FISCAL EJ VS. KAMATIS ANALYSIS UNIT- SLAPP SUITS
00:37.8
Kasi I am advocating the creation of the anti-slap law.
00:44.8
Ngayon mga kabatas natin, I believe also na yung mga finafile ni Raffy Tulfo ng mga kaso sa mga tao,
00:54.1
especially the small vloggers,
00:58.1
ako nga mga kabatas natin, limang kaso na ang meron sa akin.
01:01.5
No, limang kaso na ang na-efile sa akin in relation to Raffy Tulfo.
01:06.0
And I believe those are slap suits.
01:09.3
Gusto nilang patahimikin ako.
01:12.5
Ngayon, itong si Fiscal EJ, of course,
01:16.3
kailangan niyang mag-explain about slap suits.
01:19.6
Wala daw slap suit dito sa Pilipinas.
01:23.9
parang gusto niyang palabasin na mali yung sinasabi ko,
01:32.9
na slap ka ng slap, walang slap dito sa Pilipinas.
01:37.7
Ay syempre, yung posisyon ko may slap.
01:39.9
Ngayon, dinibank siya ni Kayu.
01:46.5
Ngayon, mga kabatas natin, lumabas na naman yung self-defeating statements
01:50.6
at sya kayong mga bangayan maneuvers.
01:56.0
O ngayon, tignan natin kung anong nangyari dito.
01:59.3
Di ba yung na-explain ko na guys?
02:01.5
Slap is a phenomena.
02:03.3
There's no law about slap because it's promoting slap
02:06.8
if there's a law about slap, right?
02:09.7
Yun nga. Kaya kailangan natin anti-slap.
02:15.1
Kid you not, mga kabatas natin.
02:17.1
Tulad na sinabi ko sa inyo.
02:19.2
I have extensive studies about slap law.
02:23.9
Slap suits. Slap suits na and the anti-slap law.
02:28.0
If ever man, mga kabatas natin, may ipasa ito.
02:32.0
We really need it.
02:33.9
Ngayon, merong slap suits dito sa Pilipinas.
02:39.0
Everywhere there is a slap suit even if there is no anti-slap law.
02:44.3
It does not follow na dahil walang batas na nagbabawal dito,
02:50.5
ibig sabihin, hindi na ito nagagawa.
02:57.2
Simpleng-simple lang.
02:58.4
Sabi ni Adorable Chaps, makakontra lang talaga.
03:01.4
Pero yun naman ang gusto natin talaga, Adorable Chaps.
03:04.1
For people to show their true colors.
03:11.5
Gusto ko yung ginagawa ni Fabry na ganyan.
03:17.3
Sabi ni Addictus Rex, copyright infringement,
03:19.9
dalawang counts yung copyright infringement eh.
03:22.8
Cyber libel na dalawang.
03:24.7
Isa kay Rafi Tulfo, isa kay Atty. Tungol.
03:28.9
Nag-result din yun dahil sa Rafi Tulfo.
03:30.9
Yung disbarment ko, dahilin dun sa Rafi Tulfo yun.
03:33.9
Dahil din sa mga comments ko kay Rafi Tulfo.
03:36.9
So lima, dalawang copyright infringement as of the moment,
03:40.9
dalawang cyber libel sa piskal, tapos isang disbarment.
03:47.9
All because of Rafi Tulfo and Rafi Tulfo in action.
03:50.9
Okay, lahat dun may Rafi Tulfo yun.
03:54.9
So, dapat merong law sa anti-slap.
04:01.9
Yun nga. Ang hindi niya... Hindi ko nga maintindihan.
04:03.9
That's very simple.
04:07.9
That's very easy to understand.
04:10.9
I don't get it why they don't understand it.
04:16.9
Sabi ni I'm Not Robot, last year din na nga ako si attorney niyang merch.
04:20.9
Oo nga. Sorry, sorry nga ako nang sorry sa merch na yan.
04:22.9
Ang dami ko kasing ginagawa.
04:26.9
Next year daw, this year na daw, sabi ni attorney Magalong.
04:30.9
Promise niya daw yun. Kasi siya yung ano yun.
04:33.9
Siya yung umako na.
04:37.9
Sabi ni Chris Tito, may slap. Walang anti-slap.
04:48.9
Sabi ni I'm Not Robot.
04:50.9
Nonsense. Pag left and right slap suits din para may...
04:53.9
Para may cases ba tawag dito?
05:01.9
Mag-vlog ka na kasi para makoblo ka din.
05:06.9
Anti-slap kasi. Right, right, right. Mahina, mahina, mahina, mahina.
