DAHIL SA BAIT, NAGKA-SUNDO RIN ANG RAFFY TULFO VLOGGERS AT AKO, PAANO SI ATTY. GARRETH?
00:57.7
Nang isang produkto. Diba?
01:00.8
Hindi magandang mag-endorso o maging mukha, maging mukha, maging mukha
01:08.1
ng isang Ponzi scheme. Okay.
01:15.3
We are in agreement with that. Wala na problema. Diba?
01:18.5
Okay. Let's give them the benefit of the doubt.
01:21.4
Sabihin na natin na itong si Mayor Magalong sometime in the future.
01:27.7
Kahit ngayon, mag-i-endorse siya ng isang Ponzi scheme.
01:33.1
Mag-i-endorse siya ng isang produkto. Mag-i-endorse siya ng kahit ano.
01:37.4
I told this already. Noong panahon pa ni Invested Lifestyle na ako mismo ang magsasabi at magiging kritiko niya
01:50.1
at sasabihin ko sa kanya, wag mong gawin yan.
01:54.0
Yung nangyari dito sa front row, I also confronted him.
01:57.7
Hindi ako nagsasabi na okay lang yan.
02:02.8
Ituloy mo lang yan kasi may one-year contract naman eh.
02:05.9
Hindi naman tayo sinabihan ng SEC na tumigil sa pag-i-endorse.
02:12.8
Hindi ko sasabihin yun.
02:15.7
I will stand in front of him and I will tell him to stop because it's not good.
02:24.4
So we agree on that already mga Tulfonatics.
02:27.7
We agree on that already mga vloggers ni Tulfo.
02:31.4
Hindi maganda yung ginawa ni Rafi Tulfo.
02:33.6
Kung ginawa man yun ni Mayor Magalong, hindi rin maganda.
02:39.5
At tulad ng sinabi ko, because I don't like that, I will criticize anyone for it.
02:46.1
Even Mayor Magalong.
02:49.9
We are in agreement now.
02:56.7
Ngayon mga patos namin.
02:57.7
Ito yung sinasabi nila mga kapatid natin na nag-endorse daw si Mayor Magalong.
03:05.3
Mag-real talk na tayo ngayon.
03:07.6
Ito kasi yung bait.
03:08.8
Alam nyo naman, binanggit ko yung kay Invested Lifestyle.
03:11.8
Alam ko na sinungaling kayo at gagamitin nyo lahat ng mga kasinungalingan nyo para ilabas
03:17.3
na itong si Mayor Magalong dito nag-i-endorse ng produkto.
03:25.2
Ngayon mga kapatid natin.
03:26.7
Kasi sinagot ko na ito, ipapaliwanag ko sa inyo kung ano yung konteksto nito.
03:33.0
Mga kapatid natin, this is about the library.
03:39.9
So, ginagaya nila doon sa ginawa ni Rafi Tulfo na nag-endorse siya.
03:47.5
Kasi siya yung face.
03:49.3
Siya yung face, mga kapatid natin, ng 1UP.
03:53.0
Siya yung brand ambassador ng 1UP.
03:56.7
So, brand ambassador ba si Mayor Magalong ng Front Row o kahit anong produkto ng Front Row?
04:09.3
Di ba? Nakita nyo yung nangyari doon.
04:12.5
In global, yung pinag-uusapan.
04:16.6
Sinabi ko, walang salita na nangyari doon.
04:20.2
And for sure, kapag hinawakan mo ang isang bagay, kahit ginamit mo yung isang bagay,
04:26.7
hindi mo ito ino-endorso unless bayaran ka ng 1-year contract.
04:43.9
Sabi niyo, no nonsense. False equivalence and red herring.
04:47.6
Pero ang maganda kasi dito, no nonsense.
04:50.1
Ang maganda dito, ang maganda dito,
04:53.4
they agreed with us.
04:55.2
Na yung ginagawa ni Rafi Tulfo, hindi maganda.
04:59.9
Kasi nga, sinasabi rin nila at ginagaya nila na ginawa daw ni Mayor Magalong,
05:06.3
tapos hindi rin maganda.
05:10.4
You see what we did there?
05:18.6
Oh, doon nga yung sinabi ko.
05:22.4
Tatanggapin ko yung kasinungalingan nyo.
05:25.2
Sasabihin ko na nag-endorse siya.
05:28.7
Nag-endorse siya.
05:30.7
Sasabihin ko sa kanya, tigilan mo na yan.
05:35.4
Parang yung sinasabi ni Rodrigo Duterte.
