03:43.0
I mean, nabooking na nga ako eh kagabi. Binabuli tayo ng mga kasama natin dito sa...
03:48.1
Richard, I caught you while you were in the meetings at Defense Ministry, Foreign Ministry, sa METI, Ministry of...
03:53.3
Nag-YouTube ka nung ginagawa mo ganun. Sabi ko, sorry na guys. Kailangan, obligations, important things are happening.
04:00.0
Naku, pagtingin natin dito. Grabe, sumabog pala. Internet broke, guys. Internet broke.
04:08.0
Kaya no, 3.2 million views, guys. 3.2 million views dun sa 2 minutes na highlight na kinuha ko dun sa speech ni tatay.
04:20.6
So imagine yung multitasking. Ito yung sinasabi ko kanina na nagsabay yung dalawa, diba?
04:26.2
Nagsabay yung dalawang mga kaibigan natin na vloggers. Good job, guys.
04:30.0
Sabi ko, I'm gonna approach this a little bit different. I mean, I'll not pretend. I didn't have time to listen and all.
04:35.5
And both are great gentlemen, so I'm sure may sarili silang take on this issue.
04:39.6
But let me approach this quite differently.
04:41.5
Now, at the risk of getting red-tagged, I would say that one way of approaching this is yung sinabi ni Trotsky nun, diba?
04:50.5
Neither peace nor war, diba?
04:54.2
Nung Trotsky was given a choice between Germany at saka yung mga Anglo-Saxon.
05:00.0
Powers and France, sabi niya, hindi ako pipili. Neither nor.
05:03.2
Which, by the way, and here, huwag niyo ako i-red-tag.
05:05.7
Actually, guys, actually, guys, ito may ano to, may more philosophical references ito.
05:13.7
Hegel tayo. Kaya alam niyo na, Hegel tayo, diba?
05:17.7
Neither nor, right? Ang approach dapat natin is neither nor.
05:21.8
Negation of negation, okay?
05:23.5
Okay, and I know, I know, this is gonna get a little bit complicated.
05:27.0
A little bit Hegelian, Zizekian. Don't worry, guys.
05:30.0
I-simplify ko sa inyo. Kasi ang dami mga iba dyan, pinapahirapan to nila yung mga konsepto.
05:35.7
Alright? I'm gonna simplify it to you.
05:38.1
So ang malaking debate ngayon is, saan dapat ang oposisyon?
05:41.9
Or saan dapat yung mga progressives?
05:43.6
Saan yung mga nagmamahal sa bayan?
05:46.0
So katulad ng pinag-usapan natin kaapon, with crush ng bayan, Ronald Aldenz Llamas.
05:53.8
May mga nagsasabi, na doon na tayo kay BBM kasi siya yung presidente natin.
05:58.4
At eto na talaga ang ating oportunidad para once and for all, di ba,
06:03.4
isiguraduin natin na hindi makabalik yung mga pinakakaren ng Philippine politics.
06:07.9
Or Kevin or Ken, alright?
06:10.1
O dibatein natin kung mas magaling Kevin or Ken doon sa lalaking karen.
06:14.4
As I said, I see the point with that.
06:17.8
Especially if ang approach mo dito is, ang approach mo dito is sequential, di ba?
06:24.7
First you deal with the biggest threat and then let's see what happens there.
06:28.4
As I said, na there's a Bernie Sanders way of understanding this.
06:31.2
Oya, ma-retag na naman tayo.
06:32.9
Essentially where yung argument is, pag may dalawang problematic ang candidates
06:37.7
or may pipili ka between the two problematic options,
06:42.3
always remember, one option you can have certain level of engagement and responsiveness.
06:48.9
Ang sinabi ni Bernie Sanders nung in-endorse na si Hillary Clinton,
06:51.7
sabi na, at least with Hillary Clinton, we can hold her feet close to the fire.
06:55.6
Meaning, there is some channel of communications.
06:59.6
And Hillary Clinton will not try to undermine the foundations of American democracy.
07:03.9
Pero kung si Trump yung nanalo, good luck na lang sa atin.
07:06.9
And anyway, hindi ako fan ni Hillary Clinton.
07:09.3
Sobrang, I'm sorry.
07:11.5
I wish America will soon elect, you know, its first female, its first, you know, minority president.
07:19.3
But as far as Hillary Clinton herself is concerned, ang dami kong mga issues sa kanya, alright?
07:23.1
I'm not gonna go deeper into this.
07:24.4
So, going back to this, mga kameta.
07:28.4
Going back to this.
07:29.2
Pag-usapan natin ito.
07:31.4
In a way, I understand if the argument here is, kailangan natin, you know, we have to, you know,
07:36.3
side with Hillary Clinton against Trump with this.
07:39.7
And then later on, let's see what, how we do with Hillary Clinton.
07:42.3
I understand where some of my colleagues and friends are coming here, okay?
07:47.0
Huwag niyo na muna hanapin si Alden, okay?
07:49.3
In demand masyado yan si Alden.
07:51.1
Dito na lang tayo sa akin, okay?
07:52.6
Alam ko, alam ko, hindi niyo ako ganun ka-crush.
07:56.6
Alam ko, hindi ko naminimula.
07:58.4
Ngunit yung mga standards niyo, okay?
08:01.4
Pero makinig kayo sa akin, because at least you're gonna get dialectical analysis, alright?
08:05.8
In a simplified vlogger fashion, okay?
08:09.3
Negation of negation, okay?
08:11.1
Neither peace nor war, okay?
08:12.8
Pag-usapan natin yan.
08:16.4
Ayan na naman tayo, democrat katabi.
08:18.5
Kakasabi ko nga lang, Bernie Sanders, ayan na naman yung mga bashers natin.
08:22.3
Intindiin nyo kasi yung sinisabi ko, reference point ko, bago kayo maghanash dyan sa mga, ano ko, sa mga comment sections ko.
08:28.4
And all, ayan, magbablush na naman ako, iinit na naman, iinit na naman ulo natin.
08:33.1
Tapos magiging mas zaddy tayo.
08:35.7
Tapos pag nag-zaddy tayo, ano na naman, oh.
08:40.2
Okay, now guys, honestly, anong nga siya ito, ah?
08:43.5
Gusto ko yung lamig dito, to be honest.
08:45.8
Kasi it feels kinda like Baguio.
08:48.8
As a Baguio boy, I like, I like cold.
08:51.6
And I really enjoy walking long.
08:53.2
As in, 12, 14, 15 kilometers na nila.
08:55.6
I really enjoy that, guys.
08:57.1
Kasi, andami natin.
08:59.1
Or dami natin, pinaprocess, et cetera.
09:01.4
And at the same time, you know, we're trying to approach things differently.
09:03.9
But anyway, going back to this.
09:05.5
So, let me put it this way.
09:12.6
May batas ba dito?
09:14.0
Pag sabi ko yung mga abogado natin, baka mamaya mamis-understand na.
09:18.7
Uy, yung mga nagsicheck sa YouTube, please understand my reference point.
09:22.7
Lagay ko na lang sa quotation mark, mamaya yung fentanyl.
09:25.3
Baka mamaya magka, ano tayo dyan.
09:28.4
Tama na tayo, guys.
09:33.7
Let me first lay out my concerns, no, with each camp.
09:38.5
Let me be also absolutely clear.
09:39.9
I don't see any equivalence between fentanyl and COVID.
09:46.2
Seryosa na tayo, guys.
09:48.5
To be honest, ah.
09:50.3
Para sa akin, ang biggest threat sa Philippine political system ay yung right-wing populism.
09:57.1
It's even worse than dictatorship.
09:58.4
In a sense that, sa dictatorship, at least alam mo sa inyong diktador.
10:02.6
Sa right-wing populism, meron pa rin kasi yung bahit ng demokrasya.
