Close
 


VIOLATIONS NG SMNI SA KANILNG PRANKISA AYON KAY MIGS NOGRALES
Hide Subtitles
Click any subtitle word to view Tagalog.com dictionary results.
Computer Shortcuts: Left / Right arrows to jump 2 seconds back or forward. +Enter or Space to toggle Play/Pause button. Full Screen Mode
VIOLATIONS NG SMNI SA KANILNG PRANKISA AYON KAY MIGS NOGRALES Eto po bagong FB natin para sa videos: https://www.facebook.com/BATASnatin-107860591437195 https://www.facebook.com/Atty-Ranny-Randolf-B-Libayan-154012243457531 Alternate YT channel po for livestreams: https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCskZGSV52krMvXgb8OXXx1g WEBSITE: https://batasnatin.com/ LAW FIRM: https://firm.batasnatin.com/ FACEBOOK PAGE: https://www.facebook.com/BATASnatin/ INSTAGRAM: https://www.instagram.com/batasnatin/ YOUTUBE CHANNEL: https://youtube.com/BATASnatinLive TWITTER: https://twitter.com/BATASnatin LAWYERS: Atty. Kristina Louise Magalong Atty. Ranny Randolf B. Libayan FIRM ADDRESS: #31 Gen. Luna St., Tuktukan, Taguig City, NCR (Across Taguig City Hall) Email: BATASnatin@gmail.com Telephone nos: +63915-954-6080 (+632)359-4203 We are a full-service Law Firm We handle and are experienced in litigating many kinds of cases. Please do not hesitate to contact us. We will be ha
Atty. Ranny Randolf B. Libayan
  Mute  
Run time: 18:14
Has AI Subtitles



Video Transcript / Subtitles:( AI generated. About AI subtitles » )
00:00.0
Alright, yan! Magandang araw mga kabatas natin at welcome sa isa na mong live stream
00:06.8
Mga kabatas natin, itong si Congresswoman Migs Nograles
00:16.5
Sinasabi dito sa balita, siya po yung nangunguna doon sa pagpapakensela
00:23.1
o sa pagtawag para doon sa pagpapakensela ng SMNI franchise
00:30.5
Ngayon mga kabatas natin, bago tayo pumunta dyan sa mga violations
00:37.5
I-issue muna natin yung issue na ini-issue kay Congresswoman Migs Nograles
00:46.5
Abogado rin siya mga kabatas natin
00:47.9
At siya ay anak din ng isang abogado na sikat
00:52.7
Sino yung tatay niya?
00:55.5
Top 1 yata sa bar yun, diba? Top 1 sa bar yun
00:58.2
Mga kabatas natin
00:59.1
Ewan ko, top 1 din ba sa bar si Migs Nograles?
01:02.4
Hindi ko alam mga kabatas natin
01:03.7
Pero may issue nga na i-issue sa kanya na i-issue din natin ngayon sa ating live stream
01:10.0
Yung SMNI mga kabatas natin kung saan siya yung nangunguna
01:14.3
na sumisigaw sa kanyang pagkansela ng prangkisa
01:22.3
Dati daw pala siyang miyembro nito
01:26.3
Ngayon sinasabi ng mga tao parang wala daw siyang utang na loob
01:31.5
Prospero Nograles
01:33.3
Siya yata? Oo, Prospero Nograles
01:36.2
Wala daw siyang utang na loob
01:38.0
Bago tayo pumunta dyan mga kabatas natin
01:40.0
At ipapaliwanag ko din yan mga kabatas natin kung ano ba't silbi ng utang na loob yan
01:44.4
E panuorin muna natin ito
01:47.2
Dito daw siya naging miyembro sa Pinoy Legal Minds
01:50.0
Ito ay...
01:51.1
Ah...
01:52.1
Mula sa vlog ni Kuya Mark Tolentino
01:54.7
Kung saan mga kabatas natin
01:57.3
Siya nga yung isa sa mga abugado ng SMNI
02:03.0
Tignan natin ha
02:04.0
Token kay Congresswoman
02:06.1
Migs Nograles as part of the show of Pinoy
02:10.4
Yan, so part of Pinoy Legal Minds
02:14.1
Makikita niyo SMNI naman mga kabatas natin
02:19.2
At siya yun, di ba?
