Sen. Tolentino May TIP kung Paano Makalusot si Quibuloy sa Senado Contempt
* AI ("Artificial Intelligence") subtitles on Tagalog.com are generated using "Whisper" by OpenAI (the same company that created ChatGPT and DallE2). Results and accuracy may vary.
* The subtitles do include errors occasionally and should only be used as a tool to help with your listening practice.
* You can request this website to create a transcript for a video if one doesn't already exist by clicking the "Request AI Subtitles" button below a video. Transcribing usually takes 30-40% of the length of a video to complete if there are no other videos in
the queue. For example, a 21 minute video will take 7-8 minutes to transcribe.
* Running a super fast cloud GPU server to do these transcriptions does cost money. If you have the desire and financial ability, consider
becoming a patron
to support these video transcriptions, and the other tools and apps built by Tagalog.com
00:00.0
In December, nung ako pa yung chairman ng Blue Ribbon Committee, binago natin yung rules.
00:10.3
And the rules, as amended, would apply likewise to persons cited in contempt.
00:17.9
So yung sa atin, sa pagbabago ng rules, binigyan po natin ng DIN yung karapatang pantao noong mga humaharap sa mga committee.
00:31.4
So sa atin po nilagay, ay dapat kilalanin din yung kanilang karapatan as an individual, as a Filipino citizen.
00:42.9
So yung sa akin, we reiterated that.
00:47.9
At during that interview, ang sabi ko po, ay kung merong pamamaraang legal na gagawin si Pastor Kibuloy sa pagdulog sa usgado,
01:01.5
kagaya nun nangyari noong NERI case sa Senado, kung inyo natatandaan pa, wala makakapigil sa kanya.
01:10.0
At hindi dapat pigilan yun kasi karapatan niya yun.
01:15.2
Kung sakaling siya naman ay dadalo sa isang pagbabago.
01:17.9
At sa tinig ng Senado, kailangan din igalang ng committee ang kanyang karapatan.
01:23.8
Ang ibig sabihin nun, huwag babastusin, huwag tatratuhin bilang isang nagkasala na.
01:33.4
Dahil ang pagdidetermine ng pagkakasala ng isang tao, the right to adjudicate the guilt of a person lies with the court and not with a committee.
01:46.4
Maliwanag po yan.
01:47.9
Ang atin pong gawain dito sa Senado is to investigate in aid of legislation.
01:55.4
It is not the right, it is not the duty of the Senate to condemn and imprison an individual.
02:02.8
Because that individual, no matter how high nor lowly he is, has the same basic human right and the right of being the right to innocence.
02:17.9
So igalang po yun.
02:20.1
Yung po yung sinabi ko nun, igalang yung karapatan ni Pastor Kibuloy.
02:32.5
Ang council of the target resource person, halimbawa yung kay Kibuloy.
02:40.0
Can he insist to the committee to recognize his council given his supposed threat?
02:47.9
Hindi po ako yung abugado dito ni Pastor.
02:54.4
Pero kung siguro kung gustong gamitin ng abugado niya, nung binago po natin yung section 16 and 18,
03:03.7
eh pwede niyang sabihin na bigyan din sila ng karapatan na mag-file ng memorandum, etc.
03:11.6
Kagaya po nung ginawa natin doon sa mga nagdaang pagdinignan.
03:17.9
So babalik at babalik po yan sa paggalang sa karapatan.
03:23.2
Kahit sino man na nandun, kahit hindi si Pastor, huwag bastusin yung mga nandito sa kumaharap sa committee ng Senado.
03:32.9
Sir, would it be, if we, if the Senate heads to the, to what Pastor Kibuloy wants, na non-appearance,
03:44.1
would this not be, would this not set a bad precedent to our,
03:47.9
other personalities who would be invited by the Senate?
03:52.7
Hindi ko alam po yung dahilan niya eh. Hindi naman ako yung...
03:56.0
So this should be case-to-case basis?
03:58.1
Correct. Correct. So ulitin ko, may karapatan ang Senado na hilingin ang kanyang presensya,
04:06.4
subalit yung kagaya po doon sa NERI case. Kung natandaan niyo yung NERI case,
04:11.3
pinawalang visa ng Supreme Court yung contempt, nilift yun, yung si Romulo NERI.
04:17.9
So na yun yung mga, yung mga bata-bata pa nun nandito nung panahon yun.
04:23.2
So kung natatandaan niyo yun, nakialam ang, ang husgado, ang Supreme Court,
04:28.0
at sinabi, lifted yung contempt order. So he can, he can utilize that.
04:34.0
May karapatan naman siya eh. May abogado siya.
04:36.7
Sir, parang yung halos nung sa farmally na umabot din sa court, parang gano'n din?
04:42.9
He can, he can maximize, utilize all legal venues.
04:47.9
Available to him. And no one should deprive him of that right.
04:56.9
Wala na. Wala na. Nakakalimutan niyo na yung chacha. Sige. Wala na. Tapos na.
05:03.6
Sir, tanong siya kung napag-usapan ba kayo informally?
05:09.8
Among senators and congressmen.
05:14.4
Kung pinag-usapan.
