01:09.3
Ngayon mga kabatas natin,
01:14.8
Bakit mo hahatiin ang Pilipinas?
01:20.8
Ang gusto ko kasing ipahihwating nila dito sa Pilipino, sa mga Pilipino, because Rodrigo Duterte was a president of the Philippines.
01:42.8
You were a president of the Philippines.
01:46.3
You were a president of the Philippines.
01:47.5
Being a former president,
01:49.7
Being a former president,
01:50.6
you owe it to the Filipino people
01:52.9
to at least, diba, put the interest of the Philippines first.
02:06.1
Ito ang una kong tanong.
02:08.1
Ito ang una kong tanong.
02:10.1
Sino ang makikinabang pag hiniwalay nyo ang Mindanao?
02:20.6
Sino ang makikinabang pag hiniwalay nyo ang Mindanao?
02:50.6
Sino ang makikinabang pag hiniwalay nyo ang Mindanao?
03:20.6
When the Philippines was treated as a whole republic, Luzon, Visayas, at Mindanao.
03:34.5
Tapos ngayon, dahil beneficial kay Mindanao na humiwalay,
03:39.7
ihihiwalay mo na lang.
03:41.4
Kahit hindi beneficial kay Luzon, tsaka kay Visayas.
03:45.6
Isn't that unfair?
03:48.1
Also, pag hiniwalay mo ang Mindanao,
03:50.6
sabi nila, huwag yan magulo.
03:54.7
Makikinabang ang Visayas at saka Luzon.
03:58.0
Isn't that unfair also to the Mindanao?
04:03.2
That's the first question that we should ask.
04:06.4
Sino ang makikinabang o kayo lang ang makikinabang?
04:10.6
O iilang tao lang yung makikinabang?
04:20.6
Yung mga pakikipaglaban natin sa insurgents,
04:24.9
Mindanao fans lang ba yung ginagamit?
04:27.8
Yung mga problema sa Luzon, yung mga problema sa Visayas,
04:31.9
Visayas fans lang ba yung ginagamit?
04:35.7
Luzon fans lang ba yung ginagamit?
04:46.2
Balik tayo sa question na yan mamaya.
04:48.5
Pakinggan muna natin siya.
04:50.6
Scott Alvarez, siya yung talagang pinakauna
04:54.2
nagparakad ng mga papel
04:57.9
about the desirability of Mindanao
05:05.1
seceding from the Republic of the Philippines.
05:12.8
They are seceding.
05:14.6
Gusto na nilang humiwalay sa Republic of the Philippines.
05:23.8
anong gagamitin mong batas?
05:28.1
Sasabihin niya ngayon ito.
05:29.8
No? Sasabihin niya ngayon ito.
05:31.1
Siya yung inang-una talagay ko.
05:33.1
Kaya ko siya inilagay dyan
05:34.6
so that we can pursue because
05:37.2
by this time he would know the truth.
05:42.4
hindi naman rebellion, hindi yan sedisyon.
05:46.0
There's a process in that.
05:48.0
I think before the,
05:55.1
I think before the U.N. daw.
05:58.5
I don't think so.
05:59.6
I'm not an expert about this one.
06:04.7
Pero ang pagkakaalam ko,
06:07.2
ang pagkakaalam ko,
06:09.3
ang U.N., mga kapatas natin,
06:11.8
they are dealing with states already.
06:16.6
Yung mga state na,
06:18.6
I think the U.N. is not involved
06:22.6
in forming states.
06:26.6
Maybe recognizing states.
06:29.8
But in the first place,
06:31.5
there should be established state first.
06:38.8
Before the U.N. can recognize it.
06:43.6
Tignan niyo yung sinasabi niya.
06:48.6
Where you would gather signatures
06:52.9
from all sorts in Mindanao,
07:00.6
Gusto kong makita,
07:03.7
hinahanap ko yung citation niya dito.