10:07.1
May illusion of, ah, ah, ano?
10:15.5
Relax lang kayo dyan.
10:16.6
Nagkakoconcentrate tayo, guys.
10:18.0
Huwag kayong magulo.
10:27.5
Bakit binoto si Digong noong 2016?
10:30.3
If I don't really understand it, may sinulat tayo ng libro.
10:34.1
May sinulat tayo mga journal articles.
10:35.9
May sinulat tayo mga academic pieces sa Cambridge University Press,
10:39.6
sa Palgrave, sa Palgrave Macmillan yung book ko,
10:42.1
sa, sa, sa Oxford University.
10:43.9
Dalawa actually sa Cambridge University Press sa mga book chapters na nasulat ko.
10:47.8
Countless articles.
10:48.8
Probably a thousand or two thousand articles ang sinulat natin.
10:51.4
So, if you want to see my academic intellectual analysis,
10:55.1
scholarly analysis,
10:56.1
nung phenomenon of deuteronomy,
10:57.5
you should know, mga kameta,
11:00.4
na wala akong judgment laban sa mga bumoto sa kanya.
11:03.4
I completely understand where they come from.
11:05.8
I do not agree with them.
11:07.3
And I did not agree with them.
11:09.3
Pero naiintindihan ko saan sila galing.
11:11.4
Ito ay galing sa frustration ng tao.
11:14.8
Malalim na frustration ng tao.
11:17.0
Dun sa mga limitasyon, kapalpakan, kayabangan, self-righteousness, whatever,
11:22.6
ng reformist, liberal project sa Philippine politics.
11:27.4
ang katotohanan dito is, mga kameta,
11:31.1
Ang katotohanan dito is,
11:33.2
lumaban ang ating mga ninuno.
11:36.5
Nag-sakripisyo sila from Gomburza to Rizal.
11:40.0
And then, nung Second World War,
11:41.6
laban sa Imperial Japan.
11:43.0
Mag-galit sila dito sa akin, but whatever.
11:47.4
nag-sakripisyo si Ninoy.
11:49.7
Lahat ng mga nag-sakripisyo nung EDSA.
11:51.9
And then, anong nangyari?
11:52.9
Purong katrapuhan anong nangyari.
11:54.4
Yung mga ilan-ilan na lang natin na medyo matinong presidente,
11:57.4
whether it's Ramos or Aquino,
11:58.8
ang dami rin mga kakulangan.
12:00.6
Ang dami rin mga may mga mali na nangyari.
12:04.3
Well, at least with Ramos,
12:05.7
nakausap ko siya,
12:06.5
at least more self-aware siguro siya dun sa mga...
12:09.0
I don't want to get into person-to-person about it.
12:11.0
I had conversation with both Ramos, Aquino.
12:13.6
Yes, also with the other ones,
12:16.0
very long conversation with Tita Roy, of course.
12:19.4
pwede niyo panorin yan sa YouTube.
12:22.7
But going back to this,
12:27.4
as much as I understand
12:32.3
yung suporta kay Tatay Digong,
12:35.0
as much as I understand
12:36.1
yung lalim ng frustration,
12:37.2
I mean, numbers, di ba?
12:46.5
hindi ako showbiz, eh.
12:48.5
Baka artist tayin,
12:49.6
pero hindi ako ma-showbiz.
12:51.2
Pero, balikan natin ito.
12:53.0
Actually, kanina,
12:53.8
dami mga pictures ng mga J-pop dito.
12:55.5
Tapos, kung mga ganun ako,
12:58.4
may second career pa tayo,
13:00.7
medyo zaddy lang,
13:05.0
balikan natin ito.
13:07.3
So, on the record,
13:10.3
non-scholarly work,
13:11.5
parati ko sinasabi,
13:14.0
bumoto kay Digong.
13:15.5
At naintindihan ko
13:16.4
bakit siya popular
13:17.2
because, in a way,
13:18.1
it was a protest vote.
13:20.4
nakaka-relate sila.
13:23.5
accessible si Digong.
13:26.3
Yung kanyang emotion,
13:27.4
regional resonance.
13:28.4
Mang galing siya sa audience impact.
13:31.4
I'm a speaker myself.
13:32.4
I deal with people.
13:33.4
Sometimes, I give a speech among,
13:34.4
you know, ten, ten,
13:37.4
20,000 yata nandun sa audience
13:41.4
Absolutely, naintindihan ko.
13:42.4
So, hindi ka tulad
13:43.4
yung mga dilawan,
13:44.4
mga judgmental snooty dyan.
13:46.4
I'm not gonna judge people
13:47.4
just because you voted for someone
13:49.4
na, sa tingin ko,
13:50.4
ay hindi karapat-dapat
13:51.4
naging presidente natin.
13:54.4
na, in fairness to President Duterte,
13:56.4
he did a few things
14:00.4
Uh, including especially,
14:02.4
dun sa Bangsamoro issue
14:05.4
Tsaka yung emphasis niya
14:06.4
dun sa infrastructure development
14:08.4
Sangayan ako kay Pangulong Duterte.
14:10.4
Tama siya. May mga tama talaga siya.
14:13.4
getting one or two things right
14:16.4
for tens of thousands of,
14:18.4
well, alleged extrajudicial killings.
14:20.4
It doesn't make up
14:21.4
for yung kapalpakan niya
14:23.4
yung cowardice and subservience
14:25.4
dyan sa West Philippine Sea.
14:30.4
China will protect me.
14:31.4
China this, China that.
14:33.4
Sobrang nakakaya talaga siya.
14:34.4
I'll be honest with you about it.
14:35.4
Yung ginawa niyang ganun.
14:37.4
I agree na dapat talagang
14:39.4
may pananagutan din
14:41.4
yung mga dating-dating mga aliado.
14:43.4
aminin natin medyo walang kwenta naman talaga
14:45.4
yung mga aliado natin dati.
14:46.4
Hindi tayo tinulungan sa,
14:48.4
sa Panatak Shoal.
14:49.4
Hindi tayo tinulungan talaga dun sa,
14:51.4
sa Panganiban Reef.
14:55.4
but you don't, as I said,
14:56.4
you don't burn down the hen house
14:57.4
to get the fried chicken.
15:00.4
pwede kang mukha ng fried chicken.
15:01.4
Pasok ka lang doon.
15:02.4
Kunin mo lang yung manok
15:04.4
Hindi mo pwede isu yung buong ano
15:05.4
para lang makukuha ka ng fried chicken.
15:08.4
Means shape ends.
15:10.4
Bad means poison the ends.
15:12.4
So, yun ang disagreement ko kay Machiavelli.
15:15.4
The end doesn't justify the means
15:17.4
because the means can poison the end
15:19.4
if the means are bad.
15:21.4
So, yung bara-bara niyang approach
15:23.4
sa foreign policy,
15:24.4
sa West Philippine Sea,
15:26.4
sa human rights issue,
15:27.4
lahat ng mga yan,
15:28.4
hindi pwede na makancel lang mga yan
15:30.4
dahil tama siya sa issue ng Bangsamoro.
15:32.4
Dahil tama siya sa,
15:35.4
a number of issues.
15:37.4
agree naman ako kay Digong
15:38.4
na ang malaking problema ng Pilipinas
15:40.4
So, kanina sabi ko,
15:44.4
ng ating Kongreso
15:45.4
ay hawak ng mga political dynasties,
15:47.4
including, of course,
15:51.4
and that's where I'll compare it with Japan.
15:52.4
So, dito sa Japan,
15:53.4
the 40 richest families dito sa Japan,
15:56.4
control barely over 2-3%
15:58.4
ng total newly created growth.
16:05.4
1-2% GDP growth they have.
