Close
 


SINO BA TALAGA ANG MAY PAKANA NG PEOPLE'S INITIATIVE- CONG. ROMUALDEZ?
Hide Subtitles
Click any subtitle word to view Tagalog.com dictionary results.
Computer Shortcuts: Left / Right arrows to jump 2 seconds back or forward. +Enter or Space to toggle Play/Pause button. Full Screen Mode
SINO BA TALAGA ANG MAY PAKANA NG PEOPLE'S INITIATIVE- CONG. ROMUALDEZ? Eto po bagong FB natin para sa videos: https://www.facebook.com/BATASnatin-107860591437195 https://www.facebook.com/Atty-Ranny-Randolf-B-Libayan-154012243457531 Alternate YT channel po for livestreams: https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCskZGSV52krMvXgb8OXXx1g WEBSITE: https://batasnatin.com/ LAW FIRM: https://firm.batasnatin.com/ FACEBOOK PAGE: https://www.facebook.com/BATASnatin/ INSTAGRAM: https://www.instagram.com/batasnatin/ YOUTUBE CHANNEL: https://youtube.com/BATASnatinLive TWITTER: https://twitter.com/BATASnatin LAWYERS: Atty. Kristina Louise Magalong Atty. Ranny Randolf B. Libayan FIRM ADDRESS: #31 Gen. Luna St., Tuktukan, Taguig City, NCR (Across Taguig City Hall) Email: BATASnatin@gmail.com Telephone nos: +63915-954-6080 (+632)359-4203 We are a full-service Law Firm We handle and are experienced in litigating many kinds of cases. Please do not hesitate to contact us. We w
BATASnatin
  Mute  
Run time: 31:37
Has AI Subtitles



Video Transcript / Subtitles:( AI generated. About AI subtitles » )
00:00.0
This is Evie Huck.
00:30.0
Okay, pag-aralan natin. Mag-start muna tayo dito sa witness na ito. Okay, let's go.
00:39.0
Pumirma lahat po dun sa barangay namin.
00:42.4
Ah, okay. Pumirma naman kayo?
00:45.0
Ako po, hindi po ako pumirma, pati po yung kapitan.
00:48.2
Bakit?
00:49.9
Ayoko po.
00:51.2
Bakit ayaw ninyo? Hindi ninyo maintindihan dahil English?
00:57.7
Ano po, naintindihan ko po.
00:59.5
Pero yung ibig sabihin ko, kaya ayoko pong pumirma.
01:03.7
Ah, okay.
01:05.2
Very good to. Naintindihan niya yung ibig sabihin.
01:08.6
Kaya ayaw niya pumirma. Hindi dahil English. Okay, let's go.
01:12.7
So ayaw ninyo na paltan yung saligang batas, yung voting jointly, at iba pa?
01:20.3
Opo.
01:21.6
May sinasabing perang ibibigay ba?
01:26.4
May narinig po ako.
01:28.1
Ganon.
01:29.5
Here's say. May narinig lang siya.
01:32.6
Buti dito, yung nagpapapirma sa kanya, pirma lang.
01:36.3
Hindi siya inalok ng pera.
01:38.2
Oh, this is a good development.
01:40.3
At may nabigyan ba ng pera dun sa mga pumirmang hindi katulad nyo?
01:44.8
Wala po.
01:45.7
Tumanggap ba yung mga BHW ninyo?
01:48.0
Wala rin po.
01:49.1
Wala naman.
01:50.5
Isipin mo yan, no? Nakapirma sila.
01:53.5
Nakakuha sila ng 8 million na pirma, wala silang pinaluhal na ayuda.
01:59.5
Eh, lahat ng mga witnesses nila sinasabi, wala pang binigay na pera eh.
02:05.4
Di ba?
02:06.8
Pero yung kapitan ninyo, pinangakuan ba sila?
02:11.3
Hindi po.
02:12.5
Hindi rin.
02:13.9
Ma'am, this is not a good witness for you.
02:17.3
Senator Aimee Marcos.
02:20.9
Dapat nga, ang tawag dito ayuda scam eh, no?
02:25.0
Libre, the alpha. Libre, libre.
02:27.1
Libre.
02:28.4
Libre.
02:29.5
Then, tapos, ano pa yung masasabi mo tungkol dito?
02:38.6
Palibasa siguro, yung kapitan hindi kaalyado ninyong...
02:41.8
Nauubusan ng ano eh, ng tanong si Manang Aimee.
02:45.7
...at kongresista. Tama po ba yun?
02:48.8
Opo.
02:50.7
Sabi ni Mang Renesa, kailan pwede po ba ilapit sa Rafi Tulfo in action na scam sila ng ayuda?
02:59.5
Sino bang tutulungan doon?
03:03.6
Kailangan mo munang alawin, Mang Rene, kung sino ang tutulungan.
03:07.2
Okay?
03:08.1
Sino bang tutulungan?
03:11.0
E, naintindihan ba nung mga kasamahan ninyo o kabaranggay ninyo yung pinipirmahan nila?
03:17.3
Hindi.
