* AI ("Artificial Intelligence") subtitles on Tagalog.com are generated using "Whisper" by OpenAI (the same company that created ChatGPT and DallE2). Results and accuracy may vary.
* The subtitles do include errors occasionally and should only be used as a tool to help with your listening practice.
* You can request this website to create a transcript for a video if one doesn't already exist by clicking the "Request AI Subtitles" button below a video. Transcribing usually takes 30-40% of the length of a video to complete if there are no other videos in
the queue. For example, a 21 minute video will take 7-8 minutes to transcribe.
* Running a super fast cloud GPU server to do these transcriptions does cost money. If you have the desire and financial ability, consider
becoming a patron
to support these video transcriptions, and the other tools and apps built by Tagalog.com
00:00.0
PLEASE SUBSCRIBE, LIKE, COMMENT, SHARE, COMMENT, SHARE
00:30.0
Thank you very much.
01:00.0
Thank you very much.
01:30.0
I think it's the sound system.
01:45.0
Oh, never mind na guys. Let's do this.
02:30.0
Thank you very much.
03:00.0
Ayan na, one second
03:30.0
Okay guys, ito na, live na tayo
03:34.7
Pag-usapan natin itong mga latest na nangyari
03:37.0
Ito na, naghanap tayo ng oras dito
03:38.9
At lahat ng mga kasama natin from iba't ibang kampo ay nandito
03:44.4
Now today I wanna talk about something na sa tingin ko is underappreciated
03:48.4
Which is yung mga risk, no?
03:50.4
Yung mga risk na nangyari ngayon, yung mga developments na nakita natin sa kanina
03:54.1
Tsaka dun sa mga ibang videos natin, pinag-usapan natin yung ongoing hearings
03:58.1
Diyan, ukol sa franchise
03:59.9
At pinag-usapan din natin yung implications, no?
04:05.0
Tsaka yung dynamics na papunta na tayo dun dyan sa disintegration ng unity, no?
04:10.6
As we speak, so nag-post tayo ng mga memes, nag-post tayo ng mga iba't ibang ebidensya
04:16.8
Na as far as the Marcus Duterte unity is concerned, mukhang medyo malabo na yung situation, diba?
04:23.7
And in fact, since kahapon, lumalakas, no?
04:27.6
Yung mga calls at saka yung mga kritiko
04:29.6
Na nagsasabi na siguro panahon na na mag-resign yung ating vice-presidente
04:34.0
Dahil sa kanyang mga disagreements, no?
04:36.5
With the president at saka sa kasalukyan ng administration
04:39.8
Pagdating sa big issues including yung mga peace process negotiations
04:42.9
So, so now medyo umabot na sa ganitong usapan
04:46.4
Katulad ang sinabi natin kay Ted Filon kanina umaga
04:51.0
Yung mga nakinig sa atin dito sa YouTube, among others
04:53.5
I'm still skeptical na President Marcos Jr. wants a total disintegration of the unity
04:58.3
Although sa tingin ko, I don't think so
04:59.6
Functionally, medyo tapos na ang usapan
05:01.6
Because very risk-averse si President Marcos Jr.
05:06.4
And I think President Marcos Jr. will try to patch things up
05:09.7
Or keep things on a kind of an even keel
05:13.2
Manage competition or manage conflict, if I can put it that way, no?
05:17.6
Over the holiday season, so that may give some respite
05:20.7
Give some space for the two camps to bring things together
05:23.9
But nevertheless, things are moving very, very fast
05:26.9
Especially dito sa situation ng SMNI
05:31.8
Not one, but I think two anchors ng SMNI
05:35.3
Especially kasama dyan yung favorite niyong anchor na si Lorraine Badoy
05:40.3
Medyo na Badoy si Badoy
05:42.6
Doon ng ibang congressman dyan, diba?
05:45.5
Nakita nyo naman, mga pinost natin, yung mga back and forth
05:48.7
Some would even say medyo hostile yung environment
05:52.6
Doon sa hearings about SMNI
05:54.8
Which kind of confirms, no?
05:55.9
Yung isang conversation natin a few days ago
05:59.6
Noong first hearings of SMNI
06:02.2
At kasama natin si Mark Gamboa, no?
