PART 2: TAPOS NA ANG TAMBALANG MARCOS- DUTERTE? PRAYER RALLY INCITING A SEDITION?
* AI ("Artificial Intelligence") subtitles on Tagalog.com are generated using "Whisper" by OpenAI (the same company that created ChatGPT and DallE2). Results and accuracy may vary.
* The subtitles do include errors occasionally and should only be used as a tool to help with your listening practice.
* You can request this website to create a transcript for a video if one doesn't already exist by clicking the "Request AI Subtitles" button below a video. Transcribing usually takes 30-40% of the length of a video to complete if there are no other videos in
the queue. For example, a 21 minute video will take 7-8 minutes to transcribe.
* Running a super fast cloud GPU server to do these transcriptions does cost money. If you have the desire and financial ability, consider
becoming a patron
to support these video transcriptions, and the other tools and apps built by Tagalog.com
00:00.7
Alright, yan. Magandang araw mga kabatas natin at welcome sa isa ng mga livestream.
00:06.1
Napag-usapan na nga natin yung inciting to rebellion, tsaka inciting to sedition or inciting a sedition or inciting a rebellion mga kabatas natin doon sa part 1.
00:17.2
So doon sa mga hindi pa nakapanood at dito nag-start panoorin nyo na lang pero mag-i-insert tayo ng konti-konti dito mga kabatas natin in relation to their definition.
00:27.8
Kasi nga, medyo dikit na dikit yung labanan. Pero hindi ko naman sinasabing nag-commit siya ng any of it.
00:35.3
Okay mga kabatas natin, nandito tayo ngayon sa pagiging adik. Di o mano ni Bongbong Marcos.
00:46.6
At siya ay nasa drugs list. Panoorin natin ulit para ma-refresh yung ating utak mga kabatas natin and let's talk about it further.
00:55.0
Evidence, pinakitaan ako ng, ako'y mayor, pinakitaan ako ng evidence ng PDEA.
01:14.6
Eta, na-discuss na natin ito kanina. Yung pinakita niya mga kabatas natin, wala namang probative value yun na evidence.
01:22.0
Ano ba kasi yung evidence na yun?
01:25.0
Ipagpastahan, nandoon yung pangalan mo.
01:33.2
Yung muna sinasabi niya, itong si President Bongbong Marcos.
01:41.8
Nasa narco list, nasa drugs list. Evidence daw yun.
01:46.2
Alam naman natin lahat mga kabatas natin na prosecutor itong si, dating prosecutor at abogado rin itong si President Rodrigo Duterte.
01:55.0
Dating President Rodrigo Duterte.
01:57.2
Tinawag niya yung evidence. Pero ako din, mga kabatas natin, abogado din, I would not consider that as evidence.
02:05.2
Kasi nga, like I said, it has no weight. It has no probative value.
02:11.3
Kung dinala mo, kung dinala mo yung narco list na yan o drugs list yan, doon sa korte, tapos walang ibang kasama yan.
02:23.2
It's a mere scratch.
02:25.0
It's a scrap of paper.
02:27.2
Okay? Like I said, it doesn't have any probative value.
02:31.7
Ngayon, kung may drugs list nga na yan, at gusto mong bigyan yan ng timbang o weight sa korte,
02:39.0
ang gagawin mo dyan, e magpapakita ka ng evidence in relation to that.
02:46.1
Because, like I said, it's almost useless.
02:55.0
It's almost useless.
02:57.4
And I don't consider that an evidence.
02:59.0
I beg to disagree with ex-president Rodrigo Duterte.
03:06.1
Tapos, pati rin yung, mga kabatas natin, at uulitin ko ulit, yung mga narco list na linalabas niya noon, I didn't like that.
03:17.2
Ayaw kong sabihin yan, kasi magkaibigan tayo.
03:23.6
Kung hindi magkaibigan.
03:27.8
Isipin mo, mga kabatas natin, no?
03:31.1
Meron kang narco list ng isang tao.
03:35.2
Ito nga, napanood ko kay Teacher Mark, no?
03:39.2
Meron kang narco list, tapos you believe in yourself that this person is actually dangerous to the society
03:44.7
because he is involved in drugs.