16:08.4
yung mga oligarchs,
16:09.4
totoong oligarchs,
16:10.4
kasi kung magaling naman talaga sila,
16:12.4
baka di sila nag-invento ng mga bagong kotse,
16:14.4
dagang technology,
16:15.4
ba't wala tayong Sony,
16:16.4
ba't wala tayong,
16:20.4
Ang tagal-tagal ng oligarkiya
16:21.4
yung mga oligarchs natin.
16:26.4
40 richest families in the Philippines
16:28.4
took home 76% of newly created growth.
16:32.4
Ito yung data ng World Bank.
16:34.4
World Bank yan, ha.
16:35.4
Data ng World Bank yan.
16:36.4
Nang may isang dilawan na ekonomist
16:38.4
sila nag-comment,
16:39.4
saan niya kinuha yan?
16:40.4
Yan kasi hindi kasi kayo nag-re-research,
16:43.4
Yan ang problema ko dun sa mga dilawan na yan.
16:45.4
Feeling galing-galing,
16:47.4
pero hanggang ano.
16:53.4
Wala mo naman, guys.
16:54.4
International lang natin.
17:00.4
I think sometimes you have to put people
17:01.4
in the right place.
17:03.4
Umayas ayos sila.
17:05.4
Yan ang problema, guys.
17:06.4
You deserve better than this.
17:08.4
We deserve better than those
17:10.4
reformist presidents that we had
17:12.4
dahil dami nilang mga kakulangan.
17:14.4
And we deserve more than
17:15.4
yung mga dilawan na analyst na yan
17:17.4
na walang sinabi kundi disinformation.
17:20.4
Pag pumunta ka sa isang academic conference
17:23.4
disinformation ang dahilan
17:24.4
na may populism sa mundot,
17:28.4
Dahil sasabihin ng mga eksperto is,
17:29.4
yes, but it's barely 15-20% of the reason.
17:32.4
There are many, many complicated reasons.
17:36.4
Kaya nga sa social sciences,
17:37.4
whatever, may tinatawag na proximate cause
17:39.4
versus structural cause,
17:41.4
so on and so forth.
17:42.4
Independent variable,
17:43.4
intervening variable,
17:44.4
I can go on and on and on about it.
17:46.4
So, pag sinabi mo,
17:47.4
lahat na nangyari sa Pilmes
17:48.4
dahil lang sa disinformation,
17:50.4
pagtatawanan ka talaga
17:52.4
in any serious academic conference
17:53.4
around the world.
17:55.4
I mean, no wonder yung mga ibang dilawan dyan
17:57.4
never published in any serious publication.
17:59.4
I don't see them in Cambridge University Press,
18:01.4
I don't see them in Journal of Democracy,
18:04.4
barely I see them even publish op-eds
18:07.4
the top publications around the world.
18:09.4
Hindi ako nag-ibang.
18:10.4
I'm just telling you,
18:11.4
huwag kayong believe na believe
18:12.4
dun sa mga ibang dilawan dyan
18:13.4
dahil lang magaling mag-Ingles.
18:16.4
Huwag kayong believe na believe
18:17.4
dahil lang published sila dun sa
18:18.4
pa-Ingles-Ingles dyan.
18:20.4
A lot of these people,
18:22.4
hindi sila natututo.
18:24.4
Hindi sila nag-upgrade ng kanilang analysis.
18:26.4
Ang kanilang analysis ay mga ano pa.
18:31.4
nagigets ko saan galing
18:33.4
yung popularidad ni Duterte.
18:36.4
Pero yung kanyang legacy talaga.
18:39.4
Yung kanyang legacy talaga, guys.
18:43.4
Grabe naman, guys.
18:45.4
Ang laki ng utang
18:47.4
na namanan ni BBM.
18:50.4
Kawabo naman si BBM.
18:52.4
Sobrang palpak yung management ng pandemic.
18:56.4
Worst in Southeast Asia
18:58.4
yung ating management ng pandemic.
19:00.4
From 2020 to 2021,
19:02.4
we had five quarters of recession.
19:04.4
No ASEAN country had that.
19:06.4
In fact, Vietnam nga,
19:07.4
nag-grow yung economy nila.
19:10.4
nag-grow pa nga yung economy nila.
19:12.4
nag-grow pa nga yung economy nila.
19:13.4
Sobrang palpak. Diba?
19:19.4
yung humanitarian catastrophe.
19:20.4
Yung nakakaya naman
19:22.4
pinagsasabihin niya na
19:23.4
I love you, ganyan-ganyan.
19:24.4
This country will protect me
19:26.4
habang binubully yung mga
19:28.4
Nakakaya talaga, guys.
19:31.4
yung pagkakaren pa.
19:35.4
medyo agree naman ako
19:37.4
na may mga kakulangan
19:38.4
yung mga dating administration.
19:41.4
kumpara mo naman yung economic records ni Pinoy
19:43.4
o yung economic record ni Ramos,
19:45.4
even yung economic record ni Tita Arroyo,
19:47.4
napaka ano naman.
19:48.4
Considering what they know,
19:49.4
considering what they inherited,
19:51.4
and what they passed down,
19:54.4
Grabe naman, diba?
19:56.4
Si Ramos inherited a totally broken system,
20:00.4
kay Corazon Aquino.
20:01.4
Total debt crisis.
20:03.4
ginawa tayo yung isa sa mga
20:05.4
rising Asian tiger economies.
20:07.4
And then, of course,
20:08.4
nagkataon, Asian financial crisis
20:11.4
But in fairness naman kay Ramos,
20:13.4
he got some things right.
20:14.4
Now, he got also a lot of things wrong
20:16.4
na mahabang usapan yan.
20:19.4
Si Arroyo, kay Arap pa nga siya eh
20:22.4
In fairness naman,
20:24.4
inayos-ayos na yung mga regulatory issues.
20:26.4
So si, hey, hindi ako,
20:27.4
hindi ako kampo-kampo.
20:28.4
I think if you did,
20:34.4
maraming ginawang maayos na
20:37.4
monetary reforms,
20:38.4
infrastructure build-up,
20:40.4
Pero alam nyo naman ang issue, okay?
20:43.4
From Hello Garcia onwards,
20:44.4
maraming pinag-usapan.
20:48.4
Nung natapos si Pinoy,
20:50.4
ang laki ng budget
20:52.4
na namanan ni Digong sa kanya.
20:56.4
Ang gandang ekonomiya na nakuha niya.
21:00.4
almost 7% growth,
21:01.4
fastest growing economy.
21:03.4
Andun ang Pilipinas sa book na
21:05.4
Breakout Nations ni Rushi Sharma
21:07.4
na sa aking palagay,
21:11.4
sa emerging markets.
21:14.4
Basayan yung book na yan.
21:15.4
Andun pa nga yung interview niya
21:18.4
even if para sa akin,
21:19.4
maraming kakulangan
21:20.4
yung mga reformist presidents natin,
21:22.4
to a certain level na Roy, no?
21:26.4
yung nakuha ni Digong nung 2016
21:29.4
and then dun sa naiwan niya.
21:31.4
to make matters more complicated,
21:34.4
To make matters more complicated,
21:36.4
grabe naman, guys.
21:38.4
Grabe naman, guys.
21:40.4
mag-retire ka na,
21:41.4
private citizen ka na kunyari,
21:43.4
ayan na naman tayo eh.
21:45.4
Ayan na naman tayo eh.
21:47.4
Kinarin mo na nga
21:48.4
yung dating presidente.
21:51.4
lahat na lang sinisi sa dati.
21:53.4
Eh six years ka nga nasa pader?
21:55.4
Six years ka na nasa pader?
21:59.4
Kung magre-reklamo ka ng ganyan,
22:03.4
nung six years nandun-dun ka?
22:05.4
Inayos mo ba ang Marawi?
22:07.4
Nareconstruct mo ba yung Marawi?