02:20.0
Wala nga namang ano...
02:22.1
Yan, gano ba siya katagal dito?
02:28.8
Yan, imute na lang natin
02:36.8
Ah, guys, ano ko walang expiration date?
02:46.0
Ah, sana'y walang expiration date?
02:51.9
Ah, sana'y walang expiration date?
02:52.1
Bukod dyan mga kabatas natin
02:53.9
Lumabas din dito sa abugado.com.ph
02:57.7
Sabi dito, may history
03:00.3
O bakit ganyan?
03:02.5
Ano ba naman yan?
03:03.4
Itong adibaba talaga
03:04.6
May history
03:05.2
Migs Nograles hosted an SMNI show
03:07.9
Before she sought its franchise suspension
03:10.6
Sabi niya
03:12.7
Before leading the call for the suspension of the franchise of Sunshine Media Network International
03:19.2
Abugado and PBA party list reputasyon
03:22.1
Representative Margarita Migs Nograles hosted a show on the network
03:27.3
Nung April, itong taon lang ito
03:36.7
Naging regular co-host daw siya ng Pinoy Legal Minds
03:40.8
Pero nung August
03:44.6
Pero sinabi walang expiration, no?
03:47.5
In-announce na niya siya ay aalis sa Pinoy Legal Minds
03:51.1
Saying she was unable to...
03:52.1
To appear in its Saturday shows
03:53.4
Due to some conflict in schedule
03:55.1
Si Tolentino, yung representative
04:01.7
Ng SMNI bilang abugado
04:04.8
Sa hearing sa House of Representatives
04:07.1
Tapos, ito naman si Nograles
04:10.6
Ang nag-file ng resolution
04:11.8
Para isuspinde ng NTC
04:14.2
Ang franchise ng SMNI
04:15.8
Yun nga yung hini-hearing nila ngayon
04:19.5
Okay?
04:20.7
Okay?
04:22.1
Ito din sa akin ito, mga kabatas natin
04:23.5
Kasi nga, ang laging lumalabas sa media
04:26.4
At yun din ang kinontent natin
04:28.2
Ay yung tungkol sa contempt issue
04:29.9
Hindi ito
04:32.0
Okay?
04:34.3
Ito
04:34.7
Nograles is the daughter of the late former speaker
04:39.7
And Davao City Representative Prospero Nograles
04:42.7
Who was once Duterte's political foe
04:44.6
Ito kasi nangyayari eh
04:45.9
Parang laban na naman daw ng ano eh
04:48.6
Ng mga politiko eh
04:50.7
So, dun muna tayo sa...
04:52.1
Mga kabatas natin
04:52.9
Sa utang na loob
04:53.9
Yung naging ano siya
04:55.1
Kung yung naging
04:56.5
Naging siya na daw yung
05:01.1
Pangunahin
05:03.8
Na nagpapakansila sa SMNI
05:05.7
Sinasabi nila wala kang utang na loob
05:07.7
Sumali ka naman dun
05:09.0
Mga kabatas natin
05:10.5
Ito lang kasi ah
05:13.0
Napakasimple lang yung issue dito
05:14.3
Ang issue dito mga kabatas natin
05:18.0
Eh, ano ba ang mas mananaig?
05:21.2
Yung obligasyon
05:22.1
Yung obligasyon mo dun sa taong bayan
05:23.5
Na naglukluk sa'yo
05:24.5
Yung obligasyon mo dun sa bansa mo
05:27.1
Sa bayan mo
05:28.0
O yung obligasyon mo dun sa dating employer mo
05:31.2
Sa tingin ko madali lang naman sagutin yun
05:33.5
Diba?
05:34.5
Kaya hindi naman na dapat nagiging issue
05:36.5
Kung naging
05:37.0
Membro siya dati ng Pinoy Legal Minds
05:39.5
Ang pagtutuunan natin ngayon
05:40.9
Dapat nampansin
05:41.7
Eh, yung mga violations ng SMNI
05:44.3
Sa kanilang prangkisa
05:45.4
Kung meron nga
05:46.1
So, kung nakalagay nga dito
05:47.7
Mga kabatas natin
05:48.7
Ay
05:49.3
Yung mga violations
05:49.9
Yung mga violations ng SMNI
05:52.1
Sa kanilang prangkisa
05:54.8
Diba?
