00:23.9
ito kaya, paano ko mapapadiscuss si Baby Boy?
00:26.5
Dito kay Boy Uhug.
00:27.9
Yung ano, Boy Uhug.
00:30.7
Yung disbarment case.
00:32.7
Kasi matagal ko nang alam na itong disbarment na ito,
00:35.8
kapag diniscuss mo ito online,
00:39.3
pwede kang madisbar na talaga rito.
00:41.8
Mapay lang ka ng kontep.
00:43.1
Tignan niyo, may papakita ako sa inyo.
00:46.8
Meron ng jurisprudence patungkol dito.
00:56.8
Ito, tignan niyo rito, ano.
01:11.1
Nakikita ba ninyo?
01:20.3
In Relatavio v. De Leon,
01:23.0
the court ruled that the premature,
01:26.8
disclosure by publication
01:29.6
of the filing and pendency
01:31.6
of disbarment proceeding
01:32.8
is a violation of the confidentiality rule.
01:36.0
So, may ipinablish dito.
01:38.3
Nagkaroon ng publication patungkol
01:40.0
doon sa disbarment.
01:42.9
Nagkaroon ng publication tungkol doon sa disbarment.
01:45.5
So, parang ibinigay yata ito
01:47.2
sa isang publishing company.
01:48.9
Tapos, ipinablish.
01:50.5
Ewan ko lang, hindi ko kasi nabasa ng buo ito.
01:52.7
Based lang dito sa binasa natin na
01:54.2
nagkaroon ng publication.
01:56.8
yung information galing doon sa ano,
02:00.1
kung sino man yung abogado na yan.
02:05.6
Filing of the pendency of disbarment proceeding
02:08.5
is a violation of the confidentiality rule.
02:22.2
in a disbarment case
02:23.4
caused the publication in newspaper
02:26.3
regarding the filing and pendency
02:28.4
of the disbarment proceeding.
02:30.8
found him guilty of
02:37.2
jurisprudence dito
02:38.2
na kapag pala ito ay
02:42.2
pwede ka palang ma-file na ng contempt.
02:47.3
bago natin ipakita yung
02:48.6
ibang mga basihan natin,
02:50.5
gusto kong panoorin natin itong
02:52.9
kung totoong nga bang
02:58.4
na i-finalize sa kanya.
03:01.4
Pakinggan natin ito.
03:02.8
Sana kung may abogado dito, no?
03:05.0
especially kabatas na abogado.
03:08.3
Para tingnan natin
03:09.2
kung anong sagot nila rito.
03:11.3
O eto, pakinggan natin
03:15.9
Or dahil kay Rafi Tulfo.
03:18.1
And we will discuss, of course,
03:19.4
the material facts.
03:20.3
Ano ba ang dahilan?
03:21.6
Di i-discuss daw nila
03:22.9
yung material of facts.
03:25.1
Material of facts.
03:26.9
So, totoo pa lang ano ito.
03:28.3
Disbarment na ito.
03:29.5
At hindi lang ito
03:30.5
basta dinaanan lang.
03:32.2
Kundi i-discuss niya
03:33.3
yung material of facts.
03:37.8
Pangunahing dahilan
03:38.8
kung bakit sila nag-file
03:41.4
ng disbarment sa akin noon.
03:43.1
It's because I criticized him
03:45.0
dito sa Seafarer's Act.
03:47.0
Actually, hindi yun ang reason.
03:49.0
Hindi yun ang reason
03:49.7
yung pag-criticize mo.
03:51.3
Hindi yun ang reason.
03:52.2
Siguro yun lang ang pumasok
03:53.2
sa maliit mong pag-iisip.
03:56.7
pinapailan ng disbarment
03:58.1
dahil sa pambabastos mo,
04:00.2
yun po ang bawal.
04:03.1
Eh, alam naman natin,
04:04.4
given naman natin na libayan
04:06.0
na bastos kang abugado,
04:07.9
kaya ka napapailan
04:10.4
Ngayon, bukod sa kabastusan mo,
04:11.8
medyo syunga-syunga ka pa,
04:13.7
diniscuss mo pa yan.
04:16.9
Tapos mamaya, mga kapans natin,
04:18.0
ipapakita din natin
04:19.0
yung mga Seafarer's Act.