03:48.2
Tapos you will not do anything about it kasi kaibigan mo or at least kakilala mo.
03:53.7
Tapos ang problema pa,
03:55.0
yung Presidente yan,
03:56.0
tapos ang malaking problema pa,
03:57.9
naging kaalyado yan ng iyong anak sa pagkapangulo.
04:01.7
So in other words,
04:03.2
even if you were saying nay or no in the beginning,
04:08.0
alam naman natin itong si dating Presidente Rodrigo Duterte,
04:12.5
eh, sumuporta pa rin dun sa kanyang anak at sa UNITEAM.
04:24.9
sabi ni Nash Nash,
04:25.9
the former President said na nakita niya ang list when he was Mayor.
04:30.2
He did not mention na andun pa si PBBM nung Presidente na siya.
04:34.9
Ayaw niya sabihin na nandyan siya sa list when he was Mayor.
04:42.5
if it was not relevant,
04:45.6
when he was President,
04:49.2
Kasi nga sabi mo,
04:50.1
Mayor siya noon eh.
04:54.0
Yun naman yung sinabi,
04:55.6
Nakita niya nung Mayor siya.
04:58.4
Tapos naging Presidente siya, di ba?
05:02.3
So, it was not relevant when he was President.
05:06.3
Now that he is not a President,
05:08.0
which is even a future time,
05:10.8
bakit naging relevant yun?
05:16.1
Yun ang malaking tanong dyan eh.
05:18.1
Bakit naging relevant yun?
05:21.7
sinabi niya rin eventually dito kasi.
05:23.9
Napanood ko na kasi ito.
05:24.9
Sinabi niya rin eventually dito kasi,
05:29.2
si Bongbong Marcos.
05:31.6
So, hanggang ngayon,
05:36.7
na parang involved pa rin sa drugs,
05:51.5
use our critical thinking,
05:54.0
use our logical thinking,
05:54.9
use our logical thinking,
06:00.5
pati common sense,
06:01.4
naku, naputol na naman tayo.
06:05.8
lahat na lang ng mga senses gamitin natin,
06:07.9
mga kabatas natin,
06:09.7
isa lang ang magiging konklusyon mo.
06:13.0
Ang magiging konklusyon mo lang,
06:15.5
ang magiging konklusyon mo lang,
06:18.7
gustong sabihin ni Rodrigo Duterte dito,
06:21.5
na walang nagbago.
06:54.2
mga kabatas natin,
06:57.8
ni Rodrigo Duterte.
07:08.4
Ano ba yung dinaanan
07:10.5
ni Bongbong Marcos?
07:12.7
Na overthrow siya
07:13.9
bilang isang presidente
07:21.6
mga kabatas natin,
07:28.6
Well, siguro sasabihin
07:31.4
wala namang rebellion
07:32.5
na nangyari doon eh.
07:36.9
publicly nag-rise
07:38.2
tapos wala namang weapons.
07:39.8
Mga kabatas natin,
07:46.5
Even the Malacanang
07:51.8
may mga taong weapons.
07:55.2
it was very peaceful.
07:57.4
It was very peaceful daw.
07:59.4
prayers and rosaries lang.
08:02.0
Some people still,
08:03.8
mga kabatas natin,
08:07.6
kumuha sila ng mga
08:12.9
Kumuha sila ng weapons nila.
08:17.1
kapag may weapons na,
08:24.3
Ganyan naman nangyayari.
08:29.2
pwede rin sedition.
08:31.2
Pag nangyari yung
08:42.3
Ferdinand E. Marcos.
08:45.8
makikita nyo na ba dito na
08:47.4
pwede nang pumasok sa
08:49.3
inciting to rebellion
08:50.6
or inciting to sedition?
09:01.2
Ito kasing rebellion,
09:09.2
Depriving the chief executive
09:11.0
or the legislature
09:12.2
wholly or partially
09:13.5
any of their powers
09:16.5
So, if you will overthrow,
09:18.3
if you will overthrow
09:22.6
or a chief executive,
09:24.1
you will overthrow
09:33.0
If you ask people
09:38.2
that's inciting to rebellion.
