COLLECTOR'S EDITION NA! RAFFY TULFO KINASUHAN ULIT SI ATTY. LIBAYAN SA ISABELA NG CYBER LIBEL
00:48.3
Well, according to Rafi Tulfo, resident daw siya ng Kawayan Isabela.
00:54.4
Eh, bahala ka sa buhay mo. Okay?
00:58.1
So, tignan natin yung sinabi ng Supreme Court dyan.
01:02.9
For the meantime mga kabatas natin, although linabas naman na ni Melo Yap ito,
01:06.8
nilabas niya na yung transcript, no?
01:09.2
Tapos, sila naman maraming beses na na pinalabas nila,
01:13.3
nakakasuhan ako sa ibat-ibang lugar na malalayo para ako ay ma-inconvenient, mga kabatas natin.
01:24.8
Totoo nga yung sinasabi nila.
01:26.3
It is my obligation din, mga kabatas natin, of course, to clarify to you if what they are telling you is true.
01:35.4
Ang daming nagtatanong na sa akin, mga kabatas natin, ano?
01:38.5
Itong kinaso niya sa akin sa Kawayan Isabela, na residente daw siya doon, mga kabatas natin,
01:45.1
itong call doon kay Barbara Milano.
01:49.0
Yung declaration ni Barbara Milano na niloko siya ni Rafi Tulfo.
01:55.4
Siyempre, pinakita.
01:56.3
Mahid na naman sa akin doon kasi nag-react ako.
02:00.1
I told you, it's very obvious.
02:03.4
Basang-basa yung utak niya.
02:06.8
Well, ang maganda dito, mga kabatas natin, no?
02:10.3
Natakot na silang kasuhan.
02:13.1
Yung mga small vloggers.
02:15.2
Kitang-kita dito na tinanggal.
02:17.7
Yung mga small vloggers, nakakasuhan nila.
02:21.7
Well, good for you, Rafi Tulfo.
02:27.0
domicile or residence?
02:28.6
That remains to be seen.
02:30.4
Basang-basa ang galawan.
02:32.4
Kinode pa ako dito.
02:33.8
Ito kasi yung video, mga kabatas natin, no?
02:36.7
February 17, 2020, for one of my staff, brought to my attention certain videos
02:41.5
she found on YouTube published by Respondent Libayan during his live broadcast.
02:45.7
In these videos, Respondent Libayan vilified and attacked my person
02:50.0
which undoubtedly put me in contempt, public shame, and ridicule.
03:24.6
his commentaries in the
03:28.1
publication, Respondent Libayan
03:30.5
made a parody song.
03:32.6
Nakita niya yan. Made a parody song
03:36.5
where he painted me as a sexual
03:42.5
naman, Raffy Tulfo, diba?
03:50.4
Respondent Libayan in the same video
03:52.3
also imputed that I am
03:54.5
living an immoral, indecent, and
03:56.3
promiscuous life by brazenly declaring
03:58.4
that I am being deceitful not only to my
04:00.4
wife, but also to the public in general.
04:04.5
Trinanscribe niya. Ito yung pinakita
04:06.5
sa inyo ni Meloyap na transcription
04:08.5
dun sa kabila, mga kabads natin.
04:12.8
Kinakaso-kaso nila.
04:16.0
Tingnan nyo dito.
04:22.2
dito sa transcript.
04:28.3
Statement number two. Yan.
04:30.5
From her past romance with Raffy Tulfo,
04:32.3
she learned that it's not easy to fall
04:34.3
in love with a married man.
04:36.8
Okay. Ako daw ang nagsabi
04:38.2
na promiscuous itong si Raffy Tulfo.
04:42.3
Sabi niya. Tapos sinabi ko,
04:44.4
mga kabads natin, this is from
04:48.1
2002 nga. Tapos diba,
04:49.8
lumabas si Barbara Milano.
05:00.1
ay may relasyon ni Raffy Tulfo.
