RAFFY TULFO VS. PAGCOR- KANINONG INTEREST ANG PINAGLALABAN?
00:46.5
Is it okay with you, Mr. Alvarez?
00:50.7
Ako po ay nagpapasalamat kung sana ay mapadali na para maganda naman ang participation namin sa kumpanya.
00:57.8
Lalo na sa pagpapasara.
00:59.1
Diba, batis nandiyan kami para mapangalagaan naman namin ang mga empyado.
01:05.2
Lalo na pagpapatupad ng CPCS, mapangalagaan naman namin ang mga empyado kung anong ibibigay sa kanila.
01:11.1
Since na hindi kami binibigyan ng pagkakataon, talagang feeling namin ay nadidepribe kami ng aming mga rights.
01:19.0
So kung magkakaganon po, maganda.
01:22.8
Kasi ako, paritire na ako, iiwanan ko na po ang pagsaya sa mga bata.
01:27.1
Isa naman, bago mo lang ako mag-retire.
01:29.1
Eh, maayos po ang pagsaya na itinayo ko po.
01:35.0
Although, ang dami ko naranasan ng mga harassment, tinatapon ako sa iba-ibang brands, hindi ko na po yung pinapansin.
01:41.7
Kasi part po yun ng aking paghihirap na maitayo ang pagsaya.
01:47.7
Bakit kayo naiyak, sir?
01:49.8
Ba't sobrang pangapi ba ang ginawa sa inyo?
01:54.2
Ilayo ka po sa mga anak mo at isawa mo.
01:58.2
Dahil nagtayo ka.
01:59.1
Nandito ka ng pagsaya.
02:00.3
Hindi mo masakit yun, sir chairman.
02:05.7
Okay, that's why sa susunod na hearing, gusto ko po nandito yung mga members ng board
02:11.7
para kung ano man yung mga kailangang maayos to the board resolution,
02:17.0
dito makapag-design na tayo.
02:18.6
Huwag natin patagalan, patagalin pa dahil napakatagal panahon sila po yung nagsakripisyo.
02:24.5
Buti nga na action na nandito ngayon.
02:25.9
Kung hindi pa sila pumunta rito,
02:27.2
hanggang ngayon hindi pa sana na action ang problema nila.
02:30.2
Salamat po sa inyong tiwala, Mr. Alvarez, Mr. Samson, Mr. Cao, sa pumunta rito.
02:34.8
At sa lahat po ng mga magagawang Pilipino,
02:37.5
huwag po kayong mag-alala.
02:39.3
Pag meron po mga problema ang hindi na actionan,
02:42.4
kaya po nandito inyong Senado para actionan yung mga hinahing.
02:46.4
Unless meron pa kayo sabihin?
02:50.1
Regarding po sa recent statements po ni Anon,
02:54.2
historically po talaga, kaya nga po napatagal,
02:57.2
yung aming abang kalagayan,
02:58.9
historically, there is really verifiable oppression po sa aming mga hanay.
03:04.9
And I am a living and breathing, speaking witness and survivor of that.
03:10.5
I do not impeach, I respectfully...
03:12.4
Sa saan usually galing yung oppression, Mr. Cao?
03:16.4
Pupunta ka ng Cebu.
03:19.0
Kasi ang oppression po na nangyayari sa amin, hindi naman confrontational eh.
03:22.8
Harapin ka ng manager mo, aawain.
03:27.2
Anon, papel lang.
03:30.0
Hindi ka tatanggap ng bonus sa papel.
03:32.7
Walang paliwanag.
03:33.9
Walang paliwanag.
03:34.5
Maray-relocate ka sa probinsya, office order.
03:37.4
And what is usually the reason bakit ka agad-agad biglang transfer, paparosahan?
03:42.0
Since it is a form of illegal and it's a crime, walang explanation po.
03:48.9
Pero usually, ano sa tingin nyo, sa palagay nyo, ba't kayo ginaganon?
03:53.9
For example, may kasama po ko sa trabaho.
03:57.2
Hindi ka lang nagustuhan, hindi ka lang type, may kinausap ka lang na, ganun po ang mga raw perception po historically sa amin.
