Close
 


Ayaw nga ba sundin ang batas?
Hide Subtitles
Click any subtitle word to view Tagalog.com dictionary results.
Computer Shortcuts: Left / Right arrows to jump 2 seconds back or forward. +Enter or Space to toggle Play/Pause button. Full Screen Mode
This is a Free legal forum @thelectureroomofattyraymondbatu. Welcome sa ating segment "Your question, my answer portion LIVE!". I will all answer your questions (hanggang sa aking katamtaman na kaalaman legal ) every Sunday in the afternoon . Mga kategorya ng free legal forum natin ay USAPANG MANA, USAPANG LUPA, USAPANG PAMILYA, USAPANG MAG-ASAWA, USAPANG RELASYON, USAPANG TAXES, at iba pang kategorya na maaring may kinalaman sa property, batas tungkol sa lupa, problema sa lupa, lupa na walang titulo, lupa na rights lang, lupa na pasalo, bahay at lupa pasalo, mother title ng lupa paano hatiin, kaso sa pangangamkam ng lupa, batas sa lupa ng magulang, batas sa mana ng lupa, hatian sa lupa ng magkakapatid, batas sa lupa ng magulang, karapatan ng asawa sa lupa, karapatan ng legal na asawa kahit walang anak, karapatan ng asawa sa sahod ng asawang lalaki, problema kung patay na ang nakapangalan sa titulo ng lupa, paano magpatitulo ng lupa na walang titulo, titulo ng lupa requirements, paano magpatitulo ng lupa
The Lecture Room of Atty. Raymond Batu
  Mute  
Run time: 43:12
Has AI Subtitles



Video Transcript / Subtitles:( AI generated. About AI subtitles » )
00:00.0
Good morning!
00:01.8
So, I'm happy to be back again
00:04.0
and without further ado
00:05.9
we will continue with our
00:07.7
discussion. Ang topic po natin ngayon
00:10.1
during this live
00:12.3
session natin ngayon
00:13.9
February 12, 2024
00:15.6
is regarding po ito doon sa
00:18.3
estate tax amnesty natin
00:20.4
na hanggang
00:21.3
2025 na lang next year
00:23.5
and then maraming nagre-reklamo sa akin
00:26.1
nagko-comment na
00:27.5
hindi talaga computer ng
00:29.3
BAR kapag walang extra
00:31.2
judicial settlement. Kasi na-discuss
00:33.5
natin noon na
00:34.7
kahit na walang extra judicial settlement
00:37.2
e pwede pong
00:38.4
bayaran. Hindi lang ma-issue
00:41.2
natin ng e-car. Kaya lang
00:43.2
ang sadya ng batas is that
00:45.3
para babayaran ito
00:47.2
gawa lang po tayo ng tiyatawag natin
00:49.1
sworn statement
00:50.9
of estate tax, ito yung E-T-E-R
00:53.8
and para sa sworn statement
00:55.6
ito yung ina-narrate natin doon
00:56.9
kung ano yung mga assets
00:58.3
and ano yung mga properties
01:00.6
in-vote for the
01:02.2
estate na decedent. Para yun po
01:04.9
ang bayaran natin. Kung merong
01:06.9
hindi na-declare, that will be
01:08.9
the subject to another estate tax.
01:10.7
Hindi ka na maaring, hindi ka na maka-apply
01:13.0
for the amnesty kung maglapaso na
01:14.7
sa 2025. So what I'm trying to say
01:17.2
is pwede po wala talagang
01:19.1
extra judicial settlement or
01:20.6
affidavit of subjudication. Marami na po tayong
01:22.9
videos niyan kasi may mga
01:24.9
heirs na nag-aaway, hindi nagkakaintindihan
01:27.4
ang
01:28.3
nangyayari is that kailangan pong
01:30.4
i-bayaran
01:32.8
ng estate for the meantime.
01:34.9
Estate tax para hindi
01:36.4
mag-a-bail po tayo ng
01:38.4
amnesty. At the same time,
01:41.3
makabayaran po
01:42.1
ang estate tax. At the same time,
01:44.4
ang government is makalikom po
01:46.0
ng taxes. Yan po ang purpose
01:48.4
ng estate tax. In fact,
01:50.2
ang batas po natin dyan na
01:52.1
pwedeng walang extrajudicial settlement,
01:54.0
ito pong yung talagang batas natin.
01:56.6
Republic Act No. 11,
01:58.3
956. Ito po yung
02:00.6
extension ng estate tax
02:02.8
amnesty. Recent, no? Hanggang
02:04.7
June 14, 2025 po.
02:07.6
Ang nakasabi po dito,
02:09.1
the application for payment,
02:11.0
palakihin natin.
02:14.9
The application for
02:16.9
payment of estate tax
02:20.2
shall be distinct and separate process
02:22.7
from the application for
02:24.5
transfer of properties. Ano po po yung sabihin nun?
02:26.5
Separate daw. Iba.
02:28.3
Hindi sila magkatintulad.
02:30.9
Iba po ang pagbayad ng tax.
02:33.0
Iba rin po yung pag-process
02:34.3
ng transfer of tax, no?
02:36.8
Provided daw, yung pruweba
02:38.9
na may settlement ng estate, like
02:40.8
meron kang apidabit of subjudication,
02:43.3
AGS, kung pag makumply mo
02:44.9
later on, or may judicial or extrajudicial
02:47.1
settlement, saka mo na
02:48.8
submit para ma-issuan ka
02:50.9
ng ECAR, yung
02:52.7
Electronic Certificate Authorizing Registration
02:54.7
kasi yan po, sa second phase natin,
02:57.0
kailangan yan para ma-transfer
02:58.3
ang mga properties
03:01.0
dun sa mga heirs. Pero yung
03:02.8
sa first part, first step,
03:05.3
hindi kailangan.
03:07.3
Kung hindi kayo, hindi mo
03:08.8
makuha itong mga documents na ito,
03:10.6
dahil nga, nag-aaway o hindi mo kasundoy, magkita,
03:12.9
is that you could file
03:14.8
an application
03:16.7
for estate tax amnesty by filing
03:18.8
a short statement, yung
03:20.7
sworn ETAR, declaring
03:23.0
din kung ilan yung mga properties.
03:26.1
Ang problema,
03:26.6
yung sabi nila,
03:28.3
hindi man kami pinapansin nung BIR
03:30.3
kasi every time we say this,
03:32.3
and even mention your videos and everything,
03:34.4
hinahanapan kami ng AGS.
03:36.6
Ay hindi ko maintindihan, bakit ganon?
03:38.4
In other parts of the BIR, but I do not have
03:40.4
any problems here in Davao City,
03:42.7
but in other areas, no?
03:44.6
In fact, may batas na ito,
03:46.5
gumawa na nga ng
03:47.5
revenue regulation, ang BIR
03:50.3
dito. Itong
03:51.7
revenue regulation number 10-23,
03:55.0
nung September 28, 2023
03:56.8
pa last year. At
03:58.2
ito,
03:58.3
na-outline po nila, na
04:00.0
ang process nga, is that
04:02.4
separate and distinct. Tingnan nyo ha,
04:04.9
we'll try to
04:05.7
palaki natin.
04:08.5
Eh o, revenue regulations
04:10.1
number 10-23.
04:12.1
Klaro yan, no?
04:13.7
And, kinalaro nga dito,
04:16.4
binigyan nila dito
04:17.9
ng emphasis, yung
04:19.9
batas natin, no? Yung Republic Act
04:22.3
11956,
04:23.6
made a dysregulations
04:26.5
para sundin po ng
04:28.3
mga personal ng Bureau of
04:30.3
Internal Revenue, okay?
