ang Pilipinas
13:07.3
ay huwag na mag-imbestiga ng international
13:09.2
crime dito sa Philippines. If there's
13:11.2
an international tribunal
13:12.8
that's actually investigating
13:14.6
those international crimes that occurred
13:17.0
here in the Philippines. In fact, pwede
13:19.1
po yung dahilan, Christian,
13:21.0
for the Philippines to say, ah, in-investiga
13:23.1
naman pala ng ICC. Hindi na natin
13:25.1
in-investigaan yan sa Pilipinas. In fact,
13:27.1
kung mayroon pong arrestwagan sa isang
13:29.1
Pilipino, e susurrender na natin
13:31.3
siya dun sa ICC.
13:33.5
At that's based on
13:35.0
Philippine Domestic Law, RA-9851.
13:39.7
Interesting, ah. Paki-expound nga yan.
13:41.4
Medyo hindi ako familiar dyan.
13:43.2
So pwedeng gawin yan? So, e ba,
13:44.6
paning quantum of evidence, pareho ba yan?
13:47.3
Pwedeng gawin, Christian,
13:49.3
oo. In fact, it will interest you
13:51.2
na noong last October, I think,
13:53.2
October 25 or 24,
13:55.1
in fact, I filed,
13:57.1
I filed a complaint for
13:59.1
Chin natives of Myanmar.
14:01.4
Oo, based on war crimes
14:03.3
that happened in Myanmar.
14:05.4
Based on universal jurisdiction.
14:07.7
Bakit? Because we believe,
14:09.3
I told our clients, na
14:10.8
there's actually a working justice system in the
14:13.1
Philippines. And there's this IHL
14:15.5
Act. So,
14:17.6
in fact, kung pwede po siya
14:19.2
sa mga foreigners,
14:21.0
how much more kung ang
14:22.8
naagrabyado pong mga biktima, yung mga Pilipino.
14:25.5
Kaya po, linagay po,
14:27.1
yan sa Section 17, in the
14:29.1
interest of justice.
14:31.1
I mean to say, in the interest of
14:32.6
Pilipino victims. The Philippines
14:35.1
can actually just surrender to
14:37.0
the ICC or any international
14:38.9
tribunal. Kung mayroon bang pong na-apusado
14:41.4
na Pilipino dahil sa
14:43.0
international crime.
14:45.9
So, ito naman,
14:46.8
I pray the devil's advocate.
14:49.3
And, e ba, it defeats the
14:51.1
purpose of the ICC bilang
14:52.8
court of last resort. E ba, dapat pagalahin
14:55.1
muna yung justice system ng state
14:57.1
parties bago pumasa sa ICC.
14:59.3
O dito, pwedeng papasukin na
15:01.4
even without exhausting
15:03.3
all legal remedies
15:04.6
or waiting for the local justice system to work.
15:07.3
Yan ang pabayon.
15:08.7
Kasi, ang context na lang ng ICC,
15:11.5
tama, it's court of last resort.
15:13.5
Kasi kung hindi ginagawa ng
15:15.1
state party, kagaya ng Philippines
15:17.2
at that time, kung hindi po inainvestiga
15:19.2
ng Philippines, yung mga international
15:21.3
crimes niya, doon po papasok yung
15:23.3
ICC. Kaya ano bang nangyari?
15:25.7
Nagkawin ba talaga ng investigation?
15:27.1
On crimes against humanity
15:29.2
with respect to the war on drugs? Wala.
15:31.9
Kaya, yun pumasok po yung
15:33.1
ICC. Second point.
15:35.2
Kaya, ibig sabihin po,
15:37.1
ang ICC, hindi niya po tinitingnan kung may
15:38.9
hong kang working justice system. At tinitingnan
15:41.2
niya lang, nag-investiga pa ba
15:42.5
ng mga international crimes? Nag-investiga ba sa
15:44.8
Pilipinas ng mga crimes against humanity?