04:07.9
So from now on, legal department, attorney Roderick Consolacion, wala nang pwedeng ma-issue na transfer order
04:14.5
nang hindi na ipapaliwanag ng gusto sa empleyado and it should be justified.
04:24.5
At kaya nga sa susunod, magkakaroon kayo ng board resolution.
04:27.2
Na it should be well explained.
04:30.2
Each and every transfer for any employee of Pagkor whatsoever, it has to be fully justified.
04:40.2
Last confession na lang po.
04:42.0
Regarding po sa basic pay, if I may present a clarification slash confession na perhaps ngayon lang po maririnig ng present leadership.
04:52.8
Pag sinabi po kasing take home pay.
04:55.1
By the way, I would like to...
04:57.2
President of Senator Tolentino.
04:59.9
Good afternoon, sir.
05:01.1
Good afternoon, Mr. Chairman.
05:03.0
Yes, yes, Your Honor.
05:05.1
Would you like to make an opening statement?
05:08.4
I'm just here to listen but I'm with the committee in its efforts to really uncover some of the inequitable practices
05:19.8
that have probably led to injustice and unfairness on the part of the Pagkor employees.
05:25.5
Kaysa po ako nyo.
05:27.2
Thank you, Senator Tolentino.
05:30.6
You may continue, Mr. Cao.
05:34.9
Pag sinabi po sa amin na take home pay, even before the CPCS, nasa minimum na po kami.
05:44.9
Ang pinag-uusap...
05:45.9
Pero pag-uusapan ho, yung basic.
05:48.4
Yun ho, hindi sa minimum.
05:49.9
Ang ginagawa po kasi sa amin, ito basic namin.
05:53.4
Tinatanggap namin.
05:54.2
Tapos tutumbasan po ito ng apps.
05:57.2
Itong basic, ang natataks lang.
05:60.0
Yung apps, hindi.
06:01.4
So, ang kawawang empleyado, pagdating ng retirement,
06:08.1
Maaring namumura yung iba.
06:09.5
Historically, talagang very rough ang interaction namin sa mga customer.
06:14.8
Eh kami yung oppressed.
06:15.7
Na sinusolusyon naman na at the present.
06:18.6
At regarding din po sa oppression ng employee,
06:23.9
naturalmente po, magiging mahina rin po ang enforcement.
06:26.0
Kaya nga rin po, ang daming report na dumadating sa inyo.
06:30.6
Na in my humble opinion,
06:33.9
dapat, una pa lang, hindi na nabigyan ng lisensya.
06:36.4
Hindi pala kayang i-regulate.
06:39.5
Nabigyan pa ng lisensya.
06:41.2
Ang daming ngayong problema.
06:43.2
Na una sa lahat, pinagpapasalamat po namin.
06:46.8
Senator, huwag niyo po kaming bitawan.
06:48.7
Marami pa pong detalye.
06:50.9
Marami pa pong kulay kayong ma-uncover.
06:54.1
At iyan po ay naisip.
06:56.0
Submit ko po nung February 1 sa inyo.
06:59.1
It's a 3-page cover.
07:02.1
Kung ano talaga ang story po ng aming makulay na agency.
07:06.8
Maraming salamat po.
07:08.4
Thank you, thank you, Mr. Cao.
07:09.9
Would you like to react, Mr. Tenko, sa sinabi ni Mr. Cao?
07:21.5
We have already implemented the CPCS.
07:24.7
I'm not sure when you said,
07:26.0
that there was deception
07:27.9
on our part, I would
07:30.1
like to ask Senator Tulfo
07:32.0
to disseminate it from the
07:36.0
management did not have anything to
07:38.0
do with the classifications,
07:42.5
We have implemented
07:45.9
government standardization law,
07:50.3
So, I do not know. Yung
07:51.7
statement mo lang na ito
07:53.7
may mabigat kang sinabi na
07:55.9
deception done on a professional
08:01.9
think you should understand
08:04.1
wala pong kinalaman
08:05.9
ang pag-core board or management
08:09.5
standardization law
08:11.3
na based on EO 150
08:15.8
authority ng GCG.
08:19.2
Go ahead, Senator.
08:21.1
I think Mr. Cao was referring to legal.
08:25.7
Chairman, we can ask the legal too.
08:27.9
Wala ba, may masasabi ba kayo rito?