09:43.0
Pero tulad nga ng sinasabi ko,
09:45.1
academic purposes ito.
09:54.3
Ito ang isang isang libro nga.
09:55.0
Ito ang isang isang isang libro.
09:55.2
Ito ang isang isang isang libro.
09:55.5
Ito ang isang isang isang isang libro.
09:55.6
Ito ang isang isang isang isang isang libro.
09:56.8
Tapos tuwang-tuwa yung mga tao.
09:58.5
Alam niyo mga kabatas natin,
10:00.0
yung sa akin lang,
10:06.1
Sinasabi nyo mga tao kasi
10:07.6
na hindi violent yung nangyari
10:09.0
kay Ferdinand E. Marcos noon.
10:10.8
It was very violent,
10:13.4
That is the reason also
10:16.0
Ferdinand E. Marcos
10:20.5
Because it was very violent.
10:22.7
It was very violent.
10:24.3
naglalaban-laban na talaga
10:26.8
yung mga Pilipino noon.
10:32.3
of how they ransacked
10:34.9
it was very violent also.
10:47.1
ayaw ko bangyari sa iyo yan.
11:02.0
itong panahon na ito.
11:12.0
So, if there will be blood,
11:19.6
Hindi ko maintindihan
11:20.9
why people are happy
11:28.5
Magkakaroon ng ganito.
11:31.5
na hindi Avengers,
11:33.7
na hindi pili-pili-pili.
11:35.2
Technically, this will be a civil war.
11:38.7
Pilipino sa Pilipino maglalaban.
11:44.1
Mga military na merong pinapanigan
11:47.4
lalabanan ng isa't isa.
11:52.0
Parang, that's not something
11:57.4
That's something you fear.
12:00.8
Isang bagay yan na kinakatakutan mo.
12:04.0
Kasi kung nangyari yan,
12:05.1
mga kabatas natin,
12:06.4
mas masahol pa yan sa pandemic.
12:11.4
Our country will not be stable.
12:14.8
Our economy will drop.
12:18.3
Investors will pull out.
12:24.6
which is our number one
12:32.7
provinces dito sa Pilipinas.
12:34.6
Even urban cities.
12:41.0
Walang pupuntang tao.
12:48.7
We will be war-torn.
12:50.0
If we are war-torn,
12:51.4
it's difficult to recover from that.
12:55.3
Ang problema pa dito,
12:59.8
after we fought with each other,
13:02.6
it will take a very long time
13:05.0
for us to stabilize.
13:06.8
Ang problema pa dyan,
13:09.1
maayos ba o matinu ba yung tao
13:11.1
na mag-i-stabilize sa gobyerno natin?
13:14.8
So it will be full of uncertainties.
13:17.8
Hindi mo masasabi
13:18.9
na kapag nagkaroon
13:22.8
na pag-overthrow sa government
13:25.4
katulad nung nangyari nung 1986,
13:31.5
na mas maganda yung kalalabasan
13:39.9
You will not be sure.
13:42.6
So if you are really
13:43.5
thinking about the future,
13:45.5
you will not be cheering for this.
13:49.7
Kahit sino ang mananatang
13:52.1
kahit sino ang matatalo dito,
13:55.1
it is us the people who will lose.
13:58.8
Tayo ang matatalo.
14:08.3
sa tao kung ano ka.
14:12.6
Ito mga kabaros natin,
14:17.3
back to scratch na naman,
14:18.8
ang dami nagsasuffer.
14:19.8
Bakit ganyan mga politiko natin?
14:22.6
this is struggle of power.
14:26.2
Naglalaban-laban sila
14:27.5
dahil sa kapangyarihan eh.
14:30.5
That's the point here.
14:33.5
Yun ang malaking problema dito.
14:38.9
huwag nang ganyan.
14:41.1
You should think about the people.
14:43.9
What is good for the people?
14:47.7
that this is not good for the people,
14:49.4
let alone for our country.
14:51.4
Anything with violence,
14:55.0
anything that is bloody,
15:01.3
And we will suffer because of that.
15:04.9
Then why are these people cheering?
15:21.4
Nagkita-kita doon sa Luzon, there was a community of Filipinos.
