* AI ("Artificial Intelligence") subtitles on Tagalog.com are generated using "Whisper" by OpenAI (the same company that created ChatGPT and DallE2). Results and accuracy may vary.
* The subtitles do include errors occasionally and should only be used as a tool to help with your listening practice.
* You can request this website to create a transcript for a video if one doesn't already exist by clicking the "Request AI Subtitles" button below a video. Transcribing usually takes 30-40% of the length of a video to complete if there are no other videos in
the queue. For example, a 21 minute video will take 7-8 minutes to transcribe.
* Running a super fast cloud GPU server to do these transcriptions does cost money. If you have the desire and financial ability, consider
becoming a patron
to support these video transcriptions, and the other tools and apps built by Tagalog.com
00:00.0
Thank you for watching!
00:30.0
20 dito po sa ating Facts First Podcast.
00:33.4
Ang ganda po na pag-uusapan natin, no?
00:35.0
Nung nilabas po natin yung teaser kanina sa social media,
00:38.6
marami na po agad na nag-react, no?
00:40.3
I think this is one of the issues that a lot of Filipinos are passionate about.
00:46.4
Ito pong political dynasties.
00:48.6
Dahil nagkalat po, as you all know, yung political dynasties dito sa Pilipinas
00:52.6
across various levels of government.
00:55.9
In particular, of course, the legislature.
00:57.7
I think there was this study.
00:59.3
By a political scientist, Dr. Julio Tijanqui,
01:03.1
I think as of 2017, 70% na ating kongreso ay binubuo na mga politiko
01:10.7
na galing po sa mga political clans or dynasties.
01:14.4
That was before, no? A few years ago.
01:17.0
Ang suspecha po natin, mas lumaki, mas tumaba,
01:20.4
at lumawak ang impluensya ng ating mga political dynasties.
01:24.5
Ngayon, meron din po, kung naaalala nyo,
01:26.2
you can also Google this, no?
01:27.5
There was this study by the Ateneo,
01:29.3
School of Government.
01:31.9
Isa po sa mga authors yan, si Professor Ronald Mendoza.
01:36.5
Pinag-aaralan po yung epekto noong fat dynasties doon po sa kahirapan.
01:41.8
At dumalabas po ron, merong direct relation.
01:44.5
Yung mas mataba yung dynastia sa isang lugar,
01:47.9
mas mahirap yung lugar na yon.
01:49.4
For instance, probinsya.
01:51.3
Ngayon, nilalatag ko lang po yung issue,
01:53.0
para meron po tayong leveling ng ating pag-uusapan ngayong gabi.
01:57.3
Alam nyo po, sa 1987 Constitution,
01:59.3
natin, sa state policy,
02:01.7
bawal po yung political dynasties.
02:05.0
Kaso, hindi po siya self-executory.
02:08.0
Ibig sabihin, kailangan pa rin po na maglabas
02:10.5
o magpasa ng batas ang Kongreso,
02:12.8
yung Senado at saka mababang kapulungan
02:14.6
ng tinatawag po na enabling law.
02:17.6
Para ma-operationalize po
02:19.1
yung nakalagay na probisyon sa ating 1987 Constitution.
02:23.2
Ang tanong, since 1987,
02:25.2
eh bakit wala pa rin po tayong batas
02:27.3
na nagde-define at nag-batas?
02:29.3
Ang mga ban, once and for all,
02:31.3
sa political dynasties.
02:32.3
Habang in the meantime,
02:33.3
nagtatabaan po yung ating mga political dynasties
02:36.3
diyan sa Kongreso.
02:38.3
O lalayo pa ba tayo?
02:39.3
Example natin, Presidente ng Pilipinas.
02:41.3
Ang anak, congressman.
02:43.3
Ang pinsan, house speaker.
02:46.3
Ang second case niya, DFA.
02:50.3
Lalayo pa ba tayo?
02:54.3
Duterte, dating presidente.
02:57.3
Anak, vice president.
02:58.3
Kailan taon sila sa Davao?
03:00.3
More than 20 years.
03:01.3
We can cite so many examples, really.
03:04.3
Ang tanong, eh bakit nga po ganun yung nangyari?
03:06.3
Now, meron pong isang grupo ng mga alumni
03:10.3
ng University of the Philippines College of Law
03:12.3
na nag-file po ng petitions sa Supreme Court,
03:15.3
basically asking the Supreme Court
03:17.3
to compel Congress
03:19.3
to once and for all
03:21.3
define and prohibit political dynasties.
03:24.3
Yung po yung pag-uusapan natin ngayong gabi,
03:26.3
ayoko nang patagalin.
03:27.3
Ang ating pong guest ngayong gabi
03:28.3
ay isa po sa mga petitioners.
03:29.3
I'd like to welcome to our program
03:33.3
the former president of the Philippine Bar Association,
03:36.3
si Atty. Rico Domingo.
03:38.3
Magandang gabi, Atty.
03:39.3
And thank you for joining us dito po sa Facts First.
03:42.3
Magandang gabi, Christian.
03:44.3
And good evening also to the listeners and viewers as well.
03:48.3
Sir, pakiexplain nga po.
03:50.3
How exactly do you think, based on your petition,
03:55.3
can the Supreme Court compel Congress
03:57.3
to pass this anti-political dynasty law?
04:02.3
As a matter of fact,
04:03.3
it can compel because
04:06.3
the Section 26, Article 2
04:11.3
Nakalagay dito, Section 26, Article 2
04:14.3
ng ating 1987 Constitution.
04:19.3
ibig sabihin na imperative, mandatory,
04:21.3
guarantee equal access to opportunities
04:23.3
for public service
04:25.3
and prohibit political dynasties
04:27.3
as may be defined by law.
04:30.3
The Constitution itself,
04:32.3
in this particular section,
04:35.3
outlaws political dynasties,
04:39.3
prohibit political dynasties.
04:41.3
Ang kailangan lamang ay definition
04:44.3
kung ano ang political dynasties.
04:48.3
So, walang choice ang Kongreso
04:50.3
kung di magpasa ng batas
04:52.3
laban sa political dynasties.
04:55.3
hanggang kailan sila pwedeng magpabanjing-banjing?
05:00.3
Kasi more than 30 years na po, ano?
05:02.3
Wala pong lumulusot na anti-political dynasty
05:06.3
Well, to borrow your language,
05:08.3
pabanjing-banjing sila ng 37 years
05:11.3
since the enactment of the 1987 Constitution.