06:04.7
Doon sa RRM natin
06:06.1
I think he correctly mentioned, this is last Friday
06:08.7
He correctly mentioned na, diba?
06:12.4
Deligado ng SMNI as things go
06:14.6
Now, having said that
06:15.9
Having said that, mga kameta
06:17.7
Sa aking palagay, medyo nakakabala pa rin yung situation
06:21.6
Alam ko yung mga iba dyan, natutuwa
06:23.1
Naglalabas na ng mga popcorn, diba?
06:25.5
Ah, ito, ito, ito
06:29.6
Yung mga naglalabas na ng popcorn
06:31.4
Excited na, yun, alam mo naman
06:34.0
Germans have a term for it, no?
06:37.3
Schadenfreude, no?
06:39.5
They call it Schadenfreude
06:40.6
Meaning, taking joy
06:41.8
Taking joy in the misery of others
06:47.2
For me, medyo short-sighted yan
06:54.8
How should I put it?
06:56.7
If you care about rule of law, no?
06:58.3
At kung gusto mo maging
06:59.6
Tunay na demokrasya ng Pilipinas
07:01.7
Sa isang, you know, balang isang araw
07:04.3
You're still gonna be worried about what's happening right now
07:10.0
Now, katulad ng sinabi natin sa isang tweet natin kanina
07:13.7
The ABS-CBN and the SMNI cases
07:18.5
And increasingly, a franchise case in both of them
07:21.4
So, on the surface, the ABS-CBN and SMNI cases look very similar
07:25.5
Franchise, in the case of ABS-CBN
07:27.8
Di sila binigyan ng bagong franchise
07:29.5
And in the case of SMNI, baka ma-revoke yung kanilang franchise
07:32.8
So, in a certain technical sense, there are two similar cases
07:37.3
Pag ina-analyze mo
07:39.4
There's some big differences there
07:42.8
As far as ABS-CBN is concerned
07:47.0
It's a blue-chip established mainstream media outlet
07:50.8
And, you know, the leading media outlet for quite a while sa Pilipinas
07:55.3
It's an internationally recognized media outlet
07:57.5
Marami siyang napanalo na outletna
08:00.5
And the anchors that have worked there
08:02.5
The analysts that have worked there
08:04.5
You know, a lot of them are recognized as world-class journalists
08:08.1
And analysts, among others
08:10.1
So, no offense, but I'm not sure SMNI is in that category
08:14.1
Kumpara sa ABS-CBN, ah, yung SMNI ay ano, right?
08:19.9
Just to be very honest about it
08:21.2
If you just look at the, you know
08:23.0
Ilan bang napanalo nila ng mga global awards
08:26.2
Or nominations sa global awards?
08:28.2
At ano yung bago?
08:29.4
At ano yung background ng mga kinukuha nilang anchors
08:31.4
In terms of high-level, world-class journalism, no?
08:35.4
And others would be even harsher
08:37.4
And they will say that pagdating naman sa SMNI
08:39.4
It's not only about credentials
08:41.4
Because, you know, credentials
08:42.4
It's one thing to talk about credentials
08:44.4
But it's another thing to talk about convictions
08:47.4
Ideological leaning
08:51.4
And, not to mention, intentions and quality of service, no?