05:56.8
Ayon kay Migs Nograles
05:58.0
O, tignan natin
05:58.8
Para makahinga muna tayo nung konti
06:01.3
Dahil medyo hindi
06:02.5
Masyadong sinasagot yung mga tanong natin
06:06.6
If it's okay with the committee
06:09.0
If we go through
06:10.2
Some violations na lang
06:12.2
Sa prangkisa nila
06:13.7
Sorry, to
06:15.6
I will ask questions
06:18.1
And mostly
06:19.6
Sections 10 and 11
06:21.6
Okay
06:22.1
Please proceed
06:23.0
To Honorable Negraves
06:24.2
To
06:25.6
SMNI, I guess
06:27.5
Attorney Mark Tomentino
06:29.0
Yes, I can answer that
06:30.4
In 2005
06:32.3
Kingdom of Jesus
06:33.6
GIS
06:34.7
States that
06:35.6
Pastor Kibuloy
06:36.6
Is the chairman
06:37.3
And registered as
06:38.7
A non-stock corporation
06:40.5
Correct?
06:42.0
I have with me
06:43.0
The
06:43.7
The history of SMNI
06:46.1
Just asking a yes or no question
06:48.1
About what, Mr.
06:49.8
Yun naman tayo sa yes or no question eh
06:51.7
O, sige
06:52.1
Sige
06:52.4
Taling natin
06:53.1
Yes
06:53.3
Mag-jowa ba sila?
06:59.8
Anong mag-jowa ba sila?
07:02.0
O, taling natin
07:02.7
Can you please rephrase the question?
07:05.1
In 2005
07:06.2
Yes or no lang po ah?
07:08.0
Kingdom of Jesus
07:09.1
The GIS states
07:11.6
That Pastor Kibuloy
07:13.7
Is the chairman
07:14.6
And the corporation is registered as
07:17.8
A non-stock corporation
07:19.6
Correct?
07:20.4
Yes, Mr. Chair
07:21.2
Yes, Mr. Chair
07:22.1
Then, Mr. Chair
07:23.4
Sometime
07:24.0
Sometime
07:25.4
You became a
07:27.3
Sole corporation
07:28.8
Correct?
07:30.2
Yes, Mr. Chair
07:30.9
When did you become a sole corporation?
07:36.5
Okay
07:36.8
In 1999
07:40.0
We are talking of Suarazug
07:48.1
Media Corporation
07:49.3
Or the executive
07:50.5
Executive
07:51.9
Executive
07:52.0
Executive
07:52.1
Kingdom of Jesus Christ
07:55.7
Yes
07:56.0
So
07:56.6
I
07:57.1
Well, at first
07:58.4
Like I said
07:59.4
Sabi ni Amic TV
08:01.6
45 years
08:03.2
Bakit mahilig sa answer
08:04.4
Mas madali kasi pag gano'n
08:06.1
Mas madali pag gano'n
08:09.0
Mas maikli din
08:09.9
Para makapaglay down kagad ng facts
08:12.6
Earlier, 2005
08:14.3
It was Kingdom of Jesus, right?
08:16.9
And it was a non-stock
08:17.9
And then
08:20.7
In 2006
08:21.1
In 2006
08:21.1
In 2006
08:21.2
In 2006
08:21.8
We amend
08:22.4
The Kingdom of Jesus Christ
08:25.3
To the Executive Pastor
08:26.4
Of Kingdom of Jesus Christ
08:28.9
By amending Article 1
08:30.8
And converting
08:31.7
Corporation
08:32.9
To Corporation Sole
08:34.6
Mr. Chair
08:35.1
So
08:35.8
2006
08:37.1
You became a
08:38.7
Corporation Sole
08:40.5
Yes, Mr. Chair
08:41.7
And during this time
08:43.2
Ito yung sinasabi rin nila
08:44.4
Parang anong feeling
08:45.7
Nang
08:46.3
Anong feeling
08:47.2
Nang yung dati mong kasama
08:48.6
Kalaban mo na gano'n
08:49.9
It's
08:50.8
It's
08:51.8
Alam nyo
08:52.5
If it's
08:53.6
If you are professionals
08:54.8
If you are professionals
08:56.2
This is nothing
08:57.1
Wala ito
08:58.6
Pag professionals kayo
08:59.6
You just do your work
09:00.5
Gagawin niya
09:02.5
Yung trabaho niya
09:03.6
Bilang isa siyang
09:04.9
Ano
09:06.0
Nilukluk ng taong bayan
09:07.8
Isang public official
09:09.1
Gagawin din ni Mark Tolentino
09:11.0
Yung trabaho niya
09:11.6
Bilang abugado
09:12.7
Nang SMNI
09:14.0
Trabaho lang yan
09:16.1
Okay
09:16.8
Trabaho lang yan
09:19.6
Who is the executive pastor
09:21.8
Of that corporation soul?