04:32.6
So, hanggang June 15, 2023
04:34.4
up to June 14, 2025.
04:36.6
Ngayon, ang issuance
04:38.5
ng Electronic Certificate Authorizing
04:40.6
Registration, kailangan na po ito
04:42.3
pag meron na po tayong prueba
04:44.1
na nakasubmit na tayo ng
04:46.0
State Extrajudicial Settlement,
04:48.7
no? Yung copy ng court order,
04:50.4
kung naging judicial or
04:51.9
Judicial Settlement of Estate,
04:54.2
or EGS or Affidavit of Subjudication, kung
04:56.3
hindi nag-aabot sa korte.
04:58.3
Ibig sabihin, pwede nga
05:00.1
ang bayaran kapag
05:01.7
ang estate tax, hindi ka lang makakuha
05:04.2
ng IEKR. Yan po,
05:05.8
klaro po yan, Revenue Regulations
05:08.5
No. 10-23.
05:11.7
Klaro po yan,
05:12.7
dinisseminate po yan.
05:14.2
At, ang naggawa po nito
05:16.2
para makita po natin, ha?
05:18.2
Okay, ang gumawa po
05:20.2
nito is that,
05:23.9
ito,
05:24.9
ginawa po ito ni Benjamin
05:26.2
E. Doc, joke, no? Nandito, klaro,
05:28.3
Benjamin E. Joke, no?
05:30.0
Secretary of Finance, noong September
05:31.8
5, 2023, at na-recommending
05:34.3
approval ni Romeo D.
05:36.3
Lumagi, Jr., the Commissioner
05:38.1
of Internal Revenue. Ano po ba?
05:41.0
Eh, yan na po
05:42.0
sinasabi. Bakit hindi nyo po
05:44.2
tanggapin?
05:46.0
Why is it? Is there a problem with
05:48.2
disseminating information
05:50.1
dun sa mga personals nyo in all over the
05:52.0
Philippines ng BIR, at hindi nila
05:54.0
naiintindihan na may batas na ganito?
05:56.1
Kulang po ba tayo ng dissemination process?
05:57.9
Kulang po ba tayo ng lecture or seminars
05:59.9
for those who are
06:01.3
um, wants to
06:03.7
avail of the estate amnesty? Kasi pag hindi po
06:05.7
nyo tanggapin yan, babalik po yung problema.
06:08.4
Now, Republic Act
06:09.5
11956 po, iginawa po itong last
06:11.5
estate amnesty, kasi
06:13.0
yung two amnesties natin before,
06:16.2
hindi naging masyadong effective
06:17.5
kasi, yun nga, the requirement
06:19.5
is that hindi nga sila nakakabayad
06:21.3
ng estate tax, dahil nga,
06:23.4
yung karamihan po, noong unang panahon pa,
06:25.3
nag-aaway-aaway ang ma-heirs. Hindi
06:27.3
nagkakaintindihan. So, anong
06:29.3
nangyari? Hindi na nababaya ng estate tax, kasi requirement
06:31.2
nga magawa ng AGS eh. So, nakita
06:33.4
po yan sa ikatatlong batas
06:35.1
na bakit hanggang, in fact, nagbigay na tayo
06:37.5
ng estate tax amnesty, eh hindi
06:39.2
pa rin na natin nakakabayad
06:41.4
yung lahat. Bakit? So, na-identify
06:43.3
nila ang problem. There is
06:45.3
some problem with the
06:47.0
fighting heirs, no? Sabi na sa video
06:49.1
lectures natin, hindi sila mag-aid, hindi
06:51.0
makagawa ng AGS, or hindi pa
06:53.0
natatapos yung court order. So, ginawa
06:55.2
nila dito sa batas na ito, as
06:57.3
implemented by this regulation,
06:59.2
number 10-2023 by the
07:01.0
BIR and Secretary of Finance,
07:03.6
sabi lang dito, iseperate natin.
07:06.9
Seperate
07:07.4
ang bayad, separate ang
07:08.9
pag-transfer ng property.
07:11.5
So, pwede magbayad ng estate tax,
07:13.5
enumerate lang ng payer
07:15.2
kung ano yung mga estate,
07:17.6
ano yung mga properties. Then, once
07:19.3
nabayaran, antay na lang. Baka magkasundo
07:21.4
rito, makagawa ng AGS, or
07:22.9
Epidemic of Self-Adjudication, or
07:25.0
baka meron ng court order. And,
07:27.3
that time, pag masabit na sa BIR,
07:29.0
diyan pa lang kayo i-issuhan
07:31.0
ng Electronic Certificate
07:33.0
Authorizing Registration.
07:36.4
Alright?
07:37.1
So, and that's the time that you
07:39.2
could use it to transfer the title
07:41.4
under the name of the
07:43.3
heirs. So, sa inyo po, no? Kung kayo po yung
07:45.2
nagpa-process. So, klaro po ito,
07:47.3
you have to
07:48.6
watch this and try to check,
07:51.4
no? Nandito naman ito sa ano, eh.
07:53.2
Itong Revenue Regulation Number 10-23,
07:56.1
download nyo po, e-print,
07:57.2
nyo. Makuha po ninyo yan
07:59.2
sa BIR website, no?
08:01.3
Na-post po dyan sa kanilang website.
08:03.8
Revenue Regulation Number
08:04.9
10-23, September 8,
08:07.0
2023. Ang title
08:09.3
po niya is simple,
08:11.1
amending
08:12.6
certain provisions of
08:15.3
Revenue Regulation Number 62019
08:17.1
and implement the
08:19.2
extension of the period of the
08:21.1
availment of the estate tax under
08:23.1
Public Act Number 11956.
08:25.0
So, to implement, ito po,
08:27.2
ang ginagamit na to implement.
08:29.2
Now, I do not know what
08:31.1
happens to their information dissemination,
08:33.9
pero may nakikita naman akong
08:35.5
sa website
08:37.2
or sa Facebook
08:39.1
nga, o. Ito, revenue issuance.
08:41.7
Revenue Regulations Number
08:43.0
10-23. Mali pa ang spelling o
08:45.1
review sa regulations.
08:47.1
But, ayun, klaro,
08:49.0
ang BIR po ang nag-post nito
08:51.0
sa kanilang Facebook. Kailangan yun lang ba?
08:53.5
Dapat siguro, your personal
08:54.8
ah, your personal
08:57.2
of themselves, dapat po ma-inform
08:59.2
about this. And, paspasan po
09:01.1
ang dapat pag-explain, lalo na po
09:03.1
yung mga sa UNEP, no?
09:05.2
At saka yung mga examiners, that they
09:07.1
will be allowed as long as
09:09.0
meron pong sworn ETAR.
09:12.1
Now, either
09:13.2
they do not know the law or they
09:14.9
refuse to follow it. Kung they
09:17.1
refuse to follow it, talaga pong
09:18.9
ayaw nila taga-gabi despite knowing about the law,
09:21.0
ayaw po, bawal po yun. Pwede po sila
09:23.2
maging liable po sa, under
09:25.0
sa ating civil service laws or
09:26.7
sa ombudsman or sa ARTA.
09:29.2
So, i-depende po yun, no? Kung talagang
09:31.2
in bad faith, ayaw talaga
09:33.1
nilang isundin. Now,
09:35.1
kung sakaling in good faith,
09:37.2
hindi talaga nila alam at hindi na-explain,
09:39.2
the best thing to do is that you go to the
09:41.1
legal officer of the
09:43.0
Bureau of Internal Revenue and present your problem.
09:45.6
Sir, ayaw po tanggapin.