05:17.3
right there and there,
05:18.3
if they're doing their job
05:20.3
that they're following the mandate
05:21.3
of the Constitution,
05:24.3
as early as after the enactment
05:26.3
of the Constitution,
05:27.3
gumawa na sila ng batas.
05:31.3
Dapat i-define na lang
05:32.3
ang political dynasties.
05:36.3
they have not done so.
05:38.3
That's why we have this petition.
05:40.3
Pakiexplain nga po yung
05:41.3
Mandamos petition niyo, no?
05:43.3
Ano ba yung nature niyan
05:44.3
kung saan pwedeng i-compel
05:46.3
ng hukuman ng isang ahensya
05:48.3
ng gobyerno o sangay?
05:49.3
Pwede bang gamitin po yan
05:54.3
because they're supposed to be
05:59.3
if they have neglected
06:01.3
performing their job
06:02.3
under the Constitution,
06:04.3
then they can be subject
06:05.3
to a writ of Mandamos.
06:09.3
pwedeng i-cite ng Kongreso?
06:12.3
Teka, co-equal bodies tayo dito.
06:14.3
Magkapantay tayo,
06:16.3
kami legislature.
06:20.3
kung anong dapat namin gawin?
06:22.3
Well, kung ganila lang
06:23.3
ang reasoning nila,
06:24.3
medyo malabnaw yata yun
06:26.3
because the Constitution
06:29.3
actually commands
06:41.3
document that should compel them
06:43.3
is the Constitution itself,
06:45.3
not the Supreme Court.
06:46.3
The Supreme Court will simply
06:48.3
ask them to abide
06:51.3
by the constitutional mandate.
06:53.3
E kung hindi po nila gawin?
06:55.3
Well, they'll be probably
06:57.3
cited for contempt.
07:00.3
By the Supreme Court?
07:01.3
By the Supreme Court.
07:03.3
Okay. So technically,
07:04.3
sino po respondents dito
07:05.3
sa inyong petisyon?
07:07.3
tsaka Senate President?
07:08.3
Opo, tsaka Kongreso itself.
07:13.3
through the process?
07:14.3
So nag-file kayo ng petisyon
07:15.3
and then pagkocommentin po, no?
07:19.3
and then what else po?
07:20.3
What will happen?
07:21.3
Then the court will probably call
07:23.3
for an oral argument
07:25.3
at their discretion
07:27.3
and perhaps will have to ask us
07:30.3
what will be the issues
07:31.3
and what are arguments
07:32.3
and the Supreme Court,
07:33.3
the Honorable Supreme Court,
07:34.3
will decide accordingly.
07:37.3
they will take cognizance
07:38.3
and give us our petition due course
07:41.3
because of its transcendental
07:44.3
issue that we have posed
07:47.3
the Supreme Court will issue
07:50.3
a judgment along that line
07:53.3
it will be an en banc decision
07:54.3
which is doctrinal in nature.
07:57.3
Pero pwede rin ba,
07:59.3
dun sa realm of possibilities,
08:01.3
pwedeng ibalik yan?
08:02.3
Iba to sa Kongreso?
08:03.3
Teka, labas kami dyan.
08:04.3
Let Congress make that decision
08:08.3
Pero kung gagawin natin dun,
08:11.3
anong remedy ng mga tao?
08:13.3
The sovereign people
08:16.3
and approved the Constitution,
08:19.3
the supreme organ of our country.
08:23.3
Nakalagay yan sa state policy natin.
08:27.3
is one of the 28 or so sections
08:31.3
in that particular Article 2
08:35.3
and that is a mandatory,
08:38.3
mandatory command
08:39.3
of the Constitution itself.
08:41.3
So, hindi dapat babaliwalain
08:44.3
ng mga branches of the government there.
08:48.3
ang Supreme Court
08:49.3
has already issued mandatory
08:51.3
or writ of execution
08:53.3
against the executive branch.
08:56.3
Marami po tayong na-encounter na ganyan.
08:58.3
Why can't the Supreme Court now
09:01.3
issue a writ of mandamus
09:02.3
against the legislature?
09:05.3
Commanding it to enact a law
09:08.3
and as imperatively mandated
09:11.3
by the Constitution.
09:13.3
defining and prohibiting
09:16.3
political dynasties.
09:20.3
why did you decide,
09:21.3
you and your colleagues
09:22.3
decided to file this petition
09:25.3
Ano yung nag-trigger
09:27.3
Talagang frustrated lang kayo
09:31.3
Alam mo, Christian,
09:32.3
kaming mga magkakapase,
09:35.3
very solid kami, no,
09:38.3
And one of my classmates
09:39.3
who is sight impaired,
09:42.3
ay nagsabi sa amin,
09:45.3
ito pa bang bulag pong namin kaklase
09:47.3
ang nagsabi pa sa amin,
09:48.3
si Atty. Wilfrido Trinidad.
09:55.3
na walang nangyayari
09:56.3
dito sa Section 26 Implementation.
10:00.3
why don't we come up with a petition
10:01.3
for a writ of mandamus?
10:04.3
Sabi namin mga makakaklase,
10:07.3
after our reunion
10:13.3
We are already at the last stage
10:14.3
of our legal practice.
10:16.3
Hindi ba natin kailangan utang natin
10:18.3
sa mga kababayan natin,
10:20.3
sa future generations,
10:21.3
sa ating mga anak?
10:23.3
Nabigyan sila ng heritage
10:26.3
na dapat ay magkaroon ng batas
10:30.3
na dapat ay sumususog
10:32.3
sa constitutionally mandated
10:34.3
and imperatively mandated
10:36.3
na dapat ay prohibit
10:39.3
ang political dynasties.
10:40.3
Alam naman po naman natin
10:42.3
kung bakit natin pinaprohibit
10:44.3
ang dynasties na talakay na yan.
10:47.3
Sinabi mong mga kanina,
10:49.3
si Professor or Dr.
10:55.3
the Ateneo School of Government.
10:57.3
Itong from fat to obese
10:59.3
political dynasties
11:00.3
after the 2019 midterm elections.
11:04.3
They're all documented.