03:20.7
Objection, Your Honor. The witness is not competent to answer that question.
03:26.7
...nung mga kasamahan ninyo o kabaranggay ninyo...
03:29.3
...nung mga kasamahan ninyo o kabaranggay ninyo...
03:29.5
Because that can be answered only by ang kasamahan.
03:33.1
...yung pinipirmahan nila.
03:35.6
Hindi po. Ang alam po nila ay ayuda.
03:38.3
Alam nila ayuda? Kasi yun ang pangako, no?
03:40.7
Opo.
03:41.2
Sino nag...
03:42.6
Ba't di mo pinaliwanag ikaw na intindihan mo yun?
03:47.4
Yung mga kasama mo?
03:48.8
Sabi na ayuda yun. Yung BHW, utos ng...
03:52.6
Wala eh. Parang itong witness na ito.
03:55.6
So yun parang...
03:56.6
Parang yung witness na ito, mga kapatas natin, parang...
04:03.3
O, sandali, sandali. Kailangan natin...
04:05.3
Kasi nandito yan, kailangan natin makakuha ng mga matitindi na ebidensya.
04:11.7
Pero so far, wala.
04:13.7
Walang pera, wala ayuda. Hindi ako pumirma.
04:17.6
Ewan ko.
04:19.9
Objection.
04:21.2
The witness can't breathe.
04:23.0
Pwede rin kaya, objection, Your Honor, the aircon is too low.
04:26.6
Hindi, too.
04:29.5
Can we lower down the aircon, Your Honor?
04:32.7
The temperature of the aircon.
04:34.6
Di hol, ganun po ba?
04:37.2
Yung...
04:37.8
Kasi balut na balut sila, baka mainitan.
04:40.1
Perception lang po siguro nung mga nando. Kasi parang nagtetrending na po kasi siya.
04:45.4
Tama. Trending na na may ayudang kalakip yun.
04:48.8
Oo.
04:49.9
Tapos, linilista ba yung mga pangalan nila?
04:54.3
Sa... Alam ko po, wala... Hindi ko po alam.
04:56.6
Kung nililista po.
04:58.6
Hindi ka naman...
04:59.6
Hindi ka naman pumirma. Ba't ikaw ang nansalita dyan?
05:13.4
Hindi rin siya nabayaran. Hindi rin siya nabigyan ng pera.
05:19.6
Parang, saan siya pinulot to?
05:23.8
Bakit ganyan?
05:26.6
Sabi ni Kayo, hindi niya alam pero isa siya sa nagpapirma daw.
05:35.4
Oo. Nagpapirma siya pero ayaw niyang pumirma.
05:37.8
Oh, very good.
05:39.2
Saan niya kinuha to?
05:42.8
Walang alam.
05:44.9
Sa alam ko po, wala... Hindi ko po alam kung nililista po.
05:49.2
Pero marami bang pumirma dun sa barangay ninyo?
05:53.2
Kunti lang po kasi nung sinabi...
05:54.6
Kunti lang po kasi nung sinabi...
05:56.6
Ang tamang sagot, opo, madami ang pumirma. Liding na nga yun eh.
06:06.8
Kunti lang po.
06:08.3
Ang tamang sagot, marami bang pumirma?
06:11.1
Marami po.
06:17.8
Liding na nga yun eh.
06:22.4
Para bang tinanong ka?
06:25.4
Parang...
06:26.6
Tinanong ka ng partner mo, ng girlfriend mo, boyfriend mo.
06:30.9
Masaya ka ba sa akin?
06:32.3
Ang tagot-sagot dun, masaya ako!
06:38.7
Kasi leading na yun eh.
06:40.6
Yun yung gusto niya marinig.
06:43.6
Ewan ko.
06:44.8
Admit po yun dahil may deadline daw po.
06:47.6
Binalik po kasi yung forms kasi kulang daw po yung mga pirma.
06:52.5
Ano yung deadline?
06:54.6
Kulang.
06:55.4
Line?
06:56.6
Sinasabi daw, ang presidente daw ang nirarason. Tama ba yun?
07:01.3
Ayan, presidente. Mga kabatas natin. Paktay tayo dyan.
07:04.6
Ayan po ang sabi.
07:06.0
Ano daw ang kinasabi?
07:07.1
Ayun, tama yung sagot niya.
07:09.6
Kasi leading question yun eh.
07:11.2
Sabi daw yung presidente ang nirarason. Tama ba?
07:14.4
Tama po!
07:16.5
Nalaman ng presidente dyan.
07:18.8
Isipin mo, yung mga ano, lahat naman kasi sila dito.
07:22.2
Pero magkakalout mamaya si Aimee dito na nagtatanong ng leading question si Marco.
07:26.6
Pero lahat naman sila leading questions eh.
07:29.0
Ang sabi po is utos daw po yun ng presidente.
07:34.4
Ano daw?
07:35.4
Utos daw po yun ng ni BBM.
07:38.0
Utos ni BBM?
07:38.3
Yun po yung exact word.
07:40.1
Ay, ganun.
07:41.7
At sumusunod lang sila.
07:44.0
Opo.