08:55.4
Some would say that ABS-CBN and SMNI cannot even be put in the same category
09:00.4
They're totally incomparable
09:01.4
Even though, technically speaking
09:03.4
More or less, yung issue ngayon is franchise
09:07.4
Franchise in the case of ABS-CBN na hindi binigay sa kanila
09:10.4
And franchise in the case of SMNI na meron sila pero pwede matanggal
09:15.4
Now, interestingly, having said that the two are related very much to each other
09:21.4
Una-una, pag tinignan nyo
09:23.4
It's hard to imagine the rise of SMNI over the past two or three years
09:28.4
Without appreciating the decline of ABS-CBN
09:31.4
In fact, in many ways, the removal of ABS-CBN from the air
09:36.4
Andun sila online
09:37.4
Sure, even na yan
09:38.4
And medyo swerte ang ABS-CBN
09:40.4
Because they were the most forward-looking major media outlets
09:43.4
They were prepared for going fully online for quite some time
09:46.4
But nevertheless, yung pagtanggal ng ABS-CBN dun sa airwaves
09:50.4
Really help to boost alternatives
09:53.4
Particularly, itong
10:00.4
So, the rise of SMNI and the decline of ABS-CBN
10:03.4
At least in terms of main airwaves
10:06.4
The two cannot be separated
10:08.4
But they're also related in a much more problematic way
10:12.4
And this is where I'm not saying na I'm siding with SMNI
10:19.4
Yung nangyayari ngayon sa SMNI cannot be separated from yung nangyayari sa ABS-CBN
10:29.4
What was done to the ABS-CBN
10:30.4
I'm not saying ABS-CBN was perfect
10:32.4
We can debate about it
10:34.4
Whether may mga issues talaga about
10:36.4
You know, their corporate structures
10:39.4
You know, all of the issues that were raised about ABS-CBN
10:41.4
Ewan ko niyo dun sa mga
10:43.4
Yung mga rants ni Tatay Digon
10:46.4
Mangina yung mga ganyan sa akin
10:49.4
You know, I've worked in different TV channels
10:51.4
And I've heard from different sides
10:53.4
We can have a debate about that
10:59.4
Yung ABS-CBN, natanggal sila ng franchise
11:02.4
At the height of the pandemic
11:04.4
When the environment was heavily securitized
11:08.4
Ito yung panahon na may lockdowns
11:10.4
Ito yung mga panahon na pwede ka mas cyber liable
11:13.4
Kung na-criticize mo yung government
11:15.4
Ito yung panahon na natatakot ng tao
11:17.4
On so many levels
11:18.4
Ito yung mga panahon na hindi makalabas at hindi makaprotest ng tao
11:22.4
Ito yung panahon na
11:25.4
People are feeling very vulnerable
11:27.4
People are worried about their jobs
11:29.4
About their safeties
11:30.4
And most importantly
11:31.4
Ito yung panahon na may emergency powers
11:33.4
Ang gobyerno at yung presidente
11:35.4
So it was really under those extreme circumstances
11:38.4
That ABS-CBN lost its franchise
11:43.4
That's one thing, the circumstances
11:45.4
It's also how ABS-CBN lost the franchise, right?
11:49.4
So it's not only what is the circumstances
11:52.4
So kung titignan niyo mga kamayata
11:55.4
You had the top leaders of ABS-CBN
11:58.4
People have been in this business for a very long time
12:01.4
Including the Lopez's
12:03.4
Including yung CEO
12:04.4
All of them were there
12:06.4
And look at yung treatment na nakuha nila sa Kongreso nung time niyan
12:10.4
Look at the nature of questions
12:12.4
Look at yung how professionally some people are conducting themselves
12:17.4
And then you also had cases whereby some people were talking about their own cases
12:23.4
Last year may report kayo sa akin na hindi ko nagustuhan
12:25.4
So like some people were wondering whether this is a vendetta situation, right?
12:29.4
And look at the humiliation that top media corporate officials were subjected to
12:35.4
Now, again, we can have a long debate about monopolistic practices
12:40.4
Sure, we can have a lot of discussion about that
12:43.4
But let's not forget
12:44.4
That it's almost impossible to imagine yung nangyara sa ABS-CBN
12:50.4
If A, hindi yung ito yung