09:25.3
Pastor Apollo
09:26.0
As an executive pastor
09:28.9
Ito sabi ni
09:30.6
Atty. May yes or no ba sa korte?
09:34.5
Meron
09:34.8
Sa cross-examination
09:36.6
Usually
09:37.1
Yes or no lang yan
09:39.1
In this corporation soul
09:42.0
By definition of the corporation code
09:44.4
He administers
09:46.2
Manages as the trustee
09:48.9
Properties of the corporation
09:51.5
Correct?
09:53.9
Yes, Mr. Chair
09:54.9
As the trustee
09:57.1
Pastor T. Boloy
09:58.0
Had the power to manage
09:59.5
The assets of the corporation
10:01.4
Meaning he may buy, sell, encumber
10:03.8
Lease properties, etc.
10:05.4
For the corporation, right?
10:07.1
But still in compliance with
10:09.0
Yes or no, Mr. Chair
10:10.5
Sir Nick
10:11.0
Prado naman po ang
10:12.7
It's answer first
10:14.3
Yes or no
10:15.3
And if you would like to explain
10:16.7
You can expound
10:17.4
Yes, Mr. Chair
10:18.6
But can I explain, Mr. Chair?
10:20.7
Sure
10:20.9
Yes, of course
10:21.5
There is a procedure
10:23.3
Not just the pastoral side
10:25.9
There is a body
10:27.4
To
10:29.4
In respect to the process of changing
10:31.6
Or with respect to the decision of the
10:33.9
So the answer is yes
10:35.9
The answer is yes
10:37.1
Siya pa rin
10:37.9
Yes, for the procedure
10:40.2
Yes, please
10:41.1
So does he have the power to sell
10:45.1
Managed by properties for beneficiaries?
10:48.4
With respect to what year, Mr. Chair?
10:50.4
Yes
10:51.5
With his power as the trustee
10:53.5
As the executive pastor
10:55.5
In what year, Mr. Chair?
10:55.8
Because the
10:56.7
The executive pastor
10:59.8
Was already transferred to
11:01.4
Pag nakikita nyo, tama rin yan, no?
11:04.3
Silang dalawa, pareho silang abugado
11:06.4
Nagre-refer sila doon sa Mr. Chair
11:09.3
Nakita nyo?
11:10.5
Yung sinasabi ko sa inyo
11:11.7
Hindi ka makikipag-usap diretso
11:14.4
Doon sa kalaban mo
11:16.9
O sa kausap mo
11:18.8
Kaya sila Mr. Chair ng Mr. Chair
11:21.1
Mr. Chair yung kinakausap nila
11:23.0
Ito, kailangan kong i-explain kasi
11:25.7
Nang paulit-ulit ito
11:26.6
Kasi maraming hindi nakakaintindi
11:28.0
That is for the orderly procedure
11:30.8
So pag titignan nyo
11:32.5
Itong si Migs Nogralis
11:33.6
Mr. Chair siya ng Mr. Chair
11:34.9
Yung Mr. Chair
11:35.7
Yung kausap niya
11:37.0
Kaya yung sinabi niya na
11:38.4
Yes or no answers only Mr. Chair
11:40.7
Sumagot si Mr. Chair
11:42.3
Sinabi niya
11:43.0
Okay
11:43.7
You answer it by yes or no
11:46.0
Then
11:46.7
After you answer
11:48.3
Ask if you can explain
11:51.1
So yun ang nangyari
11:52.3
Pinayagan siya
11:53.3
Hindi sila nagbangayan na dalawa
11:55.6
Diba?
11:57.2
Gets? Gets na?
11:58.5
Gets na?