07:44.7
Eh kung utos ng Pangulo, ba't hindi ninyo sinunod?
07:55.4
Oo nga naman.
07:56.6
Kayo.
07:59.6
Kung utos ng Pangulo yun, bakit hindi ninyo sinunod?
08:02.6
Ikaw rin.
08:04.6
Utos ng Pangulo, inaaway mo daw yung kapatid mo.
08:07.6
Ewan ko sa'yo.
08:12.6
Meron po akong freedom of choice.
08:15.6
Ayan! Yan ang gusto nating sagutan dyan.
08:18.6
Meron akong freedom of choice.
08:23.6
Recording in progress.
08:25.6
Sige.
08:26.6
At yung mga kaalyado lang ni Mayor ang binigyan ng pera, tama ba yun?
08:31.6
Hindi ko po alam.
08:40.6
Tama ba yun? Hindi ko alam.
08:43.6
Bahala kayo sa buhay niyo.
08:45.6
Hindi ko sasagutin yung mga leading questions niyo.
08:49.6
Sasabihin ko yung totoo.
08:51.6
Ang totoo, wala akong alam.
08:56.6
Hahahaha.
08:59.6
Sige, sabi niya ko nga.
09:03.6
Hahahaha.
09:05.6
Palitan niya niyang walang alam.
09:08.6
Hahahaha.
09:10.6
Wala talagang makuha mong sagot.
09:12.6
Wala. Hindi ko alam.
09:14.6
Salamat sa info.
09:17.6
Hahahaha.
09:20.6
Sige, sabi niya niya.
09:22.6
Sige.
09:24.6
Mukhang kulang binigay ng Senate na ayudo sa witness.
09:27.7
Mukhang naging hostile.
09:29.5
Parang, parang pag sa korte, ito mga patos natin, no?
09:32.4
Pag ganyan yung puro-puro sagot ng witness,
09:35.9
sasabihin yung judge.
09:37.7
Sa abogado, sasabihin niya.
09:42.0
Attorney, saan ka ba kumukuha ng mga witnesses mo?
09:45.9
Sinasayang mo ba yung oras ng korte
09:47.8
para nakikinig tayo doon sa mga witnesses mo
09:51.0
na wala namang alam doon sa nangyari?
09:55.2
Alam nyo kasi, mga kabatsa natin,
09:56.5
pati mga judge, stricto yan.
09:58.5
Pati pag uulit ka ng witness,
10:00.6
ibig sabihin uulitin mo yung testigo,
10:04.0
collaborating witness lang yun,
10:06.0
ayaw nila yun.
10:07.4
Pareho ba yung testigo nyo?
10:09.4
Sayang lang yung oras dyan.
10:12.4
Ganon.
10:13.0
E paano pa kaya yung walang alam?
10:15.2
Pagagalitan ka nung judge doon.
10:17.7
Sure ka, gusto mo i-present yung witness mo?
10:20.0
Gaganon sa'yo yun.
10:20.9
Gusto mo sayangin yung oras ng korte
10:23.6
na parang kayo lang yung kaso dito?
10:27.6
Ganon.
10:28.9
Ah, kasi meron nagbanggitan ka tulad noon.
10:31.9
May dadagdag ka pa?
10:34.0
Ah, ganito yun.
10:35.6
Yung mga kaalyado lang ni Mayor
10:37.6
ang binigyan ng pera, tama ba yun?
10:39.7
Hindi ko po alam.
10:41.5
Ah, kasi meron nagbanggitan ka tulad noon.
10:44.6
Very good answer.
10:46.5
May dadagdag ka pa?
10:48.1
Wala na po.
10:49.4
Bakit ka takot?
10:50.4
Bakit ka nagtatakit ng muka
10:52.2
katulad ng sinabi ni Kong?
10:53.6
Resmond Marcoleta.
10:54.6
Babalikan ka ba?
10:56.8
Yung leading din yun eh.
10:59.4
Gusto ko nga ako sana balikan ako
11:01.1
para bigyan ng ayuda.
11:02.6
Kaso hindi na bumalik.
11:04.2
Pwede po.
11:05.5
Nino?
11:06.8
Pwede.
11:07.4
O pwede lang.
11:08.8
Hindi o po.
11:09.7
Pwede.
11:11.5
Pwede.
11:12.4
Ah, Nino?
11:12.8
Hindi po.
11:13.3
Hindi ko po masabi dito
11:14.8
kasi matitrace po nila ako eh.
11:16.6
Pag sinabi ko po yung dahilan.
11:18.3
Ganon.
11:18.9
Pero opisyal?
11:21.0
Opo.
11:22.1
Mga opisyal,
11:22.9
babalikan ka
11:23.8
diyan sa lugar ninyo.
11:25.5
Opo.
11:26.2
Sige.
11:26.8
May maidadagdag ka pa
11:28.2
o yung mga kasamahan ko
11:29.3
may katanungan po kayo.
11:32.0
Yes, Senator Bato, please.
11:33.7
Madam Chair,
11:34.4
this is not a question
11:37.2
to our resource person.
11:38.9
Just like...
11:39.9
Pwede naman.