12:53.4
Kasagsagan ng pandemic
12:54.4
And may emergency situation
12:56.4
And heavily securitized environment
12:58.4
And B, hindi feeling empowered yung mga ibang legislators
13:04.4
To interrogate essentially
13:07.4
And to cross-examine
13:09.4
And some would even say way more than that
13:11.4
When it comes dun sa interaction nila sa mga ABS-CBN leaders
13:14.4
Just watch it yourself mga kameta
13:16.4
So that you can decide on your own
13:21.4
I mean this is not just me
13:23.4
This is an opinion
13:24.4
This is a proper analysis of the situation
13:26.4
Something changed forever in the Philippines after that
13:29.4
Because for a very very long time
13:31.4
Ang media po sa Pilipinas ay almost sacrosan
13:35.4
The media was very sacrosan
13:36.4
And if you look at the Duterte administration
13:38.4
President Duterte in particular
13:40.4
He attacked many things that were assumed as too sacred
13:45.4
To even question or criticize
13:47.4
To begin with, of course
13:49.4
Literally on sacred institutions
13:51.4
Like the Catholic hierarchy
13:54.4
But the media was always also seen as a semi-sacred
13:58.4
Pillar of Philippine democracy
14:01.4
Third estate, fourth estate, whatever
14:06.4
And having a free media was always essential to having a healthy democracy
14:10.4
And in fact it was always our strong media
14:12.4
That gave this impression that the Philippines is the freest country in Asia
14:17.4
Or at least in South East Asia
14:19.4
Let's sit next to each other
14:33.4
Let's sit next to each other, kids
14:36.4
For a very long time
14:37.4
Parang almost untouchable
14:39.4
Almost untouchable
14:40.4
Itong media natin
14:43.4
Very powerful yung media
14:44.4
I mean, you could see it
14:46.4
I mean, becoming vice president
14:48.4
Journalists becoming senators
14:51.4
Journalists, you know
14:53.4
Interrogating and back and forth
14:55.4
Going against powerful presidents and officials
14:59.4
Look at the showdown between Manila Times and Erap Estrada
15:02.4
Look at how Philippine Daily Inquirer
15:04.4
Went after Estrada
15:06.4
Went after Marcos
15:08.4
Of course, Marcos Senior
15:09.4
That really established Philippine Daily Inquirer as we know it today
15:13.4
So, for a very long time
15:14.4
The media was seen as a sacrosan institution
15:17.4
As a pillar of our democracy
15:19.4
What happened to ABS-CBN changed that forever
15:22.4
Changed that forever
15:23.4
So, now what you're seeing right now is
15:29.4
Of course, sinabi ng iba dyan is
15:30.4
Well, sinabi ni Ronald Llamas nung kausap natin siya
15:33.4
Sabi niya, it's poetic justice
15:35.4
So, I understand why yung iba natutuwa
15:39.4
Wow, poetic justice
15:40.4
Wow, itinga sa akin nila ganyan
15:41.4
Yung ganyan mindset
15:45.4
Medyo alanganin ako dito
15:48.4
You now have a situation whereby
15:50.4
Yung so-called SOTO law
15:52.4
Let's discuss that quite shortly
15:54.4
Well, more than shortly
15:59.4
Yung legal protections sa media
16:02.4
Are coming under assault or question
16:04.4
Now, we can have a legal debate about this
16:08.4
We can have further legal debate about this
16:10.4
But let me be very clear
16:11.4
Ano itong SOTO law na ito?
16:13.4
Hindi ito si Tito SOTO na ngayon
16:14.4
Pero yung dating SOTO
16:16.4
So, more than 70 years ago
16:20.4
Almost 75 years ago
16:22.4
Republic Act No. 53
16:24.4
Protected journalists from being forced
16:30.4
Yung kanilang mga confidential sources
16:35.4
Especially investigative journalists
16:39.4
Is if there's a certain degree of confidentiality
16:41.4
In the same way that
16:43.4
If you get a lawyer
16:44.4
You have a therapist
16:46.4
You need a certain degree of confidentiality
16:47.4
For that thing to work
16:49.4
Because maraming tao matatakot
16:51.4
To openly come out
16:53.4
And spill the beans
16:57.4
Is one of the very foundational laws
17:00.4
Which has allowed for the Philippines