05:38.5
Tigilan mo na yan.
05:39.9
Hindi maganda yan.
05:42.3
I will be the first one to do it to Mayor Magalong.
05:53.6
Pero ang problema,
05:55.2
hindi siya nag-endorse eh.
05:59.0
Mapupunta naman daw sa charity.
06:03.5
May binayad ba kay Mayor Magalong?
06:08.2
Tapos dito, it's about the library.
06:11.4
Tapos kinat-cut lang nila mga kabatas natin
06:14.1
para lumabas na kunwari ang ini-endorse front row.
06:21.1
Parang yung ginawa nila sa picture
06:23.0
at ginawa nila Meloyap
06:24.0
at nung ampalayagang
06:27.1
na nag-content doon
06:28.7
at nag-comment doon
06:30.0
na sinasabi nila na ganun daw
06:31.7
yung mga Tulfo vloggers
06:35.2
nag-endorse na yan,
06:36.8
nag-endorse na yan.
06:37.8
Saan ang endorsement doon?
06:43.0
Tulad nga niya sinabi ko,
06:43.9
I'll be the first one to stop him.
06:47.0
and confronted him about this.
06:49.2
Dalawa pa kami ni Mrs.
06:53.1
Sabi ko sa kanya,
06:54.0
tanungin nga natin kay Dadi,
06:55.8
ano ba yung front row na yan?
07:01.0
Oh my God, di ba?
07:02.0
Hindi kasi maganda eh.
07:04.0
Kapag ini-endorse mo yung isang produkto na
07:11.0
wala pa naman siyang
07:13.0
wala pa naman siyang SEC
07:17.0
Yung kay Garawi, susunod natin yun.
07:21.0
I will point that out.
07:23.0
I will point din na mga kabads natin,
07:25.0
kahit sa latest video lang ni Garawi,
07:27.0
yung mga kasinungalingan doon,
07:28.0
kasi doon palang madami na.
07:30.0
We don't need to look beyond.
07:32.0
Pero dito maraming kasinungalingan din.
07:34.0
Of course, that's your only weapon.
07:43.0
Mayor! Mayor! Mayor!
07:49.0
He's there as a mayor.
07:55.0
Not a brand ambassador.
08:04.0
Makikita niyo dito mga kabads natin,
08:10.0
Itong speech na ito, pinutulputul nila.
08:13.0
Ipapakita ko sa inyo yung context dito,
08:16.0
kung bakit ganyan yung mga nasabi niya,
08:18.0
mga kabads natin.
08:29.0
Philippine News Agency.
08:33.0
This was August 20, 2020.
08:35.0
Panahon ng pandemic.
08:37.0
Panahon ng pandemic yun. Ito yun, mga kabads natin.
08:40.0
Ano ba kasi ang nangyari doon, mga kabads natin?
08:43.0
Nagkaroon ng e-iskwela hub.
08:48.0
In-open yung e-iskwela hub.
08:50.0
So yung speech niya doon,
08:52.0
siyempre nagpapasalamat doon sa mga sponsors na nakipag-tie up.
08:59.0
Doon sa Baguio City Library.
09:01.0
Ito kasing summary niya.
09:03.0
e-iskwela hub. Baguio City Mayor Benjamin Magalong left,
09:06.0
ang Provenciano Partylist Representative Ronnie Ong,
09:09.0
second from left,
09:10.0
and Front Row Enterprises founder and Chief Executive Officer Samuel Versosa,
09:16.0
during the ribbon cutting for the opening of the e-iskwela hub
09:23.0
held at the Pipe Public Library in Burnham Park on Thursday, August 20, 2020.
09:32.0
e-iskwela hub. Oh wait!
09:35.0
Kapag ba may e-iskwela hub, meron bang bentahan na nangyayari doon?
09:48.0
You're just taking everything out of context?
09:51.0
Ganyan din yung ginagawa ni Garawi eh.
09:53.0
Bibigyan ko kayo ng teaser kapag iko-content natin yung kay Garawi
09:58.0
tungkol sa debate na yun.
09:60.0
Diba? Nakipag-debate daw siya sa akin.
10:03.0
Nakipag-debate daw si Nico David sa akin.
10:07.0
Kasi nga hinihingi ko lahat.
10:09.0
Open ako sa debate.
10:11.0
Yung debate na yun,
10:12.0
open ako sa debate,
10:13.0
kasama siya o si Nico David,
10:16.0
pero may kasamang developer.
10:19.0
May kasamang taga-act si Infinity.
10:23.0
Doon dinideceive ulit kayo ni Garawi.