11:41.7
Akala ko
11:42.4
question sa resource person yan.
11:44.8
Eh, wala nga siyang alam.
11:46.9
...to inquire if
11:48.0
it was ruled by
11:49.2
the Chair
11:50.3
that
11:51.2
Anthony Abad
11:52.3
will be issued
11:52.9
sa PINA
11:53.9
for the next hearing?
11:54.9
Yes, I...
11:55.9
Oo, oo, oo.
11:56.9
Napag-usapan na yan.
11:57.9
Congresman
11:58.9
Marculita,
12:01.9
kung sinabi po niya
12:02.9
Madam Chair
12:03.9
na siya ay nasasaktan
12:05.9
dahil
12:06.9
parabang
12:07.9
alluded to
12:08.9
yung buong
12:09.9
lower house
12:10.9
na sila ang nasa likuran
12:12.9
nitong
12:13.9
nitong
12:14.9
people's initiative.
12:17.9
Ako rin ay nasasaktan.
12:19.9
When he alluded
12:20.9
no, when he alluded
12:21.9
the...
12:22.9
the Senate
12:23.9
as the
12:24.9
ah...
12:25.9
opposition palagi.
12:26.9
Dahilan kung bakit
12:27.9
hindi natatuloy
12:28.9
yung ah...
12:29.9
yung ah...
12:30.9
economic cha-cha.
12:32.9
Eh, kaya nga sabi ko
12:33.9
kailangan niyong ipaliwanag,
12:34.9
ipaliwanag mo.
12:35.9
Okay.
12:36.9
O, ito, ito.
12:37.9
Kasi hindi pinaliwanag
12:38.9
ni Coco Martina.
12:39.9
Ay, hindi.
12:40.9
Coco Pimentel pala.
12:41.9
Hindi niya pinaliwanag.
12:43.9
Diba?
12:44.9
Ba't ang samantingin
12:45.9
ng babae sa akin dito?
12:46.9
Sandali lang,
12:47.9
sandali lang.
12:48.9
Relax, relax.
12:49.9
Okay? Relax.
12:50.9
Gusto ko lang
12:52.9
makakuha ng explanation
12:54.9
kung bakit
12:55.9
ayaw niyong makipag-meet,
12:56.9
ayaw niyong makipag-eyeball.
12:58.9
Pangit ba kayo?
13:00.9
Hindi, hindi. Joke.
13:01.9
Joke! Joke!
13:02.9
Kasi ganun yun,
13:03.9
mga kabatas natin.
13:04.9
Nung unang panahon,
13:05.9
yung mga radyo-radyo,
13:06.9
mga text-text, diba?
13:07.9
Text-mate.
13:08.9
Wala pang video call nun, eh.
13:09.9
Tapos,
13:10.9
syempre, meron ka ng
13:11.9
nakakapanatagan ng loob.
13:14.9
Tapos,
13:15.9
sa tingin mo,
13:16.9
mahal mo na siya.
13:18.9
Ngayon,
13:19.9
sabihin mo,
13:20.9
meet up tayo,
13:21.9
kita tayo,
13:22.9
eyeball tayo.
13:23.9
Ang daming dahilan.
13:27.9
Ang daming dahilan.
13:29.9
Malamang,
13:31.9
pangit
13:32.9
sa sabihin nila, diba?
13:34.9
O,
13:35.9
bakit ayaw niyo?
13:36.9
Magbigay ka ng dahilan.
13:37.9
Buti nga yung mga tao
13:38.9
na ayaw makipagkita,
13:40.9
makipag-eyeball,
13:41.9
nagbibigay ng dahilan.
13:42.9
Kayo,
13:43.9
hindi daw kayo nagbabigay ng dahilan.
13:45.9
Basta,
13:46.9
ayaw niyo lang.
13:48.9
At ang sinabi niya,
13:49.9
it's a political issue.
13:52.9
O, let's go.
13:53.9
Give us
13:54.9
a reason.
13:55.9
Ako po,
13:56.9
gusto ko iparating,
13:57.9
mga Madam Chair,
13:58.9
na,
13:59.9
in fact,
14:00.9
during the last Congress,
14:01.9
kaming dalawa na si
14:02.9
Rector Tolentino,
14:03.9
nag-file kami ng
14:04.9
resolution for
14:05.9
economic satsa.
14:07.9
And,
14:09.9
nagbabago po
14:10.9
yung composition ng
14:11.9
Senado,
14:12.9
at pariho na rin sa
14:14.9
lower house,
14:15.9
nagbabago rin yung
14:16.9
composition.
14:17.9
So, hindi po rin masabi na,
14:18.9
kung nag-upos sila ngayon,
14:20.9
mag-upos na yan forever.
14:22.9
E, nagbabago po.
14:23.9
Kami po ni Sen. Tolentino,
14:24.9
nag-file rin po ng
14:25.9
resolution.
14:26.9
Kaya masakit po sa
14:27.9
amin, kung sabihin niya,
14:28.9
nilalahat niya,
14:29.9
na ang buong Senado
14:30.9
ay...
14:31.9
Okay. So, yun ang dahilan niya.