08:29.4
Parang sinasabi niya, legal yung
08:33.4
Your Honor, I was not pertaining
08:35.6
sa deception. I was not pertaining
08:37.5
on the CPCS implementation.
08:40.5
Not particularly that.
08:41.8
I was particularly
08:43.0
referring to a previous experience,
08:45.5
previous incidents, indicative
08:47.3
of the culture and behavior
08:49.8
of officers in pag-core.
08:52.5
You mentioned something about legal.
08:54.4
Ah, yes, Your Honor.
08:55.7
Are you referring to the legal counsel here?
08:58.0
I was referring to the
09:01.7
verifiable documents that would prove
09:04.1
going against legality
09:07.8
done and signed by
09:09.8
legal of pag-core.
09:12.9
Have you provided
09:14.1
this committee a copy of
09:15.6
whatever proof that you have
09:17.8
right now in your possession?
09:19.4
Initially, Your Honor...
09:21.8
Kasi mahirap magbintang na ano.
09:23.2
Yes, Your Honor. Thank you so much.
09:25.7
Initially, Your Honor, I presented
09:27.5
February 1, a letter
09:29.3
without attachment, but now I have
09:31.4
those attachments with me.
09:34.5
May I present it to you?
09:35.9
To the chair, through the committee
09:37.7
secretary, with the permission of the
09:39.4
Honorable Chairman.
09:42.0
Pag-isabit mo lang, Mr. Kao,
09:43.4
and then we will review that, this committee.
09:50.0
meron pa kayong gustong idagdag?
09:51.3
Ano po, Mr. Chairman, nag-react lang po ako doon sa
09:53.3
nabanggit ka. Wala kayong gustong itanong?
10:00.2
okay na tayo. O, last na lamang.
10:04.2
ng mga empleyado, hindi pa pala natin talakay.
10:10.2
And you did guarantee that?
10:12.5
As I have submitted
10:13.6
a letter to you, I think,
10:15.5
a week ago, and also
10:17.3
GCG wrote you. Until
10:23.0
on the matter, we
10:27.3
status quo on everybody, Senator
10:29.2
Tulfo. That is very clear.
10:33.3
has, I think, reinforced that.
10:39.7
Good afternoon, Mr. Chair.
10:43.3
pasinungalingan po yung sinabi po nila.
10:45.5
Kasi po, a day po
10:47.2
after po tayo nag-usap-usap.
10:50.0
Noong February...
10:50.7
The last hearing?
10:55.1
So, after po February 1 po,
10:59.7
kagad sila ng mga sulat
11:01.1
na mag-take effect
11:04.0
po ng placement committee.
11:06.5
So, pinagpaplanuhan
11:08.2
ba rin po nila kami ipaglilipat
11:11.9
Iba po kasi yung nililipat, iba yung sisibakin.
11:14.4
Totally, wala na sa post.
11:15.3
Pero kasi po, nagkaroon po tayo ng declaration
11:17.3
ng status ko noon. So, diba po,
11:19.1
pag sinabi yung status ko, dapat kung ano
11:21.3
po yung current status, doon lang muna.
11:23.7
So, nagkaroon po ng placement committee.
11:25.1
Status ko kasi meaning walang galawan.
11:27.5
So, Mr. Tenko, hindi ko pa nakita yung sulat.
11:30.2
It wasn't given to me yet by my staff.
11:32.3
Can I ask, Mr. Gian Samson,
11:34.5
meron na ba pong linipat kami
11:36.4
noong matapos akong sumulat
11:38.9
at nag-commit sa Senate
11:40.8
dito sa Senate hearing,
11:43.7
nag-commit ang GCG?
11:46.2
Meron na po bang nailipat,
11:50.1
Pwede ko bang maitanong, Mr. Samson,
11:52.9
I think what he was referring to ay meron ng
11:55.0
sulat na natanggap sila.
11:57.1
Am I right, Mr. Samson? Correct me if I'm wrong.
12:00.6
Na nakaprogram na yung
12:02.8
paglilipat sa inyo.
12:05.4
Yes po, Your Honor.
12:07.3
Yun nga po, right after po noong February 1.
12:09.3
Yun po yun, diba?