07:08.4
Tulungan niyo ako mga kapatas natin
07:09.9
because I don't know that.
07:14.6
May napag-aralan din ako sa U.N.
07:16.2
But what I understand,
07:18.6
what I understand with the U.N. is,
07:20.6
they deal with states.
07:22.6
They don't form states.
07:26.6
actually participants
07:28.6
in forming states.
07:32.6
Balikan natin yung war
07:40.6
Di ba gusto ng Palestine
07:42.6
na mas ma-recognize
07:44.6
yung kanilang statehood?
07:46.6
Magkaroon sila ng sarili.
07:48.6
Bakit hindi gawin ng U.N. yan
07:50.6
para matapos na yung kaguluhan na yan?
08:02.6
Eto, sabi ni Eva Hornido,
08:07.6
Montevideo Convention.
08:48.6
Montevideo Convention.
08:50.6
Adapted by the seventh
08:52.6
International Conference of American States,
08:54.6
the convention stipulated that
08:56.6
all states were equal sovereign units
08:58.6
consisting of a permanent population,
09:02.6
defined territorial boundaries,
09:05.6
and an ability to enter into agreements
09:07.6
with other states.
09:16.6
yung characteristics ng isang state.
09:24.6
What are the four characteristics of a country
09:26.6
set by the Montevideo Convention?
09:34.6
Four requirements of statehood.
10:10.0
tulad nga lang ang sinabi ko sa inyo.
10:11.2
This is not how a state is created.
10:11.6
Actually, I didn't read this
10:18.0
So, pag-aralan natin.
10:25.6
Convention on Rights
10:28.4
and Duties of States.
10:34.9
Contents of the Convention
10:36.5
sets out the definition
10:38.8
rights and duties of statehood.
10:41.6
The political existence
10:48.8
of the state is independent of
10:50.4
recognition by other states.
10:54.6
It just defines a state.
10:57.8
It does not create
10:59.1
or it does not tell us how
11:01.0
a state should be created.
11:05.1
Saan dito yung signature-signature?
11:11.6
Ito sabi ni Ava Ornit.
11:14.6
If meron ang supposed state
11:15.9
ng lahat ng qualification,
11:17.3
pwede sila maging state.
11:19.2
Meron sila kasi state na sila eh.
11:20.9
Nasa Pilipinas sila eh.
11:33.3
So, how will you create it?
11:36.3
Saan yung pirmapirma?
11:37.4
Kasi pag titignan mo dito,
11:42.5
customary international law rin dito eh.
11:46.8
pag titignan mo ito,
11:48.5
it also exercises committee.
11:57.3
The only avenue open to self-determination
11:59.9
for colonial or national ethnic
12:01.6
minority populations was to achieve
12:03.2
international legal personality as a nation-state.
12:07.4
No, this is not, this is not,
12:10.7
this is characteristics.
12:14.0
this laid down the characteristics
12:21.6
State na yung Pilipinas
12:23.2
at kabilang ng state
12:28.4
Saan dito yung pirmapirma?
12:38.0
siyempre, if we talk about conventions,
12:40.6
multi-video conventions na ito,
12:45.5
yung mga signatories lang,
12:50.2
yung kasali dito.
12:53.6
Pag hindi ka signatory,
12:55.3
hindi ka rin kasali.
12:59.8
so ang gagawin nila,
13:00.8
magpapapirma-pirma sila.
13:02.6
Pag nakapagpapirma-pirma na sila,
13:04.4
hiwalay na silang state,
13:10.1
Tulad ng sinabi ko,
13:10.9
hindi ako marunong dito.
13:13.0
kasi wala akong narinig na ganon.
13:14.7
Sa buong law school ko,
13:16.8
hanggang ngayon na nagpapractice ako,
13:18.6
wala akong narinig
13:19.6
na kung gusto mong humiwalay,
13:20.9
magpapirma-pirma ka lang.