15:27.6
Galing Visayas, galing Ilunggo, galing Waray, galing Mindanao, galing Hulo, galing Lanaw, Sibu, Samar, at taas Pampanga, Apare.
15:46.6
Nagkita-kita yung mga minuno natin.
15:51.4
Kasi hinawakan tayo ng Espanyol, pati Amerikano.
15:57.2
Nung dumating ang panahon na tayo'y nagkaharap na, sabi ng mga lolo natin, ano ang gawain natin sa bayan natin?
16:11.6
Ito, irrelevant nga ito eh. Itong mga sinasabi niya na ito eh.
16:18.1
So, what's the point?
16:21.4
well, that happened sometime in, in, ano, in the past.
16:25.9
So, what's the point?
16:27.2
Pwede ba tayong magbaranggay-baranggay lang o magkaisa tayo?
16:33.0
Di na bale, iba-iba ang salita natin.
16:37.8
It was agreed by the Filipinos then of all walks of life,
16:46.4
ma-Ilocano, ma-Sibuano, mga taga-Mindanao,
16:51.0
they agreed to form a constitution.
17:00.1
Alam mo, ngayon, ngayon, mga kabatas natin, yung siguro itong sinasabi niya na they agreed to form a constitution,
17:07.2
ito yung pinakaunang-unang constitution natin.
17:09.8
Hindi ito yung constitution kung saan ang bumuo ay yung administration ni Cory Aquino.
17:23.6
Experts na yung mga nandudun eh.
17:30.3
yung constitution,
17:43.8
magawa tayo ng magandang
17:46.3
Sabi ni Valentina, sabi niya,
17:49.9
right, it's already written.
17:52.4
So, diba, it's not relevant anymore.
17:57.3
Hindi na relevant yung sinasabi mo nung unang panahon pa na ganyan yung ginawa nung mga tao noon.
18:04.4
Kasi nga, eh, nagkaroon na tayo ng, ano eh,
18:08.5
several revisions sa constitution natin.
18:11.5
Ang latest nga yung nangyari doon sa kay Pangulong, dating Pangulong Cory Aquino.
18:17.6
So, that does not stand anymore.
18:20.5
Because there were revisions.
18:25.9
We see na where we can meet and talk about the destiny of this country.
18:35.0
Doon, they agreed na yung mga laking bahay, may post eh, mga mga laking post eh, at may mga muebles at kwarto, living rooms and all.
18:52.3
Fast forward na lang sa guro natin ito.
18:54.3
Ang usapan na time to time,
18:59.7
lumalaki na ang bayan
19:01.3
at magdagdag tayo ng mga opisina
19:08.7
Cheers and everything.
19:13.5
Wala tayong pinag-usapan
19:16.4
na sirain yung bahay na yun.
19:22.5
alam nyo, hindi, hindi man lang,
19:32.1
any logical explanation
19:34.7
kung bakit, ano, mga kapatid natin,
19:37.8
ini-equate niya yung pag-ambienda sa constitution
19:41.1
sa isang pagsira ng bahay.
19:46.7
na-revise yan eh.
19:48.1
Na-revise na yan eh.
19:50.5
Meron tayong 1935.
19:53.3
Na-revise na yan eh.
19:55.5
So, ibig sabihin,
19:56.7
sinira, sinira na yung bahay noon pa.
19:59.4
Kung susundin natin yung, yung logic niya, ha?
20:03.1
Kung susundin natin yung logic niya,
20:05.9
sinira na yung bahay
20:07.2
nung 1987 constitution.
20:16.7
at inabot sa atin
20:19.0
yung constitution.
20:20.5
Kaya nga, pero, pero, ito, ito, ito rin yung, yung ano ko dyan.
20:36.1
Hindi naman nila sisirahan, sisirain,
20:38.6
a-ambyandahin pa rin.
20:43.2
A-ambyandahan, a-ambyandahan pa rin yung gagawin eh.
20:46.9
What makes it different?
20:52.4
the other amendments
20:54.2
ay hindi pagsira ng bahay
20:56.2
tapos itong pag-ambyanda ngayon ng constitution
21:00.5
pagsira ng bahay?
21:06.0
I don't understand it.