12:11.1
So, those letters that were given
12:13.5
to those employees
12:15.1
o pag-or, sabi niyo status ko,
12:17.9
cancelled yung mga letters.
12:21.2
Kaya tinatanong ko po, Mr. Senator,
12:23.8
meron na bang tama po?
12:25.0
Yung tanong niyo kanina, iba yung binabalak
12:27.4
sa iba yung pinatutupad.
12:29.3
Ang tanong ko, Mr. Samson,
12:31.5
meron na po bang,
12:32.8
kung pinasisinungalingan niyo po yung
12:34.8
meron na po bang nailipat
12:37.6
o may natanggal na
12:38.8
doon sa inyong mga
12:41.0
binabanggit? Can you cite a person
12:43.0
nang sa ganun ay akin na pong
12:46.9
na hindi sumunod sa akin?
12:49.3
Sabi niyo po kasi,
12:50.8
pinasisinungalingan niyo po
12:52.8
yung binanggit ko na suspended.
12:55.0
Doon na po muna yung
12:59.4
Meron na po ba, Mr.
13:01.3
Senator Tulfo, with your indulgence,
13:03.3
can I ask him, meron na po bang
13:05.2
isa kayong, or isa,
13:07.3
dalawa, o tatlong empleyado,
13:09.1
o kung ilanman, na mababanggit
13:11.4
niyong ilinipat na
13:15.2
doon sa kanyang pwesto sa ngayon,
13:18.5
Mr. Samson, you may answer, sir.
13:21.9
Ako na pong sasagot, Mr. Chairman.
13:26.1
Katatapos lang po natin
13:27.3
ang sinithiring na status ko.
13:30.5
Right after that,
13:32.5
nagbigay po sila ng sulat.
13:34.8
Although, sabi na natin
13:35.8
wala pa naman nililipat, pero grabing
13:37.6
stress po ang ibinibigay sa empleyado.
13:40.5
Hindi po matutumbasan
13:43.5
stress, parang mo
13:45.5
sinasakal ang empleyado
13:46.8
yung pagbibigay ng sulat na yan.
13:50.6
Yes, stressful po yan.
13:52.4
Parang ginagantihan kayo.
13:53.9
After that hearing.
13:55.9
O nga naman, right after the hearing,
13:58.8
I would take it as an insult
14:00.1
to this committee na nagkaroon tayo
14:02.1
ng agreement na magkakaroon yung status ko
14:04.1
and yet, immediately thereafter,
14:06.5
kayo po yung nagpalabas ng sulat.
14:08.1
Why did that happen?
14:10.3
Mr. Senator, hindi po.
14:12.8
Yung pumasulat na yun,
14:14.0
yun yung before the hearing.
14:16.5
Pero right after po, I wrote
14:18.3
the entire Pagkor organization
14:22.3
everything is straight.
14:22.8
No, but the letter was received.
14:23.9
The letter was received right after the hearing.
14:25.9
Sana, after the hearing,
14:27.9
wala nang sulat na matatanggap sila.
14:30.3
Yun yung concern nila.
14:31.6
Kasi stressful nga naman,
14:33.3
makatanggap sila ng sulat na sila ay natatransfer
14:35.7
na ito yung mangyari sa kanila.
14:37.8
Yun sinasabi niyang stress and anxiety
14:39.6
emanating from that letter.
14:42.1
Kahit na siguro kayo kung nangyari sa inyo yan,
14:44.1
kayo po yung matatransfer sa malayang lugar
14:45.7
matapos kayo magsumbong,
14:47.7
eh yan po hindi dapat nangyari.
14:48.9
Hindi po mangyayari yun, Mr. Senator.
14:53.8
yung sulat ko sa inyo
14:55.1
na sinangayunan. Dumating po yung sulat,
14:58.0
baka yun po yung support year.
14:59.5
Can we get a copy of the letter? Anong date doon sa letter,
15:02.6
Mr. Samson, Mr. Alvarez?
15:06.3
bali po, meron po kami na-receive
15:08.0
noong February 5.
15:10.1
Ano ang date po noong receipt
15:13.5
Receiving nga po noon, binigay po through email
15:16.0
February 5. That was after
15:18.0
noong February 1. And then
15:19.8
there was an instruction coming
15:22.3
Ma'am Che Francisco
15:25.7
and Ma'am Nanette Pakalyagan
15:27.5
na ituloy po yung
15:29.8
nagtuloy po sila ng second placement
15:31.8
process po eh. Yun po yung ano eh.
