PREVENTIVE SUSPENSION SA SMNI SAPAT NA BA? DUTERTE VS. DUTERTE
01:28.1
Ito ba ay necessary step?
01:31.1
Pero pag titignan nyo, holding it accountable.
01:33.4
I don't know if this is the actual text or words na sinabi nung mga lawmakers.
01:40.1
Kasi if you are holding something accountable already in relation to something that he has done, of course, we need due process.
01:48.8
Because that is already in the form of a penalty.
01:53.3
Ngayon, sabi nga,
01:54.1
Gabriela Women's Representative Arlene Brosa said the Maccabayan Bloc is pressing for a thorough investigation of the media entity owned by televangelist and sex trafficker Apolo Cubuloy and for the National Telecommunications Commission to enforce sanctions as necessary.
02:15.4
Okay? So parang, syempre, pag-investigation pa lang dyan, dito naman makikita mo na ang pinapatukuyan dito siguro ay preventive suspension.
02:24.1
Suspension, mga kabatas natin.
02:27.4
And, in my opinion, the logical suspension na pwedeng ipataw dito ay preventive suspension.
02:39.3
Preventive suspension.
02:40.4
Kasi alam nyo naman ang suspension, mga kabatas natin, pag sa labor code.
02:43.3
Labor code ito, ha?
02:44.8
Singitan ko lang kayo ng konting kaalaman para matandaan nyo.
02:47.7
Pag suspension sa labor code, pag nasuspenda ka sa trabaho, ang maximum niyan 30 days.
02:51.8
Kapag lumampas ka sa 30 days,
02:54.1
eh, magiging constructive dismissal na yun.
02:56.5
Siningit ko lang yun, pero hindi yan applicable dito.
02:58.9
Para lang, alam nyo yun, magkaroon kayo ng konting recall doon sa suspension.
03:05.3
DAUS Assistant Minority Leader said,
03:07.3
NTC suspension of SMNI prodded by House Resolution No. 189
03:12.5
appears to be a response aimed at addressing its numerous past violations.
03:17.6
So, ibig sabihin, mga kabatas natin, dito,
03:23.2
This is the full context.
03:25.1
Itong kinote na ito.
03:26.9
That suspension is not preventive.
03:31.7
That suspension is not preventive
03:33.9
because it is aimed at addressing its numerous past violations.
03:39.3
Ibig sabihin, penalty.
03:45.5
She added that the suspension further underscores the need
03:48.3
to address the spread of disinformation and threats through various media platforms.
03:53.2
Ngayon, dito, lumalabas din na parang preventive din siya.
03:57.8
Pwede bang dalawa?
04:04.9
Dapat pag sususpindihin mo,
04:09.8
It's either preventive siya,
04:14.1
Anong tawag dyan?
04:16.9
In the form of penalty.
04:19.4
Ngayon, mga kabatas natin,
04:23.1
siyempre, kapag it is in the form of penalty,
04:26.1
there is no use to preventively suspend them.
04:30.4
And if it is a preventive suspension,
04:34.7
you don't need to follow due process
04:36.8
because it is not penalty.
04:40.9
Sabi niyang ganyan,
04:41.7
process claimed that the SMNI and the National Task Force
04:44.7
to end local communist armed conflict
04:46.4
have been working hand in hand in spreading fake news
04:49.6
and disinformation targeting activists and progressive leaders.
04:53.1
Ito, mga kabatas natin,
05:09.6
linabas yung ano na, no?
05:14.4
Castro said that SMNI's case is unlike ABS-CBN's,
05:18.1
which the Duterte family intentionally shut down
05:21.3
for its criticisms against them.
05:23.1
Ngayon, mga kabatas natin,
05:25.2
ilagay kasi natin, no?
05:27.0
Yung ano, yung...
05:29.1
Yung mga nangyayari ngayon,
05:33.1
doon sa linalabas din nila na Duterte versus Duterte.
05:38.5
Makikita nyo naman dito, mga kabatas natin, no?
05:42.8
at saka dito sa mga sinasabi dito, no?
05:53.1
Through investigation of the media entity
05:57.7
owned by televangelist and alleged sex trafficker
06:07.1
Ngayon, puntahan natin yung kay Duterte naman.
06:11.1
Mga kabatas natin.
06:15.9
Kasi, syempre, ang linalabas dito,
06:18.8
Duterte versus Duterte.