21:14.7
Knox, nung siya presidente,
21:16.4
gusto nga nila mag-federal government.
21:18.4
Ang mahirap sa kanya,
21:20.5
hindi niya nakuha yung majority of Congress,
21:24.4
Bitter siya ang pala.
21:25.7
Well, alam ko rin naman,
21:27.1
gusto niya mag-federal noon, no?
21:31.6
Bisaya, waray, moro.
21:34.2
Bakit tayo na kaisa?
21:37.1
Magkaiba ang salita natin.
21:39.4
Ang pagkain, iba?
21:44.6
Bakit tayo andito ngayon?
21:47.5
Dahil sa isang bahay.
21:53.3
So, yung sinasabi niyang bahay na yun,
21:55.4
yung constitution.
21:56.5
Yun yung dahilan kung bakit nandito tayo ngayon.
22:02.0
Sa tingin ko, hindi naman yun.
22:04.4
Maraming ang tawag hindi alam yung constitution.
22:08.0
Maraming tao din ang hindi alam
22:09.7
na nag-i-exist yung constitution.
22:12.8
Maraming rin tao na hindi nila, ano,
22:15.2
tignan yung itsura ko dyan, nag-freeze na.
22:17.5
Hayaan ko nalang na ganyan, basta naririnig nyo ako.
22:22.5
Maraming tao, alam nyo, parang...
22:35.0
Na yung constitution ng dahilan kung bakit nandito tayo.
22:37.8
I don't think so.
22:40.1
Nandito tayo kasi pinanganak tayo dito sa Pilipinas
22:42.5
and we have to survive.
22:47.5
Dami ni Rekul, dami nga naniniwala sa Rafi Tulfoy in action.
22:55.3
Ewan ko, tatay, digs, baka it's past your bedtime.
22:59.2
Kapel, the constitution.
23:02.8
No, I don't think so.
23:05.6
I don't think so.
23:06.9
I don't think that it's the constitution that binds us.
23:13.0
ang constitution is supposed...
23:17.5
supposed to be a permanent thing.
23:24.4
Well, permanent as to its existence.
23:29.5
Pero tandaan natin, alam din ni tatay, digs ito, alam ko.
23:37.6
Loss, of course, although many are deemed to be permanent.
23:43.3
Yung constitution, mga kabatas natin,
23:46.0
it is the mother of all.
23:47.5
It's the fundamental law of the land.
23:51.5
Ibig sabihin, ang constitution, batas pa rin.
23:55.1
Tapos, tulad ng characteristics ng lahat ng batas,
24:01.4
ang batas ay dapat umaayon, umaangkop,
24:08.7
umaayon o umaangkop sa mga pangyayari.
24:15.6
Kaya nga, you can imagine,
24:17.5
you can amend or repeal laws.
24:21.2
It is the same also with the constitution.
24:24.8
You can amend the constitution.
24:29.3
Although, of course, it is permanent because it should always exist.
24:36.6
But, of course, it is not permanent dahil hindi dapat ito palitan.
24:46.1
Yun lang, mga kabatas natin.
24:47.5
Kasi, I disagree na naman dyan eh.
24:50.8
Ang batas na binigay ng constitution sa congress, lawmakers,
24:57.9
they can make laws everyday.
25:01.6
Eto, sabi niya, but it needs to be tweaked and adjusted to the changing times.
25:08.7
And, of course, because the law, the constitution is the fundamental law of the land,
25:14.4
lahat dapat na mga batas ay sumangayon sa constitution.
25:17.5
Ngayon, kapag merong mga batas na hindi sangayon sa constitution,
25:23.0
ang tawag doon ay unconstitutional law at nade-declare siyang null-invoid.
25:29.5
Kaya, kailangan i-revise din ang constitution.
25:32.4
Like, for example, yung economic provisions.
25:34.6
Yung ownership of businesses.
25:39.5
Hindi pwedeng magmay-ari ang dayuhan ng business dito.
25:42.8
E, maraming lugar, mga kabatas natin,
25:46.7
na asensado, they can own 100% of the business.
25:51.3
Ang problema kasi, it discourages competition.
25:54.7
It encourages monopolies.