14:33.9
Ang dahilan niya,
14:34.9
sila din naman gusto nila.
14:38.9
At ang dahilan niya,
14:39.9
mga kabatas natin,
14:40.9
yung past yun.
14:44.9
Yun dati ang ayaw makipag-meet.
14:46.9
Sila daw gusto nila makipag-meet.
14:48.9
Pero, ang problema ko doon,
14:50.9
dalawa lang sila ni Sen. Tolentino
14:52.9
ang parang gusto
14:54.9
makipag-meet.
14:56.9
Magkakaroon tayo ng problema dyan.
14:59.9
Kasi nga, alam natin,
15:00.9
mga kabatas natin,
15:03.9
that in
15:05.9
the legislative department,
15:07.9
it's always a game of numbers.
15:11.9
Numero lahat yan. Bakit?
15:13.9
Kailangan mo ng
15:14.9
votes ng two-thirds.
15:15.9
Kailangan mo votes ng majority.
15:18.9
Now,
15:20.9
if many,
15:22.9
or if you don't get
15:24.9
the required votes,
15:25.9
it's still useless.
15:27.9
Di ba?
15:28.9
Outlawin natin.
15:29.9
Ayaw sa
15:32.9
chacha.
15:33.9
Kami po nag-propose.
15:35.9
Gusto ko lang liwanagin,
15:37.9
Madam Chair. Again,
15:38.9
Nakikita ko dito sa comment section,
15:43.9
ang daming na one-way sa eyeball.
15:45.9
Hindi kayo sinipot.
15:46.9
Sumipot yun.
15:47.9
Nakita kayo.
15:48.9
Hindi nagustuhan yung nakita nila.
15:51.9
Hindi na kayo kinausap.
15:55.9
Outlawin natin.
15:56.9
He's a good friend of mine,
15:58.9
Congressman Marculita.
16:00.9
There's nothing personal about it.
16:02.9
Gusto ko lang rin parating sa kanya.
16:03.9
Yung mensahe na kami po ay pro-chacha rin,
16:06.9
lalong-lalong na pagdating sa economic reforms.
16:08.9
Bakit ayaw nyo yung people's initiative?
16:10.9
Ah, hindi, hindi.
16:11.9
Gusto naman nila.
16:12.9
Ayaw lang nila kung paano ginawa yun.
16:14.9
Yun yata.
16:15.9
Madam Chair, we can simplify.
16:17.9
Maybe we can have a stipulation.
16:21.9
Can the Senate stipulate
16:26.9
that of all the initiatives taken
16:31.9
Tawa si Cheese.
16:34.9
Stipulation.
16:35.9
Nasa pre-trial tayo.
16:36.9
Let's go.
16:37.9
by the House to engage you
16:39.9
as a constituent assembly,
16:41.9
all these initiatives have been refused.
16:47.9
Tama naman yun.
16:50.9
Wala pa tayong, hindi pa po tayong nag-
16:52.9
Madam Chair, Madam Chair,
16:54.9
as Senate President,
16:56.9
as the leader of this institution,
16:58.9
Iwas po to'y ha, iwas po so'y ha,
17:00.9
iwas po so'y.
17:01.9
O, let's go.
17:02.9
I can categorically state that we have not
17:04.9
refused any measures.
17:06.9
Matter of fact, I filed last week.
17:09.9
They did not refuse.
17:12.9
It's just inaction.
17:15.9
It's just inaction.
17:19.9
Ito kasi mga kapatid natin,
17:21.9
they are dwelling on semantics.
17:26.9
Ano ba yung tamang terminology dyan?
17:28.9
Hindi ko naman rin refuse eh.
17:32.9
Hindi lang ako gumalaw.
17:37.9
Diba?
17:38.9
Yun.
17:41.9
Ganun.
17:42.9
Parang yung ano,
17:44.9
yung
17:50.9
hindi naman nirefuse.
17:54.9
Wish ko sana gumalaw na.
17:56.9
O, let's go.
18:09.9
Huli siya dito eh.
18:14.9
Kasi sabi niya nag-file daw siya pero
18:16.9
he changed his mind.
18:19.9
During this,
18:20.9
please cite the record that I said.
18:22.9
I will no longer pursue this.
18:23.9
Well, it's in the
18:24.9
Yes.
18:25.9
in the privileged speech I heard
18:27.9
by one of you.
18:28.9
No, no, no.
18:29.9
I'd like to correct a misconception of my dear friend,
18:31.9
Congressman Mario Coleta.
18:33.9
We are just fighting this PI first.
18:37.9
Because this PI,
18:38.9
Oo, oo, oo, oo, oo, oo.
18:42.9
Iwas na.
18:43.9
PI muna.
18:48.9
Huwag CON-AS.
18:50.9
Diba ang pangit ng mga pangalan no?
18:52.9
CON-AS.
18:53.9
Constituent Assembly yung gagawin.
18:56.9
Tapos PI yung isa.
18:58.9
Yung isa may AS.
18:59.9
Yung isa may PI.
19:02.9
Yung CON-COM.
19:03.9
Constitutional Commission yung isa.