15:47.6
Wala. So, yun,
15:49.2
papasok siya. Kasi,
15:51.1
ano ba talaga ang pinaka-value ng ICC?
15:53.5
It's to stop impunity
15:55.1
with respect to international crimes.
15:57.1
Is it too late?
16:00.2
Let's say,
16:01.1
the new administration
16:02.9
decides to investigate
16:05.1
in earnest
16:07.0
yung mga patayang under the previous
16:08.9
administration. Pwede bang,
16:11.1
would that be enough to, for the
16:13.2
ICC to take a pause?
16:14.9
Pwede ka, ito, talaga ininvestigahan na namin.
16:17.5
Hindi na siya yung presidente, wala na siya
16:18.8
inunity. Or, it doesn't apply
16:21.1
anymore dahil tapos na yung period na yun
16:23.0
kung saan dapat ininvestigahan?
16:25.5
Oo.
16:27.1
Hindi dun sa deferral application
16:29.0
ng Philippines. Ang argument talaga ng Philippines,
16:31.0
during that time na nag-a-add siya ng deferral,
16:33.6
ibig sabihin,
16:34.8
nag-investiga siya. Pero, yun nga,
16:37.2
napatunayan sa PTC, sa pre-trial
16:39.2
chamber, na hindi siya nag-investiga
16:40.8
during the time na nag-apply siya
16:42.9
for deferral. At, in fact,
16:45.1
in-uphold yun ng appeals chamber.
16:47.6
So, mukhang for that
16:49.0
period na dapat nag-defer,
16:50.9
hindi siya nag-investiga. Purang,
16:53.1
it's a missed chance. And,
16:55.1
let's be frank, it happened during the pre-trial,
16:57.1
previous administration.
16:58.6
So, hindi po siya talagang
17:00.9
dishonored. Hindi po siya lamat
17:03.1
sa current BBM administration.
17:05.9
Kung pumasok po tayo sa ICC.
17:07.7
Kasi pinunturya po ng
17:08.9
appeals chamber ng ICC. Ay yung
17:10.7
period that happened during the previous
17:12.6
administration.
17:16.3
Sige yan.
17:17.1
Napakalinaw ng paliwanag ni Atty. Gilbert Andres.
17:19.8
Well, maraming salamat
17:21.0
Atty. Gilbert Andres for
17:22.6
explaining these things to us.
17:24.2
Maraming salamat po.
17:27.1
Maraming salamat po siya.
17:30.3
Pero, at least,
17:31.8
mali na yung audio niyo. Mas importante.
17:33.6
Mali na yung sinasabi niyo.
17:35.4
Maraming salamat po, Atty. Gilbert Andres.
17:37.4
Maraming salamat po siya. Mabuhay po tayong lahat.
17:43.9
Yan yan po si Atty. Gilbert Andres.
17:46.5
Nakapanayang din natin
17:47.7
dito po sa ating programa.
17:50.2
Kasama-sama, ano? Asama pa rin ba na
17:51.6
Atty. Gilbert Andres?
17:52.0
Okay.
17:53.0
Ayun.
17:56.0
Ayun.
17:56.6
Ayun.
17:57.1
Uy.
17:57.4
Ayun.
17:57.6
Ayun.
18:06.8
Ayun.
18:09.5
Ayun.
18:10.1
Ayun.
18:11.3
Ayun.
18:17.1
Ayun.
18:21.0
Ayun.
18:23.8
Ayun.
18:25.2
Ayun.
18:26.0
Ayun.
18:26.6
Ayun.
18:27.0
Ayun.
18:27.1
Sige, sige, sige
18:33.3
Ganyan ito muna
18:34.1
Sayang kasi yung mga baki ko
18:37.9
Happy Birthday
18:39.0
Kung hindi nyo ka nabibinig
18:40.3
Sa Monday na lang po, pasensya na kayo
18:42.4
Delighted Happy Birthday sa mga babatiin natin
18:45.8
Maraming salamat po
18:47.4
Ipakita po tayo sa
18:49.9
Monday
18:57.1
Thank you for watching!