25:57.3
Kung sino lang yung mga mayayaman dito sa Pilipinas, sila lang ang yumayaman
26:00.8
kasi nga nakakapagdikta sila ng gusto nilang presyo.
26:06.2
Kasi isipin mo na lang ito, ha?
26:09.4
Yung mga, yung mga, ito na lang ano, ito na lang telecom companies natin.
26:16.7
At saka itong mga, mga, move it natin.
26:22.3
Move it by angkas.
26:23.9
Angkas ba yung may-ari doon o grab?
26:25.5
Basta, bibilhin na lang nila yung mga up-and-coming na mga negosyo.
26:34.5
Pagtitignan mo, iisa na lang pala o kaya dadalawa ang may-ari.
26:39.5
And you cannot compete against them because the money in the Philippines is concentrated sa iilang tao.
26:46.7
So itong mga tao na mayayaman, sila na lang yung magkoconcentrate,
26:51.5
sorry, sila na lang ang magdedictate ng mga presyo ng mga bagay-bagay
26:55.2
na kailangan tayo naman bilang Pilipino because these are necessities.
27:00.4
Like for example, internet, kuryente.
27:02.9
We don't have a choice.
27:07.6
So ganun na mangyayari.
27:11.3
We have to amend the constitution for us to be able to, to, to,
27:16.7
to open our economy to foreigners.
27:22.6
And that will encourage competition.
27:25.5
And if there is healthy competition, there will be better services to the people.
27:30.6
There will be cheaper services to the people.
27:37.6
If I change it, if they want, every week, okay lang yan.
27:43.7
Huwag ninyong pakialaman ang constitution.
27:46.7
Kasi yun ang bahay opisyal.
27:55.2
Because the constitution of the Philippines is still a law.
27:59.7
Kailangan pa rin ayusin natin yung constitution ng Pilipinas.
28:07.4
I do not agree there.
28:09.7
Na huwag pakialaman yung constitution.
28:11.2
Ang bahay opisyal ng Pilipino.
28:16.7
Hindi naman naaalisin yung constitution eh.
28:19.3
May nagkakaroon dyan ng maling declaration dito.
28:21.8
Ang bahay opisyal ng constitution.
28:23.8
Kasi yun ang bahay opisyal.
28:25.7
You want every week.
28:30.0
Huwag ninyong pakialaman ang...
28:32.5
Ah, hindi. Hindi naman alisin.
28:34.0
Pakialaman daw. Huwag pakialaman.
28:36.4
Huwag pa rin. Kailangan pa rin pakialaman yan.
28:39.8
Kasi yun ang bahay opisyal ng Pilipino.
28:45.2
Pero ito, pati bahay mo.
28:46.6
Mga rinirenovate mo rin eh.
28:49.3
Kung ine-equate mo yung constitution sa bahay ng Pilipino,
28:53.8
paano pag yung bahay mo dilapidated na?
28:57.9
Huwag mo pa rin pakikialaman kasi bahay mo yun.
29:01.3
It also doesn't follow suit.
29:04.6
Hindi rin logical even if you compare it to a house.
29:11.1
Bakit pumasok sa utak ninyo yung...
29:15.5
People's Initiative?
29:16.6
Well, pumasok din sa utak mo yun.
29:28.9
Anong nakain ninyo?
29:31.4
Okay, okay. Diyan tayo again.
29:33.1
Ito ang mga kabatas natin.
29:35.2
Lipat tayo sa kabila.
29:36.6
Kasi syempre, maraming nagre-request talaga na huwag masyadong mahaba.
29:41.0
30 minutes, 30 minutes tayo. Part-part hanggang matapos.
29:43.8
Ito ang mga kabatas natin.
29:44.7
We will talk about this.
29:46.1
Lipat tayo sa kabila, mga kabatas natin.
29:48.8
Sana umayos na itong aking kamera.
29:50.9
Pero pag hindi, we will continue.
29:52.8
Maraming salamat po.
29:53.7
At syempre, tulad na lagi ang sinasabi.
29:55.0
Matulog po tayo ng mahimbing.
29:56.4
Dahil alam natin na yung natutulog ng mahimbing,
29:58.9
sya yung lagi panalo.