15:34.2
Instead na dapat po hindi na nila gagawin yun,
15:36.3
tinuloy po nila. And sir,
15:38.1
I can present to you...
15:39.3
Who's Che Ilagan?
15:41.9
Ando, ando po nga po.
15:43.4
Ano, kumsek, patawag si Che Ilagan
15:46.3
sa susunod na hearing?
15:48.1
At saka sino yung nagbigay sa inyo ng sulat?
15:50.1
It was an instruction coming from
15:52.1
Ms. Nanette Pakalyagan and
15:53.9
Ma'am Che Francisco.
15:55.0
Nanette Pakalyaga, patawag dito.
15:59.0
And Che Francisco.
16:00.3
And Che Francisco.
16:01.3
And then, ang signatory po noon, sir,
16:03.9
under oath po yun last time, si
16:05.8
Sir Dan Cecilio. Kaya nga po, nagre-request
16:08.1
po kami for contempt.
16:10.0
Very good. I like that.
16:12.0
Patawag din si ano pangal ulit?
16:14.0
Si Daniel Cecilio po.
16:15.4
Daniel Cecilio. Sa susunod na hearing,
16:17.7
Daniel Cecilio should be here.
16:20.1
Okay. Sir, dagdag ko lang po,
16:22.1
meron po kaming clear evidence po
16:24.2
ng memorandum po ng
16:27.7
What do you mean send-off party?
16:29.0
Kung talaga po wala silang balak na
16:31.9
ituloyan kami, bakit po sila nag
16:33.7
produce ng send-off party?
16:36.0
Para kanina yung send-off party?
16:37.2
Para sa amin daw po. Para daw po umalis na kami.
16:42.1
Dapat po gagawin po yun noong February
16:43.8
19, pero hindi na po natuloy nga.
16:46.5
Kasi po, ang nangyari po,
16:48.1
nagkaroon po kami ng hearing last...
16:49.8
Okay. So, kung February 19 at hindi na natuloy,
16:52.1
sabihin, sinusunod nilang
16:53.5
kung ano na pag-uusapan noong last hearing?
16:56.1
Yes, sir. Bale, yun nga po. After po
16:58.0
noong letter namin sa inyo,
16:59.8
na nag-cross-letter din po
17:02.5
kami sa GECG and sa Office of the
17:04.2
President, that's the time pa lang po na
17:06.1
nag-release sila ng final order nila.
17:08.0
Dated February 13 or 14.
17:11.9
So, all of that, pwede natin pag-usapan
17:14.2
sa susunod na hearing. Okay.
17:16.1
We can also present leaving witnesses po
17:18.1
at your honor, if you want,
17:20.3
ng mga hinaras po nila,
17:22.1
na sinabihan po nila na mareredan late kayo.
17:26.0
Dapat yung pinagsabihan, meron tayong
17:28.0
ebidensya na talagang
17:29.9
that was said, and
17:32.0
mas maganda kung meron tayong
17:33.5
sulat na ibinigay
17:36.0
doon sa tao at mga testigo. Kasi kung
17:38.0
sasabihin lang ni Juan na ako'y hinaras
17:40.1
ni Pedro, mukhang hindi naman po
17:42.3
ata tama yun. Kasi anybody
17:44.0
can say anything to, against
17:48.0
Maliban na lang kung meron po kayong mga testigo
17:50.4
o may mga documentations.
17:52.1
Signing to that allegation. Okay, sir.
17:54.2
Ayun nga po, your honor.
17:56.0
Yung mga mismong tao po na
17:58.0
nakaranas po nung
17:59.6
mga ganong situation po
18:01.8
na nagsumbong sa amin, we can present
18:04.0
them to you po next hearing kung gusto nyo po.
18:06.2
Pwede po namin silang invite dito.
18:08.0
Okay. Notices and
18:10.0
invitations for the next succeeding meetings
18:11.9
will be sent accordingly. There being no other
18:14.0
matters for consideration, this hearing
18:15.9
is hereby suspended.