05:11.9
Okay lang yan. Okay lang yan. Okay lang yan. Wala tayong magagawa.
05:14.9
Nag-iisa yata ang fiscal kasi doon. Anyway, sabi lang yun ha. Game, game.
05:20.9
Okay, okay. Sige, sige, sige.
05:23.9
Harsh ka. Harsh ka masyado, kayo.
05:37.9
And then I already made a distinction.
05:38.9
Dapat sabihin mo kasi kayo,
05:40.9
slap is a phenomenon. Tama-mali.
05:42.9
Tama. Diba? Tama.
05:44.9
Tapos kami, sasabihin namin tama. Ganun.
05:47.9
Question about the letter of the law.
05:49.9
the letter of the law, and the phenomenon.
05:52.7
That's a categorical error
05:56.3
You are making two categories
05:58.2
in one basket, which is not
06:06.3
We are talking about
06:08.3
slap dito sa Pilipinas, ha?
06:14.2
Sa Pilipinas, ha?
06:16.3
Okay. Slap sa US.
06:48.3
Ang isang phenomenon
06:49.8
like the slap suit or slap
06:54.2
na mga ito, hindi kailangan na
06:56.1
i-recognize yan ng batas natin
07:02.7
Parang ganito lang, no?
07:06.7
o kaya sa zoology.
07:10.4
Hindi dahil yung isang
07:12.2
langgam ay hindi pa
07:16.7
hindi pa napapangalan.
07:22.5
Yung langgam. May nakita kang langgam.
07:26.1
Bagong-bagong langgam ito. Wala pang
07:30.1
Tawagin natin natin yung langgam na serapi.
07:32.4
Gano'n. Serapensis
07:39.0
Yun. Yung pangalan.
07:42.2
eventually na scientific name
07:44.3
ng langgam na yun.
07:45.7
Pero yung langgam na yun,
07:48.3
serapi lang yung pangalan niya.
07:55.2
hindi nila alam na may serapi.
07:59.2
Ngayon, mga kapatid natin,
08:00.5
pwede mo ba sabihin na
08:01.5
ay wala sa libro.
08:04.1
Hindi pa nasusulat yung serapi na yan.
08:06.9
Hindi yan nag-i-exist.
08:11.2
So, mag-i-exist lang yung serapi na yun
08:13.6
kapag nagkaroon na siya
08:15.0
ng scientific name at na-discover na
08:19.7
Kasi parang gano'n yung sinasabi nila dito eh.
08:22.0
Dahil wala pa daw slap law,
08:24.3
wala daw slap dito sa Pilipinas.
08:27.2
It doesn't work that way.
08:31.0
Kaya nga ang pinapasa
08:43.5
Mayigipang tumain na lang ako.
08:45.0
Tama. I-hide nyo na yan. Tatay daw siya.
08:54.1
Ito ang hindi mo nakita dito.
08:58.8
Itong si Mark Bayagan.
09:01.6
Ang hindi mo nakita dyan,
09:05.7
Pinagpalit ka sa pagtae.
09:08.2
Importante ang pagtae.
09:10.6
Mahirap pigilan ang tae.
09:14.1
dahil sa sobrang importante ka,
09:17.1
pinigilan ni Mark Bayagan.
09:20.1
Inuna niya munang manood sa iyo
09:34.1
Itakay mo na rin sa mamuutak mo.
09:46.1
Kaya nga, di ba yung mga tao,
09:48.1
kapag natatay, tumatakbo,
09:49.1
nagdadrive na mabilis.
09:54.1
Ayun, para lang manood sa iyo.
09:56.1
Hinold niya yung pagtae.
09:58.1
Ginawa kang priority.
10:03.1
Ginawa kang priority.
10:10.1
What a coincidence.
10:14.1
Sorry, sorry sa mga kumakain.
10:17.1
Sabi ni Alpha, nasunog yung fiskal.
10:19.1
Hindi pa naman. Hindi pa naman.
10:22.1
Ay, hindi. Tapos na pala ito.
10:24.1
Rine-replay lang pala natin.
10:26.1
Alam sa slap ng ibang bansa.
10:29.1
Wala daw siya paket.
10:30.1
Ito po ang sinabi...
10:32.1
Sabi ni Zenia Jade,
10:33.1
ibalik niya yung mga mods.
10:35.1
Nagsasakripisyon.
10:36.1
Oo nga. Dapat nga gawin yung mod yan eh.
10:39.1
Isipin mo yung human necessity to poo.
10:47.1
Ang priority si Kayu?