04:20.5
Yung mga nangyari sa kanya
04:22.4
dun sa Seafarer's Act.
04:25.1
violation si Gossip Central.
04:28.0
Sabi dito ni Enpan, ano?
04:30.4
At may liyap reacts,
04:31.9
bilis mo naman mabait.
04:34.2
Ako mababait nyo?
04:40.0
hindi pa pinapanganak
04:41.2
yung mababait sakin.
04:44.0
Sige, paliwanag mo
04:46.0
ni Baby Boy dito.
04:47.6
Diniscuss ko yung content niya,
04:49.0
paano niya ako nabait.
04:55.1
Ito, mga kapans natin,
04:56.5
yung material facts
04:57.5
doon sa final sakin
05:01.7
doon sa final sakin
05:07.0
umpisang-umpis yan,
05:07.8
mga kapans natin.
05:09.3
Paragraph 3 nga eh.
05:10.3
On September 27, 2023,
05:13.0
during Senate Session No. 28,
05:15.2
the Senate of the Philippines
05:16.3
approved on 3rd Reading
05:17.8
Senate Bill No. 2221.
05:20.7
So, ito, mga kapans natin.
05:21.9
Senate Bill No. 2221.
05:25.1
On September 27, 2023,
05:27.8
during Senate Session,
05:28.9
ito pala yung hearing
05:30.7
tungkol sa Magna Carta.
05:34.2
Sabi ni En pa no secret, o.
05:36.0
Matagal na yung secret na yun.
05:37.2
Last year pa yan.
05:39.7
maniniwala pa ako sa secret nyo.
05:41.6
Yan ang style nyo
05:42.5
para maka-rebat lang kayo.
05:44.6
Parang si Baby Boy,
05:46.7
O, ayan, may ref,
05:49.4
Basang-basa ko kayo.
05:50.7
Basang-basa ko kayo.
05:52.8
Natin, parang gusto nilang
05:57.0
walang ginawang mabuti.
05:59.8
kahit maganda daw yung ginagawa
06:02.4
mga kapatas natin,
06:04.6
Kahit maganda daw yung ginagawa
06:08.4
krinikritisize ko pa rin daw.
06:10.8
Hindi yun ang problema.
06:13.5
Ang problema dito
06:14.3
yung pambabastos mo.
06:15.5
Pwede naman magkritisize, eh.
06:17.0
Marami naman nagkikritisize.
06:18.3
Marami nagbibigay ng komento
06:19.8
patungkol dyan sa, ano,
06:21.9
sa Magna Carta na yan.
06:23.7
isa sa nagbigay ng komento,
06:27.6
Pero si Pia Cayetano naman,
06:29.3
hindi naman bastos katulad mo.
06:31.9
Ikaw nagkritisize ka
06:35.0
Tignan mo yung mga title
06:35.9
ng ginawa mo dyan.
06:36.8
Ipapakita dyan mamaya.
06:39.6
Tignan nyo kung paano nila
06:41.1
tinaylor itong material facts nila
06:43.5
sa disbarment case sa akin.
06:46.7
Talagang dinidiscuss niya rito
06:48.9
yung facts nung disbarment case, ano.
06:52.2
Makinig, makinig.
06:55.0
Na-approve sa third reading.
06:58.0
Being the sponsor of the said bill,
06:59.5
Senator Tulfo received
07:00.7
from his colleagues
07:01.7
and fellow senators
07:02.9
the following well-deserved praises
07:10.9
as evidenced by the link.
07:12.5
So pinakaawa ko bigla.
07:13.9
Ang galing ni Raffi Tulfo.
07:17.6
mga kabatas natin.
07:19.4
Ito yung match nyo.
07:20.0
May sipon-sipon dito
07:21.3
Tapos binabaan niya lang.
07:22.2
Ipapahig niya lang yun.
07:25.8
Senator Raffi Tulfo
07:27.2
for the stewardship,
07:28.4
blah, blah, blah, blah.
07:29.5
Sinabi ni Grace po.
07:33.8
Si Joel Villanueva rin.
07:35.1
We thank the gentleman
07:36.2
from Isabela in Davao
07:37.3
for taking the cudgel
07:38.4
and sponsoring this
07:40.1
landmark registration.