05:01.9
Diba? Napanood natin
05:06.0
Sabi niya. Yung mayor leave
05:08.1
ay sunod natin yun. Bukas sigurong.
05:10.0
Bukas yan. Bukas yan.
05:13.2
Matatawa ka na lang
05:14.1
talaga dito sa ginagawa ni Raffy Tulfo.
05:18.0
Mga kabads natin, this is from 2002.
05:20.4
Three years ang tagal.
05:22.3
Mga kabads natin, lolokohin mo ang
05:24.1
pamilya mo for three years. Tapos ikaw pa
05:27.9
Kakasuhan naman ako ng
05:38.0
mga kabads natin,
05:39.7
collection na ito.
05:43.8
meron na tayong tour of Luzon.
05:48.2
Sabi nga nung ni Vince World
05:53.9
parte ng Pilipinas daw.
05:56.6
So, baka magkakaroon tayo
05:57.9
ng tour around the Philippines.
06:05.9
are they serious?
06:08.2
Yun ang sinasabi ko eh.
06:09.4
Siyempre, tuwang-tuwanan naman yung mga ano dyan.
06:11.4
Guilty na ako dyan sa mga ampalayag
06:13.2
at sa mga Tulfonatics.
06:14.9
This is a win for them.
06:17.4
Even if it's just starting.
06:20.8
Yung copyright infringement nga,
06:23.1
hirap na hirap na nga kayo doon sa ano.
06:25.8
Hirap na hirap na nga kayo doon sa probable cause.
06:27.9
Tapos, kayo pa yung mayabang.
06:40.8
Kakasuhan na naman ako ng cyber libel.
06:44.7
Because I will react to things
06:46.4
na mali nga ginagawa niya.
06:48.2
Yung mga maling ginagawa niya,
06:49.8
pag mag-react ka,
06:50.6
kakasuhan ka ng cyber libel.
07:04.1
Ate, hindi maganda na makipag-relasyon
07:06.4
sa isang may asawa.
07:11.7
these are may ano naman.
07:13.5
Ito yung mga sinabi ko doon.
07:17.6
Genius talaga yung si Rafi Tulfon.
07:19.3
Sabi ko nga sa inyo,
07:20.2
basang-basa ko yan eh.
07:25.2
dahil sa pag-react ko
07:27.2
sa mga hindi magandang ginagawa ni Rafi Tulfo,
07:30.0
mag-iipon ako ng kasong cyber libel
07:31.9
sa iba't ibang parte ng Pilipinas.
07:35.9
Yun ang sinasabi nung kanyang mga vloggers.
07:47.0
Matulog tayo ng mahimbing.
07:48.4
Hindi ka makakatulog
07:49.3
kung puro tibak ang nasa ulo mo.
07:51.1
Parang si Rafi Tulfo.
07:53.1
Siya naman nagsabi niyan eh.
07:58.7
So, kailangan ko na namang ilabas yun.
08:01.0
Yung sinabi mong tiba.
08:07.5
Lover boy Rafi Tulfo,
08:08.7
three years relationship
08:09.5
kay Barbara Milano.
08:10.6
It revolved around that.
08:13.3
Yung kay Barbara Milano.
08:14.6
Tapos may mga screenshot,
08:15.7
screenshot siyang ganyan.
08:20.8
na mayroon palang ibang asawa.
08:25.6
idol ng Tulfonatics.
08:28.2
Is it true or not true?
08:29.6
Galing yan kay Barbara Milano.
08:32.2
Bakit ako yung ano?
08:36.4
let's go to the Supreme Court decision
08:37.9
mga kapatid natin.
08:39.9
Tungkol sa filing of cyber libel cases.
08:46.5
Ipapakita ko lang naman sa inyo yung
08:48.7
iko-confirm ko lang
08:49.6
yung ginawa nila doon sa kabila
08:51.9
sinabi nila nila doon sa kabila.