11:59.4
Ganyan dapat
12:00.0
Diba parang maayos?
12:04.3
Diba?
12:06.0
Oh
12:06.4
Para maiwasan din ang tensyon
12:10.0
Mga disente kasi sila
12:11.8
Yes
12:12.3
Even if for example
12:14.3
Hindi mo na gusto yung ginagawa niya
12:15.9
You address the chair
12:17.0
Just like you address the judge
12:19.2
Diba?
12:21.1
Tell me how I die
12:25.9
Isa na ako dun sa hindi nakakaintindi attorney
12:29.8
Nga alam ko marami
12:31.4
Kasi kapag hindi ka talaga
12:33.3
Hindi mo talaga kabisado
12:34.7
Yung mga ganitong klaseng proceedings
12:36.1
You don't understand
12:38.6
Why?
12:39.2
Chair sila ng chair
12:40.1
Lahat sila chair?
12:41.8
Diba isa lang yung chairman?
12:43.1
Chairwoman?
12:43.9
O kaya chairperson?
12:45.3
Isa lang
12:45.8
Pero chair sila ng chair dun
12:47.3
Kasi nga dapat yung chair
12:48.8
Yung kausap nila
12:49.8
Yung chairman yung kausap nila
12:51.1
O chairwoman
12:51.8
O chairperson
12:52.5
Ang kausap nila
12:53.3
Kits
12:55.1
Tuloy natin
12:56.7
Marlon Acobo
12:57.8
Mr. Chair in 2020
12:59.0
That's why I'm asking
12:59.9
What year Mr. Chair?
13:01.9
Before the transfer na lang
13:03.5
Sige
13:03.9
Before the transfer
13:05.3
Yes Mr. Chair
13:06.0
So
13:07.1
You're saying
13:08.2
Pastor Kibuloy
13:09.1
Before that transfer
13:10.3
Has control over the interest
13:12.1
Over the properties of the corporation
13:14.9
Thus
13:15.3
Controlling interest
13:16.7
Right?
13:18.3
He is the
13:19.1
Trustee Mr. Chair
13:20.4
So
13:21.1
Subject to the
13:22.3
So may controlling interest po ba
13:23.9
Mr. Chair
13:24.4
Dahil siya yung nagmamanage
13:26.0
At lahat
13:26.7
Claro naman po natin yung sagot
13:29.2
Yes or no?
13:30.4
Yes
13:30.5
Makasingit lang your honor
13:33.9
Hindi rin pwede yan
13:35.1
Kasi kung hindi ka na-recognize
13:37.0
Ito kasi mga kabatas natin
13:38.7
Parang pinapadali nila yung pangyayari
13:41.3
Although ina-address nila si Mr. Chair
13:45.1
Parang hindi na kailangang sumagot
13:48.6
Si Mr. Chair
13:50.0
Kasi nga
13:50.8
Both of them are recognized
13:52.5
Pero yung makasingit lang your honor
13:54.8
Kailangan yung sisingit
13:56.2
Ma-recognize ka
13:57.1
Kasi kung dalawa lang sila na na-recognize
13:59.1
Na mag-uusap ng ganyan
14:00.6
Addressing you
14:02.0
Okay na na hindi ka sumagot-sagot
14:04.3
As long as it is in an orderly manner
14:06.6
Pero if there are issues to be resolved
14:09.5
Point of order
14:10.6
Motions to be resolved
14:12.0
Kailangan sumagot ni Mr. Chair
14:13.7
Okay? Tuloy natin
14:15.0
Mr. Chair
14:15.5
With respect to the Executive Pastor
14:17.0
Of the Kingdom of Jesus Christ
14:18.2
Yes, okay
14:18.9
So you mentioned
14:20.7
That there was a transfer
14:22.3
Of the Executive Pastor
14:24.8
Yes, in 2020, Mr. Chair
14:26.8
2020?
14:29.5
Yes
14:29.8
Are you sure?
14:31.4
In the year 2020
14:32.3
May amended
14:34.5
Yes, there's an amendment
14:36.7
Yes, Mr. Chair
14:37.5
2020 ba yung nakasulat dyan?
14:40.3
Or 2022?
14:43.4
Ang amended AOI nyo
14:45.5
Document
14:46.7
It says
14:49.1
I also have the document
14:50.6
And the committee has the document
14:52.8
Kung Migs
14:53.3
Can you please ascertain the date?