07:42.3
So pinapakita nila dito,
07:43.3
mga kabatas natin.
07:44.5
Sabi dito ni Kala, o.
07:46.7
Kung kinontent niya yan,
07:48.0
naku, hindi niya alam
07:51.5
ang klase na abogado ito, eh.
07:53.1
Na, ang galing ni Raffi Tulfo
07:54.4
dun sa ginawa niya.
07:55.0
Kasi ikokontrast nila yan
07:56.7
dun sa ginawa kong
07:57.7
criticism sa kanya.
08:00.7
I would like to thank,
08:01.9
I would like to congratulate
08:02.9
all the members of the Senate,
08:04.2
especially sponsor.
08:06.0
Sabi ni Enpan, o.
08:08.9
alam mo kung bakit?
08:09.8
Kasi nagpapapansin lang ako,
08:11.3
eh, pinansin mo ako,
08:12.2
kaya nabait kita.
08:14.1
guys, paki time out nga.
08:15.3
Ayan, napansin kita, ha.
08:20.6
Masama pag napansin kita, eh.
08:22.4
Nata-time out ka, eh.
08:35.1
Wala naman problema
08:39.2
Pero kung oras-oras,
08:44.7
ang nasa utak mo.
08:46.0
Napakatalinong bobo
08:47.7
naipanalo na kaso.
08:53.3
Ten minutes lang,
08:54.4
mabait ako na, weh.
08:56.2
Ang ating dakilang moderator.
08:58.4
Salamat, Ma'am Regina.
09:03.3
I-disneyo si, ano,
09:13.7
A neophyte senator
09:16.2
shepherd the process
09:17.1
and sponsor not an easy
09:18.3
piece of legislation,
09:19.8
Loren Legarda naman.
09:24.9
kasi sinabi daw dito, no?
09:27.5
ng todong-toto, di ba?
09:30.8
in stalking his perennial prey,
09:34.1
for any possible contents
09:36.7
respondent immediately
09:37.8
pounds on what he perceived
09:39.5
on the part of the former.
09:48.0
Because the flaws
09:49.0
are actually there!
10:02.2
Vindicated pa siya
10:03.1
nun lagay dito, ah?
10:03.5
He perceived three flaws
10:04.2
on the part of the former
10:05.2
when he was subjected
10:06.1
to clarificatory questioning
10:07.4
by Senator Pia Cayetano
10:08.7
during session number 28.
10:12.9
if not unwarranted,
10:14.7
blown out of proportion!
10:19.1
Hindi daw tama yung ginawa ko.
10:21.1
I blew it out of proportion.
10:23.6
the subject of his vlog
10:26.1
Alam ko hindi si Yesa Ati
10:27.5
ang nag-file na ito eh
10:28.4
kasi mayroon nag-file
10:33.7
Ito nag-file na ito
10:35.4
Based lang sa ano,
10:37.6
may nag-file daw sa kanya
10:39.4
pero hindi kilala.
10:40.8
Tinanong ko kay, ano,
10:42.1
Tony Villamorion,
10:44.9
kilala mo ba yung nag-file
10:46.5
Kasi sinasabi niya,
10:47.5
hindi ito lang na-file natin, ah.
10:48.9
Eh, bakit sobra ng isa?
10:50.8
May nag-file daw ng iba.
10:52.0
Kilala mo ba yan?
10:53.3
hindi ko kilala yan eh.
10:54.4
Tingin ko ito yun eh.
11:01.4
in his YouTube and Facebook accounts,
11:03.8
Ronnie Randolph Libayan
11:04.6
with the following link.
11:09.2
may pasabog tayo,
11:11.6
may pasabog daw siya.
11:15.1
kinontent kami kahapon.
11:17.6
kagrupo ni ano ito eh.
11:18.9
Ni Ballpoint Man.
11:22.7
Mamaya magkokontent siya.
11:26.8
may bago na ngayong kalaban
11:30.6
Dahil kay Boy Bantot.
11:35.8
yung mga ginawa ko.
11:37.8
Dami kasing views,
11:40.3
Tignan nyo yung mga title
11:43.8
versus Pia Cayetano.
