01:23.2
na pakilaman yung ating konstitusyon para daw sa ating kapakanan.
01:28.4
Mahirap naman maniwala dun sa ganong sabi-sabi.
01:31.6
Dahil kung pagbabasahan po natin, yung track record ng ating mga kagalang-galang na mga politiko
01:37.8
were they're not exactly, tawad dito, models of virtue or paragons of virtue.
01:45.3
So hindi mo natin maiwasan na magduda, ano bang motibo nitong mga politiko na ito sa pagsusulong nitong panibagong chacha or charter change.
01:54.3
Ang bago po rito, so mismo si Pangulong Ferdinand Bong,
01:58.4
sinabi niya, gusto niya talaga baguhin, i-update yung mga economic provisions sa ating konstitusyon.
02:06.1
Tapos sa interview sa kanya ng GMA7, sabi rin niya, eventually, open siya rin sa pag-amienda or pag-revise ng konstitusyon
02:15.4
when it comes to political provisions.
02:18.0
Yung political provisions po, kasama po dyan, for example, yung pagpapalawig ng termino, for instance,
02:24.9
ng presidente, vice president, mga senador o kongresista.
02:28.4
Or pwede rin gawin ng ating mga kagalang-galang na congressmen at senador.
02:34.8
Kung sakali magkaroon ng constituent assembly, paano kung gawin nila?
02:38.0
O i-lift na yung term limits up to sawa na.
02:40.3
At the same time, wala pa rin anti-political dynasty law or enabling law.
02:45.5
So yan, marami po tayong pag-uusapan.
02:47.8
Ang gagawin po natin ngayong gabi, pag-uusapan po natin yung mga bagay na dapat bantayan natin lahat.
02:53.9
And I hope kayong mga nanonood at nakikinig dito,
02:58.4
sana may mga mapulot kayo, sure ako, marami kayong mapupulot na aral dito sa discussion natin.
03:04.3
Pero ang hope ko po sana, i-share nyo dun sa mga kapidbahay nyo, sa mga kamag-anak nyo,
03:10.3
sa mga kaibigan nyo, yung mga matututunan yung leksyon dito.
03:13.7
Kasi ang in-invite po natin muli para sa episode na ito,
03:17.5
si dating Supreme Court Senior Associate Justice Tony Carpio
03:21.9
para pag-uusapan po yung mga dapat nating bantayan.
03:28.4
Sa pakulo nila na charter change.
03:33.7
Magandang gabi po, Justice Carpio.
03:35.4
And thank you again for joining us dito po sa Facts First.
03:38.9
Magandang gabi po.
03:41.1
Magandang gabi, Christian.
03:42.5
And I'm in my sister's birthday.
03:49.7
Hello, sir. Medyo choppy ata kaya.
03:58.4
Subukan natin siya.
04:03.3
Magandang gabi, Christian.
04:05.3
Sir, medyo na choppy kayo.
04:17.1
Ibalik ko po kayo, no?
04:18.4
Sige, sige. Wait, wait.
04:22.3
Ilabas muna natin. Sayang kasi, no?
04:24.0
Mukhang nasa, ano siya?
04:34.4
Okay, ilalatag ko lang yung mga pag-uusapan natin, no?
04:36.8
Ang title po natin ng...
04:38.4
Ang title po ng episode natin ngayong gabi,
04:40.7
mga dapat bantayan para iwas budol sa chacha.
04:43.6
Alam nyo po kasi,
04:45.3
alam naman natin na hindi po ganong karami,
04:47.9
hindi po ganong kalaking bilang na mga Pilipino
04:49.9
na talagang nauunawaan yung konstitusyon.
04:56.4
tingin nyo ba yung mga nagsusulong
04:58.2
o kaya sumusuporta sa pagbabago ng konstitusyon,
05:01.3
eh, sa tingin nyo lahat sila nabasa kaya yung konstitusyon?
05:04.1
At kung nabasa, naunawaan kaya, no?
05:06.5
Alam natin tinuturo yan sa school,
05:08.1
pero alam natin na medyo hindi ganong kataas ang kalidad
05:11.0
ng ating edukasyon.
05:13.1
So, hindi natin ma-expect na talagang malalim yung pag-unawa
05:16.0
ng marami sa atin dito sa ating konstitusyon.
05:20.0
kung ganyan po yung sitwasyon dito sa ating bansa,
05:22.1
hindi ganong karaming talaga naunawaan,
05:27.0
o nabasa mismo yung konstitusyon,
05:29.2
pwede pong exploit yan ng mga politiko
05:31.0
para isulong po yung kanilang sariling interest.
05:35.6
yung mga dapat nating bandayan,
05:37.8
yung ba mga nagsusulong ng pagbabago
05:40.3
sa ating economic provisions?
05:42.6
Kasi kung napapansin nyo, sinasabi lang naman doon,
05:45.2
hindi naman nila itinatakda kung ano ba talaga yung,
05:47.5
let's say, percentage,
05:48.5
let's say, in terms of foreign ownership
05:50.4
sa ilang industriya dito sa Pilipinas.
05:53.8
Hindi pa naman nila sinasabi exacto eh
05:55.5
doon sa planong amyanda nila.
05:56.9
Ang inalagay lang doon,
05:57.8
yung kataga o yung linya na
05:59.7
unless otherwise provided by law.
06:02.6
Ibig sabihin, pag isiningit po yun,
06:05.1
kung ganas na po,
06:06.0
yung maglalabas ng specific na batas
06:08.1
pertaining to that particular provision.
06:10.7
Ayan, pasensya na kaya,
06:11.4
medyo technical itong pag-uusapan natin.
06:13.6
So, nandito na po ulit si Justice Cargill.
06:15.8
Magandang gabi po, sir.
06:23.0
Ayun, mas malinaw po.