14:57.0
20 or
14:57.4
Is it really 2020?
14:59.8
Yeah, pagtignan nyo
15:00.8
Medyo maayos itong usapan na ito
15:04.8
Kapag merong hindi na maayos na nangyayari
15:08.2
Magbabat in si Mr. Chair
15:10.6
Iaayos niya
15:12.2
Kaya meron siyang gavel dun eh
15:14.3
Pag nagkakagulo na
15:15.4
Pupukpukin niya yun
15:18.2
Mayroon ito
15:19.3
Mayroon ito
15:20.6
I think the committee has the AOI
15:26.4
Mr. Chair
15:27.3
Yes
15:27.9
Of the amended AOI
15:29.7
Mayroon ito
15:30.4
Atty.
15:32.5
Mayroon ito
15:34.3
Is it 2022?
15:37.8
2022 applied but approved in 2023
15:40.1
2020
15:41.9
You have a copy of
15:43.2
You have a copy of Mr. Chair
15:45.5
Applied in 2022
15:46.6
Approved in 2023
15:49.1
So hindi 2020
15:50.1
Okay
15:51.0
So Mr. Chair
15:53.7
If I can just direct to the committee na lang
15:55.7
If you have the copy
15:57.0
Yes
15:58.1
Can you please read na lang
16:00.4
If he can read Mr. Chair
16:02.1
The amended articles of incorporation
16:05.0
On when the date it was adopted
16:08.1
Who are you directing?
16:10.5
Sabi niya
16:11.4
Bakit sa tenant attorney palaging magulo?
16:15.2
Siguro may chance naman silang ayusin dun no?
16:18.0
Parang naging ano yata eh
16:19.7
Mga kapatid
16:20.1
Naging kampante na sila
16:22.0
O kaya naging comfortable na sila sa magulo
16:24.1
Diba?
16:26.3
Naging comfortable na sila sa magulo
16:27.9
I have with me here Mr. Chair
16:31.3
Yes
16:31.9
Can you please
16:33.4
Mr. Chair
16:34.4
On December 19, 2022
16:37.2
So 2022
16:38.1
Okay
16:39.7
And attached there
16:42.7
Is a transfer
16:47.7
Certificate of appointment
16:50.0
Yes Mr. Chair
16:51.5
That's the basis Mr. Chair
16:53.1
For the transfer
16:54.8
Of the new trustee
16:56.6
Yes Mr. Chair
16:58.1
Anyway mga kapatid natin
17:00.4
Siguro ano no
17:01.4
Gusto ko lang naman i-emphasize dito muna yung
17:04.3
Propriety no
17:05.5
Kanyang
17:06.2
Pagtatanong
17:07.6
Tapos isusunod na natin yung mga ano
17:10.5
Yung mga paglabag
17:11.7
Siguro ipupunto ko na dun sa mga diretsyong
17:14.7
Paglabag na inaano nyo
17:16.3
Kanyang mga pinupunto
17:20.0
Gusto ko lang munang ipakita sa inyo mga kapatid natin
17:23.0
Na pwede namang maging maayos
17:24.6
At ipaliwanag sa inyo na yung kaayusan
17:27.0
Madali lang naman makamit yun
17:28.6
If people will really participate
17:30.9
In following the rules
17:33.8
Okay
17:34.6
Yan
17:36.1
Tsaka syempre yung issue na binabato sa kanya
17:38.3
Na parang wala siyang utang na loob
17:40.2
Na nasagot na rin natin
17:41.8
Sabi ni ano ni Deans
17:46.1
Libs, bugok ka daw
17:48.7
Yun na ba?
17:49.3
Yun na ba yung pinakamatindi?
17:53.0
Oo, Margarita
17:54.4
Wannabe, babay na
17:56.2
Yun na bang bugok na yung
17:59.0
Pinakamatindi nila?
18:00.8
Try again, hindi masakit
18:02.4
Maraming salamat at syempre tulad na lagi
18:04.5
Ang sinasabi, matulog po tayo na mahimbing
18:06.5
Dahil alam natin na yung natutulog na mahimbing
18:08.5
Siya yung laging panalo
18:09.9
Paalam po, pansamantan