11:05.3
We have empirical data, Christian,
11:09.3
the political dynasties
11:10.3
are the root evil,
11:13.3
of the bad governance
11:15.3
as well as the underdevelopment
11:18.3
And we have not done that
11:20.3
to prohibit the political dynasties
11:25.3
the records of the Commission,
11:27.3
the Constitutional Commission will show
11:29.3
that's exactly what is the need
11:33.3
That's why they inserted
11:35.3
included that Section 26,
11:40.3
of the Constitution
11:42.3
The last time I interviewed
11:44.3
one of the members
11:45.3
of the 1986 Constitutional Commission,
11:47.3
si Atty. Christian Monsod,
11:49.3
naiitanong ko rin po kasi yan,
11:52.3
ba't kasi hindi niyo
11:55.3
yung provision na yan?
11:58.3
yung desisyon sa Kongreso
12:00.3
ano ba yung political dynasties
12:02.3
para ma-eban sila
12:03.3
sa ating politika?
12:07.3
They underestimated the greed for power of our politicians.
12:13.0
And true enough, talagang tumaba po ng tumaba yung mga dynasties.
12:16.6
Pati nga yung party system natin na hijack and na-bastardize nila.
12:20.5
Ang tanong ko po sa inyo, attorney, realistically,
12:24.5
paano makakapagpasa ng anti-political dynasty law
12:30.0
ang isang kongreso na infested, for lack of a better word,
12:35.0
infested by political dynasties?
12:37.6
Because if you think about it, that would be an existential threat to them.
12:44.0
Paano? Would be talagang malaking question mark yan.
12:48.2
For the past 37 years, hindi pa nila ginagawa yan.
12:52.3
But somehow, somebody has to compel them.
12:55.9
Because the Constitution is the supreme organ that should be followed.
13:00.6
And it says you should prohibit political dynasties.
13:03.9
Now, kung hindi nila tinutupad dyan ng kongreso for whatever reason that you have just stated,
13:11.1
na hindi na puro self-serving yan, marami siyang public of interest sa mga kongreso
13:15.0
because they're part of the political dynasties themselves,
13:18.0
most of them, if not all,
13:20.4
then ang tao na ang maguhusgal sa kanila.
13:23.9
Because the Constitution is the sovereign people's enactment.
13:28.9
Di ba ba? Ang Constitution, ang sovereign people, ang gumawa niyan.
13:33.9
Hindi ang kongreso.
13:36.0
Sinasabi ng Constitution, dapat i-prohibit ang political dynasties, Christian.
13:41.8
Maliwanag na maliwanag na imperative at mandatory ang command ng Constitution.
13:47.9
At hindi dapat yun ay binabaliwala ng kongreso.
13:52.1
Yung nga po eh. Yung context po ng tanong ko, sir, I completely understand where you're coming from.
13:57.5
Napakalina po yan sa Constitution. Pero realistically, for instance,
14:00.9
although in fairness naman, I think,
14:03.9
nasa pa yung lumusot sa Senado kesa dito sa mababang kapulungan.
14:07.1
Pero that's just my gut feel. Pwedeng mali po ako, no?
14:09.9
Kasi for instance, tingnan po natin yung composition ng Senado.
14:13.6
May mag-ina, Villar. May magkapatid, Alan and Pia Cayetano.
14:19.6
Magkapatid na naman, Jinggoy and JV.
14:22.6
Dati nga, nag-abot pa si Jinggoy at saka yung nanay niya, si Lo Ejercito.
14:26.8
Kung nanalo pa si Vice President Binay noong nakarang eleksyon,
14:30.0
I think he placed 13.
14:32.4
E di nag-abot pa sila na si Binay.
14:33.9
I mean, for a 24-seat chamber, ang dami magkakamag-anak.
14:39.6
So doon pa lang po sa Senado yan. E pupunta pa tayo sa House.
14:42.3
Yung Speaker mismo, di ba?
14:44.8
Belongs to a very fat dynasty.
14:47.9
Tapos yung mga Marcoses, nag-ugroom pa ng mga susunod sa kanila, for instance.
14:51.8
I mean, realistically po yung tanong ko.
14:55.2
Aside from the legal, that's a very clear issue.
14:58.4
Pero realistically, do you think Congress would be,
15:03.9
in their interest, to pass a law that would go against the interests of the political dynasties?
15:10.8
Because they're answerable to their constituents.
15:14.1
Remember, they are representatives of the people of their respective territories.
15:19.4
That they are supposed to be a congressman of, a governor of,
15:23.0
the palanggay of, the town of, or the city of.
15:27.1
So they are answerable to the people themselves.
15:29.4
That's why, Christian,
15:32.3
but we should heighten,
15:33.7
the awareness of the Filipino people,
15:39.1
na nandito sa atin for 37 years.
15:41.2
So even before that,
15:42.3
that's why the Constitutional Commission put that,
15:45.7
Section 26, Article 2,
15:48.0
dapat ng mga tao mamulat na.
15:51.1
At sila ay mismo magsabi,
15:55.4
matagal na po kayo dyan.
15:57.1
Mayon, matagal na po kayo dyan.
15:58.7
Wala po ba namang marunong at qualified
16:03.7
kandidato so that we can change leadership
16:06.0
and hopefully have a better leadership in the future.
16:09.2
And not people belonging to the political minorities
16:12.9
who are monopolizing political power
16:16.2
and influencing the respective districts and territories.
16:19.2
That's exactly, we need to also tell the people,
16:23.5
kailangan na magkaroon ng spark plug dito
16:26.5
for the people to be able
16:28.9
to realize that they're being
16:33.2
by the representative and districts.
16:35.3
Because it is in the interest of these political dynasties
16:38.5
to keep the people poor.
16:41.1
Right, Christian?
16:42.9
So that during the election time,
16:45.3
these poor people,
16:46.8
their constituents who come to them
16:48.4
and would ask money
16:49.8
and resources from them.
16:52.2
And they want that to be perpetuated.
16:54.7
That condition to be perpetuated.
16:56.7
That's why we have
16:57.7
these political dynasties.
16:59.5
There's no competition whatsoever.
17:01.8
Ang dami-dami magagaling,
17:03.2
mga mga kandidato, talo
17:05.2
because wala silang pera,
17:07.0
wala silang influence,
17:08.2
at wala silang network.
17:10.2
That's exactly why Section 26, Article 2
17:13.1
was promulgated by the Commission
17:18.9
Ganda ng paliwanan niya,
17:20.0
Atty. Rico Domingo.
17:21.2
Yan po yung talagang root cause natin.