06:38.1
Medyo nag-freeze kayo.
06:43.2
Hintayin natin makapag-settle down si, ano,
06:46.0
si Justice Carpio.
06:51.0
Mukha nasa isang event siya, no?
06:54.0
Ayun natin, masayang discussion natin
06:55.5
kasi ito nga yung team natin ngayong gabi.
06:57.8
Ano ba yung mga dapat nating bantayan
06:59.7
dito sa isinusulong na charter change?
07:02.1
Parang ano rin ito?
07:02.8
Public service itong episode natin
07:04.7
dahil nga ayaw natin ma-exploit tayo.
07:08.5
Lalo yung mga iba pa mga Pilipino
07:10.8
na, kunwari, pinapapirma rito.
07:12.3
Hindi nila alam siguro
07:14.2
o lubos na na-uunawaan
07:16.2
yung implications ng kanilang paglagda.
07:18.7
For instance, dito sa isinusulong na people's initiative.
07:25.5
paano kung ilang politiko pala natin
07:27.8
alam naman natin marami sa mga politiko natin
07:30.6
ay malalaking negosyante rin
07:32.3
o hawak ng mga malalaking negosyo.
07:34.5
Eh, baka naman isinusulong nila
07:35.6
yung pagbabago sa ilang economic provisions
07:37.5
eh, para mag-benefit yung ilang industriya
07:39.9
kung saan na makikinabang talaga
07:41.4
ay yung kanilang mga patron
07:49.8
bantayan yung mabuti.
07:50.6
Pag masyadong, kunwari,
07:51.5
mabulak-lak yung pananalita
07:52.6
ng ating ilang mga politiko,
07:54.4
kailangan pag-aralan mabuti.
07:57.8
pag-uusapan natin,
07:58.8
yung mga dapat nating bantayan.
08:02.0
Sige na, Justice Carpio?
08:03.2
Yes, I'm okay now.
08:06.4
Ayan na si Justice.
08:07.3
Ayan, malinaw na po.
08:13.9
Okay lang po ba kayo sa ganyang ano?
08:18.5
Okay lang po ba kayo sa ganyang angulo?
08:27.5
Pag-uusapan natin,
08:28.5
ano ba yung mga dapat bantayan
08:29.9
naming mga ordinaryong Pilipino
08:33.2
para hindi naman kami mabudol
08:35.1
dito sa isinusulong na charter change?
08:44.8
we give them a blank check, no?
08:47.4
Kasi yung proposal nila,
08:50.3
there will be joint voting.
08:54.4
pag joint voting,
08:55.3
that's 24 senators
08:58.1
316 members of Congress.
09:01.8
Pag joint voting,
09:05.4
one house member,
09:06.8
one senate member.
09:11.8
The senate will be overwhelmed.
09:13.7
Kahit na lahat na senators
09:16.1
against a provision,
09:18.1
talo pa rin sila.
09:19.7
Unlike in an ordinary law
09:21.3
where separate voting,
09:23.3
pag ayaw ng senate,
09:24.5
hindi pwede pumasa.
09:27.5
ang problema dito,
09:29.2
the house wants a blank check
09:31.1
to revise the constitution.
09:33.3
Pero hindi nila sinasabi
09:34.7
kung ano talagang revision gusto nila.
09:39.4
economic provisions lang daw.
09:42.7
rest of guarantee,
09:43.8
the moment they are given
09:44.9
the full authority,
09:46.5
they can change anything they want.
09:51.0
yung economic provisions naman,
09:52.8
we have one of the most liberal
09:54.4
investment laws already
09:58.3
We are more liberal
10:04.3
So, if we have higher unemployment,
10:07.3
we have lower foreign investments,
10:10.5
it's not because of the economic provisions.
10:13.0
it's not because of the investment laws.
10:16.2
Kasi, binuksan na natin yan eh
10:17.8
under the amended Public Service Act.
10:20.6
We allow 100% foreign ownership
10:27.5
We have left only about 6 sectors
10:31.0
that are still subject
10:32.8
to 60-40 ownership.
10:35.0
We are more liberal than China,
10:37.1
we are more liberal than Vietnam,
10:38.7
we are more liberal than Indonesia.
10:41.4
mas madaming foreign investments sa kanila.
10:46.8
hindi yung constitution.
10:49.5
we have higher power rates,
10:53.1
we are doing business policies,
10:57.5
are very restrictive.
11:00.3
to open a business here,
11:01.8
mag-umpisa ka pa sa barangay,
11:03.9
tapos pupunta ka sa mayor,
11:05.6
pupunta ka sa department secretary,
11:09.4
China or Indonesia,
11:10.9
one-stop shop sila.
11:12.2
Isa lang pupuntahan mo,
11:13.3
makuha mo na lahat na lisensya kailangan mo.
11:15.9
So, we don't have that ease of doing business.
11:20.8
it's surprising bakit they are saying
11:23.0
we want the power to amend the constitution
11:26.8
we want to change the economic provisions.
11:30.6
hindi nila dinidiretsyo.
11:32.3
They should go straight to the point.
11:34.4
Ano yung economic provisions?
11:36.2
Pumapayag na yung Senado eh,
11:38.5
mag-economic provisions na lang tayo.
11:40.4
Ayaw pa rin ang house,
11:42.7
they continue collecting signatures pa rin.
11:46.6
ano ba talagang gusto nila?
11:51.4
Madaming nagsasabi na
11:52.7
they want to convert to parliamentary.
11:55.2
Madaming yung iba,
11:56.5
they want to lift the term limits.
11:59.9
if we give the house a blank check.
12:03.7
An authority that will disregard the Senate.
12:07.7
So, yung Senate has practically no more voice.
12:11.4
So, yun ang babantayan natin.