10:28.0
Dinideceive kayo doon.
10:30.0
Nagkaroon lang kami ng contentan.
10:33.0
That's what happened.
10:40.0
You really are a joke.
10:43.0
You are a joke when you said that.
10:47.0
Because you know very well
10:48.0
na naghahanap kayo ni Nico David
10:51.0
ng isang developer
10:53.0
na makakasama niyo o makakasama ng kahit sino
10:56.0
para maka-debate ako.
11:04.0
That is the context there.
11:06.0
This is an iiskwe lahab.
11:08.0
Nagkaroon diyan ng speech doon na pinutol-putol nila na
11:11.0
parang lumalabas na ini-endorse niya yung front row.
11:16.0
It's about education for the children.
11:24.0
The hub will provide free use of computers,
11:30.0
and printing of modules for students and teachers.
11:35.0
This was during the pandemic.
11:37.0
Ano ang malaking problema ng pandemic noon?
11:39.0
Ang malaking problema,
11:40.0
nung pandemic noon,
11:42.0
e maraming estudyante ang walang computers.
11:47.0
Maraming estudyante ang walang access sa internet.
11:54.0
So may nag-donate.
11:56.0
Nirecognize yung nag-donate.
11:58.0
In-endorse mo ba?
12:02.0
Yung speech ni Mayor Magalong doon,
12:05.0
it is about giving opportunity to children
12:08.0
because of studying,
12:10.0
because of school,
12:19.0
For students and teachers,
12:21.0
also in the photo,
12:22.0
our course counselor,
12:23.0
Betty Lord Estabanda,
12:35.0
The first iiskwe lahab
12:37.0
was open Thursday at the Public Library
12:40.0
led by the City Government,
12:42.0
Daang Probinsyano Party List,
12:44.0
and Front Row Enterprises.
12:49.0
Parang yung ginagawa nila sa picture.
12:51.0
Hinawakan mo lang yung produkto,
12:54.0
in-endorse mo na.
12:60.0
let's go back to debate.
13:04.0
You agree with me now,
13:06.0
na ang pag-i-endorse,
13:12.0
ng isang produkto
13:18.0
hindi ko sinasabi naman na itong Front Row ay
13:25.0
I never delved deep.
13:27.0
Pero in general, I don't like MLM.
13:33.0
That's my personal choice.
13:36.0
I stick to the fact still
13:38.0
na sinabi ng Supreme Court na
13:41.0
And I showed you,
13:43.0
I showed you already
13:46.0
a Supreme Court decision about that.
13:48.0
Not all MLMs are pyramid schemes
13:51.0
or Ponzi schemes.
13:55.0
Pero mga kabatas natin,
13:58.0
kapag naman na-flag na ng SEC yan,
14:04.0
Dito tayo magkakaroon ng problema ngayon.
14:07.0
Dito tayo magkakaroon ng problema ngayon.
14:10.0
We are in agreement na,
14:12.0
mga Tulfunatics vloggers,
14:13.0
na hindi maganda yung mag-i-endorse ng produkto.
14:16.0
Hindi maganda mag-i-endorse ng isang shady business,
14:21.0
Tulad ngang sinabi ko sa inyo,
14:23.0
ako mismo magsasabi kay Mayor Magalong,
14:25.0
sabihin nyo sa akin,
14:26.0
kung kunwari in-i-endorse niya yan,
14:28.0
kahit sasabihin ko ulit sa kanya mamaya.
14:29.0
Pero after that, nung nakita ko doon,
14:31.0
sinabi ko sa kanya,
14:32.0
tinanong ko rin siya dyan.
14:34.0
And ngayon, nagiging maingat na siya.
14:38.0
Sabi ko kasi, hindi maganda, hindi maganda,
14:40.0
nakikita ng mga tao yung ganyan.
14:42.0
Sinabi ko rin sa kanya,
14:44.0
at pinaliwanag ko sa kanya,
14:45.0
kung ano yung mga schemes na ginagamit ng mga MLM.
14:54.0
I'll be the first one to do that.
14:57.0
Pero anong sabi ni Atty. Garrett?
14:59.0
Bukta tayo sa sinabi ni Atty. Garrett.
15:04.0
Again, what we endorsed was not those who were selling,
15:10.0
but the product itself.
15:12.0
Produkto, hindi tao.
15:14.0
So we will continue the memorandum of agreement
15:17.0
because we are obliged under the contract to continue it.
15:23.0
Tungol said, sabi dito,
15:26.0
there's no lawful order to prevent the senator from endorsing the product.