22:09.4
Yung problema ng droga,
22:12.4
three to six months,
22:13.4
kamusta yung mga totoong pigfish?
22:15.4
Hindi yung mga ano-ano dyan,
22:16.4
yung mga totoong big fish.
22:19.4
pangalanan ba natin?
22:22.4
Galit ka daw sa oligarchs
22:23.4
habang biglang yung isa na ano,
22:25.4
biglang billionaire na yung iba dyan.
22:26.4
O, may Duterte-garchs, diba?
22:28.4
Ang tayo ko dyan.
22:31.4
Ang dami kong pwedeng pag-usapan.
22:33.4
Mahabang listahan po yan.
22:37.4
ang daming hanash.
22:38.4
Eh gusto mga mga federalist
22:40.4
yung constitutional change dyan.
22:42.4
gaganyang-ganyay mo lang.
22:45.4
kinarin mo nga yung dati.
22:46.4
Kakarin mo pa yung sumunod sa'yo.
22:50.4
purong ikaw na lang.
22:54.4
Best in the solar system nga,
22:55.4
sabi ng mga kaibigan natin dyan.
23:00.4
hindi lang si Michael.
23:02.4
Maraming pa tayong mga pangalanan.
23:04.4
O, alam nyo na, guys.
23:06.4
Huwag nag-iisip ka talaga.
23:08.4
I-google mo lang.
23:09.4
Alam nyo na this, guys.
23:10.4
Alam nyo na this.
23:12.4
Alam nyo na this talaga, guys.
23:22.4
Talaga, pound for pound king.
23:24.4
From jet ski boy to budol boy.
23:32.4
Ginaganyan lang si BBM.
23:33.4
Binabastos lang yung presidente natin.
23:35.4
Hindi ko binoto yung isa dyan.
23:38.4
Marami akong mga reservations.
23:41.4
presidente na natin yan.
23:42.4
O, sasabihin ng iba.
23:43.4
Presidente ng mga SD cards.
23:46.4
Mag-prove na kayo dyan.
23:48.4
as far as I know,
23:49.4
officially siya yung presidente natin.
23:54.4
yung kasalukuyan na presidente
23:55.4
na ganyan-ganyan lang.
23:58.4
Yakuza muna na sa PEDEA list.
24:04.4
Yung mayor ka lang,
24:05.4
ba't ka bibigay ng PEDEA
24:10.4
galit na galit ka sa PI.
24:11.4
PI ka ng PI sa PI.
24:17.4
diba gusto mong magpa-federal?
24:24.4
sabi na incitement to rebellion
24:26.4
yung ginagawa niya.
24:28.4
yung mga pro-DDS na mga vloggers,
24:30.4
isi-spin nila yan,
24:31.4
na hindi yan incitement,
24:35.4
magka-criticize ka lang ng konti,
24:37.4
lalagay ka lang dun sa matrix niya,
24:40.4
Lalagay ka lang sa destabilizer list,
24:45.4
openly kinakall-out ng ganyan.
24:50.4
Alam ba naman tayo dyan,
24:55.4
dito ako naging emotion,
24:56.4
every time nandun ako sa mga kapidbahay natin,
25:00.4
kung nasa Europe tayo,
25:04.4
iba kasi mga bansang yan,
25:05.4
but every time nandun tayo sa mga kapidbahay,
25:06.4
na mas maunlat sa atin,
25:08.4
kaya nga tayo hindi umuunlat?
25:09.4
Palpak na nga yung leaders natin.
25:10.4
Tayo pa yung naawa sa kanila.
25:13.4
Tayo pa nga kinakawawa.
25:14.4
Tayo pa nga nagdi-defend sa kanila.
25:16.4
Tayo pa nga nag-apologize para sa kanila.
25:19.4
Anong klase tayong bansa?
25:21.4
Kailan tayo aakyat?
25:22.4
Kailan tayo babangon?
25:25.4
Kung ganyan ang mindset natin.
25:26.4
Sabi nga ni Rizal,
25:33.4
if there are no slaves.
25:35.4
There will be no currents
25:41.4
may sasabihin ako pero kinontrol ko na.
25:49.4
sasabihin nung isa,
25:50.4
maghihiwalay na daw yung Mindanao.
25:55.4
as if hindi niyo kontroladong
25:58.4
Andun ba sa rally nila?
26:00.4
Andun ba si rally nila?
26:01.4
Yung taga Bangsamoro?
26:03.4
Si Hedge Morad nandun?
26:05.4
Andun ba yung mga governors
26:06.4
ng mga ibang Mindanao provinces?
26:09.4
Central Mindanao?
26:10.4
Western Mindanao?
26:13.4
Kayo ka lang niyan
26:17.4
Ayan na naman tayo dyan eh.
26:22.4
I see other governors
26:23.4
and other top officials
26:25.4
galing sa Mindanao
26:28.4
ano ninyong tatay,
26:31.4
that this has currency anymore.
26:34.4
may sarili ng ano yan eh.
26:36.4
Bakit may ganyan?
26:39.4
Wala nga itong TikTok na
26:41.4
nilalagay tayo ng...
26:44.4
Biglang may ano na ako dito sa...
26:48.4
And let me be absolutely clear,
26:51.4
mga kameta, okay?
26:53.4
Excuse me lang ah.
26:55.4
This is an important data, okay?
26:57.4
Yung blue is revenues raised,
27:06.4
nag-raise ng taxes
27:10.4
National Capital Region.
27:11.4
Tingnan niyo, yung blue
27:12.4
ay mas malaki sa red.
27:13.4
Kitang-kita niyo?
27:15.4
Yung blue ay mas malaki sa red.
27:17.4
Yung blue mas malaki sa red.
27:20.4
So, ito yung data galing
27:22.4
sa Philippine Statistics Authority.
27:24.4
Ang National Capital Region,
27:26.4
kung saan tayo galing,
27:31.4
billion neto, no?
27:33.4
Billion nung 2021.
27:35.4
Pero ang ginastos lang natin
27:38.4
So, meron kang almost
27:39.4
70 billion na extra.
27:41.4
Kaya saan pumunta yan?
27:43.4
Now, look at the same graph
27:44.4
and look at different regions
27:46.4
especially ang Mindanao region.
27:48.4
Essentially, guys,
27:50.4
I'll post it sa baba.
27:53.4
Essentially, guys,
27:57.4
NCR ang nagsasubsidize
27:59.4
ng ibang mga LGUs.
28:02.4
Dahil hindi sila nag-raise
28:04.4
ng sufficient revenues
28:06.4
galing sa sarili nila.
28:10.4
ayaw tumulong yung mga ating mga kababayan
28:12.4
from Mindanao region.
28:15.4
yung mga supra-trapos
28:17.4
sila ang nakahawak
28:19.4
dyan sa mga iba't-ibang.
28:21.4
So, isa pa yung...
28:22.4
This is a different data.
28:23.4
Revenue collection.
28:24.4
Tingnan nyo sa image.
28:26.4
Tingnan nyo gano ka dark
28:30.4
The darker the area,
28:31.4
that means the more revenues
28:33.4
Tingnan nyo gano ka laki?
28:35.4
Tingnan nyo gano ka laki?
28:36.4
Tingnan nyo gano ka laki?
28:40.4
tayo sa NCR talaga.
28:42.4
Ayan na naman tayo.
28:44.4
NCR because oligarch capital.
28:46.4
Kuya, nagbabayad ba
28:50.4
nagbabayad po ng revenues
28:51.4
yung mga ordinaryong tao po.
28:54.4
Syntax pa lang yung mga gano'n.
28:56.4
mag-isip naman kasi kayo
28:57.4
bago kayo magsalita.
28:58.4
Papaya na naman na kayo sa sarili.
29:00.4
Ayan na naman kasi tayo.