12:15.2
So, basically may punto yung Senado
12:16.8
kasi yung lahat na miyembro ng Senado,
12:20.4
naglabas ng strongly worded statement
12:22.8
condemning people's initiative.
12:25.1
So, mga viewers natin,
12:26.5
ito po yung diniscuss natin kagabi.
12:29.3
May punto yung mga Senador
12:30.9
na kung matuloy yung people's initiative na yan,
12:35.3
It's as if they do not exist.
12:40.9
this is an existential threat.
12:47.3
ang gusto ng house,
12:49.3
that they will meet
12:55.0
papayag na maabolis sila.
12:56.5
Of course, they will not do that.
12:58.9
they don't want to meet.
13:01.2
pwede naman natin i-amend yung
13:02.9
economic provisions separately.
13:05.5
You pass it in the house,
13:06.9
we pass it in the Senate,
13:08.5
and then we submit it to the people
13:09.9
for ratification.
13:11.1
Pwede naman yan eh.
13:12.8
but ayaw ng house ngayon.
13:14.9
intention talaga nila.
13:18.5
anong tingin niyo intention?
13:19.5
Ano po yung tingin niyo intention talaga ng house?
13:22.7
they want to convert to parliamentary.
13:25.2
I think that's very clear.
13:26.5
You ask any politician,
13:28.4
they will tell you that.
13:30.5
Kasi kung talaga...
13:31.7
What made you think po,
13:33.0
na they want to convert to parliamentary?
13:37.3
matagal na nang gusto ng house yan, no?
13:44.0
in the 2028 election,
13:49.7
and then ang kanilang
13:52.0
kung papatakbuhin nila si Martin,
13:56.5
presidential election.
13:57.8
So, pag na-convert tayo
13:59.1
to parliamentary,
14:00.8
mawawala si Sarah.
14:01.9
Wala siyang, ano eh,
14:03.1
wala siyang supporta sa Congress, eh.
14:08.5
yung mga Dutertes,
14:10.4
alam nila na this is directed against Sarah.
14:16.4
I was against the Duterte administration,
14:21.8
not because I've,
14:25.6
I'm not favoring them.
14:27.6
I'm not favoring them.
14:30.0
that if you want to change the Constitution,
14:32.3
do it the proper way.
14:34.6
Hindi pwede yung,
14:37.2
tinatago mo yung intention mo.
14:41.1
you lay your cards
14:42.0
and show it to the people.
14:43.7
ano bang gusto mo?
14:44.5
And so that we can vote accordingly.
14:46.8
Hindi pwede yung,
14:48.1
they will ask us for a blank check
14:49.8
to change the Constitution.
14:52.4
pag pinalitan na nila,
14:54.2
walang time magawa.
14:55.2
inautorize na natin sila eh.
15:00.8
mas maintindihan ng mga viewers natin.
15:02.7
Dito mukhang dalawang steps
15:03.9
na gusto mangyari
15:04.7
ng mga kongresista.
15:06.4
People's initiative
15:07.3
para maging klaro
15:08.7
yung provision ng Constitution
15:09.8
na kung sakaling magkaroon
15:11.5
ng Constituent Assembly
15:13.7
yung Senado at House
15:15.5
bilang isang kapulungan
15:18.7
o revise yung Constitution
15:27.1
Pero yung initial step,
15:29.4
because right now,
15:32.1
my position is that
15:34.6
in an ordinary law,
15:36.9
you need the approval
15:40.1
when it comes to the Constitution,
15:41.5
if you want to amend it,
15:42.8
you must get the approval.
15:45.2
ang kanila hindi clarify.
15:48.3
Instead of the House
15:50.1
approving the Constitutional change,
15:54.6
have the Constitutional change.
15:56.0
So, yun ang masama.
15:58.0
So, buburahin yung Senado?
15:59.7
Buburahin yung Senado.
16:05.5
buburahin ang Senado
16:06.4
para malaman ng tao
16:07.6
yung anong gusto nila.
16:10.6
Last 24 senators,
16:12.7
regardless of political affiliation,
16:15.4
Alam nila na silang
16:16.4
silang mawawala dito eh.
16:20.5
ito po yung isa ring punto
16:23.0
na gusto kong pag-usapan eh.
16:26.1
aksaya naman sa ano yan?
16:28.6
Itong isinusulong
16:29.5
na people's initiative?
16:31.5
Kung marami naman
16:32.2
questions dyan, diba?
16:33.1
Kasi, for instance,
16:34.2
ibabalidate pa yun
16:36.3
Siyempre, may pondo naman
16:37.9
Pero, pera ng taong bayan yun eh.
16:40.8
which is questionable
16:43.1
hindi po siya cheap
16:43.9
to begin with, diba?
16:46.4
Yeah, magasto yan.
16:47.5
I don't know the,
16:49.6
the estimate is about
16:59.5
budget ng Comilic,
17:02.2
there is an item there na
17:07.2
the conduct of election,
17:09.3
for the conduct of
17:14.0
pag ginamit mo yan sa
17:15.3
plebiscito ngayon,
17:16.7
wala, kukulangin ka
17:20.8
So, yun ang problema.
17:23.4
nakalagay naman doon
17:27.6
pwede gamitin nyo
17:29.1
Pero, kukulangin.
17:30.4
Kung ibubuhos mo ngayon
17:33.8
kukulangin ka para sa
17:37.6
So, pupunta ka ngayon
17:39.5
at saka sa House.
17:44.1
ba't ninyo ginamit
17:46.4
people's initiative,
17:50.1
inaabolis lang kami.
17:54.5
that's the other problem
18:01.6
for all of these activities.
18:03.1
So, if you put the money
18:04.3
in people's initiative,
18:06.1
kukulangin ka para sa
18:07.3
regular election.
18:10.2
Ito po po yung isa kong
18:11.0
tanong, Justice, no?