17:24.1
Nakadikit po sa political dynasties
17:25.9
sa mga viewers po natin,
17:27.2
yung issue ng political patronage
17:28.8
o yung tinatawag na clientelism.
17:31.3
Nararamdaman po natin yan,
17:34.0
Para bang yung Pilipino
17:35.0
nakatanghod sa mga politiko
17:36.4
for resources na galing din naman sa kanila.
17:39.2
That's another issue.
17:41.8
Meron kayong katukayo.
17:43.7
Ay, hindi pala katukayo.
17:47.9
He was eagerly awaiting
17:49.3
your appearance ito po sa ating programa.
17:52.1
Si Atty. Michael Henry Yusinko.
17:54.2
Ando rin po siya.
17:55.3
Senior fellow dyan
17:56.6
sa Ateneo Policy Center.
17:58.3
Interesting din yung tanong niya.
18:03.6
yung pag-enact ng isang batas
18:06.0
against political dynasties
18:07.5
dito sa People's Initiative?
18:10.1
Baka mas realistic daw yun
18:12.0
kesa idaan sa Pandamos.
18:17.5
That's an alternative.
18:23.3
in practical terms,
18:25.3
pwede yung People's Initiative naman.
18:28.1
mga political dynasties yun.
18:33.2
the design of the system
18:36.1
such that that will favor them.
18:38.9
So saan natin makikita yun?
18:43.4
ang Honorable Supreme Court
18:46.5
and issue the writ of Pandamos
18:49.3
para makita ng tao
18:51.4
merong nangyayari dito sa ating bansa
18:56.3
ang political dynasties
18:59.4
by the Constitution
19:06.2
pressure yun natin
19:12.1
kung ano sino magbaboto
19:13.5
sa political dynasties
19:14.9
law proposed bill
19:17.8
ng political dynasties.
19:19.2
Pakita natin sa mga tao
19:24.3
ng proposal na yan.
19:29.1
political dynasties
19:30.2
who would like to
19:31.1
perpetuate themselves
19:34.6
Makikita ng tao yun.
19:36.2
Sa next electoral contests
19:37.7
makikita ng mga tao
19:39.4
ito ang mga political dynasties.
19:41.8
Itong ating tinutukoy dito.
19:43.6
Itong pinoprohibit
19:44.6
ng saligang batas natin.
19:48.7
yung mga ganyang dynasties
19:50.0
hindi naman sila nahihiya dyan.
19:51.3
Nagmamalaki pa nga.
19:53.8
ang susunod na mayor
19:55.0
sa ating lungsod.
19:58.1
Alam na alam natin yan.
20:00.6
pinaperpetuate yun
20:01.6
ang feudal system.
20:03.0
Na ating umiiral dati.
20:06.4
ang sistema natin.
20:07.9
It's only a modern day
20:11.3
puksuinan natin yan.
20:12.7
We are a democratic
20:14.8
Dapat puksuinan natin
20:16.1
yung political dynasties
20:17.3
to avoid the feudal system
20:19.2
that we are experiencing
20:21.7
At hindi lang yun.
20:27.4
Because kung ikaw
20:39.3
respective territories.
20:41.7
So that will only
20:54.5
ng mga congressmen
20:56.4
local government.
21:00.9
ang local government
21:10.7
themselves in power
21:11.6
at makipagpapatayan
21:18.6
their leadership.
21:22.9
rationalizations.
21:32.8
nakakausap ko po.
21:35.7
yung Erap Dynasty.
21:37.1
Isa po yun sa mga
21:41.2
political dynasties
21:42.2
in the Philippines.
21:43.2
Nagsimula sa San Juan.
21:44.9
Tapos he tried to expand
21:50.2
medyo manipis na eh.
21:52.2
That was the story
21:53.8
of the Estradas in Manila.
21:55.9
Pag nakakausap po sa Erap,
21:57.7
ang lagi niyang sinasabi,
21:59.5
binoboto kami ng mga tao eh.
22:03.8
pinapamana technically.
22:05.5
Binoboto raw sila ng tao.
22:07.0
And this argument
22:12.7
Si Jingoy Estrada,
22:13.7
pag pinanong nyo,
22:14.8
ang argument niya
22:21.1
Ano ba yung mali roon?
22:22.5
Kasi parang ginagamit
22:28.5
of these political clans.
22:30.3
Ano pong sagot nyo doon?
22:33.2
Tinang naman natin
22:34.3
with all due respect
22:35.6
to Senator Estrada.
22:37.8
man of conviction.
22:42.3
ng Sandigan Bayan.
22:44.3
So in other words,
22:55.5
electorates themselves
22:57.1
very well informed
23:01.3
Because they have
23:02.0
already the machinery,
23:03.6
they have the media,
23:06.4
environmental media,
23:15.2
political dynasties na yan.
23:17.0
Hindi mananalong sila
23:18.8
So anong gusto natin?
23:20.8
for another 37 years
23:22.3
for the Supreme Court
23:26.1
the political dynasty
23:35.0
eh huwag niyong lalahatin
23:36.0
kasi meron namang
23:39.4
Marami naman daw.
23:40.2
In fairness din naman,
23:41.1
may mga lugar sa Pilipinas
23:44.2
ay political dynasties.
23:46.1
sa parasot po nila dyan,
23:49.7
siyempre dynastia.
23:52.7
brand of public service.
23:55.1
sa mga probinsya.
24:00.1
do you subscribe?
24:02.5
Hindi, meron namang
24:04.1
and they also bring
24:05.3
change and development
24:06.7
in areas in the Philippines.
24:10.2
that can be probably true
24:11.6
with respect to some
24:14.7
and more altruistic
24:17.4
political dynasties.
24:20.6
why did the commission
24:21.7
enact the Section 26?
24:26.6
there are empirical data
24:27.9
that will support
24:28.8
that political dynasties
24:31.1
for the governance
24:34.4
So, kahit ano sabihin nila
24:36.0
that they're more qualified
24:37.8
they're enlightened
24:38.6
political dynasties
24:39.9
at binoboto kami ng tao.
24:41.4
Paano sila binoboto
24:46.5
dalawang kalaban nila,
24:47.9
isa yung napakagaling
25:00.2
Nawalang kondiksyon.
25:06.4
that would be a promise
25:07.7
that the leadership
25:08.8
of that particular person
25:10.0
that they would vote on
25:13.5
as compared to the one
25:14.6
who had been convicted.