17:02.4
To have one of the most vibrant
17:06.4
But one of the most vibrant
17:07.4
And freest media anywhere in Asia
17:10.4
At the very least
17:12.4
So, let's read this
17:15.4
The author of this
17:17.4
Is Senator Vicente Soto
17:19.4
Ito yung first ha
17:21.4
Hindi yung Tito Soto
17:23.4
Hindi ito yung mga Idbolaga people
17:25.4
Pwede natin pag-usapan ng Idbolaga
17:27.4
Separately one day
17:29.4
Ito yung the first
17:31.4
This is the special guy
17:32.4
This is the grand guy
17:34.4
And if you remember
17:38.4
Nung sa interview natin
17:40.4
With Lisandro Claudio
17:43.4
He was talking about how
17:46.4
Is reportedly going back to the works
17:49.4
Of his great-grandfather or grandfather
17:52.4
Itong si first Vicente Soto na yan
17:55.4
As a source of inspiration for statesmanship
17:59.4
Senator Vicente Soto
18:00.4
Ito yung pinaka-original
18:03.4
Ito yung pinaka-original
18:05.4
He is a legendary statesman
18:07.4
That really deserves a lot of respect
18:09.4
And one of his greatest contributions
18:10.4
To Philippine democracy
18:11.4
Was itong tinatawag na
18:12.4
Soto Law Republic Act No. 53
18:15.4
Let me just read mga kameta
18:16.4
Itong Section 1 ng batas na yan
18:19.4
Which was enacted in 1946
18:23.4
So, essentially at the inception
18:25.4
Of the Philippine Republic
18:27.4
Democratic Republic
18:28.4
Let's be very clear about that
18:30.4
So, masahin natin ha
18:32.4
Kung makinig kayo
18:33.4
I'll of course post this also sa baba
18:35.4
Para ma-appreciate nyo ito
18:37.4
The publisher, editor
18:39.4
Or duly accredited reporter
18:41.4
Of any newspaper, magazine
18:43.4
Or periodical of general circulation
18:48.4
Cannot be compelled to reveal
18:51.4
Hindi pwede pilitan
18:53.4
Ang isang reporter ng isang dyaryo
18:56.4
Or any duly accredited reporter
18:58.4
Ng dyaryo, magazine, or periodical
19:00.4
Ng isang general circulation
19:02.4
Cannot be compelled to reveal
19:04.4
The source of any news report or information
19:06.4
Appearing in said publication
19:08.4
Which was related in confidence
19:10.4
To such publisher, editor, or reporter
19:14.4
Of course, there's a caveat there
19:15.4
The court or a house
19:16.4
Or a committee of congress
19:18.4
Finds that such revelation is demanded
19:21.4
By the interest of the state
19:24.4
The interest of the state
19:26.4
Key dito yung issue ng interest ng state
19:29.4
Yung interest ng bayan
19:31.4
Or in this case, Estado
19:33.4
To be literal about this
19:35.4
Now, not long after
19:37.4
Yung definition of the phrase
19:39.4
The interest of the state
19:41.4
When isang newspaper reporter
19:43.4
Ay si Angel Parrazo
19:45.4
Angel, sorry Madrid
19:49.4
Ay nagsulat na isang news story
19:50.4
On the alleged leakage
19:53.4
Sa bar examination that year
19:55.4
So, matagal pa yan, no?
19:56.4
So, the reporter argued that
19:57.4
The interest of the state
19:59.4
Should be read to mean
20:00.4
Security of the state or public safety
20:03.4
But in ruling in December 1948
20:05.4
Eto, ruling ng Supreme Court of the Philippines
20:07.4
Yan, ito yung pinakamataas na
20:11.4
Maintaining that integrity of the examination
20:13.4
Qualified as interest of state
20:14.4
Ordered Parrazo to disclose the source
20:16.4
Or sources of information
20:17.4
For the news item
20:19.4
Of course, nag-refuse siya
20:20.4
And he was jailed
20:27.4
RA 1477 was passed
20:29.4
Amending itong section 1 ng batas na yan
20:32.4
So, the controversial phrase
20:33.4
Interest of the state
20:36.4
Pinalitan ito sa security of the state
20:39.4
Because the term interest
20:40.4
Is a little bit too vague
20:42.4
And pwede mo i-stretch yan
20:44.4
In fact, I think the proper term is
20:46.4
Pwede i-weaponize yan
20:50.4
Or to make it more academic, technical
20:52.4
Pwede yan i-securitize
20:55.4
Was changed to the security of the state
20:56.4
The phrase without prejudice