18:12.2
Assuming maging successful
18:13.6
itong people's initiative,
18:16.6
huli nating discussion,
18:17.9
napakadaming questions,
18:19.6
Kung meron ba talagang
18:21.4
sufficient enough
18:22.8
for this people's
18:26.7
Assuming mag-work po
18:27.6
itong people's initiative
18:32.0
i-coconvene naman
18:32.8
yung constituent assembly?
18:37.3
Papano na yun nila?
18:39.9
That's another hurdle.
18:43.0
as a constituent assembly,
18:48.0
simply lang gagawin
18:49.6
They will not pass
18:53.9
it will have to be
18:55.7
Hindi matuloy rin
18:56.5
yung constituent assembly.
18:58.9
Yun ang problema nila.
19:00.8
masusolb yun ngayon.
19:03.2
That's the last card
19:06.6
their abolition, no?
19:14.3
naglabas ng resolution
19:17.0
ang primary sponsor
19:18.3
ay si senate president
19:19.7
Juan Miguel Zaviri
19:25.8
doon sa economic provision.
19:27.8
So, hindi yun kung mag-abinding
19:29.1
in the bigger scheme of things, no?
19:36.6
Kasi ang sabi niya doon,
19:43.0
you were still operating
19:44.1
under the unamended provision.
19:49.6
when they came out with that
19:51.4
and the house still continued,
19:53.7
Tuloy pa rin ang provision.
19:55.7
signatures ng house,
19:58.4
hindi na namin ituloy
20:01.5
binabaliwala ninyo
20:04.5
suggestion namin,
20:06.5
yung recommendation namin
20:07.8
na ituloy natin yung
20:11.0
voting separately.
20:15.4
people's initiative nila
20:22.2
i-suspend nila yun,
20:24.0
they have suspended
20:27.5
on the resolution.
20:30.6
parang yun yung sagot nila,
20:32.8
economic cha-cha,
20:34.0
may resolution na kami.
20:42.9
Parang bait ba yun?
20:44.7
I think that was the
20:46.2
intention of the senate
20:49.0
linabas nila yung
20:52.4
in-smoke out nila,
20:54.2
intention ng house?
20:56.7
tuloy pa rin yung
20:58.2
yung cha-cha ng house,
21:07.3
speaking of smoking out,
21:10.0
mismo si President Marcos po,
21:11.6
nagsarita na rin.
21:12.9
Okay siya sa economic
21:14.6
and then later on,
21:15.6
open din siya sa political
21:31.4
unahin natin yung
21:32.5
economic provision,
21:33.8
and then sunod na yung
21:34.6
political provision.
21:36.7
all under the same
21:37.8
authority na hiningi
21:44.5
they can pass the
21:45.3
economic provisions
21:49.1
Ganyan rin ang labas.
21:59.4
papalitan nila yung
22:00.5
political provisions
22:12.7
of our politicians.
22:19.5
talaga in overhaul,
22:21.0
Di ba meron po yan
22:21.8
transitory provisions?
22:26.2
kung disente naman yung mga
22:27.9
ng bagong konstitusyon,
22:29.4
dapat hindi sila mag-benefit
22:32.9
panibagong konstitusyon?
22:34.6
kung papalawigin yung
22:37.2
o ililip yung term limits,
22:39.5
decency or delicadeza
22:43.7
dahil isa ka sa mga
22:52.2
andyan yan sa lahat
22:53.5
constitutional changes,
22:55.3
Na it will not benefit
22:56.5
those who approved
22:57.4
the new constitution.
22:59.9
pag tinasan nila yung
23:01.6
hindi sila mag-benefit
23:12.1
already the authority,
23:19.9
Pero alam mo na yung
23:22.1
it's the majority
23:26.7
hindi na buboto yan, eh.
23:31.0
yung ratification.
23:33.5
Sa plebiscite pa?
23:37.8
it's the majority
23:38.8
of those who vote.
23:46.0
ang bumuboto lang,
23:48.7
are those who want
23:49.4
the constitution approved.
23:54.4
Hindi ko po naisip yun, oh.
23:56.0
Mas madali talaga.
23:58.0
Pag sa ratification,
23:59.6
madali na lang yan.
24:02.3
Tama nga naman, oh.
24:04.2
Kung ayaw mo kasi,
24:04.9
di ba, hindi ka po
24:05.5
magpa-participate
24:06.4
kasi ayaw mo kang paritan, eh.
24:11.4
yung mga dapat bantayan, oh?
24:13.2
pag may mga questions
24:14.2
kayo yung mga viewers, no,
24:15.3
kasi medyo complicated
24:16.3
yung topic natin, oh.
24:17.6
Ano po po yung mga
24:18.2
dapat bantayan dito
24:19.2
ng mga ordinaryong Pilipino
24:20.5
dito sa isinusunong na tsa-tsa?
24:22.0
Nabanggit nyo na yung PI, no?
24:23.8
Eh, nga pala, sir,
24:24.8
yung PI itself po, no,
24:26.5
ano ba yung mga questionable doon?
24:32.4
framers of the Constitution
24:36.0
the Constitution.
24:38.6
Kasi we copied this
24:40.9
People's Initiative concept
24:43.0
from the U.S., no?
24:45.6
People's Initiative
24:46.5
para amendment lang
24:48.0
hindi pwede i-revise
24:49.1
yung Constitution.
24:49.9
Kasi pag ni-revise mo
24:51.3
yung Constitution,
24:52.4
ang daming debate yan, no?
24:55.7
so many provisions.
24:56.9
So, for practical purposes,
25:00.7
yung mga single matter lang,
25:03.9
single issues, single matter,
25:06.2
fundamental change
25:08.3
of the structure.
25:11.1
fundamental principle,
25:13.5
Yung mga simple amendments lang.