05:16.8
Informally. Ano magsasabi?
05:17.9
Hindi na informally. Hindi formal.
05:21.9
Alam mo, masaya kami kanina. Nung sa, ano, sa prior to the signing, si,
05:28.1
nasa harapan ko nakaupo si, si BBM, o sa kaliwa si SP,
05:35.2
sa harapan ko sa kaliwa si, si speaker.
05:39.0
So wala naman ako nakikitang, ah, rift.
05:43.5
Ang, ang alam ko ay, ah, iisa pa rin ng kongreso.
05:47.9
The lower house. Ang daming congressmen kanina.
05:51.3
The lower house and the upper house. So, wala ko nakikitang, ah, pag-aaway.
06:00.0
Sa voting separately, would it not be a contentious issue?
06:05.4
Kasi yung house naku, walang gano'ng...
06:07.0
Well, well enshrined ang bicameralism sa ating sistema.
06:17.9
Wala pa naman, hindi pa naman tinatanggap na unicameral body ang dalawang kapulungan.
06:25.0
Kaya, ah, even without mentioning that, voting separately yun.
06:31.2
Sir, how would you deal with this ban ng, ano, ng kongreso?
06:37.1
Ah, ulitin ko, ha?
06:39.4
Tatlo lang ang modes ng pag-amend ng saligang batas.
06:45.0
One, constitutional convention.
06:47.9
Two, constituent assembly.
06:50.8
Three, people's initiative.
06:52.6
Itong nangyayari ngayon, this is, this is pursuant to a fourth mode coming from a commentary of the late Father Bernas.
07:06.2
So, the lower house, by invoking the fourth mode, yung resolution of both houses, number seven, is in effect,
07:17.2
saying that we are going to utilize the fourth mode, but even if the resolution is silent as to the manner of voting,
07:30.9
the fourth mode speaks of voting, implies voting separately because of the bicameral nature of our congress.
07:44.0
Pinahil nga nila ng bukod.
07:46.3
Pinahil din namin ng bukod.
07:47.2
Dinidinlig nila ng bukod.
07:50.0
Dinidinlig namin ng bukod.
07:51.9
Kung merong pagkakaiba doon, papasok sa bicameral conference committee.
07:57.6
So, even though they're silent, their mere acceptance of the fourth mode implies that it has to be voted upon separately.
08:12.2
Kuwentas klaro tayo doon?
08:16.2
Ang dami niyo recitation?
08:17.2
Kasi may may statement ng mga congressman, may mga congressman, may mga congressman,
08:21.9
na ako ay mga congressman na si Jelena.
08:24.5
Kaya eventually, di mo rin hindi nilang kukuhain sa mga congressman.
08:28.7
So, mga congressman, may mga congressman, may mga congressman, may mga congressman,
08:33.4
They have to read the constitution.
08:35.7
They have to read the constitution.
08:37.6
No offense to them.
08:39.8
So, parang may wala yung mga religious, yung mga worries ng semen,
08:45.8
o yung mga unnecessary,
08:47.2
yung mga worries ng semen,
08:49.4
yung mga worries ng semen,
08:50.1
dapat ako kasi mga kategorical statement,
08:52.6
galing from the speaker,
08:53.7
hindi approved separately,
08:55.0
para magagawa sa iyo.
08:56.5
It doesn't follow.
09:03.4
After the adoption,
09:09.2
Senate approves RBH 6.
09:12.7
Without a self-improvement,
09:17.2
it would have to be reconciled in a bicameral conference committee.
09:34.5
And the end product would be submitted to the people in a plebiscite
09:43.2
called for the purpose of approving or rejecting,
09:48.2
Ultimately, yung tao rin ang mag-de-decide nito eh.
09:56.8
Pa-share paper na kayo.
09:58.8
Sir, yung sentence sa pilingan,
10:03.8
have you attended the three,
10:05.8
the past three hearings ang saktong meeting?
10:07.8
Matatapos ko ba na?
10:09.8
Nakatatlo na ba? Dalawa pa lang?
10:11.8
Hindi, yung una kasi yung general provisions eh.
10:19.8
business and education.
10:21.8
Although not the entirety.
10:23.8
From what you've heard,
10:25.8
ano yung mas malamang
10:29.8
Diba may sinasabi?
10:31.8
Kailangan ng 18 votes
10:35.8
Kailangan ng 18 votes whether to amend or not.
10:37.8
So personally po,
10:39.8
kadamit yun sa mga narinig nyo?
10:43.8
Hindi, ikaw nga yun eh.
10:47.8
Sir, from what you,
10:49.8
from your point of view, mas madami
10:51.8
na sumusuporta sa to amend it?
10:53.8
O huwag muna, it's not
10:57.8
Palagay ko mas maraming sumusuporta.
10:59.8
Hindi ko lang alam kung
11:09.8
Pero hindi pa tapos. May advertising pa tayo.
11:15.8
Okay na tayo? Nakangalay na?
11:17.8
Salamat, salamat, salamat, salamat.
11:19.8
Pansin niyo kung may mga
11:21.8
orokan doon sa paper.