25:18.2
Tsaka ang problema po dyan,
25:19.5
Yung mga dynasties,
25:21.3
ay kontrola din nila
25:22.1
yung rules of the game
25:23.0
pati electoral system.
25:25.3
Magkadikit yan kasi.
25:26.7
the high cost of campaign
25:27.9
or election spending,
25:30.8
miski magaling ka
25:31.5
pag wala kang pera,
25:33.5
napakaslim ng chance
25:34.9
ng kandidatong gano'n
25:36.0
to actually win an election
25:37.8
is political dynasties.
25:42.6
ng mga political dynasties
25:49.0
na mapapantayan yan.
25:54.9
sa political dynasties,
25:56.3
wala siyang kalaban-laban.
26:01.0
sa electoral system natin
26:04.2
part of this would be
26:06.8
the electoral system
26:11.9
the political dynasties
26:14.0
which is required
26:14.9
by the Constitution
26:16.4
na hindi pa natin
26:18.4
since 37 years ago.
26:23.7
ng ating mga magagaling
26:26.0
o members ng Senate
26:30.2
constituent assembly.
26:32.5
i-define namin yung
26:33.1
political dynasties
26:34.7
ng anti-political
26:38.9
sa political chacha
26:40.1
hindi lang economic chacha
26:41.4
which we all know
26:42.7
can open a Pandora's box.
26:45.5
Paano kung ganun po
26:47.3
Yan ang pwedeng gawin nilang
26:51.2
pwedeng nilang sabihin
26:52.7
ng People's Initiative
26:53.7
or amendment ng Constitution
26:56.2
makikita naman ng tao
26:57.4
ang kanilang ginagawa.
27:00.7
people who would be
27:03.1
or would be faced
27:03.9
with the referendum
27:11.5
one of the arguments
27:14.0
of political clans
27:16.9
undemocratic yan eh
27:19.0
political dynasty.
27:21.6
very qualified naman yung anak,
27:32.0
o mataas yung pinag-aralan,
27:36.9
ang kalaban nila.
27:38.4
Ang ginagawa nila eh,
27:39.7
stifling competition eh.
27:41.9
Political dynasty
27:43.9
nila yung kalaban nila eh.
27:45.5
Tinan natin mabuti,
27:47.1
will elect freely
27:47.9
and choose themselves.
27:51.6
state policy says
28:01.7
Yan ang pinapangalagaan
28:04.4
kung ang political
28:05.9
dynasty sa nandyan,
28:14.4
They are constricting
28:17.0
who are qualified.
28:18.9
Kung kinonstrict mo
28:19.7
ang pool of candidates,
28:21.5
the number of candidates
28:23.3
sa political dynasty,
28:24.6
eh walang kalaban
28:25.3
talaga yung ibang pang.
28:29.2
I'm sure if there's
28:31.1
maraming mga magagaling
28:38.2
tama po ang ginagawa nyo
28:39.6
kasi dito sa aming
28:41.9
wala nang nangyayari.
28:43.5
puro mga abogado yun.
28:45.5
professionals yun.
28:47.0
Hindi kami nang manalo.
28:48.5
hindi po kami mananalo
28:57.3
ang aming ginagawa.
28:58.3
Magtulong-tulongan tayo
29:02.2
of what's happening.
29:20.1
ay magkasama-sama
29:24.0
at kailangan natin
29:28.1
ang Supreme Court
29:30.8
to also implement
29:34.1
in this particular
29:40.2
tanungin ko na rin po
29:48.0
and consanguinity
29:58.1
ba? Anong tingin niyo?
30:00.6
hindi ko pa masyadong
30:04.5
kasi that actually
30:05.5
a question that is
30:06.8
on the discretion
30:10.4
tell the Supreme Court
30:11.6
to tell the Congress
30:13.1
or what they want to do
30:17.1
What is imperative
30:18.7
would be the passage
30:27.2
kung ako ang tatanungin mo,
30:39.7
Makikita naman natin
30:43.5
ng mga congressmen,
30:46.2
nagigiging kasama
30:49.2
Kahit na kung saan,
30:58.4
or may connection
31:02.0
ma-anticipate yun
31:12.8
against political
31:30.4
the Constitution,
31:56.6
Ito ang nararating
32:48.4
naman napakagarapal
33:13.5
kasi napaka-creative
33:21.2
Baka sabihin nila
33:23.4
Kabit ko nga yan.
33:24.9
minsan naaaminan,
33:26.9
relations whatsoever.
34:10.9
Hindi maari tayong
34:59.2
kahit napakagarapal
35:20.0
I'm sorry to say.
35:21.0
Medyo natutulog tayo
35:29.5
Mag-enforceful na tayo
35:33.8
ang hirap sa ating
35:36.3
to our countrymen,
35:39.2
apathetic sila eh.
35:44.7
Siguraduhin natin
35:45.4
na ang gusto natin
35:49.5
huwag tayong patumpik-tumpik pa.
35:52.2
Dapat sabihin natin
35:59.9
Kami ang bumabota
36:02.4
Pag narinig nila yan,
36:03.3
matatakot din yan eh.
36:09.6
papayag na gagawin nilang
36:11.7
dapat nilang gawin.
36:12.5
Dapat ang tao mismo,
36:13.6
ang people power,
36:15.4
dapat umiiral na naman
36:21.2
Maraming maraming salamat
36:22.1
Atty. Rico Domingo.
36:23.3
Invite ko pa po kayo ulit
36:24.4
to ask for updates
36:27.2
Salamat, Christian.
36:28.2
At more power to you,
36:30.4
Sa inyo rin po, sir.
36:31.1
Maraming salamat po.
36:34.4
Yan po si Atty. Rico Domingo.
36:37.3
Nakausap po natin.
36:38.3
Tukol dito sa napaka-importanting
36:42.1
sa Korte Suprema, no?
36:43.7
Kung napapansin niyo po,
36:46.4
na tinututukan natin.
36:47.9
I don't even know
36:49.4
in terms of addressing
36:51.7
political democracy.
36:52.1
Pero yung binabanggit ko kanina,
36:55.0
talagang madalas ko po
36:57.3
ng political dynasties
36:58.4
na nakakausap ko.
37:01.4
anong magagawa na?
37:04.4
Parang ano yan, eh.
37:05.4
Ang argument nila lagi.
37:06.5
Kunwari, isang pamilya,
37:07.7
merong doktor yung tatay.