09:47.4
Eto po yung Revenue
09:48.9
Regulations No. 10-23,
09:51.0
allowing separate po ang
09:52.8
transactions with respect to payment
09:54.9
at separate naman din yung
09:56.7
pag-present transfer. Ay, gusto ko magbayad lang
09:58.9
muna ngayon. Hindi ako magta-transfer kasi
10:00.7
nag-aaway pa nga kami ng mga heirs eh. Hindi pa kami
10:02.8
nagkakasundo. But I want to pay now para maka-bail
10:05.0
ako ng estate tax amnesty.
10:07.5
And then, the legal
10:08.9
officer will understand that. Usually, lawyers
10:11.0
yan sila. Oh, yes. Dapat ganito rin to.
10:13.1
Then, they will have to
10:14.4
reprimand or advise those examiners
10:16.8
downstairs that you have to accept that.
10:19.2
I-comply lang po yung
10:20.6
ETER or sworn declaration
10:22.6
or pag, may iba, nagpapagawa pa ng
10:24.7
separate affidavit yung sworn declaration.
10:26.7
Of the properties
10:28.8
or estate of the
10:30.6
dissident, no? Okay lang yan. No problem.
10:32.5
Dahil naman yan. I-enumerate naman yung mga properties
10:34.4
as far as you know. Ito ang mga
10:36.8
properties involved, no? Kasi if you
10:38.7
will not do that, if the BIR personal will
10:40.6
not accept it, magkakaroon tayo ng problema.
10:43.0
Problem in the sense that ang collection
10:44.7
na purpose po ng batas
10:46.7
is to get, no? To get money
10:48.8
from this
10:49.5
amnesty. Issue 1
10:52.5
ng government, 11956.
10:54.5
Hindi natin masusunod.
10:56.7
Second is that magkakaroon ng
10:58.6
injury or damage on the part of
11:00.7
the taxpayer na gusto mag-avail.
11:03.4
Now, that damage under
11:04.5
Republic Act 3019, yung Anti-Grap
11:06.7
and Corrupt Practices Act, can make
11:08.7
these people liable for, yung
11:10.4
taga-BIR, for Anti-Grap and Corrupt
11:12.7
Practices Act. And pwedeng
11:14.7
may kulong provision yan eh.
11:16.7
Huwag na lang po natin paabutin yan. Hindi ko po
11:18.7
tinatakot or sinasabi yun and everything. But
11:20.5
you have to be vigilant also.
11:23.1
Not only as taxpayers, but
11:24.6
also the BIR. It presented
11:26.7
with a certain situation na meron
11:28.7
pong regulation na ganito,
11:30.6
try to check and study. And kung hindi
11:32.5
po maintindihan, i-refer nyo sa inyong RDO
11:34.7
or i-refer nyo sa inyong legal officer
11:36.8
there, sa legal department
11:38.8
so that magkaroon po ng idea
11:40.5
kung paano nga pag-proceed nito. Because
11:42.6
that is the law. Huwag na po
11:44.8
natin antayin na magkakaroon ng problema
11:46.6
because, I know, you might
11:48.6
want to, you might not have known
11:50.7
that meron ganyan regulations
11:52.4
but once it is presented now
11:54.7
or you have, ano, you have to
11:56.7
apply that. Kasi sayang po, no?
11:58.9
Ang purpose po ng batas is to
12:00.8
let the people, no?
12:04.5
The Filipino people
12:05.5
to avail
12:06.3
with this one-time amnesty.
12:09.0
Pangatunan nga po ito, eh. Tapos
12:10.7
hindi pa sila makakabayad because of that.
12:13.4
So, having said that, please,
12:15.0
no? Ang akin naman po, huwag na po
12:16.7
natin pahirapan yung
12:18.5
taxpayer natin.
12:20.6
Nandito na po yun. Nandyan na po ang
12:22.5
availment ng amnesty. Sayang po yan.
12:24.4
Let them avail. That is their right.
12:26.7
It is their
12:27.1
obligation to pay. And that is the right
12:30.3
granted under the law. Iba naman kasing
12:32.7
taga-personal. Minsan, magkainang
12:34.9
kwento sa akin. Pag ini-insist nga
12:36.8
nung taxpayer na, babayad po
12:38.7
kasi sabi dito sa Revenue Regulations
12:40.3
No. 10-23. Sabi po sa lecture
12:42.7
ni Atty. Batu, meron po akong video
12:44.6
dito. Hindi ako man. Umalis ka.
12:46.9
Pina pa. Pina pa. Alis pa.
12:48.7
Naiinis. Yung sent out.
12:50.6
Huwag naman po gano'n. No? Yung taxpayers
12:52.4
are actually entitled
12:54.8
to be,
12:56.7
told of what to do. Kung
12:58.5
meron pong pinipresent na valid and
13:00.7
legitimate claim and
13:02.6
valid and legitimate argument,
13:04.7
pakinggan po natin. So, ang akin
13:06.7
lang po din sa mga taxpayers na nakakaroon
13:08.9
ng problems na ganito, kindly
13:10.7
download that Revenue Regulations No.
13:12.8
10-23. Ipigay po
13:14.9
yun sa kanila. Ag-ayaw pa rin po
13:16.8
nila din sabihin po ninyo,
13:19.1
magawa po kayo ng letter, ipareceive
13:21.0
niyo po attaching the revenue issuance
13:22.6
and tell them to deny it
13:24.7
in writing.
13:26.7
Within a period of, urgently,
13:28.8
within a period of at least 5 days.
13:31.1
Para,
13:31.7
para kung i-deny talaga
13:34.7
then you could bring that up
13:36.2
to the higher authorities. Pwede po sa legal nila.
13:39.4
Meron naman din silang disciplining
13:40.7
authority. Pwede rin sa civil service. Pwede rin sa
13:42.8
ombudsman or sa anti-red
13:44.9
tape act council.
13:46.8
Okay? So, gano'n lang po. That's
13:48.8
the only remedy that we could do. Wala na po tayo
13:51.1
magawa niyan. Because
13:52.6
kung hindi tayo pinapansin or
13:54.6
sinasadyang hindi tayo pansinin,
13:56.7
or matigas talaga uro pansinin.
13:58.9
Pero, hindi ito sa buong
14:00.8
Pilipinas, ha.
14:02.8
Kalat-kalat lang po ng mga other
14:04.8
regions na tumatawag sa akin,
14:07.2
nag-chat sa akin, nag-comment sa akin,
14:09.3
Attorney, this is a problem. How can,
14:10.9
what can we do? And it has been
14:12.7
recurring for quite a time. Eh, sana
14:14.7
tapos na saan ang discussion ko dito sa
14:16.6
SST Tax Amnesty. I do not
14:18.8
want to discuss more pa kasi, yun nga,
14:20.6
tapos na ako naka-discuss dito, nabigay ko na sa inyo.
14:23.1
However, ito po yung problem na
14:24.6
natatanggap ko, which I would like
14:26.7
to address. And
14:28.3
hopefully, that makarating ito
14:30.7
sa kanila. At maliwanagan po
14:32.7
na meron po tayong Revenue
14:34.5
Regulations No. 10-23
14:36.5
Implementing Republic Act
14:38.8
119.6. Last na po
14:40.7
amnesty natin hanggang June
14:42.5
14, 2025 po.
14:45.3
Please, I hope
14:46.5
we can have this kind of
14:48.4
privilege to, you know,
14:50.7
to avail, no? Pag po
14:52.6
ninyong
14:54.4
allow po ninyong tao
14:55.5
maka-exercise nito.
14:56.7
Mga taxpayers. Okay, thank you
14:58.6
so much. And so,
15:00.4
before that, I would like to
15:02.4
to go to this, some
15:04.7
questions,
15:06.9
no? Or mga, well, I haven't
15:08.8
responded to so many
15:10.0
questions for a while dito sa
15:12.6
comments natin. It has been a time, long time,
15:14.8
no? Mga abot yata ko na almost
15:16.5
a month, hindi ako nakaka-live and everything. So,
15:18.6
well, sabi nila, health is wealth, so you have
15:20.6
to take care of your health. Unahin po na natin yun.