29:02.4
Tingnan nyo gano ka laki
29:04.4
yung contribution natin sa NCR.
29:08.4
ang implication na ito ay very clear.
29:10.4
Even sa rice production.
29:12.4
Thanks pala kay Sir Ivan
29:14.4
kasi may pinost din siya dyan.
29:16.4
But I also had my other death.
29:19.4
Ipo-post ko rin dyan mga kamets.
29:20.4
Don't worry about it.
29:22.4
And you can go and Google it on yourself.
29:25.4
Maraming ebidensya
29:27.4
na yung mga trapos at dynasties
29:29.4
dun sa mga ibang riyon ng country natin,
29:31.4
sarili lang nilang iniisip nila.
29:33.4
Yung pamilya lang nilang iniisip nila.
29:35.4
I'm not gonna name names.
29:36.4
But I've been to many provinces.
29:38.4
Beautiful tourist destinations.
29:40.4
Na alam ko ang laki nang kinikita nila sa mga turista.
29:45.4
Walang matinong asfalte.
29:47.4
Walang matinong infrastruktur.
29:48.4
O alam natin saan pumupunta yung pera.
29:51.4
So the reality is actually
29:53.4
sinesubsidized ng ordinary taxpayer sa NCR
29:57.4
yung mga iba't ibang probinsya across the country.
30:01.4
And unfortunately, dahil sa Mindanao, dahil napaka
30:03.4
lakas yung hawak ng mga dynasties and warlords,
30:07.4
dahil napaka-concentrated yung power
30:11.4
at napaka-hinay yung mga institutions.
30:14.4
Napaka-hinay yung mga institutions.
30:16.4
Talagang umaasa sila sa subsidy.
30:21.4
So in a federalized system guys,
30:23.4
ang mangyayari dito,
30:24.4
yung ngayon filter sa TikTok,
30:25.4
pag ganyan ko may shades na ako, may ganyan.
30:28.4
So kung mag-federalize tayo guys,
30:31.4
lalong magka-concentrate,
30:32.4
yung wealth sa Metro Manila and NCR and developed regions
30:36.4
because hindi na kailangan mag-subsidize ng ibang region,
30:38.4
kanya-kanyang discarta na yan.
30:40.4
Yun kasi dapat naisipin.
30:42.4
Yung mga magagaling at malalaking business,
30:44.4
lalong pupunta sa Manila yan.
30:46.4
So to give you a very good example,
30:47.4
look at the United States.
30:49.4
Ang tagal na nilang federal.
30:51.4
Ngayon, alam ko yung mga iba dyan na nag-United States,
30:54.4
nagka-California, New York lang.
30:56.4
Now punta kayo dun sa mga ibang estado.
30:58.4
I'm not gonna say which states,
30:59.4
but you know which states.
31:00.4
You go to many states,
31:01.4
in the middle of America,
31:02.4
south of, but north of United States,
31:04.4
ang layo nung agwat nila
31:07.4
dun sa hindi lang kultura,
31:09.4
yung levels of development sa New York,
31:12.4
sa mga big coastal cities.
31:16.4
na pinakamayaman na bansa,
31:18.4
at least in terms of size of the GDP in nominal terms,
31:21.4
kitang-kitang mga laki nung agwat.
31:25.4
Kaya yung mga magagaling na bata,
31:27.4
matatalinong bata,
31:28.4
pumunta na lang sila sa New York.
31:31.4
kaya pala may kilala tayo
31:34.4
at pumunta nag-aaral sa California,
31:37.4
Usually ganun yung story, diba?
31:39.4
Or galing sa mahirap na lugar sa Midwest,
31:41.4
pumunta mag-aaral sa Yale,
31:44.4
and then mag-stay na dun,
31:45.4
hindi na bumabalik.
31:46.4
So we have very clear examples
31:48.4
in very, very developed countries,
31:51.4
na yung mga inequalities will persist over time.
31:55.4
At yung mga siwa dyan na nagsasabi,
31:57.4
eh, pag inayos natin,
32:00.4
pag binuksan natin ang sarili natin
32:02.4
sa lahat ng foreign investors,
32:03.4
magically maging okay tayo.
32:06.4
Alam nyo ba ang China at Vietnam
32:08.4
na napaka-bilis ng growth nila?
32:10.4
Ang dami nilang capital,
32:11.4
foreign capital restrictions.
32:13.4
Ang isang dahilan na napaka-successful
32:15.4
yung mga country na yan,
32:16.4
aside from geography and geopolitics,
32:18.4
is actually trade and industrial policy.
32:20.4
Now, if you want to know more about it,
32:22.4
please check, just go to YouTube,
32:24.4
put, hey, Darion, industrial policy, trade policy.
32:26.4
Tignan nyo, guys, yung mga explanation natin,
32:29.4
why those factors are important.
32:31.4
O, diba? I promise you guys to be serious.
32:33.4
To be serious about this topic.
32:35.4
May pang-infentan lang gano'n.
32:37.4
So, walang kwenta yung argument na
32:41.4
pag nag-ganyan tayo,
32:43.4
automatic lahat ang problema natin na hindi mawala.
32:46.4
I completely understand yung sentimento sa Mindanao
32:49.4
at yung mga ibang region ng bansa natin
32:51.4
na gusto kong humiwalay or something.
32:52.4
I completely understand.
32:53.4
I'll tell you what.
32:54.4
I'll tell you what.
32:56.4
Tagabagyo ako, diba?
32:57.4
Kami nga ng Tagabagyo,
32:59.4
meron din kami minsan inis sa mga taga-Manila.
33:03.4
Nyamet, paingat ka sa Teka Story.
33:05.4
O, Nyamet, palaingat.
33:09.4
Yung mga Ilocana dyan, mga Tagabagyo,
33:11.4
alam nyo na, diba? Yung mga sinisabi na.
33:15.4
pag pumunta ako sa Bagyo,
33:16.4
nag-Ilocana na lang ako dun sa mga,
33:18.4
para alam nila, one of the, ano diba?
33:21.4
Kasi alam ko, may meron talagang resentment.
33:24.4
Kasi, gets ko, guys.
33:26.4
I understand the sentiment.
33:29.4
But sentiment doesn't get you national success.
33:33.4
Parang gilas yan eh.
33:34.4
Hindi pwede purong puso lang.
33:35.4
Kailangan ng talento.
33:36.4
Kailangan ng diskarte.
33:37.4
Kailangan ng practice.
33:38.4
Kailangan ng magaling na coach.
33:40.4
Hindi pwede purong...
33:41.4
At yun ang problema ko.
33:43.4
Ang ating demokrasya is a popularity contest.
33:47.4
Kaya napakasyong nga yung argument na sabihin mo,
33:49.4
eh, ang taos ng popularity.
33:52.4
Misa nga yung mga popular,
33:54.4
yung pa yung mga palpak eh.
33:55.4
Dahil, alam mo na,
33:56.4
madali naman yung popular.
33:57.4
Pamigay-migay ka lang,
33:59.4
kawawa na yung bansa.
34:00.4
Usually, yung mga mga galing land leaders,
34:03.4
Because they do the difficult things.
34:05.4
I'll give you an example.
34:06.4
It's like having a good parent.
34:07.4
Diba yung isang parent mo,
34:14.4
Gustong-gusto mo siya.
34:15.4
Tapos yung isang parent mo,
34:17.4
dahil ayaw niya maging kawawa yung pamilya,
34:19.4
tataas ang utang,
34:21.4
babawasan niya yung mga excess expenditure niyo.
34:25.4
sino mas popular sa kanilang dalawa?
34:27.4
Yung irresponsable
34:28.4
or yung responsable?
34:30.4
Most likely, mas popular,
34:31.4
yung irresponsable.
34:33.4
Right? Do you understand what I'm saying?