37:09.6
Eh, diba gusto rin
37:12.2
kung abogado yung nanay
37:13.6
at saka yung tatay,
37:14.5
eh, gusto rin yung anak nila
37:15.3
maging doktor din.
37:16.7
Eh, ang claim nila kasi,
37:18.2
yung joining politics
37:19.9
and seeking an elective post
37:22.7
is similar to that
37:25.2
a profession or career.
37:27.2
Yun ang argument nila dyan.
37:30.0
hindi siya technically pareho, eh.
37:33.0
pag iniisip nyo kasi,
37:36.0
Although, again, ah,
37:37.3
isa nahirapan po talaga
37:38.4
akong ipaintindi ito
37:39.9
sa mas nakararaming Pilipino
37:41.2
because they also understand
37:42.7
the realities on the ground.
37:47.3
to talk about these things,
37:50.2
the evils of fat dynasties
37:52.3
in programs like this.
37:54.1
Pero dun sa maraming Pilipino
37:55.9
na mas marami sa nang iniisip,
37:59.3
ano ba yung kakainin bukas?
38:01.0
Ano ba yung saan makukuha
38:03.1
para sa aking anak
38:04.2
para makapasok man lang bukas?
38:06.9
Yung issues ng political dynasties,
38:09.5
that's the least of their concerns.
38:12.9
hindi gut issues sa kanila yun, eh.
38:15.3
Bakit ko mapoproblemahin
38:16.4
yung mga dynasty na yan?
38:17.7
And sa akin lang,
38:18.7
basta pwede makatulog,
38:19.9
yung nakaupong politiko,
38:21.8
okay na po ako dun.
38:22.7
And we cannot really blame
38:26.2
na ganun po mag-isip.
38:27.3
Kasi yun po yung reality, eh.
38:28.7
Ang dapat po natin sisihin
38:30.2
ay yung mga membro
38:31.3
ng political dynasties
38:32.6
who are exploiting
38:35.0
in such situations.
38:37.0
Yun po yung masakit dyan.
38:38.3
Kasi they're supposed to know better,
38:39.9
yung mga politiko na yan.
38:41.0
Ang ginagawa nila,
38:42.7
dapat ganyan ang mentality nyo.
38:44.3
Kasi pag natuto kayo
38:46.2
tatanggalin nyo kami sa pwesto.
38:49.9
nakapag-pag-graduate,
38:51.8
mas namulat yung mata niya,
38:54.3
ganito talaga ang sistema natin.
38:56.8
ng sistema ng ating eleksyon
39:00.1
nag-multiply yung ganung,
39:05.3
across the Philippines,
39:06.8
eh mabibilang na po talaga
39:08.1
yung araw ng mga political dynasties.
39:11.7
until that day comes,
39:13.6
marami po sa ating
39:14.9
mga kapwa ang Pilipino,
39:16.0
eh hawak po sa liig,
39:18.3
ng mga political dynasties.
39:19.9
Ang ginagawa nila,
39:21.3
bibigyan namin ganyan
39:22.2
ng konting tulong,
39:24.2
konting development.
39:26.2
social media na, no?
39:27.5
Lalabas kung sino yung
39:28.3
bugok na politiko, no?
39:30.1
napansin nyo ba yung
39:32.8
pandemic lockdowns,
39:34.3
Napilitang mag-step up
39:35.5
yung ilang mga local officials, eh.
39:37.9
lumalabas sa social media
39:39.0
kung sino yung mga tatanga-tanga
39:40.3
tsaka papapatay-patay
39:41.6
na local governments, eh.
39:43.3
So, nagkaroon sila
39:43.9
ng healthy competition,
39:45.6
dynasty man o hindi.
39:48.1
pag tinignan po natin
39:49.1
yung ugat ng political dynasties,
39:52.1
in many parts of the country,
39:53.3
pag tinanong nyo yung mga kababayan natin,
39:55.8
hindi issue sa kanila yung
39:56.7
political dynasty.
39:58.8
eh, nakakapag-deliver ba
40:00.4
yung nakaupong, ah,
40:02.6
mayor, for instance,
40:05.5
pumapasok dyan yung
40:06.4
political branding, eh, no?
40:07.8
Nadinig ko yan dati.
40:09.4
nandun ako sa, ano,
40:11.8
I did a special report
40:19.8
Nakausap ko yung ilang mga kababayan
40:21.1
natin dyan sa Davao City.
40:22.3
Tinanong ko lang.
40:23.3
yung mga man on the street interviews,
40:25.2
tinanong ko sa kanila,
40:26.9
yun ang nakausap ko,
40:28.8
sino po ba ibaboto nyo
40:32.1
ibaboto po namin si Sara.
40:34.9
ah, hindi naman po si Sara
40:38.9
sa darating na eleksyon.
40:40.4
Ah, vice president po
40:41.5
yung tatakbuhan niya.
40:43.7
ano, basta Duterte.
40:45.4
yung brand na yun,
40:47.6
tinitingnan nila eh.
40:48.4
Parang brand siguro
40:49.2
ng toothpaste, no?
40:52.4
Ah, anong Colgate gusto mo?
40:55.6
na-imagine nyo, no?
40:57.1
Yung political branding
40:58.6
has been very, very effective
41:01.7
political dynasties, no?
41:04.5
yun na yung byword eh.
41:05.6
Ah, for instance,
41:06.5
yung sa situation
41:07.1
na binabanggit ko.
41:09.2
tapos ang problema,
41:10.7
yung mga argument na ganyan
41:11.8
na sinasabi nila,
41:12.5
eh, binaboto kami ng tao eh.
41:13.8
Napaka-democratic naman
41:15.3
ah, pinigilan nyo kami
41:17.9
Eh, gusto lang naman namin
41:25.1
Nagbobulahan pa ba tayo dito?
41:26.8
gusto nyo maupo sa pwesto
41:28.1
dahil gusto nyo yung kapangyarihan.
41:30.8
Kapangyarihan ang gusto nyo dyan eh.
41:32.5
Hindi naman siguro
41:33.2
kayo nagisigisang umaga
41:34.3
talaga nag-uumapaw, no?
41:36.1
Sasabog yung puso nyo
41:37.1
dahil punong-puno
41:39.3
para sa ating mga kababayan.
41:40.6
I really want to help
41:43.2
So, talagang gusto,
41:43.8
gusto ko silang tulungan.