10:54.1
Wala daw siyang pakelam sa slap ng ibang bansa.
10:58.1
Tama ba yun? Tama ba yung pagkakaano?
11:02.1
Tama ba yung guys yung pagkakarinig natin?
11:06.1
Alam niyo mga kabatas natin ha?
11:09.1
May ipapakita ko sa inyo na ginagawa ko.
11:12.1
Yung isa sa pinaka ano no.
11:15.1
Isa sa pinaka ano.
11:16.1
Isa sa pinaka-ginagamit, mga kabatas natin.
11:27.2
Isa sa pinaka-ginagamit na linyahan against cyber libel dito sa Pilipinas.
11:36.2
Yung pagpa-file ng mga kabatas natin, ng mga slap suits, galing din sa Amerika.
11:46.1
Ito yung kasong US versus Bustos.
11:56.9
Ginagamit ko na rin naman yung ano eh.
11:59.1
Ito, papakita ko na sa inyo.
12:00.5
Kasi ito na rin yung counter-affidavit ko kay Rafi Tulfoy.
12:05.7
Papakita ko sa inyo yung citation ko, ha?
12:10.6
Nakikita niyo ba?
12:12.6
This is also a US case.
12:16.1
So, hindi mo pwede talaga sabihin na meron tayo, na wala kang pakialam sa US, sa batas ng US.
12:26.1
Kasi, secondary source ng Philippine law, kapag walang makuha sa Pilipinas na batas,
12:34.8
humihiram yung ating Supreme Court sa Amerika.
12:38.6
O, total, ginagawa ko na ito.
12:40.9
The Supreme Court in Philippine Daily Inquirer,
12:43.9
Incorporated et al.
12:46.1
In this connection, the court declares its continued recognition, blah, blah, blah, blah.
12:51.6
Tapos, ito, mga kapatid natin.
12:55.0
Of the right of every citizen to enjoy a good name and reputation.
12:58.5
The court, however, is equally cognizant of the important role that the continuing guarantee of the freedom of the press serves to our nation.
13:06.1
As the words of Justice Malcolm in the early case of US versus Bustos.
13:12.2
Mga kapatid natin.
13:13.3
That is a US case.
13:16.1
And Justice Malcolm, mga kapatid natin, is a justice in America.
13:22.8
The interest of society and the maintenance of good government demand a full discussion of public affairs.
13:29.2
Complete liberty to comment on the conduct of public men is a scalpel in the case of free speech.
13:35.9
The sharp incision of its probe relieves the abscesses of officialdom.
13:41.9
Men in public life may suffer under a hostile and unlawful,
13:46.1
unjust accusation.
13:47.7
The word can be assuaged with the balm of a clear conscience.
13:51.8
A public officer must not be too thin-skinned with reference to comment upon his official acts.
13:59.6
Tignan niyo, mga kapatid natin.
14:01.0
Too thin-skinned.
14:05.5
Dapat hindi ka too thin-skinned.
14:11.4
That is an American case.
14:17.6
Yung Miranda Doctrine.
14:20.0
That is also a case borrowed from the US.
14:37.6
Pagka tayong pakialam sa islap ng ibang bansa.
14:51.6
Sige, sige, sige.
14:53.6
Wala tayong pakialam.
14:55.9
Sabi ni attorney, yung too thin-skinned is said by the court doon sa case ni Trillianis versus Mukauson.
15:03.3
Talo si Trillianis doon.
15:06.3
Kaya nga, hiniram natin sa Amerika yun.
15:09.7
US versus Falcom.
15:10.9
Ginagamit na rin ng Supreme Court natin yan.
15:15.2
Happy New Year sa'yo.
15:32.3
Ito yung pinapakita ni Kayo ngayon dito.
15:36.8
In the 1980s by University of Denver,
15:41.5
Professors Penelope Kanya and George W.
15:45.8
an original defined as a lawsuit involving communications
15:49.5
made to petition for a governmental action or outcome,
15:54.1
which resulted in a baseless suit
15:57.3
filed against individuals or non-governmental organizations
16:01.3
on a substantive issue of some public interest.
16:05.9
Di ba yun yung pinanalo niya?
16:12.7
It seems that we do.
16:14.1
We do care about it.
16:16.8
Alam niyo kung bakit.
16:18.5
Alam niyo kung bakit hindi niya pinakita to.
16:22.2
Bakit hindi niya pinakita to.
16:26.6
Eto, eto, eto, eto.
16:29.4
Tinanong ko ngayon.
16:31.2
Ay, hindi, hindi.