25:18.8
during the debate
25:21.3
sa Constitutional Commission,
25:22.6
everybody agreed na
25:25.4
by People's Initiative
25:27.5
is only for simple amendments.
25:30.2
Hindi pwede revision.
25:32.8
you need a CONCON
25:34.3
or a Constituent Assembly.
25:43.4
to change the voting
25:46.1
separate to joint,
25:53.1
Pero, hindi klaro yan.
25:55.9
That is not a clarification only
25:58.3
because the majority opinion
26:00.7
is that to change
26:02.8
the Constitution,
26:03.9
there must be approval
26:05.2
of both House and Senate
26:06.5
in a Constituent Assembly
26:08.2
voting separately sila.
26:11.9
ang issue ngayon,
26:13.5
itong amendment nila,
26:15.9
this People's Initiative
26:18.8
the Constitution,
26:19.9
the way I look at it,
26:21.1
this is a revision.
26:23.5
pinapalitan mo yung
26:24.4
check and balance eh.
26:26.5
check and balance
26:28.7
you make it a joint voting.
26:33.7
members of the House,
26:36.0
24 lang yung Senate.
26:37.5
The Senate will always be outvoted.
26:40.8
they will always be outvoted.
26:44.5
check and balance
26:53.9
Dito sa highest law
26:56.2
pinagsama mo sila
26:58.4
yung members of the House.
27:01.1
walang check and balance.
27:03.6
that's what we have
27:07.5
Baka i-home run nila ito
27:14.0
People's Initiative.
27:21.7
this is a revision.
27:25.5
Napaka-importante
27:28.8
Hindi lang amendment
27:29.8
yung isinusulong dito
27:34.5
amendment lang ang pwede.
27:36.8
malinaw ito sa marami
27:39.5
pero alam ko marami
27:40.3
naguguluhan dito, no?
27:42.1
may tanong si Jerwin.
27:44.0
kailan magsasalita
27:44.9
ang Supreme Court
27:46.4
People's Initiative?
27:50.1
pirma-pirma na yan?
27:51.1
Dalit na siya, no?
27:52.2
Okay, paka-explain nga po
27:54.0
Hindi naman pwede
27:54.5
makialam yung Supreme Court
27:56.3
diba, for instance?
27:59.1
The Supreme Court
28:05.6
go to the Supreme Court
28:08.9
justiciable controversy.
28:13.0
controversy means
28:14.1
there is a petition
28:22.6
they filed their petition.
28:25.1
pinag-file na petition eh.
28:29.8
So if they file a petition
28:31.0
let's say tomorrow,
28:33.7
the Supreme Court
28:34.8
this is sufficient
28:36.1
in form and substance.
28:40.2
of the signature.
28:43.3
sa Supreme Court.
28:55.4
a people's initiative
28:59.1
of the Constitution.
29:00.5
Nasa rules nila yan eh.
29:01.9
Kasi they adopted
29:07.4
this is sufficient
29:14.1
meron ba kinakikita
29:15.5
Parang possibility
29:19.6
constitutional crisis
29:21.0
a very serious clash
29:23.3
legal principles.
29:25.5
malinaw na questionable
29:30.6
binubura yung Senado,
29:32.9
yung mismong prinsipi
29:34.5
ng checks and balances po.
29:37.0
ipilit pa rin po ito
29:40.7
we all have to go
29:41.6
to the Supreme Court
29:42.6
to ask the Supreme Court
29:47.0
the final arbiter
29:48.0
will be the Supreme Court
29:51.6
follow the jurisprudence
29:53.5
that the Supreme Court
30:07.3
explain niya na po
30:08.7
pero reminder lang po
30:10.3
sa mga viewers natin
30:11.3
kasi si Justice Carpio
30:12.4
siya yung sumulat
30:16.3
Kasi diba yung mga promotor
30:19.1
ginagamit yung ano
30:20.4
yung desisyon na yan
30:23.8
na naglabas ang opinion.
30:26.5
Pakiexplain nga po.
30:29.0
Lambino versus Comelec
30:31.5
the disposive portion
30:33.5
of the main decision
30:34.8
the petition is dismissed.
30:39.4
Hindi naman sinabi na
30:40.7
the initiative law
30:48.7
Sinabi lang dismissed.
30:51.8
sinabi ng Supreme Court
30:53.4
the motion for recon
30:54.9
is denied with finality.
30:57.5
But the Supreme Court
30:59.2
there are 10 justices
31:01.1
who maintain their opinion
31:02.8
that the initiative law
31:06.3
Now, anong meaning yan?
31:10.7
you have to look at
31:11.7
the dispositive portion.
31:14.6
That is the ruling eh.
31:17.4
the petition is denied
31:21.7
The motion for recon
31:23.1
is denied with finality.
31:24.8
Yun ang ruling eh.
31:25.9
Wala namang sinabi
31:26.9
the Santiago versus Comelec
31:30.8
decision is reversed.
31:33.8
Wala namang sinabi
31:38.8
pag sinabi ng Supreme Court
31:43.4
Several years past
31:44.7
hindi naman pwede
31:46.1
sabihin ng Supreme Court
31:52.1
they should go to Congress
31:53.3
and pass a new law.
31:55.3
there is what we call
32:02.3
of final decisions.
32:04.5
Pag nag-final na yung
32:05.9
decision ng Supreme Court
32:07.1
hindi na dapat baguin yan.
32:08.7
Just to preserve stability
32:10.6
in our legal system.
32:12.7
So, ang dapat gawin
32:14.0
since sinabi ng Supreme Court
32:16.9
naging final yan,
32:19.6
more than a decade na,
32:21.5
hindi pwede buhayin yun eh.
32:23.8
They should go back to Congress
32:25.2
and get a new law.
32:26.8
that will be a new doctrine
32:29.5
and that will really upset everything.
32:32.2
Kasi mawala yung immutability.