06:21.1
Bias daw si Duterte.
06:24.7
Parang yung article din kanina na yun,
06:30.1
Anti din kay Duterte yung sinabi ng Castro na yun
06:33.4
kasi nga, may bias din siya.
06:39.0
Sinabi ni, ano daw, no, Duterte.
06:42.6
It's a impact leadership ito.
06:44.8
Noong December 21, 2023,
06:46.7
a temporary preventive suspension is by itself already censorship.
06:51.5
You can't speak, you're censored.
06:54.9
So, to me, to that extent or to the full time
06:58.1
that you are not allowed to talk,
06:59.7
it is a derogation of your right,
07:01.8
of your constitutional right to free speech and free expression.
07:06.6
Sa akin naman, mga kabatas natin,
07:08.8
yung preventive suspension,
07:10.5
hindi naman necessary yan na, ano siya, censorship.
07:16.4
If it is based on valid grounds.
07:19.9
Like, for example,
07:20.9
dapat may paliwanag mo naman kung bakit nagkaroon ng preventive suspension.
07:25.5
Bakit nagkaroon ng preventive suspension para hindi na sila makapagkalat ng fake news?
07:32.0
So, you have to explain it.
07:34.0
Tulad na sinabi ko sa inyo,
07:35.1
ang isang preventive suspension, mga kabatas natin,
07:36.8
it's not a penalty.
07:38.4
It does not require due process na,
07:42.5
yung due process na magkakaroon ng penalty at the end,
07:46.0
it only requires valid grounds.
07:51.6
Ito yung sinabi niya noong June 27, 2022.
07:54.3
I used the presidential powers to tell Congress that you are dealing with scoundrels
07:58.0
and if you continue to koto with them,
08:00.1
kawawa ang Pilipino.
08:01.6
Kaya tinirakos ko talaga sila.
08:04.8
Sabi niya ganyan.
08:06.3
Pero hindi ko makita talaga yung, ano, mga kabatas natin,
08:08.8
yung contrast dito sa sinabi niya dito,
08:15.2
Siyempre, alam naman natin, mga kabatas natin,
08:17.0
na malapit siya sa SMN.
08:20.0
At miyembro siya ng SMN.
08:21.8
That alone, mga kabatas natin,
08:23.6
will show us that there is bias.
08:25.2
And everyone has bias.
08:27.4
Like me, for example,
08:28.8
I'll be biased towards my family members.
08:35.7
whether you will parang think of me evil or not,
08:41.3
I'll try to protect them,
08:45.4
in every legal manner I can.
08:49.3
Kasi pamilya ko sila eh.
08:50.7
That's how families work.
08:52.8
That's why you also have families.
08:54.2
Because your families are your ride or die.
08:57.2
They stick with you.
09:00.2
Ngayon, bakit ko sinabi yan?
09:02.7
Because of the adversarial positions.
09:06.6
Katulad din kay Rafi Tulfo.
09:09.0
We are the adversarial position.
09:12.0
Ang daming nagre-request sa akin na parang itong si Rafi Tulfo,
09:15.0
ganto-gantohan mo.
09:16.6
After niya akong kasuhan,
09:18.1
yung Rafi Tulfo in action,
09:20.2
yung copyright infringement,
09:22.1
yung multiple cyber libel cases,
09:24.2
yung mga disbarment na yan na finafile nila sa akin,
09:26.8
tapos gusto nyo magsabi ako ng maganda tungkol sa kanya.
09:30.3
Seryoso ba kayo mga Tulfonatics?
09:33.6
Tulad na lagi akong sinasabi noon pa,
09:35.5
yung pagsasabi ng maganda,
09:37.8
doon na sa mga fake accounts,
09:40.7
sila na yung bahala doon.
09:44.5
sila na yung bahala doon.
09:45.6
Ang dami namang troll farm na,
09:48.0
lumalabas para kay Rafi Tulfo eh.
09:50.4
Sila na bahala doon.
09:54.3
So, can you take this against him?
09:57.2
Especially now that he is not a president?
10:01.6
He's free to choose sides now.
10:04.3
Wala nang problema.
10:06.3
There are adversarial positions now.
10:11.2
Ganun naman talaga ang nangyayari dyan.