19:06.9
Change topic.
19:07.9
Change topic.
19:08.9
Okay.
19:09.9
Change topic.
19:10.9
Change topic.
19:11.9
Huli.
19:12.9
Let's go.
19:14.9
This fake people's initiative
19:17.9
is going to undermine
19:19.9
the processes of vote.
19:22.9
No, it will not.
19:26.9
Because they are independent from each other.
19:32.9
During the discussions of Constitution.
19:35.9
Ang hirap magpaliwanag kapag ano no.
19:39.9
Kapag change topic.
19:41.9
Mahirap.
19:42.9
Mahirap.
19:43.9
Mahirap magpaliwanag talaga.
19:45.9
How will it undermine?
19:47.9
Diba?
19:48.9
Magkaiba naman sila eh.
19:51.9
Constitutional change.
19:52.9
Hindi po kami papayag na makapon.
19:55.9
Ito, ito.
19:56.9
Can we actually,
19:57.9
can we actually make a,
19:59.9
can we take this,
20:00.9
itong sinasabi nila dito,
20:03.9
na guarantee na
20:05.9
they all
20:07.9
concur naman eh.
20:08.9
Tuloy na sinabi ko kanina.
20:09.9
They all concur that we need amendment.
20:10.9
Sa ating Constitution.
20:12.9
Especially the economic provisions.
20:14.9
Because it's so outdated
20:16.9
and it is anti-Filipinos.
20:20.9
Kasi nga, it is pro-monopoly.
20:23.9
Pro-mayaman.
20:26.9
Yung mga mayayaman lang ang pwede
20:28.9
dito sa Pilipinas.
20:30.9
It's anti-competition.
20:33.9
Kailangan na, diba?
20:34.9
Nabaguhin.
20:36.9
Alam niyo ang problema
20:37.9
dito
20:38.9
sa Congress natin.
20:40.9
Yung tinatawag nilang lobbying.
20:42.9
It's not illegal.
20:43.9
Pero mga kabatas natin,
20:45.9
people,
20:46.9
many people who have money
20:48.9
lobby
20:50.9
for their own interest.
20:53.9
Like for example,
20:54.9
mga kabatas natin,
20:55.9
bakit ang bagal-bagal
20:57.9
ng roll-out ng mga electric cars
20:59.9
dito sa Pilipinas?
21:01.9
Kasi may mga nagla-lobby dyan,
21:03.9
mga kabatas natin,
21:04.9
na,
21:05.9
wag muna.
21:07.9
Kasi nga,
21:08.9
maraming nakainig,
21:10.9
mag-invest sa gasolina.
21:14.9
Bakit mga kabatas natin,
21:16.9
ang tagal-tagal mong mag-apply
21:18.9
ng net metering
21:20.9
para sa solar power?
21:25.9
Kasi nga,
21:28.9
wag muna.
21:30.9
May negosyo akong ganyan.
21:32.9
Mamamatay yung negosyo ko.
21:36.9
Bakit ayaw nila ng anti-slap law?
21:38.9
Kasi nga,
21:39.9
wag muna.
21:41.9
Baka mabisto ng mga tao
21:43.9
kung ilan ang asawa ko.
21:47.9
That's how they do it.
21:50.9
Kaya naman namamatay yun eh.
21:52.9
Isa pa,
21:53.9
yung Fair Collections Act.
21:57.9
Napakaganda yun para sa mahihirap.
21:59.9
Para hindi ka maharas kapag ikaw
22:03.9
ay sinisingil ng taong
22:05.9
pinagkakautangan mo.
22:07.9
Bawal.
22:08.9
Bawal
22:09.9
mangharas.
22:10.9
Bawal mag-text sa'yo sa 10 oras ng gabi.
22:12.9
Bawal i-contact yung mga kamag-anak mo.
22:15.9
Bawal magsabi sa'yo
22:17.9
ng mga threatening words,
22:19.9
ng mga bagay-bagay na makakasira sa'yo.
22:22.9
Bawal.
22:23.9
Ang ganda ng batas na yun.
22:26.9
Bakit hindi napasa?
22:27.9
At hanggang ngayon hindi mapasa-pasa?
22:30.9
Kasi nga, sino ba yung nagpapautang?
22:33.9
Yung mga maraming pera.
22:38.9
Ganon kasimple yan.
22:45.9
That's why mga kabatas natin,
22:47.9
maraming tao ang ayaw ma-amendahan
22:50.9
lalong-lalo na yung ownership ng business.
22:52.9
They don't want that.
22:53.9
Because if you will,
22:54.9
have competition here in the Philippines.
22:57.9
Sa Amerika mga kabatas natin,
22:59.9
yung mga telco,
23:01.9
telecom companies nila doon,
23:03.9
yung binabayaran ko
23:05.9
sa aking linya,
23:06.9
mga kabatas natin,
23:07.9
doon sa Amerika,
23:09.9
pang isang pamilya yun.
23:13.9
Pang isang pamilya yun.
23:14.9
Isa lang yung nagbabayad sa kanila,
23:16.9
yung tatay lang nila,
23:18.9
tapos lahat sila may line na.