34:35.4
So, popularity does not equate
34:39.4
Sometimes, inversely related yung dalawa na yan.
34:42.4
In fact, in history,
34:43.4
you have many examples.
34:44.4
Hindi ko na sasabihin na
34:45.4
mga Kim Jong Un, Saddam,
34:46.4
yung mga dictator na yan.
34:47.4
But, many problematic people
34:49.4
had very high approval rating.
34:50.4
So, please lang, don't say,
34:52.4
hindi ito popularity contest.
34:54.4
This is about competence.
34:57.4
Alam mo dito sa Japan,
34:58.4
alam mo yung approval rating
34:59.4
ng prime minister nila,
35:04.4
So, you're telling me
35:05.4
na si Digong na 90%
35:07.4
ay 4-5 times more competent
35:13.4
Magtawa na nalang tayo dito, di ba?
35:15.4
Do you get what I'm saying?
35:16.4
Kaya na, dumb yung argument na
35:18.4
kung mataas yung popularity,
35:19.4
mas competent din.
35:21.4
It's a dumb argument.
35:27.4
Dumb argument, okay?
35:29.4
But, again, sabi ko nga,
35:30.4
I completely understand
35:32.4
yung sentiment ng tao.
35:33.4
Kasi sentiments comes from
35:34.4
decades and history of frustration.
35:37.4
Now, does that mean na ngayon
35:42.4
talon naman tayo doon sa kapilang kampo?
35:46.4
Sometimes, pwede ka rin na
35:47.4
mababa rin approval
35:49.4
at palpak ka rin.
35:50.4
Hindi naman mutually exclusive yan.
35:51.4
But, I'm just saying,
35:52.4
just because mataas ang approval mo,
35:53.4
hindi ibig sabihin na magaling ka.
35:55.4
In fact, sometimes,
35:56.4
it means the opposite.
35:57.4
But, it is very possible also,
36:00.4
na mababa yung approval mo
36:02.4
at palpak ka rin.
36:06.4
I'm not discounting that.
36:07.4
But, yung Kishida,
36:08.4
yung Prime Minister dito,
36:09.4
I don't think he's incompetent.
36:10.4
Pero, yung approval niya
36:13.4
na he is one-fourth
36:17.4
of competence of,
36:20.4
or he's like one-half
36:21.4
competence of Trump,
36:23.4
na 40% approval or something?
36:24.4
Do you get what I'm saying?
36:26.4
Kaya nga stupid yung argument na yan.
36:28.4
Sorry again to say it.
36:29.4
But, it's really ridiculous.
36:31.4
Nakakaya yung mga ganyan na arguments.
36:33.4
It doesn't belong
36:34.4
in a proper intelligent conversation.
36:37.4
Let's just be very clear about that.
36:40.4
let's go to the second part of our discussion.
36:42.4
negation of negation.
36:44.4
na automatically support na mo naman
36:48.4
O, yung mga ka-Pepsi diyan.
36:53.4
Now, I've been absolutely clear.
36:55.4
That I do believe
36:57.4
that our current president
36:58.4
is doing the right things
36:59.4
sa West Philippine Sea.
37:01.4
Now, we can have a long discussion
37:02.4
about the circumstances of that.
37:04.4
O, dahil ba yan sa...
37:06.4
Magpapogi sa West?
37:08.4
We can have a long conversation
37:09.4
about intentions.
37:10.4
But in terms of effect
37:11.4
and formal policy,
37:12.4
I think President Ferdinand Marco Jr.
37:14.4
is doing the right thing
37:15.4
sa West Philippine Sea.
37:17.4
Is it free of risk?
37:19.4
Is it 100% correct?
37:22.4
But is it in general
37:23.4
in the right direction?
37:27.4
So, I'm very clear about that.
37:29.4
But, does that mean
37:30.4
na just because gusto natin
37:32.4
yung foreign policy niya
37:33.4
or just because mas gusto mo siya
37:35.4
rather than yung kabila,
37:39.4
okay ka na sa kanya 100%?
37:41.4
Okay ka na sa Maharlika Fund?
37:43.4
Okay ka na sa People's Initiative?
37:45.4
Although, in fairness,
37:46.4
to be fair to the President,
37:49.4
And so on and so forth.
37:51.4
So on and so forth.
37:52.4
Now, in fairness,
37:53.4
I appreciate yung paglaya
38:01.4
Ang habang araw to.
38:02.4
I appreciate yung recalibration of drug war.
38:06.4
But I need to see way, way, way
38:10.4
Including on the economic front.
38:12.4
Including in terms of inflation management,
38:14.4
quality infrastructure
38:17.4
in terms of bringing high quality investments,
38:20.4
so on and so forth.
38:23.4
I'll give you a good score
38:25.4
But I'm still gonna look at other issues.
38:28.4
Now, having said that,
38:29.4
actually, one issue I also have with
38:31.4
President Marco Jr. right now is
38:42.4
Dapat mas forceful yung response niya
38:49.4
Kasi kung conflict avoidan ka,
38:53.4
you're inviting, essentially,
38:57.4
And as I said nga,
38:58.4
one of the biggest paradoxes
39:01.4
the conflict avoidant president
39:02.4
is also facing a lot of crisis
39:04.4
Because the more conflict avoidant you are,
39:05.4
the more you're welcoming.
39:07.4
The more you're welcoming challenges
39:08.4
and contestation.
39:09.4
Guys, i-ano lang natin,
39:10.4
block lang natin itong mga ano,
39:12.4
Ang maunggoy dito.
39:25.4
Block natin itong mga
39:29.4
Okay, okay, okay, okay, okay.
39:33.4
Block din natin ito si,
39:35.4
Obvious na, obvious na.
39:36.4
Fake ang account.
39:41.4
Two thousand ang fina-follow niya talagang
39:43.4
mga kalakaran ng,
39:44.4
kalakaran ng troll.
39:48.4
Okay, may mga low life dyan pero
39:50.4
kailangan nila kumita.
39:53.4
Isa rin ang issue ko.
39:54.4
Marami pa rin ng tolos
39:55.4
kasi alam ko mataas ang inflation
39:57.4
kailangan kumita ng iba
39:58.4
kaya pagbigyan natin.
40:03.4
Hindi na rin, hindi na rin
40:04.4
kailangan mo to write.
40:05.4
Actually guys, I enjoy it.
40:07.4
Kasi sabi ko nga,
40:08.4
kung naniwala ka talaga sa sinasabi mo,
40:09.4
kung may conviction ka sa buhay,
40:11.4
alright, di ka ma-intimidate.
40:13.4
In fact, matutuwa ka pa
40:15.4
mga low life na ganyan.
40:18.4
Anyway, and I feel flattered
40:19.4
and thank you for pushing up my engagement
40:21.4
but going back to this,
40:27.4
kaya kanina may survey tayo.
40:29.4
Sabi ko, ano dapat ang response ni BBM dito?
40:34.4
medyo next level na to eh.
40:37.4
Incitement to secession, to rebellion,
40:40.4
openly akusahan ka na gumagamit ka ng droga, etc.
40:43.4
which, you know, the president rightfully said,
40:45.4
I'm not even gonna dignify that kind of question.
40:47.4
Now, pwede natin pag-usapan
40:49.4
ano yung kasaysayan ng isang tao.
40:50.4
Parang, pwede natin pag-usapan, ano yung kasaysayan ng isang tao.
40:51.4
But, you know what?
40:52.4
As far as I know,
40:54.4
there's no evidence that, you know,
40:56.4
you know what I'm gonna say, right?
40:58.4
Um, but as I said,
41:00.4
if you have something, go ahead.
41:01.4
But, as far as I know,
41:04.4
hindi eto yung sabog sa foreign policy natin.
41:07.4
Hindi eto yung sabog na hindi niya makompleto yung sasabihin niya.