20:58.4
To his liability under the civil and criminal laws
21:00.4
Was also added to the beginning of the section
21:02.4
So, nagkaroon na amendments na
21:04.4
It shouldn't be prejudiced
21:06.4
To the liability under civil and criminal laws
21:08.4
So, ito yung context
21:11.4
Ng pinag-uusapan natin
21:15.4
Baka late na ako sa ano natin
21:17.4
So, please check this on your own
21:20.4
Ipupost ko yung mga kameta
21:21.4
Para basahin nyo na mabuti
21:23.4
Kasi mahalaga yan
21:24.4
Because what's happening right now
21:26.4
Is may mga nandyan sa Congress
21:31.4
SMNI anchors na kinulong
21:33.4
Over the past 24 hours or so
21:38.4
Kasi hindi sila duly accredited
21:42.4
Conception natin ng
21:46.4
What makes you a newspaper
21:48.4
Which raises a bigger question
21:55.4
Medyo mahabang usapan yun
21:57.4
I don't know how to go into this
21:59.4
Being a journalist
22:01.4
Sa aking palagay ha
22:03.4
I mean we can have a debate about this
22:05.4
But the moment you work already
22:07.4
For a major media outlet
22:10.4
You're a de facto journalist
22:13.4
And let's not forget that
22:15.4
There are big questions about
22:17.4
Ano ba talaga yung
22:18.4
The organization for accreditation of journalists
22:22.4
The moment you work for something like
22:23.4
The Philippine Daily Inquirer
22:26.4
Which is the leading newspaper in the country
22:27.4
The newspaper of record
22:29.4
The moment you work for ABS-CBN
22:33.4
Yung mga big media networks na yan
22:34.4
Whether kasama ka sa isang organization or not
22:37.4
You already qualify
22:40.4
So I consider myself as a journalist
22:44.4
Of course I'm not
22:47.4
I've not been part of any organization
22:49.4
But I do journalism
22:52.4
Nagsusulat po tayo dun sa pinakamalaking
22:55.4
Paper record in the country
22:56.4
And I've been working in the biggest
22:58.4
Television and media networks of the country
23:00.4
Over the past 6 years
23:02.4
And now the other one
23:05.4
That makes you a journalist
23:09.4
Kung hindi ka lang
23:12.4
Organization X, Y, and Z
23:14.4
Even though nag-work ka sa isang major mainstream media
23:16.4
Then hindi ka journalist
23:19.4
Wala kang protection side lalim ng
23:22.4
Or pwede mag-question yung
23:24.4
Pagiging journalist mo
23:27.4
This could actually set a very dangerous precedence
23:34.4
For you to work in a major media outlet
23:37.4
Whether it's a columnist, analyst, etc
23:38.4
Hindi ka required
23:41.4
Get accreditation from one body
23:43.4
Last time I checked
23:44.4
They're like multiple or
23:48.4
Also in the Philippines
23:50.4
All over the place
23:52.4
Yung journalism community
23:55.4
It's very fragmented
23:56.4
There's no longer single center of gravity
24:00.4
And the media landscape has
24:01.4
Completely changed
24:02.4
Completely changed
24:04.4
Over the past 10, 20 years
24:08.4
What I'm saying here is
24:09.4
We have to be very careful about
24:14.4
Kasi alam ko yung iba dyan
24:15.4
Excited lang sila
24:21.4
They have an axe to grind
24:22.4
Yung iba naglalabas ng popcorn, etc
24:24.4
I understand the short-term joy
24:26.4
Some people are getting
24:29.4
Always keep in mind
24:30.4
That we may set aside
24:32.4
Another dangerous precedence here
24:35.4
Kaya kung maalala niyo mga kamay
24:36.4
Nung nakausap natin si
24:42.4
Well the other month
24:43.4
Pinag-usapan naman yung issue ng
24:45.4
Yung mga pro-China propagandist
24:49.4
Eh yung iba parang binababoy nila
24:50.4
Yung ating demokrasya
24:52.4
Para supportahan yung position
24:54.4
Ng kalaban natin sa West Philippine Sea
24:56.4
Hindi ba kailangan na
24:57.4
Magkakaroon tayo ng mga batas
24:58.4
Kung saan pipilitin yung mga
25:03.4
Ano sila bayaran sila
25:06.4
I-declare nila na foreign agent sila
25:07.4
Then they can legally continue what they're doing
25:09.4
Pero at least transparent yung situation
25:10.4
Pero nalala nyo yung sinabi ni Justice Carpio