15:22.5
Now, I'm okay. So, I'm back and
15:24.6
I'm going to, habol po ako.
15:26.7
Bawi po ako sa inyo lahat ngayon dito.
15:28.9
And, sabi dito ni Ricardo
15:30.7
Bulado, 5711,
15:32.7
at any good day po, may titulo na po kami sa
15:34.6
subdivision plan, pero
15:36.6
pumasok ang porsyon ng bahay ng
15:38.5
kapatid ko sa lupa ko.
15:40.5
At nakapinaw ako ng consent, gagamitin
15:42.7
daw sa hearing sa RTC. Well,
15:44.9
ang problem, Ricardo, is
15:46.4
hindi ko alam kung ano ang
15:48.6
purpose ng kanyang pagpagawa
15:50.7
ng consent, no? Consent
15:52.5
to put up a
15:54.1
pinayagan nyo na nakapasok siya.
15:56.7
Para po magkaroon
15:58.5
ng improvements and everything.
16:00.9
Well, that is one of the requirements usually
16:02.6
ng City Engineer's Office, no?
16:09.1
You have to ask kung ano talaga
16:11.0
ang purpose ng consent. Dapat kasi
16:12.8
kung may consent, it's an affidavit
16:14.8
form, nakalagay dun po ano ang purpose
16:16.9
para malaman po natin
16:18.7
na yun po ang sadya talaga.
16:20.7
Okay?
16:23.6
Alright. So,
16:24.9
answeran natin.
16:26.7
Please watch.
16:31.4
Medyo matagal-tagal ako,
16:32.8
hindi naka-
16:33.8
nakasagot eh.
16:35.5
Pre-br-row.
16:37.6
Hindi pa spelling.
16:39.0
Alright.
16:42.7
Okay. So, ito si
16:44.8
Ricardo. One day ago niya ito.
16:46.9
Thank you for that question. Ito naman si
16:48.8
Lino Lasso, one day ago.
16:51.1
Thank you so much,
16:52.6
Lecture Maternity. Dahil yun,
16:54.4
talaga yun ang nangyayari sa amin. Nag-usap na po kami
16:56.6
sa barangay. At napatunayan na
16:58.7
palsipigado papel na ginamit sa pag...
17:00.9
Patitulo. Hango ito
17:02.7
sa video ng pagpanood niya nung
17:04.1
isang uri ng scam sa pag-aagaw
17:06.6
ng lupa. Ito po yung...
17:08.3
From there,
17:11.0
meron siyang comment or reaction
17:12.9
on that Bibdi lecture.
17:14.5
Okay. So, si Kobe575
17:16.6
regarding ito dun sa video na
17:18.6
pinanood niya na valid ba
17:20.6
ang DDoS na hindi inuntang taryado.
17:23.2
Sabi niya,
17:23.7
Hi, Atty. B. Good day.
17:25.7
I bought title land,
17:26.6
from air so far. At first,
17:28.8
walang problema. Nasa stage na kami
17:30.6
paying estate tax nito.
17:33.7
Dito kami na-stack
17:34.8
kasi nang kumuha kami ng certification
17:36.5
sa provincial assessor's office,
17:39.2
may lumabas dalawa ang
17:40.5
property ng owner, which is separate
17:42.6
title. Naalala ng mga
17:44.6
heirs na nung buhay pa mother nila, binenta
17:46.8
na ito. But I think hindi ito na process
17:48.6
ng buyer. I assume kaya
17:50.6
pangalan po ng original owner
17:52.9
ang lumabas na record. Ngayon,
17:54.8
gusto po ng BIR na isama ang
17:56.6
gano'n na yan sa isang property kung ano ang
17:58.5
June estate. Well, alam niyo po, ganito yan.
18:01.8
The thing about estate
18:02.8
tax, kung maraming properties po
18:04.7
ang isang
18:07.0
land owner, ang isang decedent, yung
18:08.7
namatay, tapos bibilihin mo lang isa
18:10.8
doon from the heirs. Lahat po
18:12.8
ng estate tax na yan babayaran.
18:15.3
Now, the only way
18:16.8
to know whether or not ano ba kadami
18:18.9
ang properties is that to get
18:20.7
a certificate of total landholding from
18:22.6
the assessor's. That's what happened to you.
18:25.7
Nakita dito sa
18:26.6
city assessor's office na meron
18:28.8
pa pang lang ibang properties yung napagbilan
18:31.0
mo. And allegedly, sabi nila
18:33.0
na ibenta na ito. Bakit hindi pa na
18:34.7
process na transfer? Now, if
18:36.8
you could look to that, look for
18:38.8
that buyer na nakabili noon at first,
18:41.0
no problem. Maka-share
18:42.9
siya ng estate tax. At least naman ma-process
18:44.7
ng kanyang property, di ba?
18:46.7
Now, the problem here is that
18:48.7
if hindi na makontakt at
18:50.7
hindi na process, well, we have no choice but to
18:52.8
pay for the estate tax.
18:55.2
Idamay po yun. Mababayaran po.
18:56.6
Anyway, kung sakaling
18:58.7
baka covered ito sa estate tax
19:00.8
amnesty, eh, baka-baka mabura
19:02.7
kayo. Isama nyo na po. Wala po kayong choice.
19:04.6
Otherwise, hindi po kayo ma-issue ng e-card niya
19:06.5
ng BIR pag hindi nyo bayaran. Now,
19:08.6
since you made already an extrajudicial settlement
19:10.5
with estate for that property,
19:12.8
tapos nakita ng BIR na meron pa
19:14.6
palang property, so ano ba ang
19:16.5
gagawin yan? Gagawa po kayo ng tinatawag nating
19:18.3
addendum. Addendum sa
19:20.5
extrajudicial settlement to include now
19:22.2
that property na hindi nyo na-include sa previous
19:24.5
AGS ninyo. Para po tanggapin.
19:26.6
BIR, bayaran ng proper tax.
19:28.5
At the same time, ma-issuean po kayo
19:30.5
ng e-card. Well,
19:32.3
that's it. That's how the law is
19:34.6
though. So, durolex and lex,
19:36.6
the law is hard, but that is the law.
19:38.7
Latay magawa. We have to follow
19:40.7
it. Okay. Take note.
19:43.2
O, si Josephine Orong.
19:45.2
Good morning, attorney. Ask ko lang.
19:46.6
My grandfather have an untitled land.
19:49.3
Pero sa registered, sa
19:50.7
registry of deeds,
19:51.9
ask ko lang. My grandfather have an
19:54.6
untitled land.
19:56.6
Pero na-register sa registry of deeds
19:58.7
on her name.
20:01.8
Grandfather tapos
20:02.7
her name. Bakit naging
20:04.2
eh, ibig sabihin, baka
20:06.8
na-applyan ang title. Kung bakit nag-aroon
20:08.7
na siya ng titlo sa registry of deeds. So,
20:10.9
that would be good. So, you better
20:12.8
still, you ask registry of
20:14.9
deeds, ingin kayo ng traceback documents
20:16.7
on how it was transferred. So, if it's an original
20:18.7
patent o CT pa siya, o CT siya,
20:20.7
ibig sabihin na-applyan. Pwede kayo
20:22.5
pumunta sa
20:23.0
DNR to inquire about
20:26.4
that. Okay, Josephine.
20:28.5
Thank you so much, Josephine.
20:30.7
And then, si Kobe.
20:33.7
Attorney Gude,
20:34.6
siya pa rin ulito kanina. I have a question.