10:14.3
ang problema kasi dito,
10:16.2
pati doon sa issue kay Rafi Tulfo,
10:20.0
ayaw nilang makarinig
10:22.0
ng kahit anong negative kay Rafi Tulfo.
10:26.0
nandoon ka sa posisyon na yan eh.
10:28.0
E di magsabi ka ng maganda.
10:30.0
Kung may hindi kami magandang sinasabi,
10:32.0
di sabihin nyo rin.
10:35.0
Ganun naman talaga.
10:39.0
Sabi ni No Nonsense,
10:41.0
we were not born yesterday,
10:43.0
unlike the troll accounts.
10:45.0
Oh, puro newly created accounts.
10:48.0
Ganun talaga yun.
10:53.0
meron ding nagsalita.
11:05.0
Tulad ng sinabi ko sa inyo,
11:06.0
adversarial position,
11:07.0
the media entity owned by televangelist and alleged sex trafficker,
11:15.0
Nilalabas nila yan.
11:19.0
It works for them.
11:22.0
Sabi niya ako eh,
11:24.0
that this is how democracy works.
11:28.0
You're free to defend your opinions,
11:34.0
That is protected by the state.
11:37.0
Oh, tignan niya dito.
11:49.0
Robin Padilla naman,
11:51.0
for his part on Friday,
11:52.0
moved to investigate the decision of the NTC
11:54.0
to suspend the operations of SMNI,
11:56.0
saying it violated the right to due process of Quiboloy Media Company.
12:00.0
Ang problema ko naman dito mga kabatas natin,
12:11.0
a government employee
12:14.0
that is not your job or work,
12:18.0
distance yourself from it.
12:24.0
you're not supposed to
12:31.0
Pinagbabawal yan eh.
12:33.0
Pag ikaw ay isang government employee,
12:35.0
kaya na-na-na-realize nyo kanina yung sinabi ko,
12:42.0
anong tawag diyan?
12:43.0
Private individual na siya eh.
12:45.0
So, pwede siyang mag-side sa kahit sino.
12:50.0
kapag ikaw ay government entity,
12:52.0
ikaw ay isang public official,
12:54.0
pinagbabawalan yung
12:59.0
pagbibigay ng favor.
13:00.0
Although hindi ko naman sinasabi literal na
13:02.0
pagbibigay ng favor nito kay,
13:04.0
sa SMNI, itong ginagawa ni
13:06.0
Sen. Robin Padilla.
13:10.0
it looks that way.
13:13.0
you're not supposed to use your position kasi
13:15.0
to favor any private individual or entity.
13:23.0
the baseless issuance of a 30-day suspension order
13:26.0
is a transgression of the SMNI's
13:29.0
right to due process,
13:30.0
which will result in serious and irreparable damage
13:34.0
to its employees no less, sabi niya.
13:37.0
Ito kasi mga kabatas natin din.
13:39.0
Siyempre, NTC yung nag-issue dyan eh.
13:42.0
Ngayon, because NTC issued the 30-day suspension,
13:45.0
there is presumption of regularity.
13:48.0
So ngayon, mga kabatas natin, ang baseless dito,
13:51.0
as of the moment,
13:53.0
ay yung statement ni Robin Padilla na yan.
13:59.0
accuse or claim or to allege that something is baseless,
14:04.0
however, it is done in
14:07.0
the performance of the duty of a government entity,
14:14.0
deemed regular yun.
14:18.0
So for the meantime, ang baseless itong claim na ito.
14:21.0
Kasi dapat ipakita niyo muna na baseless yung ginawa nilang suspension
14:27.0
masabi na baseless ngayon.
14:30.0
Di ba? Kasi there is the presumption of regularity
14:32.0
in the performance of governmental functions.
14:38.0
Pero pag titignan niyo dito,
14:39.0
nagkaroon agad ng adversariality.
14:40.0
Nagkaroon agad ng adversarial position.
14:42.0
Pag titignan niyo rin dito kay Brozas, mga kabatas natin,
14:45.0
na siyempre ang position niya rin eh anti-SMNI siya.
14:48.0
Si Padilla naman eh pro-SMNI.
14:52.0
Ang suggestion ko kasi dito dapat,
14:54.0
let's not politicize matters like this.
14:57.0
Because these matters can be easily investigated eh.
15:01.0
What do I mean by investigation?
15:03.0
By presenting evidence.