32:35.5
we have peace of mind na
32:36.8
yung decision na yun,
32:38.4
hindi na mababago yan.
32:40.8
you introduce a new element na
32:42.6
kahit na final 10 years ago,
32:51.4
the decision can always be questioned
33:00.4
of final decisions.
33:02.1
That's very important
33:03.2
in our legal system.
33:04.8
Para pag tapos na,
33:06.6
hindi na pwede balikan yan.
33:11.6
itay mo lang magbago yung
33:12.9
membership ng Supreme Court
33:15.7
pag tapos erase mo na
33:17.1
that question again,
33:21.0
destabilize our legal system.
33:29.1
through another decision
33:30.5
several decades later.
33:35.9
Nga po pala, Justice,
33:37.8
kayo po ba mismo,
33:41.6
are you considering
33:43.7
sa Supreme Court?
33:46.3
magkaroon ng, ano,
33:48.3
justiciable controversy?
33:50.4
Well, madaming grupo
33:51.5
na nakakausap ko,
34:04.1
I'd like to give you
34:05.7
the opportunity para,
34:07.3
kausapin yung mga
34:08.2
tao mismo directly.
34:13.7
Nakasalubong nyo,
34:14.3
kunwari sa tindahan,
34:15.7
alam mo yung mga,
34:17.1
yung parang simpleng,
34:18.9
dito sa isinusulong nilang
34:30.8
ang gusto sa Lambino,
34:36.5
ano yung gagawin nila.
34:39.3
that was the ruling
34:40.2
of the court, eh.
34:43.8
we convert to parliamentary,
34:45.7
pero hindi sinasabi
34:47.7
ano yung mga provision.
34:48.7
Yung mga bullet points
34:49.9
lang linalabas nila.
34:53.9
ng Supreme Court,
34:57.7
proposed amendments
35:02.7
mga hundred thousand.
35:12.0
ano yung papalitan?
35:13.9
ang problema ngayon.
35:19.1
yung Constitution,
35:21.2
bigyan mo muna kami
35:22.1
ng full authority
35:25.8
di ba mas masahol yan?
35:28.6
Sabihin lang nila,
35:30.5
give us the authority,
35:34.8
gagawin ba natin yan?
35:36.9
sinabi ng Supreme Court
35:43.0
must fully disclose
35:45.7
What are the provisions
35:47.5
they want to change?
35:49.1
The exact provision
35:57.4
to change anything.
36:07.3
kasi they can change
36:17.6
sinabi ng Supreme Court,
36:24.8
you must disclose
36:25.7
fully ano yung papalitan.
36:30.4
Give us the special
36:31.5
power of attorney,
36:33.9
Pero hindi sinasabi
36:35.5
ano talagang papalitan?
36:41.2
a gigantic fraud.
36:42.7
Ganito rin ito, eh.
36:47.2
budol po yan, oh.
36:48.2
Galawang budol, no?
36:49.8
Pirmakan ako ng bahala.
36:52.8
Diba ganun po yan,
36:53.9
yung classic na pambubudol?
36:55.3
Pirmakan ako ng bahala
37:00.3
this is what they're doing.
37:01.9
Ginawa na nila yan
37:04.8
sinabi ng Supreme Court,
37:06.7
you have to disclose
37:11.7
It's the same thing.
37:17.6
Pasensya na kayo, no?
37:23.0
Pero alam niyo, Justice,
37:24.1
isa po sa mga goals ko
37:26.1
ay mapagtagalog kayo.
37:28.0
Dahil napapagtagalog ko na kayo,
37:30.0
I would count that
37:31.9
major victory, no?
37:35.5
kung mga nakakausap ako.
37:40.7
Maraming salamat po.
37:42.6
Thank you, Christian.
37:43.4
Thank you, Trevor.
37:45.7
Ayan, totoo yan, ha.
37:49.3
Isa yan sa mga goals natin
37:50.5
dito sa Fox First, eh.
37:53.7
si Justice Carpio.
37:55.2
Nakikita niyo naman yung
37:56.0
progression, diba?
37:57.5
Kasi ano yan, eh.
38:02.9
Nagpapaliwalag siya
38:03.4
usually in English.
38:05.6
Pag ginag-guess ko siya,
38:06.8
lahat ko may nare-remind
38:07.7
sa kanya na, ano,
38:08.6
sir, medyo, ano tayo,
38:09.8
mag-Filipino tayo
38:16.8
natutunan ko rin, ano,
38:18.2
when I was with ANC.
38:19.9
the language was English,
38:21.6
the newscast was in English.
38:24.8
ang primary viewers
38:27.9
yung mga policy makers,
38:31.2
medyo highbrow, no?
38:34.7
when I shifted to YouTube,
38:38.2
hindi lang sila dapat
38:39.0
yung audience, eh.
38:40.7
yung mga same viewers
38:43.5
sumunod naman dito
38:45.7
Pero, mas gusto ko talaga
38:49.2
yung mas nakararaming
38:52.4
Nag-shift po tayo
38:55.0
more conversational
38:59.0
hindi naman po tayo
38:59.7
hirap mag-Filipino
39:09.2
Ang isasabihin ko.
39:15.2
doon sa mga naghahanap
39:16.6
available na po ngayon
39:17.6
yung charcoal black.
39:24.1
in-launch po natin
39:27.3
naghahanap ng ating
39:32.3
nanonood ka, diba?
39:34.3
inisip ko rito, eh.
39:36.0
naglagay kami rin
39:47.7
sa ating official
39:53.2
malalaman kung peke
39:54.3
yung binibilhan nyo?
39:55.5
Kasi nagkalat yung peke
39:58.2
Pinepeke yung ating
40:01.5
original yung nabili nyo?
40:04.7
Meron po akong, ano,
40:06.0
nilalagay ng note.