41:09.4
Hindi eto yung sabog na, ano,
41:11.4
alas 1am magbibigay ng speech or...
41:19.4
Kailangan magpaano yung isa, diba?
41:22.4
Sir, magkano ka naman dyan?
41:23.4
Pahinga ng konti.
41:25.4
Pahinga-pahinga naman dyan.
41:27.4
balikan natin eto.
41:33.4
There's a lot that has to be fixed.
41:36.4
There's a lot that is lacking.
41:41.4
kaya nga ang point ko is,
41:43.4
ang challenge talaga dito is,
41:44.4
ano ba talaga dapat ang gagawin ng totoong oposisyon?
41:48.4
Now, alam ko maraming galit sa akin sa totoong oposisyon.
41:50.4
Actually, hindi eh.
41:52.4
Ang mga galit sa akin ay,
41:54.4
well, alam nyo yung isang banda.
41:58.4
yung mga galit sa akin, yung mga iba,
41:59.4
nag-binooking ko talaga na hindi sila updated, hindi sila upgraded.
42:03.4
Now, I'm sorry guys.
42:06.4
You know, I'm a...
42:09.4
You know, if you're really a good educator,
42:11.4
you're compassionate,
42:13.4
you're understanding,
42:15.4
but you will be tough when you need to be tough
42:17.4
to push people to be the best version of themselves.
42:20.4
In a very judicious way.
42:22.4
Sobrang nainis talaga ako dati kasi
42:25.4
pinipilit pa rin yung disinformation ito,
42:28.4
disinformation ito,
42:29.4
pinipilit pa rin yung argumento na
42:31.4
nung nanala si Marcos Junior,
42:32.4
ito nang katapusan ng Pilipinas,
42:39.4
O, i-google nyo na ang ibisa ng puerile.
42:41.4
It's intellectually puerile.
42:42.4
It's politically self-defeating.
42:44.4
I'll be just brutally honest about it.
42:46.4
Now, hindi nila ako iniimbitas sa mga events nila.
42:57.4
May sasabihin naman ako pero control ko naman sa sarili.
43:00.4
Sabihin naman nila mayabang tong batang to.
43:02.4
Hindi kasi, guys.
43:03.4
Ayoko yung pahambal effect na hambog naman talaga.
43:07.4
Mas maganda na hindi ka pahambal effect.
43:10.4
But actually, deep inside,
43:11.4
you're willing to learn.
43:12.4
In fact, that's the reason why I'm open to collaboration.
43:14.4
Whether ito si crush ng bayan na si Ronald Alden,
43:19.4
may sagri ako na mas tama siya,
43:23.4
parang mas tama na naman ako kay Ronald.
43:26.4
tingnan nyo naman yung response ni BBM.
43:32.4
Okay daw ang lahat sa unit team.
43:35.4
And then beso-beso with Sarah.
43:38.4
Buti pa nga yung first lady.
43:41.4
O medyo nagpakita ng discontent.
43:43.4
Di na siya nag-hi-hi-hello.
43:44.4
Gumanon na lang siya doon sa departure speech.
43:46.4
Ipapost ko rin yung video.
43:47.4
Ipapost ko rin yung video niya.
43:48.4
Hindi ko napost kasi ang daan akong ginagawa.
43:52.4
the president has to draw the line once in a while.
43:54.4
You have to show you're the president.
43:55.4
You have the mandate of people.
43:56.4
Yung tangal ng opisinay na sa'yo.
43:59.4
And then, sabi nung isang kapatid niya
44:01.4
na nag-apologize naman daw yung isang mayor,
44:03.4
yung anak ni ganito,
44:07.4
you have to show decisive leadership.
44:10.4
But the same also goes for the opposition.
44:12.4
They have to also show decisive leadership.
44:15.4
kung talagang humble case,
44:17.4
you're willing to listen.
44:18.4
I won't say corrected.
44:20.4
you get different perspective.
44:21.4
Kaya natuwa ako doon sa
44:23.4
conversation namin ni Ronald Diaz mas kapon.
44:27.4
in fairness, may mga efforts naman behind the scenes.
44:30.4
one thing that I'm very happy about
44:35.4
there's growing openness
44:37.4
to the idea of a grand opposition,
44:39.4
a grand coalition.
44:40.4
I mean, from Franz Castro
44:42.4
and the center-left-left
44:43.4
all the way to Riza Ontiveros
44:46.4
So, left-center-left.
44:48.4
to Liberal Party,
44:53.4
We're seeing embers of that.
44:54.4
And yung term na ginamit ni,
44:57.4
dati kong professor,
44:59.4
According to Ronald Diaz,
45:00.4
di ko binabasa si Alex ngayon.
45:04.4
Notorious din ako ng estudyante.
45:07.4
Ako yung tipong estudyante.
45:08.4
Siguro, galit yan si Sir Alex sakin.
45:10.4
Ako yung klase ng estudyante na,
45:13.4
alam niyo yung first day of class,
45:16.4
tignan niyo yung syllabus, diba?
45:18.4
Tignan ako ng syllabus, diba?
45:20.4
Tignan ang syllabus.
45:23.4
Parang kulang ang syllabus mo.
45:29.4
may mga kaklase ako dati
45:31.4
na kung alam nila doon ako sa klase,
45:34.4
Ganon sila kagalit sa akin.
45:35.4
Kasi Karen daw ako.
45:37.4
Well, medyo may pagkakaren ako,
45:38.4
pero in a good way.
45:43.4
modern political thought?
45:44.4
Bakit wala si Nietzsche?
45:45.4
Bakit wala si Nietzsche?
45:46.4
Bakit wala si Dekide?
45:47.4
Bakit wala si Foucault?
45:49.4
O kulang yung mga readings natin.
45:50.4
Ganyan akong estudyante, guys.
45:51.4
Kaya ang daming galit sa akin
45:53.4
nung college pa lang.
45:55.4
Eh, hindi ba nakasalanan?
45:59.4
I want to learn the most.
46:01.4
Nagihirap yung ating mga parents
46:07.4
So, I want to make sure
46:08.4
when I go to a class,
46:10.4
You know, I have a world class education.
46:12.4
hindi galit si Sir
46:13.4
kasi pinagdagdag ko yung kanyang
46:17.4
yung idea ng PTSD
46:24.4
they don't take constructive criticism
46:26.4
in the wrong way.
46:28.4
And I hope na-appreciate nila
46:29.4
where we're coming from.
46:31.4
Kaya rin yung brutal to
46:33.4
I know we can do better
46:35.4
I know we can do better
46:37.4
I know the opposition
46:38.4
can do better than this.
46:42.4
I think President Duterte
46:45.4
I think President Duterte
46:46.4
was right to raise some questions
46:48.4
questions about our foreign policy
46:50.4
or our dependence on the US.
46:52.4
But the answers were horrible.
46:55.4
we have to fight against
46:57.4
but tignan mo namin
46:58.4
barabaran yung response.
47:00.4
With President BBM,
47:01.4
I think he has a good
47:02.4
foreign policy so far
47:03.4
at least given things.
47:07.4
on the domestic front
47:08.4
before, you know,
47:09.4
going out and saying
47:10.4
dapat yan ang supportahan natin
47:11.4
in the middle of this.
47:14.4
the opposition has to
47:18.4
I hope they don't take
47:19.4
things against us
47:20.4
when I point out certain things
47:22.4
independent voices.
47:23.4
And hindi naman ako
47:25.4
Maybe I know what
47:26.4
I'm talking about.
47:28.4
Maybe there's a reason why
47:29.4
all around the world
47:31.4
dahil maybe they know,
47:33.4
maybe I know something.
47:37.4
I'm just a human being.
47:38.4
I have my limitations.
47:40.4
but the Lord also knows
47:46.4
Like thinking is my life.