13:25.6
yung binobotohan,
13:31.2
Kung maging autonomous
13:32.6
ang isang region.
13:39.6
if Duterte confused that
13:47.8
tapos makakahiwalay ka na,
13:49.2
tapos separate na state ka na,
13:52.0
I haven't heard of that one.
14:06.9
You will be an autonomous region.
14:09.9
You will enjoy more independence
14:12.3
from other regions.
14:19.7
I don't understand.
14:21.9
Pero tignan natin.
14:24.2
in the presence of so many people,
14:26.5
design that we want
14:32.2
Kaya kung ganon lang naman
14:34.4
dyan na sa Luzon.
14:36.2
So, ganon na yun.
14:38.1
Pipirma na lang kayo.
14:39.2
Gusto kong yung...
14:40.3
Ano yung parang divorce?
14:52.9
Magpirmahan na tayo.
14:57.3
Magpirmahan na tayo.
14:58.8
Hiwalay na kami sa inyo.
15:04.4
Patay sa Visayas.
15:15.6
Sabi niya, I am fake enough.
15:17.7
Tama yung autonomy yung sinabi ni FRD.
15:19.5
Gusto nilang mayiwalay forcibly.
15:21.6
But autonomy is...
15:24.6
you still belong to the Republic of the Philippines.
15:28.1
Kasi yung Cordillera Administrative Region,
15:31.2
Cordillera Autonomous Region,
15:33.5
you still belong to the Republic of the Philippines.
15:34.2
You still belong to the Republic of the Philippines.
15:34.4
Nagkaroon ng botohan yan noon.
15:48.0
pag autonomous region ka,
15:49.7
administrative region ka,
15:51.7
you are still part of the Republic of the Philippines.
15:55.0
hihiwalay na daw siya sa Pilipinas.
16:09.7
Nandito man sa atin lahat.
16:13.4
our resources to them.
16:22.6
We only give our resources to them.
16:24.9
Okay, sige, sige, sige.
16:27.0
Wala man ang Samar,
16:28.8
wala man ang pagdala sa atin.
16:34.4
and Mindanao is rich.
16:39.0
saan ba ang Marawi?
16:43.4
Saan ba yung Marawi?
16:46.1
Mindanao yun, di ba?
16:48.8
Nung nagkagyera doon.
16:58.7
O, sa Lanao yun, di ba?
17:00.6
Gusto ka lang siguraduhin.
17:01.9
Gusto ka lang siguraduhin.
17:04.9
Yung mga lumaban ba doon,
17:06.3
puro taga Mindanao lang?
17:12.2
Kasi parang sinasabi niya,
17:13.7
wala daw tinulong eh.
17:16.7
Wala man ang Samar,
17:18.0
wala man ang pagdala sa atin.
17:21.1
Wala man ang Samar,
17:28.4
Nandito man sa atin lahat.
17:30.8
We all give our resources to them.
17:31.9
We all give our resources to them.
17:37.1
You only give your resources?
17:39.9
Huwag naman gano'n.
17:53.2
yung location kung saan namatay
17:59.9
Pakisagot nga sa comment section,
18:01.9
Mga kapatid natin.
18:16.4
Saan yung SAF 44?
18:19.3
yung inkwentro na yun?
18:41.9
Yung mamasapan o.
18:45.2
Luzon, Visayas o Mindanao?
18:59.0
So walang naitulong.
19:01.9
Ilan ang Cordilleran,
19:06.5
na namatay sa SAF 44?
19:10.1
Karamihan sa SAF 44.
19:23.7
ang tinaya sa Mindanao.
19:27.1
Tapos sasabihin mo yan?
19:28.4
Tapos sasabihin mo yan?
19:35.1
Nandito man sa atin lahat.
19:46.5
What is the greatest sacrifice?
19:58.4
Huwag tayong ganyan.
20:04.2
Our resources to them.
20:07.3
Wala man ang sama.
20:09.6
Sabi niya Melanie ko.