41:45.0
And so, ang gagawin ko,
41:46.3
tatakbo ko for mayor.
41:47.5
Wala naman siguro gano'n, no?
41:49.8
Siguro, that's more of an exception
41:52.9
Ito po yung problema.
41:54.5
Pag ang isang political dynasty
41:56.6
hawak na isang political dynasty
41:58.0
for so many years,
42:00.1
talagang restrictive, no?
42:01.6
Talagang ibaboto sila ng tao
42:03.1
kasi yung choice is very limited, eh.
42:04.8
Di ba? Napansin nyo ba?
42:06.9
marami sa mga posisyon
42:08.9
during the 2022 elections,
42:10.7
walang kalaban yung mga kandidato,
42:12.7
yung mga political dynasties.
42:15.0
eh, paano mo lalabanan yun?
42:16.8
O, wala ka naman pera
42:19.0
pambili ng, for instance,
42:21.2
campaign para for Nelia.
42:23.1
Wala kang pangpondo,
42:25.7
sa mga meeting de avance, eh.
42:27.3
O, yung mga barangay captains,
42:29.3
bayad ng tumatakbo
42:31.2
o kaya nakaupong mayor.
42:32.3
Paano mo naman lalabanan yun?
42:35.1
pag nakampanya ka house to house,
42:36.4
nag-e-expect yung mga lalapitan mo,
42:38.7
o, magkano po bang ibibigay nyo?
42:41.0
Paano ka lalaban sa gano'ng sistema?
42:44.4
okay na ba yung 3 million?
42:48.0
Ipunin mo na lang yan,
42:52.4
Kaya nananalo yung mga political dynasties,
42:54.7
kaya sila ini-elect
42:55.8
in a democratic process,
42:58.3
which we call elections,
43:00.2
i-kontrolado nila yung game, eh.
43:05.2
mahirap manalo rito sa ating eleksyon
43:07.4
kung wala kang pera.
43:09.1
Okay, maniniwala rin sa mga kandidato
43:12.8
walang akong pera eh,
43:14.6
pinapatakbo tayo ng mga kababayan natin, eh.
43:17.8
Gusto lang natin talagang maglingkod.
43:20.0
Huwag na po tayo magbulahan, no?
43:21.5
Sakit po sa tingin ng gano'n, eh.
43:23.6
Maga, nagkakagaguhan tayo, eh.
43:28.4
Yun po yung sinasabi ko lagi, no?
43:30.5
Kontrolado nila yung sistema.
43:31.8
Minsan, may mga political dynasties na
43:33.7
magpapatakbo ng mga,
43:35.9
yung mga token opponents.
43:39.3
O, tumakbo ka nga dyan
43:40.2
para may kalaban ako.
43:41.4
Pero alam mo namang siya'y mananalo.
43:44.0
Well, in fairness naman
43:46.1
sa ilang mga political dynasties,
43:47.6
meron din po talagang mga political dynasties
43:50.1
na nagdi-deliver.
43:51.8
At talagang na-i-develop yung kanilang mga lugar.
43:55.2
That we have to give to them.
43:57.4
Pero syempre, in the long run,
44:00.2
sana mas ma-expand po yung opportunities
44:02.2
for other people to serve as well.
44:05.5
Kasi may hirap pag-inisip mo na
44:06.7
ikaw lang yung pwede mag-deliver
44:08.2
ng ganyang klaseng public service.
44:10.8
That in itself is undemocratic.
44:14.0
Napakataas naman ang pagtingin mo sa sarili mo
44:15.9
kung ang tingin mo,
44:17.4
ang makakapagbigay ng ganyang katinding servisyo.
44:21.7
Ang suggestion ko sa inyo,
44:23.3
maganda po yung petition na yan
44:24.7
nila attorney Rico Domingo.
44:26.6
Ang importante po dyan,
44:27.7
a critical component of that
44:29.2
is pressure from the public.
44:31.5
Pressure galing po sa inyo.
44:32.8
Napaka-importante po yan.
44:36.1
dito sa ating representative democracy,
44:38.3
na alam naman natin
44:39.1
na hindi naman tayo nasusunod
44:42.4
our representatives
44:44.0
representing their own
44:45.6
political interests.
44:51.7
Eh yan po yung gusto ng tao eh.
44:54.2
Panag-align yung interest nila
44:55.9
doon sa interest ng constituents nila,
44:59.1
doon lang babanggitin yung
45:00.3
prinsipyo ng representative democracy.
45:03.1
O kaya ginagamit na excuse
45:04.4
yung mga kababayan natin.
45:09.4
Example lang, no?
45:12.3
yung 70 congressmen,
45:14.0
who voted against the
45:15.3
franchise application
45:18.6
nagkonsulta ba yan
45:19.4
sa kanilang mga constituents?
45:21.3
At sa tingin nyo ba
45:22.1
yung constituents nila,
45:23.2
kung kinonsulta man nila,
45:24.8
sinabi sa kanila,
45:28.5
tsaka kay Alan Peter Caetano
45:30.1
at i-reject nyo po
45:31.3
yung franchise ng ABS-CBN.
45:33.4
Hindi naman siguro
45:34.7
yung mga kababayan natin.
45:36.6
Ngayon, kung nakinig sila
45:38.2
doon sa kababayan nila
45:39.6
at sinabi ng mga kababayan nila,
45:41.3
bigyan nyo ng bagong franchise
45:43.8
yun po yung tunay
45:46.5
sa kanilang constituents.
45:47.9
Pero alam naman natin,
45:48.8
political interest
45:49.7
and survival nila
45:50.5
yung tinitingnan nila eh.
45:52.3
Huwag na tayo magbulahan dyan.
45:53.6
Napaka-specific na example ko.
45:55.5
And that is very true.
45:58.9
Ngayon, in the meantime,
46:01.2
yung mga nakikita natin
46:03.9
yung political dynasties.
46:05.5
importante po talaga,
46:08.7
yung public pressure
46:11.2
for our politicians.
46:12.4
To once and for all
46:16.1
an anti-political dynasty law.
46:21.1
pag nag-snowball nga yan,
46:22.2
tulad ng binabanggit
46:23.0
ni Atty. Rico Domingo,
46:25.2
pwede ma-pressure yung ating mga
46:27.8
gawin po yung tama.
46:31.7
eh, let's focus on
46:32.7
possibly small victories
46:34.0
that we can achieve, no?