20:36.6
I don't know kung na-discuss na ito.
20:38.4
Ang property po binenta after
20:40.5
the annulment.
20:43.5
Ang tanong, hindi alam
20:44.5
ng ex-husband, may
20:46.4
dalawa silang anak, hindi
20:48.4
minor. Ito po eh, binenta
20:50.6
ng ex-wife at si Nolo. Pwede
20:52.4
po ba ito mangyari? At may habol pa ba
20:54.5
ang anak dito? Or even the ex-husband?
20:56.4
Well, ganito po, kung may annulment
20:58.7
po tayo ng marriage,
21:00.3
kasama po sa annulment ng marriage is the
21:02.3
separation of properties. May order po, dapat
21:04.3
ang judge yan. May directive po ang judge.
21:06.3
Hindi lang po pag-severe ng kanyang
21:08.3
marriage relationship. But dapat po tuloyin
21:10.4
po rin yung separation
21:12.5
of properties between the
21:13.9
parties. Why? Because those are
21:16.4
two different things na dapat
21:18.3
isali. Kasi,
21:20.3
kung yung marriage lang po tuloyin mo, magkakaroon
21:22.5
tayo ng problema sa settlement
21:24.2
kung ibebenta yung property or saan pa po.
21:26.4
Kasi bakit? Kakailangan pa rin natin
21:28.4
ng marital consent. Now, you
21:30.4
have to check, Koby, kung meron po
21:32.4
ba doon sa annulment. Kung meron
21:34.6
pong declaration, kanino po ba
21:36.3
nakaasaad yung property?
21:38.7
Kung kanino nabigay? Let's say, nabigay
21:40.5
sa wife, no problem.
21:43.1
Kasi,
21:43.8
kanya pala yun.
21:46.3
However, kailangan po yung annulment
21:48.2
or decision
21:50.1
ng annulment na meron nakaasaad doon
21:52.3
na na-assign sa kanya yung property.
21:53.9
Dapat po, mapanotate po yan sa registry.
21:56.4
Because without which,
21:58.6
kailangan po ng marital consent ng
22:00.1
ex-husband. Okay? Take note of that,
22:02.6
Koby. Kailangan po ng marital
22:04.5
consent kapag hindi na-annotate.
22:06.3
At kung wala po nakalagay sa
22:08.5
decision ng
22:10.6
court, kung kanino na-adjudicate
22:12.8
o na-ibigay yung lupa na yun,
22:14.7
bigay ba yun? Kailangan po ng
22:16.3
marital consent. Alright?
22:18.9
Take note of that. Si Rowena
22:20.6
Ferrer, 5278.
22:23.1
At yun yung tanong ko lang po,
22:24.2
na po, process paglipat ng
22:26.2
titulong ng lupa. Alright?
22:28.2
Nakabili po kami last 2020.
22:30.5
May deed of sale na po kami.
22:32.2
Matanong, maraming salamat po. Eh,
22:34.1
alam mo, Rowena, ang problem niyan, 2020,
22:36.6
pwede mo magamitin yan. Pero ang problema
22:38.4
is grabe na ang penalty niyan,
22:40.4
no? Because it is 2020.
22:42.7
So, just imagine,
22:44.3
21, 22, 23, 24,
22:45.9
4 years na, make it,
22:48.0
almost, that you will have to have
22:50.0
to be paying so much taxes on that, no?
22:53.0
Penalties po, compromise.
22:55.2
Yan po ang,
22:56.2
problem sa capital gain tax, no?
22:57.8
Tsaka sa doc stamps. So, akong suggestion,
23:00.2
yun, talk to the
23:02.2
sellers of that property. Baka pwedeng
23:04.3
i-cancel ninyong old sale ninyo
23:06.0
at gawa kayo ng bago para ma-update
23:08.3
po kayo. And you have to process that within 30 days,
23:10.5
no? Para hindi po kayo
23:12.4
magkaroon ng penalty sa
23:14.1
capital gain tax. Sa documentary
23:16.1
stamp tax naman, every 5th day of the
23:18.3
month. Alright, Rowena,
23:20.4
I hope you
23:21.3
got something about this.
23:24.2
Okay, si Mera Fe,
23:26.2
Bala Sabas.
23:27.5
Thank you, attorney, for your message na hindi madadala
23:29.8
ang lupa sa kamatayan. God bless you po.
23:32.9
That's correct.
23:34.1
Hindi naman talaga natin madadala
23:35.4
yung lupa sa kamatayan natin, no?
23:37.7
As I said, we are just passers-by
23:40.1
in this world. And
23:41.8
ang purpose lang natin is to enjoy the
23:43.9
properties that we have while we are still
23:46.1
here in this earth, no?
23:48.3
Now, pag matay tayo, itatransfer
23:50.3
nga natin yan doon sa ating mga ears.
23:52.1
And now, they have now the privilege to enjoy
23:53.9
what you have left them. Take note,
23:56.2
hindi po natin madadala ang propidad
23:58.3
kahit itong propidad pa yan
24:00.3
kapag namatay po tayo.
24:02.0
Kaya ingatan po at enjoy natin kung anumang
24:04.3
biyaya binigay ang Panginoon sa atin
24:06.2
na hindi naman
24:08.1
masama na marami tayong properties
24:10.1
kung yan po ibinigay po talaga sa atin.
24:12.2
Alright? So, thank you lang po
24:13.9
kung meron ganun.
24:15.7
Alright, may laban ba ako
24:17.6
sa kapatid ko? Binenta niya
24:20.3
ang lupa ng tatay ko na hindi
24:22.2
namin alam. Bali, rights lang
24:24.3
ang pinahawakan ng bumili pero ang mother,
24:26.2
title sa amin. Well, ang point ko
24:28.3
is that, ang panong muna is
24:30.0
kanino ba ang may-ari ng property?
24:32.1
Kung tatay ba ninyo o naka-rest
24:33.4
nung naka-rest doon or baka sa
24:36.2
Now, kung
24:38.2
mother title pa, I think
24:40.1
that's a great-grandfather or grandmother
24:42.0
so baka may share lang yung lolo nyo.
24:44.3
Well, basically, kung buhay pa yung papa
24:46.2
nyo, siya dapat na pwede magbili,
24:48.0
magbenta, no? Pero kung patay na rin
24:50.2
siya, dyan po kayo magkakaroon ng
24:51.9
right as an heir. Kasi kung
24:54.1
patay na ang parents ninyo tapos binenta
24:56.2
yung isang kapatid yung
24:57.6
property. Ah, hindi po pwede.
25:00.2
Kasi kailangan po ng
25:01.2
kanyang consent. Alright? Take note of
25:04.2
that, user.
25:06.8
NM5, JV90,
25:08.6
Q90. Okay.
25:11.6
So, si
25:12.2
Yoyetan, tax declaration under
25:14.2
the name of the died parents, can the children
25:16.3
sell the land? Well, wala mong problema.
25:19.0
Extrajudicial settlement
25:20.1
with sale po ang
25:22.2
gagawin natin. Okay?
25:24.1
So,
25:26.2
baka untitled yung property
25:28.5
nyan, similar process
25:30.1
and you have to pay for the capital gains
25:32.3
of tax stamps and transfer tax,
25:34.4
then you have to register the sale
25:36.4
of the unregistered or untitled
25:38.0
sa registry of deeds para mapalitan po
25:40.5
ang tax declaration
25:42.8
under the name of the buyer.
25:44.4
So, extrajudicial settlement with sale,
25:47.0
bayaran po ng estate tax,
25:48.2
at the same time, bayaran po ang
25:50.5
capital gains tax and tax stamps.