15:30.0
Wait, but what about undersecretary?
15:33.0
What about undersecretary C?
15:39.0
Undersecretary C said it's not good.
15:44.0
which was approved by the proper licensing and other regulatory bodies.
15:48.0
We will continue.
15:49.0
I have advised him to continue that.
15:53.0
Ako, I'm not advising Mayor Magalong
15:56.0
if indeed nag-i-endorse siya
15:59.0
ng hindi maganda.
16:04.0
I'll tell him, no.
16:08.0
Kung ginawa mo yan,
16:15.0
Okay. Tulad nga na sinabi ko, let's admit it.
16:18.0
I will admit your kasinungalingan.
16:20.0
Even if it was an edited video showing na parang endorsement ito sa front row, no.
16:26.0
The endorsement there was for the children.
16:30.0
The children to study.
16:36.0
Yung mga kwento na sinasabi doon,
16:39.0
kwento ng mga testimonies ng mga founders.
16:44.0
Well, maganda nga naman kasi yung kwento nila.
16:46.0
Kaya nga sila nakaka-recruit, di ba?
16:49.0
Pero my point is,
16:51.0
I still don't like it.
16:53.0
And even if, for example,
16:58.0
for the sake of argument, in-endorse niya nga yun,
17:01.0
I will be the first one.
17:03.0
And I am actually the one who told him, don't do it.
17:08.0
Until they told me,
17:11.0
hindi naman front row.
17:13.0
Yan, sabi niya sa akin.
17:14.0
Yan yung tungkol sa library.
17:16.0
Yung speech ko diyan, tungkol sa library.
17:23.0
Tignan niya, sabi dito.
17:25.0
There's no lawful order
17:30.0
to prevent the senator from endorsing the product
17:33.0
which was approved by the proper licensing
17:35.0
and other regulatory bodies.
17:37.0
We will continue.
17:38.0
I have advised him to continue that, he said.
17:44.0
However, sabi dito sa dulo,
17:46.0
under Secretary Xi's legal view is that
17:50.0
even if politician accept no compensation
17:53.0
for their efforts or appearances,
17:54.0
or waive it in form of a charity,
17:57.0
there is no doubt that they benefit from
17:60.0
the free public and constant exposure.
18:04.0
That's why it's unethical.
18:08.0
Sinabi pa dito yung code of conduct.
18:11.0
I-elaborate natin yan ulit sa susunod.
18:14.0
Ang maganda dito, tulad nga na sinabi ko,
18:16.0
sige, maniwala na yung mga tool fanatics,
18:18.0
nag-endorse si Mayor Magalong.
18:20.0
Huya, tao lang naman.
18:22.0
For the sake of argument,
18:23.0
paniwalaan na natin sila na ang ini-endorse
18:26.0
ng front row, hindi library.
18:28.0
Okay. May nakita ba kayong produkto doon?
18:30.0
One elixir? Wala, di ba?
18:34.0
There was branding of front row.
18:36.0
I didn't like that too.
18:38.0
It was the pandemic.
18:40.0
People need stuff.
18:42.0
People need stuff.
18:46.0
Nagkaroon ng speech.
18:48.0
Sige, pagbigyan na natin.
18:50.0
Yung speech na yun,
18:53.0
kahit kasinungalingan yung sinasabi nila
18:56.0
para sa front row,
18:58.0
hindi maganda yun.
19:07.0
that it is wrong.
19:09.0
But, we will continue.
19:11.0
Sabi ni Atty. Tungol.
19:15.0
Mga vloggers ni Rafi Tulfo,
19:17.0
kausapin niyo si Atty. Tungol.
19:23.0
Please, kausapin niyo siya.
19:30.0
Ako pa daw yung kasinungalingan.
19:33.0
Pinakita ko na sa inyo yung konteksto nito.
19:35.0
This is not endorsing front row.
19:38.0
Hindi siya brand ambassador.
19:40.0
So difficult for us to be managing
19:44.0
And we're facing a lot of challenges.
19:48.0
A lot of problems.
19:50.0
Yan. Ano yung mga problema dyan kasi?
19:52.0
Yung mga access to the internet.
19:55.0
Laptops. Computers.
19:56.0
Yun yung problema na ina-address dito.
20:01.0
It's not yung magpamember ka na front row
20:03.0
na pinagsisinunga... na napagsisinungaling
20:05.0
ng mga vloggers ni Tulfo.
20:10.0
Pero one thing that I like about front row...
20:19.0
I like about front row...
20:22.0
Give me an opportunity.