08:52.7
Sinabi nila doon sa kabila
08:53.8
na kaso-kaso na yan.
08:57.0
mga kamadis natin.
09:04.1
this is May 5, 2010.
09:06.4
This is before the
09:11.1
anti-cybercrime law.
09:14.1
And I know that for a fact.
09:17.5
rules on warrants
09:24.0
Pero nagkaroon kasi
09:25.1
ng declaration doon.
09:26.8
Katulad din ang nagkaroon
09:40.9
Ang sinabi ng Supreme Court doon
09:44.1
Kasi it is the same case.
09:46.0
It is just punished.
09:48.6
Because there is a new means
09:51.3
which is social media.
09:54.2
Ngayon, mga kabatas natin,
09:56.3
anong importante dito?
10:03.3
in its original form
10:04.8
provided that the venue
10:06.2
of criminal and civil actions
10:07.5
for written defamations
10:08.6
is the province wherein
10:09.8
the libel was published.
10:13.0
Ay, hindi pala nakakita.
10:26.6
Bonifacio versus RTC.
10:35.3
in its original form
10:37.4
provided that the venue
10:39.6
of the criminal and civil actions
10:41.2
for written defamations
10:44.3
where the libel was published,
10:45.6
displayed, or exhibited
10:46.8
regardless of the place
10:48.0
where the same was written,
10:49.1
printed, or composed.
10:53.0
the public officers
10:55.3
the preliminary investigation
10:59.2
Before Article 360
11:01.3
the rule that a criminal action
11:02.6
for libel may be instituted
11:04.3
in any jurisdiction
11:05.5
where the libelous article
11:09.4
irrespective of where
11:12.7
People versus Borja.
11:15.1
the criminal action
11:17.3
and the injured party
11:18.3
has a choice of venue.
11:24.7
kung saan yung venue mo.
11:31.2
Pero, mga kapatid,
11:32.7
tulad nga ng sinabi ko,
11:34.5
dapat ibangga ito
11:39.6
the issuance of warrants
11:43.3
especially cyber libel.
11:49.1
that will be abandoned.
11:50.5
Kasi, there is no
11:56.1
causing case, di ba?
11:59.3
experience had shown
12:01.9
that under that old rule,
12:03.2
the offended party,
12:04.9
ito, pakinggan nyo ito,
12:06.0
mga kapatid natin.
12:06.9
Experience had shown
12:08.2
that under that old rule,
12:09.8
the offended party
12:10.8
could harass the accused
12:13.5
by laying the venue
12:15.2
of criminal action
12:17.6
or distant place.
12:20.5
Malayo ba yung kawayan, Isabel?
12:52.3
Thus, in connection
12:53.1
with an article published
12:54.3
in the Daily Mirror,
12:55.4
blah, blah, blah, blah,
12:57.1
to forestall such harassment,
12:59.4
Republic Act No. 4363
13:02.4
It lays down specific rules
13:04.9
of the criminal action
13:08.4
the offended party
13:09.8
in written defamation cases
13:11.5
from inconveniencing
13:15.4
out-of-town libel suits,
13:18.0
meaning complaints
13:31.0
was the indiscriminate
13:32.9
laying of the venue
13:38.2
or far-flung areas
13:39.6
meant to accomplish
13:51.2
becomes even more acute
13:53.2
where the offended party
13:55.2
of sufficient means
13:56.7
or possesses influence
14:12.0
If the circumstances
14:13.0
as to where the libel
14:14.5
and first published
14:15.4
are used by the offended party
14:19.2
in the criminal action,
14:22.2
with particularity
14:23.2
where the defamatory article
14:25.0
and first published
14:28.7
of their editorial business.
14:30.4
Ito kasi printed ito
14:31.4
mga kabatas natin eh.
14:32.5
Pero may sasabihin din siya dito
14:37.4
ito kasi ang pinagtatalunan dito
14:39.0
was this abandoned
14:41.3
Because of the ruling
14:43.3
I guess this is not
14:50.4
there are no new cases.