40:07.6
Personally signed
40:13.7
magpaka-celebrity
40:16.5
Taus-pusong pasasalamat
40:18.2
dun sa pag-suporta
40:19.4
dito sa Facts First.
40:22.5
Umabot na po tayo
40:23.3
sa 200,000 subscribers
40:28.3
subscribers na po tayo
40:33.0
lumalaki ang ating
40:40.6
Yan po yung ating
40:41.9
kilalagyan ngayon.
40:44.7
malalaman yung original
40:49.7
sa Shopee and Lazada
40:52.2
Pag nandun po yung
40:54.6
na may pirma ko po.
40:56.0
Pinipirmahan ko talaga siya.
40:57.1
That's my penmanship.
40:59.4
naglalaki po kami
41:00.6
free stickers doon.
41:05.9
dito sa Shopee and Lazada.
41:11.0
pagmumukha nila, no?
41:16.6
Grabe yung isa, no?
41:17.8
Yung t-shirt po natin,
41:22.6
Tingnan nyo itong
41:23.1
kapalang mukha ni itong isa, no?
41:29.0
Tapos, yung picture
41:29.8
na ginagamit niya,
41:37.4
Yung mga tinamaan
41:38.5
na magaling natin
41:40.2
ang pangalan ng store,
41:50.0
Ayan ang pangalan niya.
41:55.9
Pakireport na rin po, ha?
42:00.6
Legit yung nabili
42:02.7
Ayan, may sticker.
42:04.1
Hindi ganyan kapangit
42:05.8
Minsan nagmamadali lang.
42:06.7
Pasensya na kayo.
42:14.1
Lagi nanonood dyan.
42:17.3
Ayan, madalas manood dyan.
42:20.8
Pagpunta ka ng Hong Kong,
42:22.2
dala-dala ka maraming
42:25.3
Gusto kong pumunta
42:27.9
sa atin yung China eh.
42:33.3
Pupunta po ako dyan
42:35.6
Baka makasalubong ko yung mga
42:39.3
Pupunta po ako dyan
42:46.3
Nakalumutan ko lang.
42:51.4
for our friends in Japan.
42:52.8
Hindi ko pala nalagyan
42:53.5
ng personal note.
42:54.4
Ayan, nagagalit si Menchie oh.
42:55.8
Ayoko naman pinapainit
42:56.8
yung ulo ni Menchie eh.
43:01.6
Buwan-buwan naman
43:02.1
umuwi sa Pilipinas
43:03.2
siya si Menchie eh.
43:16.5
ng pecking shirts
43:18.1
binabanggit kong ano no.
43:27.4
Ingat kayo sa gano'n no.
43:29.3
Maging see-through
43:36.1
si Manuel Velasco.
43:43.7
ng mga kababayan natin
43:45.0
dun peki yung dala niya.
43:50.6
Nililino po natin
43:53.1
from Manila to Tokyo.
43:54.3
Urig po lahat yan.
44:03.9
Baka makasalubong kita
44:07.3
Pupunta tayo dyan.
44:09.0
Si Dennis Leonardo.
44:10.8
Happy 32nd birthday.
44:17.6
Si Ma'am Rose Williams.
44:18.9
Lagi nanonood dyan.
44:22.8
Meron tayong ano.
44:24.6
hinahandang special
44:25.8
Valentine's edition
44:27.8
Facts for Shirts.
44:29.4
So nagtatanong si Fritz
44:30.5
kung aabot ba yung ano
44:31.7
pang Valentine's.
44:33.6
Siguradong sigurado ako.
44:35.9
inihahandang bagong
44:42.4
Yung Midnight Blue
44:44.3
wala pa kasi naubusan
44:46.1
Yung manufacturer natin.
44:48.3
Pero kung ako tatanong niya
44:50.1
Midnight Blue eh.
44:56.2
Tsaka sa asawa niya
44:57.3
na si Jackie Ray.
45:05.7
may kaibigan kasi
45:07.9
pronunciation daw
45:14.0
Naniniwala ako sa kanya.
45:16.4
Kay Mang John ah.
45:18.4
confirmation na pwedeng
45:19.6
mabasa opinion ko.
45:21.9
Nababasa naman natin yan.
45:23.1
Minsan lang natatabunan.
45:24.2
Ang dami kasi eh.
45:27.2
Pasensya nakagabi.
45:31.0
sa comment control
45:33.2
Hindi ko napigilan eh.
45:34.1
Masyado ako nagalak
45:35.0
dun sa comment eh.
45:45.3
personalized card
45:53.0
Maraming salamat sa iyo.
45:53.9
Taka baka makalimutan ko
45:56.2
yung mga babatiin natin eh.
46:00.3
pag may mga naiskip ako eh.
46:01.5
Kaya binabalikin ko
46:02.5
sa comment section eh.
46:29.7
May kaibigan ako dyan.
46:31.6
Tapos good evening
46:34.2
kay Father Gilbert Reyes
46:42.4
Lagi ako nanonood
46:44.5
Father Gilbert Reyes.
46:46.9
Maraming salamat po
46:48.5
Sana hindi po kayo
46:50.7
pinag-uusapan natin
47:01.7
Happy birthday sa'yo.
47:03.1
Maraming maraming
47:06.2
kay Christy Santos
47:15.9
I miss Hong Kong.
47:16.8
Kasarap pumunta dyan.
47:19.9
mag food trip dyan eh.
47:35.3
Coordinator sa Bulacan.
47:36.9
Maraming salamat sa'yo.
47:38.6
watching from Shanghai.
47:40.7
Alam niyo gusto kong pumunta
47:42.1
Hindi pa ako napupunta dyan eh.
47:43.4
Pero yung nga medyo
47:46.9
Alam niyo naman ng China.
47:48.0
Baka bigla tayong gawa
47:48.9
ng masama dyan eh.
47:49.9
Bigla harangin sa airport eh.