25:12.4
Na that's the dangerous
25:13.4
Kung mga precedence eh
25:16.4
Wala tayong problema dyan
25:17.4
Pero paano kung sa future
25:18.4
May mananalala naman ng pro-China president
25:21.4
Pwedeng gamitin yan
25:23.4
Oh ikaw pro-US ka
25:24.4
Or pro I don't know Japan ka
25:25.4
Tapos pwede gamitin sa iyo
25:26.4
So yung precedence is very important mga kumeta
25:30.4
An important glass ceiling was already shattered
25:34.4
Nung ginawa nila yung ginawa nila sa ABS-CBN
25:41.4
If hindi nangyari yun
25:42.4
I don't think mangyayari ngayon
25:44.4
Yung nangyayari sa SMNI
25:46.4
Pwedeng sabihin nung mga iba
25:47.4
Oh poetic justice yan
25:53.4
That's a kind of short-sighted
26:01.4
Because yun nga eh
26:04.4
Okay sabihin natin ganito ah
26:06.4
I'll push it to its logical conclusion
26:08.4
Sabihin natin okay
26:09.4
In the next six months
26:10.4
Ma matanggal talaga ng mga SMNI
26:12.4
Duterte lahat na yan sa eksena
26:14.4
And then anong mangyari
26:15.4
What happens the next day
26:16.4
Sa tingin niyo happy na everything
26:23.4
What I'm saying is at the very least
26:24.4
Watch very carefully what's happening right now
26:26.4
Because we might end up setting another precedence
26:28.4
Which can later on come to haunt people
26:33.4
I don't want to be prejudicial
26:34.4
Dun sa content ng diskusyon
26:36.4
Dun sa loob ng kongreso ngayon
26:39.4
I'm still willing to listen
26:40.4
I'm still looking at the arguments of different congressmen
26:43.4
Some of them saying that
26:45.4
Hindi eh hindi applicable ang SOTO law dito
26:48.4
We have to watch very carefully
26:51.4
Para siguraduin na hindi niya maweaponize
26:57.4
Ang certain interpretation of SOTO law
27:00.4
Or maweaponize yung
27:02.4
Invocation of exemption from the SOTO law
27:04.4
This is very very important
27:07.4
And I'm not saying this because I'm a person who happens to work in a major media outlet
27:12.4
But I'm saying as someone who's actually looking at the rule of law
27:15.4
And rule of law means
27:17.4
Predictable and uniform applicability of law across time and space
27:21.4
Alright let's be very clear about it
27:22.4
Rule of law doesn't mean na
27:23.4
Kung anong sinabi nung isang gobyerno
27:26.4
Pagdating sa interpretation nila sa batas
27:28.4
That's not rule of law
27:29.4
That's rule by law
27:30.4
The proposition is very important there
27:32.4
A rule of law situation is across time and space
27:35.4
And different administration
27:36.4
There's a uniformity and predictability
27:38.4
In application of law
27:41.4
You don't do mumbo jumbo interpretation
27:43.4
Based on who's holding the throne
27:47.4
So that's why mga kamenta
27:48.4
Alam ko yung iba sa inyo
27:50.4
Poetic justice yung thing nyo
27:53.4
Naglalabas kayo ng popcorn
27:54.4
But be very careful
27:55.4
But be very very careful
28:00.4
Nagpa-popcorn yung iba dyan
28:02.4
Nung tinatanggal yung franchise ng ABS-CBN
28:05.4
O nasan sila ngayon?
28:06.4
Nung sinasabi nung iba is
28:09.4
Yes but at the same time
28:11.4
Minsan precedence is also important
28:13.4
Bilog ang mundo maybe for
28:15.4
You know you could argue that
28:16.4
Yes bilog ang mundo dun sa mga nag-abuso
28:18.4
Pero minsan bilog din ang mundo
28:20.4
Para dun sa mga hindi masamang tao
28:23.4
Tignan mo yung nangyari kay Layla dyan?
28:25.4
Tignan mo yung nangyari sa
28:27.4
Maraming kaibigan natin sa journalism
28:31.4
But these are good people
28:33.4
And what was done to them was unjust
28:35.4
It's very very important mga kamenta
28:37.4
To look at what's happening right now
28:39.4
And making sure na hindi magkakaroon ng
28:41.4
Isa pang problematic precedence
28:43.4
Because even if sabihin natin
28:45.4
Things go down to their logical conclusion
28:48.4
At matanggal ng mga Dutertes
28:50.4
Mawala talaga ng UNITEAM
28:51.4
At matanggal ng SMNI
28:53.4
The question is what's gonna happen the day after?