14:53.3
There is no new crime
14:54.6
that is being punished
14:59.9
of committing a crime.
15:03.9
New means of publication
15:05.1
which is social media.
15:21.9
that is very relevant here.
15:24.8
cannot be reasonably expected
15:26.5
when it pertains to
15:27.7
defamatory material
15:29.1
appearing on a website
15:32.8
as there would be
15:35.0
no way of determining
15:36.1
the suits of its printing
15:44.0
mga kabatas natin.
15:45.1
To credit Jimenez's premise
15:46.7
of equating his first access
15:48.6
to the defamatory article
15:49.9
on petitioner's website
15:53.7
and first publication
15:56.8
that the amendment
15:59.5
of the Revised Penal Code.
16:01.1
Tandaan nyo sinabi kasi doon
16:02.4
mga kabatas natin,
16:06.1
Kaya kinorect nilang
16:07.6
yung maraming hindi maganda
16:09.4
na naging rulings
16:11.1
ng Supreme Court noon
16:12.4
nung causing case
16:17.6
as a different case.
16:20.7
as a different case
16:23.5
So ito mga kabatas natin,
16:25.1
amendment to Article 360
16:27.3
sought to discourage
16:30.8
amendment sa Article 360
16:33.1
yung pagpa-file ng kaso
16:36.1
sa far-flung areas
16:38.2
mangharas ng tao.
16:40.4
It hardly requires
16:45.6
where the website's
16:49.7
who posts messages
16:50.8
there could be sued
16:52.7
anywhere in the Philippines
16:55.2
complainant may have
16:56.2
allegedly accessed
16:57.3
the offending website.
16:59.8
Ngayon mga kabatas natin,
17:02.3
meron na kaming kaso
17:07.5
ang residence niya
17:12.7
residence mo ulit
17:13.6
sa Kawayan Isabela.
17:28.4
For the court to hold
17:29.9
that the amended information
17:31.5
sufficiently vested jurisdiction
17:33.0
in the courts of Makati
17:34.5
the defamatory article
17:35.5
was accessed therein
17:36.7
would open the floodgates
17:38.3
to the libel suit
17:40.2
in all other locations
17:41.4
where the PEP Coalition
17:42.7
website is likewise
17:44.5
or capable of being
17:56.6
yung Supreme Court doon eh,
18:02.4
mga kabatas natin,
18:12.1
nagkaroon ng damage.
18:15.1
kung saan mo na-access,
18:16.6
pwede ka mag-file
18:20.1
Ngayon, mga kabatas natin,
18:23.3
kasi nga nalilito siya
18:24.2
sa residence at domicile.
18:25.7
Ngayon, mga kabatas natin,
18:29.6
yung sa residence mo,
18:38.3
yun ang tanong ko dito eh.
18:42.5
mag-file ako ng kaso
18:44.9
sa lahat ng residence ko?
18:48.8
akong bahay doon.
18:52.6
pwede mong gawin yun.
18:56.2
hindi ka mayaman,
18:58.4
hindi mo pwedeng gawin yun.
19:00.3
Kasi yung iba nga,
19:07.9
Ikaw, kung marami kang bahay,
19:09.6
may advantage ka.
19:10.8
Pipili ka kung saan mo
19:11.8
gustong mag-file ng kaso,
19:14.5
filan mo ng kaso yung tao
19:16.6
sa lahat ng lugar
19:20.6
At your own convenience.
19:29.3
Ngayon, mga kabads natin,
19:30.7
tulad nga yung sinabi ko,
19:31.7
matatawa ka na lang talaga.
19:33.2
But I already predicted this.
19:35.9
marami pang kaso ang darating.
19:38.5
I expect that from Rafi Tulfo also.
19:48.2
I expect that already.