23:21.9
Apat, lima.
23:23.9
Samantalang dito, ako lang nagbabayad nun.
23:26.9
Sa akin lang yun.
23:28.9
Pati internet doon ang mura-mura.
23:32.9
Dito sa atin mga kabatas natin,
23:33.9
sobrang mahal.
23:37.9
Bakit?
23:38.9
Kasi we don't want those
23:42.9
cheap ones to come here.
23:44.9
Mamamatay yung negosyo
23:45.9
ng mga taong matagal nang gumagatas sa Pilipino.
23:50.9
Bakit?
23:51.9
Eh hirap na hirap tayo
23:53.9
para lang magpasok ng negosyo.
23:54.9
Ayaw naman ng mga tao
23:56.9
na negosyante na ang magkokontrol Pilipino.
24:00.9
Kasi most of the important businesses,
24:04.9
60-40.
24:05.9
Ibig sabihin,
24:06.9
60 sa Pilipino.
24:07.9
Ibig sabihin,
24:08.9
majority of the control
24:09.9
eh nasa Pilipino.
24:12.9
Eh wala nang pondo yung mga Pilipino na yun.
24:16.9
Deads.
24:20.9
Diba?
24:23.9
It's a problem.
24:25.9
Why don't you want to fix it?
24:29.9
Because,
24:32.9
your interests
24:34.9
are different.
24:35.9
Are different.
24:37.9
Iba yung gusto nyong mangyari.
24:40.9
Hindi para sa tao,
24:41.9
kundi para sa padrino.
24:45.9
Hindi ko nila lahat.
24:47.9
Pero,
24:48.9
well,
24:49.9
you know.
24:52.9
Ang Senado,
24:53.9
kasi mawawala po ang bicameralism
24:55.9
that is stipulated five times in our Constitution
24:59.9
and provides for the checks and balances of our...
25:03.9
Wala na.
25:04.9
Change topic na si Sir.
25:06.9
...institutions.
25:07.9
Yun lamang po.
25:08.9
Wala po tayong pinag-aawayin kundi itong PI.
25:11.9
Kasi,
25:12.9
ah,
25:13.9
alam mo, sa totoo...
25:16.9
Iba na to.
25:17.9
Wala, Madam Chair.
25:18.9
We're going,
25:19.9
we're veering away from the topic here.
25:21.9
Yes.
25:22.9
And you changed the topic again.
25:23.9
Okay?
25:24.9
But really quickly,
25:25.9
kung yung point,
25:27.9
yung PIPO's initiative,
25:28.9
kung ninagay po nila dyan,
25:30.9
sino bang mga proponents dyan?
25:32.9
Kung ninagay ng pirma dyan
25:34.9
to amend the...
25:36.9
Pero bakit mo sisisihin yung PIPO's initiative
25:39.9
kung you have the initiative also
25:42.9
through a constituent assembly?
25:47.9
Tingnan niyo yung sasabihin niya, ha?
25:49.9
Shifting the blame.
25:51.9
For example,
25:52.9
public services
25:53.9
to allow 100% foreign ownership,
25:55.9
sa tingin ko walang gulo eh.
25:57.9
Pati sa amin walang aalma.
25:59.9
Oo.
26:00.9
Pero bakit ayaw niyo pa rin gawin?
26:02.9
Iyan.
26:03.9
If in the first mode
26:06.9
na constituent assembly,
26:08.9
you can do that,
26:09.9
why are you not doing it?
26:13.9
Yun ay napakasimple.
26:15.9
That is a right given by the Constitution.
26:18.9
Pero hindi eh.
26:19.9
It's a very simple question to vote as one,
26:22.9
but it is very...
26:24.9
It is full of...
26:28.9
Wala na.
26:29.9
Palusot lang naman ito eh.
26:32.9
Merong...
26:33.9
Meron akong ano dito.
26:34.9
Sino bang may pakana?
26:36.9
Merong linabas na picture-picture dito eh.
26:43.9
Dito sa dulo yung kausap niya.
26:45.9
Anyway,
26:46.9
kukuha-kuha naman tayo ng ano dito eh.
26:48.9
Ito, ito.
26:49.9
Tingnan niyo ito.
26:50.9
Tignan niyo ito.
26:51.9
Kukuha-kawa tayong pag-uusapan natin dito.
26:53.9
Okay?
26:54.9
Akala siguro ni...
26:55.9
Pero yung mga ano,
26:56.9
yung mga Tulfonatics,
26:57.9
relax lang kayo.
26:58.9
No?
27:00.9
Yung...
27:01.9
Yung tupad.
27:02.9
Bising-bising ngayon,
27:03.9
nagbibigyan ng tupad si Raffy Tulfo.
27:06.9
Tuloy natin.
27:07.9
We're trying to enlarge the picture
27:08.9
to share it with everyone in the room.
27:14.9
Okay, bibigyan ko kayo
27:15.9
nang nangyari dito mga kots natin.
27:17.9
Konteksto.
27:18.9
Tinanong dito si Onyete ba yun?
27:22.9
Baka...