16:33.6
Tinanong ko si Jules.
16:36.3
Bakit yun ang ginamit niyang generic,
16:38.5
hindi yung tinanong ko sa Philippines?
16:40.5
Bakit masusunog kasi siya sa Philippines?
16:45.4
What is slapsuit in the Philippines?
16:49.0
Hindi niya ginamit yun.
16:54.4
Yung dagdagdagdagbawas eh, no?
16:58.8
update in January 22.
17:02.7
The Philippines had not yet enacted specific legislation
17:05.4
addressing slapsuits.
17:09.1
However, discussions and proposals...
17:11.8
Tignan niyo, mga kapatid.
17:12.6
Ito yung slapsuit.
17:12.7
Lagyan natin yung terminology na ginamit, no?
17:16.1
Addressing slapsuits.
17:17.6
So, existing talagang slapsuits dito sa Pilipinas.
17:20.9
Regarding anti-slap legislations were ongoing.
17:31.0
Alam niyo na kung bakit.
17:33.4
Members of the press,
17:38.8
ordinary citizens
17:40.4
from fully exercising their right
17:42.6
in the matter of public concern.
17:49.7
Hindi talaga nila nag-guess.
17:51.4
Ang sakit sa ulos.
17:54.0
bilib na bilib kay Piskal.
17:56.2
Working right now.
17:56.7
Yun nga, hindi ko rin maintindihan eh.
18:00.2
this is not actually a matter of law.
18:04.5
Understanding that the existence of slapsuits
18:07.9
is not a matter of law.
18:14.6
itadrag mo siya into a legal,
18:19.4
ano, legal discourse
18:22.4
it's merely the existence of slapsuits.
18:25.2
It's not the existence of an anti-slap law.
18:31.9
Hindi na, walang ikinig lang ako
18:34.6
through earpads ko.
18:45.6
Tingnan nga natin kung ano.
18:52.6
A passage of the Fed Law
18:54.3
is also actually in line
18:56.1
with the recommendation
18:56.9
of the 2016 UN Committee
19:07.2
Kala mo lulusot sakin yung ganyan.
19:20.9
Natignan pa natin.
19:23.7
Na may pakialam tayo
19:25.1
while gusto niya nga lang
19:26.1
i-quote sa batas natin.
19:32.9
Akala ko without care.
19:39.1
kung gagamitin ko,
19:43.5
it's enacted into law?
19:49.5
The age of sexual consent.
19:50.9
Huwag natin mag-usapan yan.
19:52.2
Age of sexual consent.
19:57.0
The information...
20:00.4
Kung yan lang yung point mo,
20:03.1
ako rin yung nag-provide.
20:09.5
Kasama si Kavit Teddy,
20:13.1
karating mo lang ba?
20:18.8
Can you actually do...
20:19.9
Can you actually raise that issue?
20:24.3
Ito tayo sa dulo.
20:30.1
Walang ego and pride.
20:33.3
Alam nyo, ito lang.
20:35.8
Dito ako mag-e-end.
20:38.2
tungkol sa reliability.
20:39.7
Kasi nagtanong dito
20:41.2
between you and the lawyer
20:42.7
who is more reliable.
20:47.9
Hindi nga naman talaga
20:49.0
tama yung tanong na yan.
20:50.6
Kasi I will admit,
20:52.0
mga kabatas natin.
20:52.8
Tsaka dun sa mga nagsasabi din
20:54.0
na parang dinebank tayong pareho
20:58.7
pareho nga kami ng posisyon
21:00.6
Hindi ko nga maintindihan
21:01.5
kung bakit kasali ako
21:02.4
sa debunk na yun.
21:04.3
Eh gusto niya lang naman
21:06.1
Parang yung si Rafi Tulfo
21:07.6
nag-endorse ng isang
21:11.2
si Mayor Magalong din
21:13.2
nag-endorse ng isang
21:15.5
Ngayon itong si Fiscal EJ
21:16.7
ganyan yung sinabi niya
21:18.0
at dahil lawyer siya
21:19.4
tapos dinebank niya
21:22.6
dinebank niya rin ako.
21:25.1
Hindi ko maintindihan din
21:26.3
yung ginagawa nyo na ganun
21:29.5
tsaka Ampalayagang
21:30.5
parang ganito lang yung simple.
21:32.4
Ganito lang yung dulo niyan
21:37.3
existing yung slap
21:38.6
dito sa Pilipinas.
21:42.6
Okay may slap suits.
21:46.5
Alam, maraming beses
21:47.5
ko nang pinaliwanag yan.