28:55.4
Or the year after?
28:57.4
Or what about isang pang presidente
29:01.4
Na sobrang authoritarian ulit
29:04.4
At pwedeng gamitin itong mga nangyari ngayon
29:06.4
Para i-silence ang media
29:08.4
Even worse than that
29:10.4
Baka nga maraming mga journalist
29:12.4
Or media man dyan
29:13.4
Ay magdadalaw ang isip na forever
29:15.4
Magsa-self-censor na sila
29:17.4
Mag-worry na sila
29:18.4
Because nakikita nila
29:19.4
O itong ginawa sa IBC men
29:20.4
Itong ginawa sa SMNI
29:25.4
Undermines the fundamentals of our democracy
29:31.4
Excited din yung iba
29:32.4
Nagpa-popcorn na yung iba
29:33.4
Schadenfreude din yung iba
29:34.4
But do not forget mga kameta
29:36.4
We cannot have a real democracy
29:38.4
Until we have real rule of law
29:40.4
And that's why it's very important
29:41.4
You don't have to be a lawyer
29:42.4
You don't have to be a constitutional law expert
29:44.4
You don't have to be a legislator
29:45.4
You don't have to be an official
29:47.4
For you to care about
29:48.4
How law is applied in this country
29:50.4
And what interpretation of law is applied
29:53.4
Across time and space
29:54.4
And administrations
29:55.4
Otherwise, banana republic tayo
29:57.4
I'm not saying that's our case
29:58.4
But I'm saying we have to make sure
29:59.4
We don't become a banana republic
30:01.4
But instead we become a nation of rule of law
30:04.4
Thank you very much mga kameta
30:05.4
Kailangan ko na tumakbo
30:07.4
I really appreciate this discussion
30:09.4
Salamat sa lahat ng mga naka-comment dyan
30:11.4
Sa mga supporta dyan
30:13.4
Medyo pagod na tayo
30:14.4
Ang dami nating ginagawa
30:15.4
Pang-ilan na na natin yan
30:17.4
Live natin today pa lang
30:21.4
Yeah, these are intense moments
30:25.4
May kanchawan ako
30:31.4
But I'm a very serious guy
30:32.4
I'm also looking at the
30:35.4
That's what leadership is all about
30:37.4
That's what critical thinking is about
30:39.4
You're not only looking at
30:40.4
What happiness you're getting now
30:41.4
Or what sadness you're getting now
30:43.4
You're looking at the
30:44.4
Long-term horizon
30:45.4
Because that's the best way
30:46.4
We can care about our democracy
30:48.4
So best wishes sa ating mga congressman
30:50.4
As they try to examine
30:51.4
What's happening here
30:52.4
Because if indeed
30:53.4
There has been a clear abuse
30:56.4
Journalistic prerogative
31:00.4
Of yung franchise na binigay
31:01.4
Sa isang media outlet
31:04.4
There should be a basis
31:05.4
For re-examining that franchise
31:07.4
So I'm not against
31:08.4
Re-examine the franchise
31:09.4
But we have to make sure
31:10.4
That this is in accordance
31:12.4
Yun po yung sinasabi natin
31:14.4
So whether you feel good
31:16.4
That should be secondary
31:17.4
It's the rule of law
31:18.4
Which is the most important one
31:21.4
Thank you very much
31:24.4
Natutuwa yung mga kat-DDS natin
31:25.4
Mga lalaki yung mga followers
31:26.4
Natin ng DDS igla
31:29.4
Thank you very much
31:33.4
And God bless the Philippines
31:36.4
Naihirapan ang bansa natin
31:37.4
But we have to do our best
31:38.4
To make sure our democracy
31:41.4
And hopefully thrive
31:43.4
With or without unity
31:45.4
Mukhang wala ng unity
31:48.4
Thank you very much guys
31:49.4
And talk to you soon
31:51.4
Pasensya na kung hindi ko
31:52.4
Nakakaayos yung audio dito
31:53.4
Hopefully next night will be
31:54.4
But hindi ko nakahanap
31:55.4
Sana hindi nakahulog
31:56.4
I hope hindi nakahulog
31:57.4
Yung wiring system natin
31:58.4
Salamat God bless