25:52.7
By the way, guys,
25:54.4
yung sa estate tax,
25:56.2
sa amnesty natin,
25:58.1
kahit na ano siya, yung
26:00.4
untitled land,
26:02.2
pwede niyo i-avail siya sa estate tax amnesty.
26:04.5
Hindi po ang estate tax
26:06.2
amnesty para sa titled lands lang.
26:08.4
It will give
26:10.3
the benefit.
26:11.5
The loss benefit extends
26:13.9
doon sa mga unregistered
26:16.0
or untitled lands.
26:18.0
So, take note of that.
26:20.1
Okay? So,
26:22.2
what else?
26:22.9
Let us see.
26:26.2
Okay.
26:33.6
Attorney, paano po
26:34.9
makaka-apply ng adverse claim
26:36.6
or what does we limit? Well, adverse claim,
26:38.9
if you have a claim adverse
26:40.8
to the owner, usually, nangyayari
26:42.8
kapag nakabili ka ng portion ng property
26:45.0
at pag ngayon,
26:46.6
hindi niya binigay ang title
26:48.8
o hindi niya pinurases din.
26:50.2
In order na
26:51.3
maprotektahan ka na baka maibenta ulit ito
26:54.6
sa another person,
26:56.2
yes, you could
26:56.8
annotate an adverse claim.
26:59.1
Gawa po kayo ng affidavit niyan
27:00.5
of adverse claim and have it annotated
27:03.1
on the registry of deeds.
27:04.8
Title ng titulo.
27:07.3
Kasi ang
27:08.1
duplicate owner's copy
27:10.6
ng title
27:13.3
na doon man sa
27:14.0
i-benta. So, meron pa mang isang copy
27:16.7
sa registry of deeds na
27:18.2
pwede po natin gamitin.
27:20.6
Alright. So, yun ang gagamitin natin.
27:23.2
Okay?
27:24.8
Now, baka
27:26.2
depende, no? Kung tanggapin ng
27:28.4
registry of deeds o hindi ang
27:30.0
affidavit mo. It's possible na
27:32.5
i-annotate. It's possible na i-de-deny.
27:35.4
Pwede rin nyo i-elevate
27:36.7
and konsulta doon po
27:38.6
sa
27:39.1
LRA kung sakaling
27:42.6
i-de-deny po siya.
27:44.9
Yan lang naman ang proseso.
27:46.5
Paraga, wala na tayong
27:47.9
ways for that. But that is
27:50.3
how we should
27:51.7
take care of our
27:54.3
kind of problem.
27:56.2
So, that kind of problem.
27:57.9
Alright. So, with that, what else?
28:01.4
Gusto po kayo, they're watching
28:02.5
from Canada. Si Anton Escobar.
28:05.6
Asko lang tungkol sa
28:06.6
estate tax amnesty. Ano po ba
28:08.3
qualifications para mag-apply?
28:10.0
Para na po nanay ko since 2013.
28:11.8
Well, yes, you could apply, no?
28:15.1
Sir Anton, please.
28:17.2
Please watch and
28:18.6
look at the video lectures that we have
28:20.7
on the settlement of the estate.
28:22.6
In fact, pwede kayo mag-apply.
28:24.4
Please watch other videos.
28:26.2
On this matter.
28:30.1
Let's tag natin siya, no?
28:31.8
Maraming po tayong video lectures niyan,
28:33.6
Anton Escobar.
28:36.1
Okay, sir, yung asawa ko
28:38.2
may minanang lupa, okay?
28:40.4
And then, ngayon, pinasubdivide na nilang
28:42.5
drum kapatid. Tanong ko lang po,
28:44.2
mag-type rin po ba ang natin
28:45.6
kasamang right to pay? Of course naman.
28:48.4
The rule is that kung walang
28:49.9
arrangement as to how it
28:52.3
will be divided,
28:54.3
mag-type po dapat.
28:56.2
Right to pay, no? Kasi,
28:58.0
ang purpose talaga ng batas is to
28:59.7
make it fair to all the
29:02.0
all the heirs na
29:04.4
makatatanggap ng property.
29:06.6
Yun ang proseso natin.
29:08.9
But, meron naman ding
29:10.2
a partition agreement na mas
29:12.2
jumalaki sa kabila, sa kanila.
29:14.2
Yung isa hindi, no? Depende po yung
29:15.9
susapan. Pero, as a rule, yes.
29:18.3
Totoo po, yes. Pwede po.
29:20.3
Okay.
29:20.7
Okay.
29:23.2
So, ito po ang hanggang ngayon
29:25.3
ang pwede po.
29:26.2
And, let us see. I could have
29:27.8
about 3 minutes muna dito sa aking
29:30.5
I'll see the docs
29:32.3
if nandito na po yung iba kong
29:34.4
Well, I have not
29:36.7
talked to them for quite a while.
29:38.4
Ito, dami na rin sila.
29:40.3
And, I have to answer dun. Si May Bagares.
29:42.7
Good morning, attorney.
29:44.1
Good morning, May Bagares. Shoutouts po sa inyo.
29:46.7
Kumusta po kayo? How are you?
29:48.9
I was not able
29:50.4
to tune in for quite a while.
29:52.7
Pasensyahan na po natin.
29:54.4
Now, okay.
29:56.2
As discussed, no?
29:58.2
Okay.
30:00.3
Sige. Yan.
30:02.1
Pag-i-key natin. Pag-maganda. Okay.
30:05.7
Okay.
30:06.8
Si Severino Sabes, yes.
30:09.3
Ah, Severino, talagang
30:10.6
ngayon lang talagang nakapag-live ulit, no?
30:12.9
Okay. Si Beth Belunta.
30:15.3
Maraming salamat, Beth.
30:16.4
Shoutout po sa inyo. Beth, no?
30:18.5
Si Flor Delisa Amor.
30:20.5
Good morning. Good morning also po sa inyo.
30:23.4
And, si Kling
30:24.2
the Explorer. Good morning, too, no?
30:26.2
May tanong po siya.
30:27.9
Attorney, ask ko lang po. Is it possible
30:30.2
to have two owners in one
30:32.1
single lot number, but the area is
30:34.1
different? Ah,
30:36.0
mahirap, no? Bakit nagkakamali ng
30:38.0
covers only
30:40.0
kapag, ah,
30:42.6
it covers only
30:43.7
kapag
30:45.8
meron siyang, ano, yung
30:47.6
ah,
30:52.8
it covers only kapag
30:54.1
merong patay or estate tax amnesty.
30:56.2
Yung debt ngayon, hindi sinasabi
30:58.0
na yung 11956 natin
31:00.2
may prospective application. Ibig sabihin,
31:02.9
kasali na po dapat
31:04.1
yung mga debts na namangyayari
31:06.2
until now.
31:09.1
Kasi, unfair naman, eh.
31:10.4
Eh, what if po namatay ngayon?
31:12.0
Tapos hindi rin nagkakaintindihan ang mga heirs.
31:14.3
Hindi magpirma ng AGS.
31:16.3
Eh, ngayon, sabihin ng BI, okay,
31:18.6
ang coverage na ng Republic Act
31:20.2
11956 is yung sa estate tax amnesty.
31:23.1
Eh, outside case
31:24.4
sa estate tax amnesty. Eh, wala namang
31:26.1
sinasabi na hindi requirement ng
31:27.9
AGS. So, AGS bago namin
31:30.1
kumputan. See, magkakaroon
31:32.4
ulit, babalik-balik ang problema
31:34.2
na iniiwasan sana
31:36.2
ng batas. I hope that the
31:38.0
lawmakers will understand, no?