20:24.0
Give me an opportunity.
20:26.0
Opportunity. Why?
20:28.0
Because meron silang dinonate na library.
20:37.0
They took it out.
20:42.0
All the necessary context.
20:45.0
They took it all out.
20:48.0
Para pagpalabasin na masama.
20:52.0
Good for our cause because we baited them
20:55.0
that now you understand.
20:58.0
Now you agree that it's wrong.
21:01.0
Ngayon ang hindi na lang natin nakukumpinse
21:11.0
Baka naman pwedeng hindi na mag-endorse si
21:18.0
Baka naman pwedeng makinig kayo kay Undersecretary C.
21:22.0
This is said to be.
21:51.0
be the first person to ask him to
21:53.1
stop. Don't do it.
21:57.0
Huwag mo nang gawin. Hindi ko
21:58.9
sasabihin sa kanya na tuloy mo
22:07.3
Tuloy mo lang. Okay lang.
22:10.6
Hindi ko sasabihin
22:15.5
Sabi ni Kayo, hindi natin
22:17.3
na-convince si Atty. Tungol
22:19.2
tas mag-file pa ng cyber libel sa
22:21.0
Daily Tribune author.
22:25.2
na-convince natin Kayo, yung
22:27.1
mga vloggers ni Tulfo.
22:29.8
Now they agree with us that
22:33.1
Because when Mayor Magalong did it,
22:37.2
according to them,
22:42.9
Kaya nga sabi ko,
22:44.2
okay, let's admit it na.
22:46.5
For the sake of argument
22:49.2
And it's wrong, right?
22:52.7
That's why you're not supposed
22:55.6
Eh, bakit we will still continue?
22:59.1
Yun ang sagutin nyo,
23:00.3
mga Tulfo Datics vloggers.
23:03.8
Yun ang sagutin nyo.
23:05.5
Kasi ako talaga, tulad na sinabi ko,
23:07.8
I'll be the first one to tell him to stop.
23:13.2
Sabi niya, accidental agreement ng
23:15.2
Tulfo vloggers dahil sa Desperate Times
23:19.2
Kaya, they didn't know.
23:21.5
Sinabi ko nga eh,
23:22.6
yun kay Mayor Magalong,
23:24.2
ilalabas na naman nyo yung
23:27.0
kay Invested Lifestyle.
23:29.2
Sinabi niya yan noon,
23:31.1
O di rinisearch nila.
23:49.2
Ganyan lang kaya nila eh.
23:50.2
Dati picture lang daw.
23:52.3
Ngayon may video na galit pa rin.
24:03.2
Walang galit dito.
24:07.5
Walang galit dito.
24:09.5
We are in agreement.
24:10.8
Tulad nga na sinabi ko sa inyo,
24:12.3
hindi ko man makokontrol si Mayor Magalong
24:14.5
kung siya ay mag-i-endorse.
24:17.4
Kung mag-i-endorse siya.
24:19.9
But I will tell him
24:25.1
if he is doing it.
24:32.2
Tapos yung video kasi,
24:37.3
Pero you take it out of context.
24:42.6
Tapos sabi mo ngayon may video na galit pa rin.
24:45.3
Alam ko na merong video na ganyan.
24:48.8
Ako nga ang nagsabi sa kanila
24:50.3
na hanapin niya ni Hauma.
24:57.8
Hindi ko man sinabi directly
24:59.9
pero sinabi ko na
25:01.2
meron yung front row.
25:04.7
Linabas ni Invested Lifestyle yun.
25:11.3
This person right here.
25:14.8
Paano ako magagalit
25:15.8
kung sinunod nila yung gusto ko mangyari?
25:27.6
Thank you sa inyo.
25:30.7
The face of one up.
25:41.5
The face of one up.
25:44.5
Yan. Maraming salamat mga kapatid natin.
25:46.5
Hindi pa tayo tapos dyan.
25:48.8
Hindi pa tayo tapos dito.
25:50.7
Tulad ng sinabi ko,
25:52.4
Marami tayong mapupulot na aral
26:00.7
Official face pala of
26:18.8
Pero pang ganito,
26:19.8
nung natikman ko,
26:20.7
the rest is history.
26:26.3
Anyway, mga kapatid natin,
26:29.8
we are in agreement now.
26:32.9
We are in agreement na
26:38.0
Pero bakit continue?
26:39.4
Yan lang. Maraming salamat.
26:41.4
Thank you for watching.
26:43.4
Thank you for watching.
26:48.8
Paalam po, pansamantala.