15:06.0
Claims like these ones, no,
15:09.0
are not evidence.
15:15.0
Claims like these ones are not evidence.
15:17.0
You have to show evidence.
15:26.0
the chair of the Senate Public Information and Mass Media Committee
15:29.0
pointed out that the Supreme Court has already declared
15:32.0
basic and fundamental procedural principles should always be observed
15:36.0
even in administrative proceedings.
15:40.0
Dapat ma-observe talaga.
15:43.0
Pero yun nga ang sinasabi ko sa inyo,
15:44.0
if it is in the form of a preventive suspension,
15:47.0
you just need cause, reason for the preventive suspension.
15:52.0
You don't need due process.
15:59.0
While NTC was authorized to suspend the broadcast network's operations
16:02.0
for violating its regulations,
16:04.0
he said such action should be made to avoid serious irreparable damage.
16:07.0
irreparable damage or inconvenience to the public
16:10.0
or to private interest.
16:12.0
Siya rin naman umamin na may meron silang kapangyarihan eh.
16:16.0
Pag binaylit yung regulations.
16:18.0
So you just have to substantiate.
16:22.0
Meron bang serious and irreparable damage?
16:26.0
Ganun naman kasi yung preventive suspension eh.
16:30.0
Tapos tignan nyo dito, oh.
16:33.0
Pati naman inquiry.net may bias din.
16:36.0
Padilla who is not a lawyer said he would file a resolution.
16:40.0
Talagang i-emphasize pa yung who is not a lawyer.
16:44.0
Dito na na makikita yung mga biases ng mga tao
16:47.0
and biases are inert.
16:49.0
I always tell you that.
16:51.0
So when people call me bias, of course I have biases.
16:55.0
Pati nga sa banda na gusto ko, may bias ako eh.
17:01.0
Padilla who is not a lawyer said he would file a resolution seeking a legislative inquiry.
17:06.0
Eh hindi naman necessary yung pagiging lawyer para mag-file ka ng resolution seeking a legislative inquiry.
17:11.0
Ang kailangan lang, senador ka.
17:16.0
Into the NTC suspension order which is based on a resolution passed by the House of Representatives.
17:25.0
The NTC in its show cause and suspension order failed to indicate the need to suspend the operations of the SM&I.
17:31.0
Much more express how this is necessary to avoid serious and irreparable damage or damage.
17:34.0
To avoid serious and irreparable damage or inconvenience to the public or private interest, he said.
17:38.0
O siyempre, kwento mo yan, bida ka.
17:42.0
Eta, si Laila Diliman naman sabi niya,
17:46.0
it is not prior restraint.
17:51.0
Since these were made in relation to past, not future speech.
17:53.0
So yun sinasabi kasi nila, parang,
17:58.0
Hindi siguro penalty yan.
18:00.0
Preventive suspension lang.
18:01.0
I believe it's preventive suspension.
18:04.0
Eto, alleged death threats.
18:08.0
Yung travel expenses.
18:12.0
Tapos, fake news organization.
18:15.0
Masquerading as a legitimate broadcast media entity.
18:18.0
O ano yan? Sinong nagsabi diyan?
18:20.0
There's polarity.
18:24.0
Ngayon sasabihin niyo, tatanongin niyo si ano?
18:26.0
Tatanongin niyo si Dilima, bakit hindi ka nagsabi ng kahit anong maganda?
18:33.0
Para kay Duterte.
18:37.0
Imposible naman na walang nagawang maganda si Duterte.
18:41.0
Tatanongin mo rin kay Duterte, bakit wala kang nasabing maganda kay Dilima?
18:45.0
Imposible naman walang magawang maganda si Dilima.
18:49.0
Yun din yung tanong sa akin ng mga Tulfonatics.
18:52.0
Bakit wala kang sinasabing maganda tungkol kay Rafi Tulfo?
18:58.0
Imposible naman walang nagawang maganda si Rafi Tulfo.
19:02.0
Of course may nagawa siyang maganda.
19:04.0
Pero hindi ko na trabaho yun.
19:06.0
That's not my side.
19:14.0
Senator who left his first family.
19:16.0
Maraming salamat mga kapatid natin.
19:19.0
At syempre tulad ng laging sinasabi, matulog po tayo ng mahimbing dahil alam natin na yung natutulog ng mahimbing, siya yung laging panalo.