31:40.3
I hope I could, I don't know if I could
31:42.1
write someone else here, na dapat
31:44.0
magkaroon ito ng prospective application
31:46.2
para naman po, ah,
31:48.5
yung mga namatay ngayon is that
31:50.3
yung mga nag-away
31:52.3
ang heirs na namatay ngayon is that pwede
31:54.0
sinabayaran na muna estate tax. Until such,
31:56.1
time, na maayos nila
31:58.0
ang, maayos nila
32:00.0
ang estate tax, ah,
32:02.3
ang kanilang extrajudicial settlement
32:04.0
or court settlement kung nasa
32:05.8
korte mo nito. Alright, take note of that.
32:10.1
Alright, so,
32:11.6
unfortunately, it is a common occurrence, attorney,
32:14.0
that the lack of awareness by public servants
32:15.9
and officials of current laws and procedure is
32:17.8
what leads to subpar
32:19.9
and mediocre
32:20.7
public service. Yun ang problema, eh.
32:24.0
Um,
32:26.1
we just try to be vigilant
32:28.9
and try to tell them, right?
32:31.5
Siguro, we'll just help on our own.
32:33.6
With the latest technology that we have,
32:36.6
internet, etc.,
32:38.5
we could tell them what we know, no?
32:41.0
Pag talagang, ayaw talagang
32:42.5
ngampanan ang tungkulong lang, kahit na meron
32:44.7
pong klaro na directive po,
32:47.8
then,
32:49.0
that's the time that we go to
32:50.5
the disciplining authorities.
32:52.4
Okay? Si Nelia Alarcon,
32:54.5
good morning po, ma'am.
32:56.1
Nelia Alarcon, kumusta po kayo?
32:58.1
And si Mark Anthony.
33:00.5
Sa BIR, pasig, ayaw din po
33:02.2
tangkapin kahit pinakita ko na yung
33:04.1
revenue regulation 10 to 10. Kailangan pa rin po
33:06.3
daw ng AGS. Kaya nga, Mark,
33:08.2
ang sabi ko, if that is the case,
33:10.4
sabihin nyo, pakid deny po in writing
33:12.6
and
33:14.2
itong application ko
33:16.2
para po maakyat ko ito sa higher ups.
33:19.2
Kailangan nyo pong ireklamo yan.
33:20.9
Kasi may batas po at may
33:22.3
revenue regulations 10 to 10. Kasi
33:24.2
it's easy for them to say,
33:26.1
hindi, yun talagang law. Because mag-stick
33:28.4
lang sila doon. Tamad ba?
33:30.5
Ayaw mag... Ito, ano nga yan? Patingin nga.
33:32.8
Kung ano, sandali. Pwede mo ko balikan
33:34.4
kung sabi kang legal namin at RDO kung tama
33:36.5
ba ito? Ayaw basahin.
33:38.7
Ayaw makinig.
33:41.3
Get? Ang problem.
33:42.5
So, I think the best thing to do
33:44.4
is to really push the issue.
33:46.8
And write,
33:48.2
write the RDO
33:50.6
at i-put it in writing. Alam mo,
33:52.5
kaming mga lawyers, mahilig kami
33:54.2
that we always put in writing.
33:56.1
Ang sagot ng kabila is they should
33:58.2
also put it in writing para po magamit
34:00.3
namin ang evidence later on
34:02.4
to prove na kung may negligence
34:04.0
ba na nangyayari or meron bang bad
34:06.2
faith or gross misconduct.
34:09.2
Yan ang dapat natin gawin.
34:10.3
Not a choice. That is
34:12.0
how it is, no?
34:14.8
Ang clamor,
34:16.2
marami nga. Adi na mo, dito ngayon,
34:17.9
sa nakikinig, meron ganun. Hindi tiyatanggap.
34:21.2
So, basta as long
34:22.2
as it falls under the
34:24.0
estate tax amnesty.
34:26.1
Ang death ng decedent.
34:28.8
Pasok po ito.
34:30.6
Okay? Take thought of that.
34:33.9
SRS,
34:34.5
good morning, how are you?
34:35.9
And si Ruena Narito.
34:38.9
Ask ko lang po, kami po ay
34:40.3
nakadalawang hearing na po sa
34:42.0
Lupun at Barangay.
34:43.9
Sabi po ng Lupun, i-endorse na po ang
34:45.9
kaso kasi di naman kami
34:47.5
ng respondent magkaintindihan.
34:50.0
Pwede na po ba naming isuhan ng
34:52.0
CFA? Oh yes po, after the third
34:54.0
hearing, pag hindi pa rin kayo ma-issue,
34:56.1
magkaintindi, mag-there's no
34:57.9
amicable settlement, then ma-issuhan
34:59.9
po kayo ng CFA. Or yung katawag
35:01.9
natin, Certificate to File
35:03.8
Action in Port. And from there,
35:05.9
you could now proceed to port by
35:07.5
filing whatever causes of action na
35:09.9
meron kayo doon sa
35:11.5
hindi nyo sa respondent.
35:13.9
Okay? SRS, tanong ko po,
35:16.4
sino ang owner ng property?
35:18.8
Ang heir na may hawak
35:20.0
ng original title certificate
35:21.9
na naka-name sa heir
35:23.1
at magbabayad ng tax
35:25.8
o ang donor ang hawak
35:28.0
document ng deed of donation lang?
35:30.6
Well, pinag-usapan natin
35:32.4
owner. So, sino ba
35:34.2
ang may-ari? Of course, kung kanino
35:35.8
dinonate, siya ang may-ari. Hawak
35:38.0
lang nga yung OCT.
35:39.9
In fact, under the law, if you're the owner,
35:41.8
you could even demand from that person
35:44.0
to surrender the title sa'yo dahil
35:45.9
ikaw man ang may-ari ng
35:47.8
property, being the
35:49.6
doni. Sa'yo kasi dinonate
35:52.1
ang property.
35:53.8
Mindoro 28, good morning attorney, watch
35:55.8
in from Guam. Thanks for the info.
35:58.0
Yes, sir. Thank you so much, Mindoro
35:59.7
28. And si
36:01.8
Ruena, bago lang po ang kapitan
36:03.8
namin, sabi, itatanong
36:05.7
pa raw nila sa pulis kung pwede na siya mag-issue
36:08.0
kahit dalawang hearing. Hindi po,
36:09.7
gawin nyo three hearings
36:11.9
unless both parties,
36:14.2
complainant and respondent
36:16.0
agrees na mag-issue na ng CFA.
36:18.6
Pero pag hindi po,
36:19.8
huwag nyo pong pilitin, magkakaroon po kayo ng
36:21.6
technicality niyan later on.
36:23.8
I-third hearing nyo po kung kailangan
36:25.8
pa. Pero kung magpahayag, i-waive na
36:27.7
yung third hearing, basta in writing
36:29.6
ang waiver ng
36:30.7
respondent, no problem.
36:33.7
Okay?
36:35.6
Ang realty tax
36:36.8
at tax clearance,
36:39.7
land holdings issued by the donor
36:41.5
or LGU.
36:43.4
Ang realty tax
36:45.5
issued by the
36:47.0
Okay. Ang statement
36:49.5
of account ninyo para sa real property
36:51.7
tax, magbigay
36:53.8
niyan is ang treasurer's office.
36:55.8
Ang magbibigay sa inyo ng
36:57.7
tax declaration, ang city
36:59.7
assessor's office.
37:01.2
Ang magbibigay sa inyo ng total adholding,
37:03.9
ang city assessor's office.
37:05.7
Ang total adholding,
37:07.8
city assessor's office din po.
37:09.8
Okay? Take note of that.
37:12.9
Assassin
37:13.3
180, napirmahan na po yung
37:15.7
aming acceptance payment from
37:17.4
estate tax amnesty. Maraming
37:19.5
salamat po sa inyo, attorney. See?