21:49.2
Yun din yung sinasabi ni
21:52.1
Existing yung phenomenon.
21:53.9
ginamit ko rin yung
21:54.6
environmental cases noon.
21:56.4
Kasi nag-research nga ako
21:57.4
tungkol sa slap law
21:58.2
dito sa Pilipinas.
21:59.2
Ang nakita kong slap law
22:03.9
yung anti-slap law
22:06.2
dito sa Pilipinas.
22:07.2
Tapos ang nakita kong
22:10.1
sa environmental cases.
22:11.2
So it only covers
22:13.4
environmental cases
22:15.1
pronouncement yung
22:15.8
Supreme Court tungkol dyan.
22:17.3
Kaya pinaliwanag ko din yun
22:18.5
na sana magkaroon tayo
22:24.0
environmental laws.
22:25.5
Because it is not only
22:27.7
environmental suits
22:32.0
Ganun lang kasimple.
22:33.0
Ganun din kasimple
22:33.8
yung gustong ipaliwanag
22:35.8
Kaya lang syempre
22:37.6
doon sa sinasabi ko
22:40.9
walang slap suits.
22:41.2
Ang slap suit dito
22:45.0
Ngayon mga kabatas natin
22:46.0
bakit ko ba pinagdidiilan
22:47.3
yung slap suit dito?
22:48.4
Because I have a purpose.
22:53.2
the case is filed
22:55.1
goes the extra mile.
22:58.8
Lahat itong lima na ito
23:00.2
umabot sa Supreme Court.
23:03.1
hanggang sa Supreme Court
23:04.7
mga kabatas natin.
23:07.1
how it will hold.
23:15.7
all related to Rafi Tulfo
23:18.4
mga kabatas natin
23:28.3
mga kabatas natin
23:37.5
Tapos ito yung tinanong niya
23:39.3
who is more reliable?
23:40.5
Between you and a lawyer
23:42.2
who is more reliable?
23:45.4
aaminin ko sa inyo
23:46.2
mga kabatas natin.
23:48.3
Hindi talaga maganda
23:49.1
yung tanong na yan.
23:52.9
si ChatGPT sa akin.
23:56.1
Mas reliable siya sa akin.
23:58.7
mas reliable siya sa akin
24:08.0
Mas reliable siya sa akin
24:12.1
ng mathematical equations.
24:14.8
Mas reliable siya sa akin
24:22.2
and current events.
24:27.8
mas reliable ako sa kanya
24:32.2
dito sa Pilipinas.
24:37.4
Malamang ikakatna naman nila yan.
24:48.4
all the time superior.
24:50.0
Depende sa galing mo.
24:54.5
sino ang mas magaling?
24:58.4
Ikaw o si ChatGPT?
25:01.3
Sino mas reliable?
25:05.1
Aaminin ko sa inyo
25:17.8
nagpakadalubasa ako
25:19.8
Si ChatGPT, hindi.
25:22.4
mga kabatas natin,
25:23.1
tanungin mo siya ng
25:37.3
Sino ang mas reliable?
25:40.5
Pero ang ginawa kasi dito
25:42.9
between you and a lawyer
25:44.0
who is more reliable,
25:45.4
it's the wrong question,
25:46.9
you get the wrong answer.
25:53.2
Pero tulad ng sinabi ko rin dati,
25:55.0
you have to verify.
25:56.2
Pero most likely,
25:57.3
if it's about facts,
25:59.5
kasi nasa search nila
26:03.4
malamang tama siya.
26:05.2
Pero not all the time.
26:08.3
artificial intelligence.
26:15.6
walang latest news
26:18.5
Gated sa December 21,
26:20.7
ang data ni ChatGPT.
26:22.6
Mas may edge ka pa din,
26:31.6
Tanungin natin si Copilot.
26:34.1
tignan natin si ChatGPT.
26:37.8
Tanungin natin siya
26:40.5
tanungin natin siya
26:45.5
tungkol sa lindol
27:10.5
kung ano naman yun?
27:26.0
Tignan natin si Copilot.
28:10.3
Japan occurred on
28:18.3
The quake triggered
28:21.3
Ang nabalit ako nga 3
28:24.3
this information is
28:25.3
accurate as of the
28:31.3
checking a reliable
28:51.3
mas reliable tong
28:54.3
alam niyo kung ilang
28:56.3
alam niyo kung kailan
29:01.3
New Year's Day pala
29:06.3
mga kapatid natin.
29:09.3
po tayo ng Mahimbing
29:11.3
na yung natutulog ng
29:13.3
siya yung laging panahon.