11:52.3
kaya ka nakakasuhan ng ano,
11:54.0
kaya maraming nagagalit sa'yo.
11:56.8
sa pagbabatikos mo,
11:58.6
sa pambabastos mo.
12:09.6
ang ginawa nila dito after,
12:13.8
na statements ko daw.
12:16.2
kinokopya ko lang naman
12:19.9
Bawal sa isang lawyer
12:21.2
ang magsalita ng hindi maganda.
12:23.3
Kahit na sabi mong
12:24.2
kinopya mo lang yan,
12:25.7
kung ipatutungkol mo
12:27.7
na hindi maganda,
12:31.8
diba yung salitang mokong
12:37.0
yung salitang mokong
12:40.8
Pwede mo bang sabihin,
12:42.2
kaya ko lang namang
12:42.8
ginamit yung salitang mokong
12:44.1
kasi nabasa ko na
12:45.0
yun ang tawag sa kanya.
12:48.5
nabasa mo lang yun,
12:51.3
na ikaw ay isang abugado,
12:52.9
na meron kayong dignidad
12:54.1
na iniingatan nyo,
12:56.3
hindi naman ako abugado.
12:57.8
Kung tawagin ba kitang
12:59.8
pwede ba ako i-contempt?
13:03.6
Tulo kasi ng tulo
13:05.4
tapos ikaw naman,
13:06.4
papahirap mo lang ganit,
13:07.3
papahid mo lang sa damit mo.
13:14.6
if only to provoke
13:15.4
interest and excitement
13:16.4
to generate views
13:20.5
ang haba na neto,
13:22.4
dinidiscuss niya rito.
13:24.0
Ang dinidiscuss niya rito,
13:25.3
yung disbarment niya.
13:26.9
So, bawal po yan.
13:28.2
may papakita ako sa inyo.
13:30.4
May papakita ako.
13:35.5
Sayang walang abugado
13:40.2
mapabasa natin ito
13:57.2
law is a profession,
14:03.1
as officer of the court
14:09.1
that the legal profession
14:14.3
the legal profession.
14:16.1
Lawyer are generally
14:20.7
Hindi pwede mag-advertise
14:22.0
ang isang abugado.
14:24.3
nag-advertise ito eh.
14:25.7
Pati yung notary public
14:26.8
niya, in-advertise niya eh.
14:28.4
Kung ako ang magsasampan
14:32.4
Isasama ko yung ano na yan.
14:34.3
patungkol dyan, ano?
14:35.6
Pero hindi yan yung
14:36.5
pinaka-main event.
14:46.4
The confidentialness
14:54.0
disbarment proceeding
14:57.4
a lawyer's reputation
14:58.6
in a public sphere.
15:00.9
Just the general rule
15:05.0
disbarment proceeding
15:09.9
diniscuss mo pala
15:17.8
nung pinakita ko kanina
15:22.5
yung isang abugado.
15:41.8
attorney relativo
15:45.5
in a disbarment case
15:46.6
caused the publication
15:49.4
regarding the filing
15:52.0
of the disbarment
16:00.1
So nakita na ninyo,
16:02.6
bawal mag-discuss
16:03.8
ang isang abugado
16:05.1
pagdating sa disbarment.
16:08.6
e pababasa pa ako
16:12.5
Antayin lang natin
16:13.6
yung content dito
16:17.8
Tignan-tignan ninyo ito,
16:35.3
So nakita na ninyo,
16:38.1
tsaka suspension ha.
16:46.0
ay isang confidential.
16:47.8
Proceeding against
16:51.4
and confidential.
16:54.2
laban sa isang abugado
16:57.9
and confidential.
17:02.1
shall be made public.
17:04.3
Kailangan yung court
17:05.1
nilang magpapublic.
17:06.7
As in other cases,
17:08.1
coming before the court.
17:19.3
So nakikita na ninyo,
17:20.3
may mga abugado ba dyan?
17:21.9
Sana meron abugado dito
17:23.3
para at least ngayon
17:25.2
matutulan nila yung
17:26.3
yung sinasabi ko na ito.
17:30.9
So nakita na ninyo.
17:32.5
So antayin natin ito.
17:39.8
Pagpalusot ka na naman.