20:26.2
Yung mga PMA years natin
20:28.4
saan sila dinidistino
20:31.5
pag second lieutenant sila?
20:40.6
Get down your high horse.
20:58.4
Imagine, mag-ooperation, galing sa Norte yung mga sundalo.
21:08.0
Tapos you only give?
21:19.5
Alam nyo, ito kasi eh.
21:21.5
Ito yung nakaka-insulto.
21:26.4
You aren't talking about facts.
21:28.4
Do you know how many people sacrificed because of Mindanao?
21:47.3
Tapos you only give?
21:51.2
And you want division instead of unity?
21:54.5
Is that the right thing to do right now?
21:59.4
You think we forgot our American song in the rooted ax?
22:04.8
Ayaw niyo públicong acto na lang yung agad ng Pakayowa.
22:07.8
Yung showing kong kanilang naayam,
22:10.3
kaya ito siyang halog pati yung ang unyong,
22:11.9
habang ano rin sa Ibreak video na ito,
22:13.5
kung siya rin din ayunit agad rin,
22:15.4
Irei na pala rin dito,
22:17.2
hindi natin nakita dito.
22:19.6
kung ano rin lang dito ng lahat.
22:20.3
Porosong watan na lahat natin ng mga UFO.
22:38.1
As on its growing years
22:40.7
You have to restrict
22:44.8
Mga Tagalog son Visayas
22:46.6
We will not deny you
22:58.4
Hindi naman passport
22:59.8
Hindi daw passport
23:09.9
Isipin nyo ito ha
23:24.3
Pero isipin nyo ito
23:26.1
Gusto nyo humiwalay
23:28.7
Mag-isip kayo ng pangalan
23:32.8
You delineate the
23:36.4
Kailangan nyo bumuunan
23:38.5
You have to have structure
23:43.3
What is the structure?
23:47.0
Gakokopihan nyo lang
23:47.9
Lahat sa Pilipinas
23:49.7
O di same rin lang
23:51.7
Humiwalay pa kayo
23:52.2
Humiwalay pa kayo
23:52.6
Why divide the people?
24:05.6
Patay na talaga yung unity
24:18.8
Nung panahon namin
24:25.4
Bugbogan sa concert
24:28.4
Tapos may mga nabukulan
24:46.0
Diba dapat ang purpose natin
24:52.3
Kunti ano lang yung ibigay na card
24:57.3
Kung mag-independent tayo
25:00.3
Ako gusto ko talaga
25:03.2
Magsawa na ako sa
25:05.2
Ilang presidente na kasi eh
25:08.8
Ikaw naging presidente ka rin naman
25:22.3
What he's talking about anymore
25:24.3
Wala nangyari sa Pilipinas
25:29.3
Nagi-presidente ka rin
25:47.2
Kanya kasi Pilipino eh
25:48.8
Mailig sa drama eh
25:52.3
Sige, isip, isip. Ano bang pwedeng sabihin?
26:00.6
make a political party.
26:05.2
in front of Bebot now,
26:11.0
tayo ng mga partido na
26:14.5
party mates naman.
26:19.6
hindi naman yung prinsipyo ta.
26:21.7
The highfalutin thing.
26:25.6
Marunong magtingin.
26:29.2
convenience na isang liparan lang
26:33.7
But I do not, I do not
26:35.4
really. Wala akong
26:37.4
masabi dyan sa mga congressman na
26:46.1
yung mga sinasabi niya. Wala rin
26:47.9
ako maintindihan. So paano ako
26:51.7
Ah, yan lang mga kapatid natin.
26:56.5
Maraming salamat po sa inyo.
26:57.8
At syempre, tulad lang yung sinasabi.
26:59.6
Matulog po tayo ng mayimbing dahil alam natin
27:01.9
na yung natutulog ng mayimbing
27:03.9
siya yung laging panalo.
27:05.1
Paalam po, pansamantalan.