37:22.0
So,
37:23.6
nung una, o ayaw ding pirmahan yung
37:25.6
sa amin dahil di pa raw nila na-encounter
37:27.4
ang ganito. Pero later on, nung pinagkita
37:29.7
ko po yung batas na repub, RR1023,
37:32.2
ay pumayag na rin po sila.
37:33.5
See? Tingnan mo si Assassin 180.
37:36.2
They enforce the right.
37:37.7
I-push talaga. Bigay mo yun.
37:39.4
Print mo yung RR1023.
37:42.3
Bigay mo sa kanila. Pag ayaw nyo
37:43.6
tanggapin yun, ma'am, i-deny mo
37:45.5
ako in writing. At
37:47.4
i-aket ko po yun sa higher ups.
37:49.5
Medyo kakabahan na yan sila. Teka,
37:51.4
bakit higher ups ang pinagsasabi nito?
37:53.6
Kasi po, may batas eh. Bakit yung
37:55.4
hindi sundin?
37:57.1
I'm happy for Assassin 180. At least
37:59.5
talagang natanggap yung
38:01.0
payment nila. Di ba? Thank you for
38:03.4
sharing that, Assassin 180. At
38:05.4
very important po, so that
38:07.3
everybody here watching will know na
38:09.3
meron po talagang ganitong situation
38:11.1
na pwede rin talagang ipilit kapag
38:13.3
maintindihan nila. Okay, good morning
38:15.4
si Chen Ed Quinones. Hello, sir.
38:17.6
Ma'am, kumusta po?
38:19.2
Sila yung lang ni Adriano. Good day, attorney. My aunt
38:21.3
passed away last May 2023.
38:23.5
Kung magbayad po kami ng estate tax,
38:25.4
hanapin na po ba agad ang EGS?
38:27.4
Di po ba applicable yung separate
38:29.1
estate tax at yung issuance ng e-carport
38:31.4
transfer? That's the problem.
38:34.1
Now, if, sabi ko nga,
38:36.5
Republic Act
38:37.2
11956, hindi nagsasabi
38:38.9
na it covers also
38:41.2
death prospectively
38:42.9
na yung namatay after the coverage
38:45.5
ng Republic Act 11956.
38:48.0
Di ba? So,
38:50.3
wait ha. I will
38:51.5
try to check the
38:52.9
Republic Act 11956.
38:55.4
Sabi ng batas dito
38:57.4
is that
38:59.1
it covers
39:01.0
death on or before
39:03.5
May 31
39:04.8
Ito ito. Yan o. Coverage o.
39:08.6
Yan o.
39:09.8
Claro po yan o.
39:11.9
It covers
39:13.6
death
39:14.1
on
39:16.5
Ito ito ito.
39:21.2
Estate who died on or before
39:23.2
May 31, 2022.
39:25.4
Now, ang question
39:27.1
ko po is that
39:28.7
how about for deaths on June
39:31.4
1, 2022 onwards
39:33.6
up to now?
39:35.9
Pwede ba natin i-impose
39:37.7
itong batas na ito?
39:39.9
Republic Act 11956
39:41.3
na nagsasabi na dalawa po
39:43.5
ang proseso. Payment
39:45.4
and transfer.
39:47.3
Silent po ang batas.
39:50.3
Meron kaming
39:51.1
rule na kapag
39:53.7
maganda ang batas, meron siya
39:55.4
prospective application. Ibig sabihin, pwede
39:57.3
i-apply. Pero, wala pa
39:59.1
umaabot sa korte para i-interpret
40:01.4
ito. So, two
40:03.4
options would be that
40:04.7
iklaro po sa batas
40:06.6
na mga lawmakers
40:09.2
natin by making a law clarifying
40:11.5
that it involves
40:12.9
deaths occurring after May 31,
40:15.6
2022.
40:17.4
Or, you go to court and ask
40:19.4
for declaratory relief.
40:22.1
Now, problem,
40:24.6
matagal yan ang proseso.
40:25.4
So,
40:26.1
yes, and hindi natin sila pwedeng
40:30.2
pilitin na hindi nila tanggapin
40:32.5
kapag walang AGS. Kasi nga,
40:35.1
hindi ka na tayo cover sa
40:36.2
estate tax amnesty eh. But, we have
40:38.3
to comply with the old law. Again,
40:40.4
balik na naman tayo doon
40:42.4
sa law under
40:44.4
the train law na kailangan
40:46.2
requirement is AGS or prop order.
40:49.5
I'm planning to,
40:50.4
baby, I'm planning to write, no?
40:52.1
Siguro someone para dito sa matter na ito
40:54.2
how this will be.
40:55.4
If I do.
40:58.0
Okay? So, take note of that.
41:00.4
Tunay na amo. Attorney, saan mas
41:02.3
madaling bumili ng lupa?
41:04.4
Sa lupa na nakapangalan sa isang
41:06.3
bangko or sa isang
41:07.9
individual? Well,
41:10.2
actually naman, tunay na amo.
41:12.2
Thank you for that question. Noob daw
41:14.3
siya dito. Ibig sabihin, baguhan. Okay?
41:16.5
So, actually,
41:19.2
sa pagbili ng
41:20.3
lupa po, risky lahat mo.
41:23.4
Kung sinabi mo
41:24.6
madaling bumili, well,
41:27.4
assuming na malinis
41:28.7
ang papel and everything,
41:30.4
mas mabilis bumili sa isang
41:32.3
individual. Kasi, kung sa bank
41:34.6
kasi, marami pa silang
41:36.2
dadaanan. Let's say, for example,
41:38.8
the bank already
41:39.7
foreclosed the property,
41:42.2
nalipat na ang title sa kanila.
41:44.3
Now, if you want to buy
41:46.6
that, dadaan pa sa mga
41:48.1
corporate ladder yan eh. Banko eh.
41:51.1
Marami pa approval and everything.
41:52.5
Tapos, second, it's possible,
41:54.6
kamay naka-possession pa dun sa property.
41:57.5
Ikaw pa ang kukuha
41:58.5
ng re-possession.
42:00.4
Diba? Eh, diba?
42:02.2
Tapos, it will take time.
42:04.2
Pero, hindi ko sinasabing hindi okay.
42:06.5
Okay pa rin. But, it takes time.
42:09.8
Whereas, sa individual,
42:11.2
at that very moment,
42:12.3
pagbilihin mo ang property, t-check mo yung
42:14.1
property, makikita mo kung mayroong imposition
42:16.2
or anong problema ng property, makikita mo
42:18.4
kagad. So, case to case
42:20.5
basis. Pero, it's a general
42:22.5
rule. It's a nutshell.
42:24.6
General lang. Mas mainam.
42:26.8
As mas mabilis kapag bumili tayo sa
42:28.6
isang individual. Okay?
42:31.5
Cling index lawyer.
42:32.4
Attorney, sorry pero nakat po yung sagot mo
42:34.5
doon sa una kong tanong kanina.
42:36.3
Nagka-propose po sa live or video nyo. Di ko po
42:38.4
tuloy narinig ng sagot. O, ano ba yung tanong mo?
42:42.2
Yung tanong ko po
42:42.9
kanina ay, possibly po bang may
42:44.5
two owners in a single left number
42:46.4
but the area is different. Bakit nakat?
42:48.6
Well, yes. It's possible.
42:52.3
Kaya nga,
42:52.8
kailangan nyo po ng certification.
42:54.6
From the
42:55.4
from the
42:58.1
city assessors. Kung bakit
43:00.6
nagkaroon ng klaseng gano'ng
43:02.4
situation. And if it is
43:04.4
alright with them na nagkaroon ng
43:06.5
different, no? Walang problema.
43:09.2
Then, you can use that later
43:10.5
on as a basis.