27:23.9
Onyete, hindi Onyeta.
27:26.9
Tama ba yung...
27:27.9
Tinanong siya,
27:28.9
kung nag-meet ba kayo,
27:31.9
o kasali ba dito si Romualdez
27:34.9
dito sa People's Initiative na ito?
27:36.9
Sinabi niya hindi daw sila nag-meet,
27:38.9
wala daw silang meeting.
27:39.9
Ngayon, may pinakita silang picture.
27:42.9
Tingnan natin.
27:51.9
O, Onyete.
27:52.9
Hindi Onyeta.
27:54.9
Baliktad.
27:55.9
Onyete.
27:56.9
Onyete.
27:57.9
Noel Onyete.
27:59.9
Nakita niya yung picture?
28:00.9
Nakita niya yung picture.
28:03.9
People's Initiative for Charter Change Staff Meeting
28:06.9
from left to right.
28:07.9
Atty. Dante Atienza.
28:08.9
Atty. Alex Avisado.
28:11.9
Tapos nasa gitna.
28:12.9
Ito.
28:13.9
Itong gitna na ito mga kots natin.
28:15.9
Yan si
28:16.9
Congressman Romualdez.
28:18.9
There we go.
28:19.9
I think that's as big as we can get it.
28:23.9
People's Initiative for Charter Change
28:26.9
Staff Meeting
28:28.9
January 8.
28:29.9
Can you tell us who are in the picture,
28:32.9
Mr. Onyete, please?
28:34.9
Madam Senator.
28:37.9
The question is who, sir?
28:39.9
That was the time that I coordinated with the Speaker.
28:45.9
You said you never met the Speaker.
28:48.9
Nor Mr. Saldico, our Congressman.
28:50.9
You're under oath, sir.
28:52.9
Yes, that was the time that I met with the Speaker.
28:57.9
Sabi mo lang na hindi naman kayo nagkita.
28:59.9
Sabi niyo si na Congressman Garvin lang.
29:02.9
Yeah, because, you know, it slipped my mind.
29:05.9
It slipped my mind, Madam Senator.
29:10.9
Okay lang, okay lang.
29:11.9
Kung nakalimutan ninyo bigla,
29:13.9
is Speaker Martin Romualdez supporting your group?
29:16.9
To help us in the signature campaign, yes.
29:18.9
Okay, so it's very clear that
29:20.9
Speaker Martin Romualdez is supporting your group po.
29:23.9
He is all out behind the People's Initiative.
29:26.9
Is that correct?
29:28.9
Yes, we coordinate with the Speaker and the Congress.
29:31.9
Thank you very much.
29:33.9
Yung right answer doon. Ang right answer doon.
29:36.9
I don't know because I am not Mr. Speaker.
29:42.9
Tingnan niyo.
29:43.9
Naggulat yung abogado niya dun sa sinabi niya.
29:46.9
Is that correct?
29:48.9
Tingnan niyo yung tanong.
29:49.9
Okay, so it's very clear that
29:50.9
Speaker Martin Romualdez is supporting your group po.
29:53.9
He is all out behind the People's Initiative.
29:55.9
Is that correct?
29:57.9
Yes, we coordinate with the Speaker and the Congress.
30:00.9
Naggulat yung abogado niya sa attorney Alex Avizano.
30:06.9
The answer is, I don't know.
30:10.9
Only the Speaker can answer that.
30:15.9
If he is all out in supporting the People's Initiative.
30:19.9
I am not him, therefore.
30:21.9
I am not capable of that.
30:23.9
I am not capable of answering that question.
30:26.9
Is that correct?
30:29.9
Yes, we coordinate with the Speaker and the Congress.
30:32.9
Thank you very much.
30:33.9
In getting the 3% pair of Congressional District.
30:36.9
That's correct.
30:37.9
Yung abogado niyo, tingnan niyo.
30:40.9
Oh my God, sabi niya.
30:42.9
Ang hirap naman dipensahan na yan.
30:44.9
Madam Senator.
30:45.9
Thank you very much for helping us along with this investigation.
30:50.9
I'd like to turn it over,
30:51.9
turn it back to Senator Chase.
30:54.9
I'll wind up.
30:55.9
Okay mga kabatas natin.
30:56.9
Diyan na lang muna.
30:57.9
Kasi nakita naman na natin binabanggit si BBM.
31:03.9
Pero dito sa mga resource person niya na ito.
31:06.9
Si Onyate mga kabatas natin.
31:08.9
Si Onyate.
31:09.9
Siya yung nagpondo ng kalahati dito sa People's Initiative.
31:14.9
Siya yung nakita natin na nagsalita kanina.
31:17.9
Okay?
31:19.9
Let's go mga kabatas natin.
31:21.9
Hindi pa tayo sa kabila.
31:23.9
Maraming salamat po.
31:24.9
At syempre tulad ng laging sinasabi,
31:26.9
matulog po tayo ng maimbing
31:27.9
dahil alam natin na inatutulog ng maimbing,
31:29.9
siya yung laging panalo.
31:30.9
Paalam po.
31:31.9
Pansama tayo.