47:49.4
Kaya tayo nakapagsulat
47:51.4
Kaya tayo nakapag-vlogs
47:53.4
Kaya tayo nang-interview
47:55.4
Because I'm constantly
47:57.4
Wala akong time na
48:05.4
sa mga ganun, guys.
48:12.4
The rest is just reading
48:17.4
Before I sleep nowadays,
48:18.4
ito yung binabasa ko.
48:19.4
Ito yung libro ni Rizal.
48:21.4
Gandang libro yan.
48:22.4
I really suggest it
48:24.4
Very, very good book.
48:26.4
Ma-inspire ka talaga.
48:30.4
yung mga sakripisyon
48:31.4
na ginawa ng ating mga ninuno.
48:32.4
Mahiya naman tayo
48:34.4
Mahiya naman tayo
48:36.4
Mahiya naman tayo
48:38.4
Mahiya naman tayo
48:39.4
na konting ganyan lang.
48:48.4
atakin natin si Darian.
48:49.4
Ang kapal na mukha niya.
48:52.4
Ako yung Johnny Cumlaty.
48:53.4
Baka hindi ka lang nagbabasa.
48:57.4
Kaya wala tayong time
48:58.4
sa mga haliparot.
49:00.4
Actually, kahapon,
49:01.4
yung sa end ng meeting,
49:02.4
nagroponggi-roponggi
49:03.4
yung mga kasama ko.
49:04.4
Kumuwi na lang ako.
49:05.4
Nagvlog na lang tayo.
49:07.4
Hindi ako lumalabas sa gabi.
49:09.4
Nagvlog lang ako.
49:13.4
Social life, whatever.
49:16.4
nahihiya ako sa sarili ko
49:18.4
kung hindi ko ginawa yung best ko.
49:20.4
This is the least that I can do.
49:22.4
This is the least
49:30.4
kasi nag-heater ako.
49:31.4
Actually, malamig dito sa likid.
49:32.4
Sobrang lamig dito.
49:35.4
when it's hot and all,
49:36.4
lang nga ganyan ako.
49:47.4
thanks guys sa mga nakinig sa atin.
49:50.4
na-appreciate nyo itong ginagawa natin.
49:53.4
I start with some jokes,
49:59.4
But at the end of the day,
50:00.4
you see what I'm doing guys.
50:01.4
We eventually move towards
50:03.4
a proper serious discussion.
50:07.4
you had an introduction to Hegelian dialectics.
50:10.4
Negation of negation.
50:13.4
Yan ang critical thinking.
50:15.4
Ang critical thinking po ay hindi mag-criticize ka lang all the time.
50:21.4
A critical thinking is to criticize a bad criticism.
50:25.4
When you know what is a good criticism,
50:27.4
and you know what's a bad criticism,
50:29.4
then you're having critical thinking.
50:31.4
Pero yung banat ka lang ng banat na hindi nag-iisip,
50:37.4
ikaw lang ang banat sa mundo.
50:38.4
Yun yung sinasabi ko,
50:39.4
may ma-hurt na naman si Banat ba yung magka-comment eh.
50:42.4
May copyright na daw siya.
50:44.4
Eh, di ka mam say.
50:50.4
before you sleep,
50:51.4
kung mahal yun yung bansa,
50:52.4
maghanap kayo ng mga ganitong libro
50:53.4
na may inspire kayo.
50:56.4
I have the time and energy and all,
50:57.4
thanks to your support.
50:58.4
I'm hoping to have something like that.
51:00.4
collection of my writings and all,
51:01.4
and Rizal and all of that.
51:03.4
I'm also writing books on geopolitics,
51:12.4
one of the big advices of Marcos Aurelius was this,
51:15.4
the contemplation of the sage.
51:18.4
Every time na naiirapan kayo sa buhay,
51:21.4
every time na hindi kayo sure sa gagawin nyo,
51:23.4
isipin nyo yung tao na iniidolo nyo.
51:28.4
well, iniidolo is actually blasphemo, sorry.
51:30.4
As a man of faith,
51:32.4
I don't wanna use that term.
51:33.4
Think of a person that you look up to.
51:36.4
At sasabihin mo sa sarili mo,
51:38.4
anong gagawin ng taong ito
51:41.4
pag ganito yung kanyang dilema?
51:45.4
Do you think ang gagawin niya ay ganito or ganyan?
51:48.4
So, the contemplation of the sage,
51:49.4
that's the term that stoics use.
51:51.4
Very important yan.
51:52.4
So, every time naiirapan ka sa buhay,
51:54.4
every time na gusto mo mag-back out,
51:56.4
every time na naguguloan ka or confused ka and all,
52:00.4
yung tao na nire-respeto mo,
52:02.4
anong gagawin niya sa ganitong situation?
52:08.4
as a proud Filipina,
52:09.4
I will always ask,
52:10.4
what would Rizal do?
52:11.4
I'm not saying I'm like Rizal in all of that.
52:13.4
Lahat naman tayo may sariling,
52:15.4
babash na naman ako.
52:17.4
I always ask myself,
52:18.4
what would Rizal do?
52:25.4
Well, guess what?
52:27.4
I think Rizal would have been a vlogger.
52:29.4
I think Rizal would exactly do
52:31.4
what we're trying to do here.
52:33.4
To write the top publications around the world,
52:35.4
to do the scholarly work,
52:36.4
to fight the good fight,
52:38.4
but also to vlog.
52:44.4
To be truly humble,
52:46.4
not kunyaring humble,
52:48.4
and to call out nonsense.
52:50.4
To call out nonsense.
52:52.4
Including your own nonsense.
52:56.4
thank you very much.
52:57.4
Maraming salamat,
52:58.4
including sa mga trolls natin
52:59.4
na tinataas yung ating engagement.
53:01.4
I always appreciate that.
53:03.4
I always appreciate that.
53:05.4
I appreciate that.
53:08.4
and talk to you soon.
53:10.4
And yeah, of course,
53:11.4
there are many, many other great books.
53:12.4
There are other books kasi, guys, na...
53:14.4
I'm writing a review, by the way,
53:16.4
probably I also have to start doing
53:18.4
serious book reviews and all.
53:20.4
I mean, we can go with, you know,
53:24.4
Fathers and Sons,
53:25.4
and we can go Gogol,
53:26.4
and War and Peace,
53:30.4
what is Book of Ambeth,
53:32.4
Patricia Vangelista,
53:34.4
mga books closest to my heart,
53:37.4
the book that I think was responsible for me,
53:39.4
like Falling in Love with the Legacy of Our Forefathers,
53:44.4
you know, I can go on and on about it,
53:45.4
but yun lang, guys.
53:48.4
We are serious people.
53:50.4
We joke here and there,
53:51.4
we make humor and all,
53:52.4
but we are serious people.
53:54.4
And God willing, sana,
53:55.4
I can write enough so that I can put them together,
53:59.4
I don't think I can separate, right?
54:00.4
But I can put something nice together
54:03.4
But thank you so much, guys,
54:04.4
dito sa continuous support niyo.
54:06.4
Ito yung tiwala niyo sa akin.
54:08.4
Kahit minsan nagbibiro lang ako,
54:11.4
dahil tao lang pa eh.
54:12.4
At kakagaw ko eh,
54:13.4
nakita niyo talagang eye bags na.
54:15.4
I mean, meron pa rin,
54:16.4
but you can see I was really, really tired.
54:19.4
sabi ko, go pa rin.
54:21.4
Let's discuss this.
54:22.4
Let's discuss this.
54:24.4
I hope you appreciate
54:25.4
what we are doing here.
54:29.4
God bless and talk to you soon.
54:41.4
Thank you very much, guys.
54:46.4
Grazie, grazie, grazie mille.
54:48.4
Grazie mille, grazie mille.
54:51.4
Talk to you guys soon.