19:50.6
Ngayon, tulad nga nang sinabi ko sa inyo,
19:52.6
if this will be part of the Guinness
19:54.4
Book of World Records,
19:57.8
kaya lang may 1 million yata,
19:59.1
2 million yata yung babayaran dun eh.
20:02.3
na number of suits filed
20:04.8
because of one person.
20:07.1
I'm on the top of the list.
20:11.3
filed by a government official, ha?
20:16.6
Ngayon, mga kabads natin,
20:21.7
Gusto ko lang i-update kayo
20:25.5
Kasi ang daming nagtatanong na sa akin dyan eh.
20:27.3
Kasi nga nilalabas naman na nila may luwep yun
20:29.6
tsaka dun sa mga palaya
20:30.9
na pa-file lang ka ng kaso sa iba't ibang lugar,
20:34.8
malalayong lugar,
20:38.4
Tapos sinabi pa nila na okay lang ma-dismiss
20:40.5
ang importante na abala ka.
20:44.8
so bawal na mag-react sa ginawa niya.
20:50.6
Siya lang yung nagsasabing bawal dyan.
20:55.8
that's why I'm here.
20:58.0
That's why we're doing this,
20:59.1
mga kabads natin.
20:59.8
That's why we're doing this,
21:02.3
Even if we will be the examples,
21:05.8
We will be the sacrificial lambs.
21:08.9
We will fight for it.
21:10.7
Even if it's a David and Goliath fight.
21:14.7
siya yung makapangyarihan at maraming pera.
21:20.0
Even if siya na yung maraming bahay at maraming residents.
21:26.0
Even if umabot ng isang daanang ikaso niya sa akin,
21:31.6
We will be telling the truth.
21:35.0
Ngayon mga kabads natin,
21:39.3
ano, isusunod mong ikakaso.
21:43.9
Kasi pag titignan niyo,
21:44.8
ganito yung pattern ni Rafi Tulfo.
21:49.3
maraming views na videos ko,
21:52.7
doon siya magahanap ng ikakaso niya sa akin ng Cyber Libel.
22:03.0
Pangalawa, itong Barbara Melano.
22:05.1
Nag-viral din yung kay
22:06.3
kay Ma'am Grendy at saka kay Ma'am Julie.
22:10.2
I'll be waiting for that, Rafi Tulfo.
22:16.8
It just shows that you are just filing slapsuits.
22:23.7
Ito pa ang tanong ko.
22:26.0
I want you to think about this.
22:30.1
If you really want justice,
22:34.2
If you really want justice,
22:36.4
what is the point of also inconveniencing yourself?
22:41.3
Dahil may bahay ka sa Isabela,
22:44.7
doon ka magpa-file.
22:48.5
Doon ka magpa-file dahil may bahay ka sa Isabela.
22:51.7
Samantalang alam mo naman na marami na tayong kaso dito sa Metro Manila
22:55.3
at dineclare mo na na ang residence mo ay dito sa Metro Manila.
22:58.4
What's the point?
23:01.8
I want to know the answer to that one.
23:05.1
Baka bukod sa, ano, no?
23:08.3
pagsisinungaling nung mga
23:11.4
vloggers mo, Rafi Tulfo,
23:13.4
at paglalabas ng mga
23:19.9
doon sa mga pina-file mong kaso sa akin,
23:22.4
baka pwede nilang sagutin yun.
23:26.3
It's very well convenient for you
23:28.4
to file the case here in Quezon City.
23:31.3
Just like you filed
23:32.2
a case here in Quezon City.
23:38.0
What's your purpose?
23:39.8
Maraming salamat mga kapatid natin
23:41.3
at syempre tulad lang yung sinasabi.
23:43.6
Maraming salamat po sa inyo
23:45.0
at syempre matulog po tayo na may
23:46.6
ming-ming dahil alam natin
23:47.5
na inatutulog na may ming-ming
23:48.6
siya yung laging panalo.
23:50.0
Paalam po, Pansamantala.