47:57.0
watching from Pasay City.
47:58.9
Live siyang nanonood.
48:06.3
Of course si Grace Menil
48:09.8
Coffee Brown Shirt
48:10.9
sabi ni Den Seven.
48:14.4
Hindi ko type yung
48:14.9
Coffee Brown Shirt eh.
48:16.7
Hindi ko type ah.
48:18.5
Baka naman marami sa inyo
48:20.5
Pero ako personally
48:22.2
Hindi nyo ako mapapagsuot
48:30.0
Sino pa ba yung mga
48:30.7
nanonood natin kanina?
48:38.1
Watching from Japan po.
48:40.3
Keep safe and God bless.
48:47.7
Si Chris Marie Zaldivar.
48:57.8
baka magkamali ako ng
48:59.5
pronunciation eh.
49:01.5
Pusong Pinoy pa din.
49:02.6
Even if my passport
49:12.5
mabait na dilawan.
49:20.9
Dilawan pala ako.
49:21.9
Nakapula nga ako ngayon.
49:29.0
Kung dilawan ako,
49:30.2
wawakwakin si Ronald Llamas.
49:33.0
Wakwak na wakwak eh.
49:34.1
Wala tayo itinira
49:34.9
kay Ronald Llamas
49:35.8
kung napapansin nyo.
49:38.3
hanggat natapos yung programa,
49:41.2
sa totoo lang eh.
49:43.6
na nakakatawa yung comment eh.
49:51.8
Watching from Edmonton,
49:54.0
Sobrang lamig siguro
50:02.8
Si Rosela Delgado.
50:04.1
Proud pink lawan.
50:10.2
Nag-sorry ba kagabi?
50:12.1
Yung nag-comment.
50:15.9
Ba't siya nag-sorry?
50:21.6
Dina watching from Lipacity.
50:23.7
Ruel watching from Hong Kong.
50:29.3
may nakasulubong ako
50:32.0
Magnolia last weekend.
50:35.0
Ang pangalan niya
50:35.7
si Sir Henry Azul.
50:39.9
karga ko yung baby ko eh.
50:42.7
uy, nanonood ako ganyan-ganyan.
50:44.5
sige sir, maraming salamat.
50:46.7
Nakalala ko lang yung pangalan niya
50:47.8
si Sir Henry Azul.
50:49.9
mabuting kalagayang kayo.
50:51.7
Maraming maraming salamat
50:55.6
Tapos may estudyante ko kanina.
50:57.1
First day ng klase namin.
50:58.3
Nagpapa-shoutout eh.
51:00.2
ba't naka-white t-shirt ka lang dito?
51:02.6
Sa UST may uniform eh.
51:04.2
Naka-white shirt eh.
51:05.2
Sabi ba naman sa akin,
51:06.1
Sir, pa-shoutout na nga lang.
51:14.9
Maraming salamat sa iyo.
51:24.3
Dominic Marasigan
51:25.4
watching from San Jose, Batangas.
51:28.4
Dansam watching from Bacolod.
51:31.7
watching from Dallas, Texas.
51:33.1
Si Teodoro Angeles
51:34.6
watching from Harare, Zimbabwe.
51:44.4
watching from United Kingdom.
51:52.4
nakakapogi po talaga ang salamin.
52:02.1
maraming salamat sa iyo.
52:07.7
Chichibog muna ako.
52:10.0
maraming salamat sa inyo
52:10.9
for joining us tonight, no?
52:18.2
Si Maria Cristina Penana
52:19.7
watching from Qatar.
52:22.4
Si Yolanda Castillo
52:23.6
watching your replay, no?
52:25.3
I hope may inapulit po kayong
52:26.9
kapakipakinabang dito
52:28.1
sa discussions natin, no?
52:32.5
baka isipin na iba,
52:34.1
hindi natin sineseryosa
52:35.0
yung mga topics natin
52:36.0
kasi minsan may mga episodes tayo
52:38.7
pinagkakatuwaan natin
52:40.2
yung mga topics, no?
52:42.8
pinapatawa lang natin kayo
52:47.2
i-atake natin sa mga issues,
52:48.6
parang hindi naman
52:50.7
kinakausap natin eh.
52:54.0
alam naman natin na mali yung
52:55.6
yung mga political dynasties
53:03.8
Wala na kami reklamo sa inyo.
53:05.8
Ibigay na yung hilig.
53:07.4
mukhang marami sa ating
53:09.3
Gustong-gusto yung nilolokot,
53:10.8
ninanakawan sila, eh, no?
53:11.9
Parang tuwan-tuwa, eh, no?
53:13.2
And finally nga pala,
53:14.3
bago makalimutan, no?
53:15.5
Pag inanalyze siya itong issues
53:16.6
sa people's initiative
53:22.4
yung mga cast of characters,
53:23.8
kung sino yung mga
53:24.6
taong involved, no?
53:26.1
Parang napakamalas talaga
53:27.3
minsan ang mga Pilipino, no?
53:29.2
Parang we're caught between
53:30.9
a rock and a hard place.
53:34.4
Between the devil
53:35.2
and the deep blue sea.
53:38.2
kahit sang palagay,
53:39.3
ang sama ng option mo, eh.
53:41.2
So hinahanap mo nalang
53:42.1
yung lesser evil, eh.
53:50.4
matitinong leader?
53:52.1
ipaprioritize yung
54:00.2
pero yung demokrasya natin,
54:06.9
at yung interest nila.
54:08.7
Demokrasya lang tayo
54:10.5
sa mata ng mga, ano,
54:20.0
doesn't work really for
54:21.2
the ordinary people.
54:23.3
It works for the people
54:24.3
in control of the resources
54:25.7
and the wealth of this country.
54:37.4
Kita-kita po tayo
54:38.7
Magandang gabi po.