46:36.1
ito po yung iiwan ko
46:38.3
Maingat po kayo doon
46:40.5
nakabago-bago lalo.
46:46.0
Gusto nyo po bang
46:46.7
pangalanan natin?
46:48.5
Ito, example lang, no?
46:51.1
paborito po nating
46:52.8
I'm a big boxing fan.
46:54.5
Gustong-gusto ko po
46:58.1
The only 8th division
47:08.1
for so many years.
47:11.1
Diba, nung una pumasok
47:17.2
Kung mga kabago-bago
47:18.9
nagtatayo ng dynastiya.
47:26.4
ilan silang Tulfo
47:27.1
na nakaupo ngayon?
47:29.5
Huwag na tayong lumayo.
47:32.8
Mga Metro Manila,
47:34.3
dynasties na meron dito?
47:37.2
dynasties sa Las Piñas,
47:43.7
natanggal kasing dynasty
47:45.4
dahil nanalo yung Zamora, no?
47:47.4
It remains to be seen
47:49.3
masyado pa kasing bata
47:51.7
ng Mayor Francis Zamora, no?
47:53.1
Para mag-dynastie.
47:54.2
Pero yung tatay niya,
47:55.3
diba, congressman din
47:59.5
So, nandun din yung
48:04.4
pag nakakausap natin
48:06.2
mas maalam sa issue na ito,
48:08.0
yung mga political scientists,
48:10.4
Dr. Julio Tejanki,
48:12.4
na malawak po yung pag-aaral
48:19.5
lang ang ating ipas, eh.
48:21.3
package of reforms,
48:24.0
might be easier to achieve,
48:26.0
others might even be
48:29.5
Ano ba yung mas mahirap
48:30.3
i-achieve dyan, for instance?
48:31.6
Siguro yung anti-political
48:33.6
medyo mahirap yan.
48:38.4
anti-party switching,
48:39.7
yung anti-balimbing law,
48:40.6
baka mas mabiris.
48:43.3
Maraming ano yan, eh.
48:46.1
to change the rules
48:48.8
Ako nga alam nyo,
48:50.0
is actually in favor of
48:53.1
to elect senators
48:58.1
ang pagboto ng ating
49:00.8
Example lang yan, oh.
49:02.8
Eh, mapipilitan yung
49:09.5
para isa o dalawa lang
49:11.3
mag-emerge sa kanila.
49:13.5
hindi gugustuhin nyo
49:15.0
kasi bilangin nyo yung dynasties
49:16.2
for instance sa Metro Manila.
49:18.4
kung nga rin mag-eelect
49:19.1
ng isa o dalawang senador
49:21.7
Eh, baka magpatayin
49:22.6
yung mga dynasties dyan.
49:25.7
sinasabi nila dyan,
49:26.9
if you change the rules
49:28.7
you can change the behavior
49:29.7
of our politicians
49:31.0
and also the electorate.
49:33.3
So, mahabang discussion po yan.
49:37.3
eh, simulan nyo nalang po.
49:40.1
Again, to be fair,
49:41.0
may mga good dynasties
49:42.2
at may mga bad dynasties.
49:44.2
Pero, in the long run kasi,
49:46.1
even the good ones
49:47.1
limit the opportunities
49:48.4
for other people to serve.
49:50.8
Yun po ang point doon.
49:55.1
even if they are good dynasties,
49:57.4
still control the rules of the game.
49:59.5
That's the sad part of it.
50:04.1
Napakabato rin yung
50:05.1
komentaryo ko, no?
50:08.6
palitan nyo natin itong ano.
50:12.2
Pangalan nalang ilagay natin.
50:14.9
medyo na-carried away ako dyan
50:16.0
kasi natagal na natin
50:17.6
tinututukan yung issue
50:18.7
ng political dynasties.
50:22.0
Kasi gagapal naman talaga
50:23.6
ng ilang mga dynasties natin.
50:26.1
Para bang sila lang
50:27.6
parang sila lang yung pwedeng,
50:29.5
sila lang yung may karapatan
50:30.6
at sila lang yung magaling.
50:35.9
Greetings muna tayo.
50:39.8
watching from San Francisco,
50:42.2
Tapos si Dignak King,
50:44.1
shoutout sa mga New Yorkers.
50:46.6
Nanonood po sila ng
50:48.1
Dun sa mga naiinis agad.
50:50.4
Pag nadedelay lang ng konti
50:51.9
ang pagstart ng Facts First.
50:53.5
Watching live from New York.
50:56.4
Yung mga nagagalit eh.
50:58.0
Minsan may nagme-message.
51:01.0
Pasensya na kayo.
51:01.8
Minsan technical issues eh.
51:02.9
Tsaka pagkibulihang topic natin eh.
51:04.7
Mukha napapastop yung ating streaming eh.
51:07.0
Napapansin ko yan eh.
51:08.1
Hindi pa tayo nagkaroon
51:10.0
internet connection
51:12.2
kibuloy yung topic natin.
51:14.0
Malapit na akong maniwala
51:15.3
na talagang powerful
51:16.7
appointed son of God.
51:21.7
si ang ating kaklase.
51:25.7
At panagsulat po siya
51:28.9
Si Eugene Keeler.
51:29.8
Would it be fair to say then
51:31.0
that there is a lack of
51:35.5
Ano ba yung delikadesa?
51:37.5
Kung politiko ka,
51:38.9
ano ba yung delikadesa?
51:44.7
Thank you raw sa greetings
51:49.5
Ito nga pala, no.
51:50.4
Pag-usapan natin ng konti
51:51.5
bago tayo magtapos.
51:52.4
Yung silver lining.
51:55.4
ang ating kongreso
51:58.6
political dynasties.
52:00.8
Tingnan nyo lang yung pangalan, no?
52:02.0
Tingnan nyo lang yung pangalan
52:03.9
Ng roster ng ano?
52:05.6
Yung roster ng ating mga
52:08.9
Yung member ng mababang kapulungan
52:10.3
at saka nung ating senado.
52:12.2
Pare-pareho yung apelido, no?
52:15.3
the first time I covered
52:16.3
the House of Representatives
52:24.5
kong politiko roon,
52:26.7
nalipat ako ng coverage,
52:28.2
napunta ako sa iba,
52:31.5
Yung mga time na bumalik ako
52:35.5
interviewin ko nga to
52:36.7
kasi pamilya niyo
52:40.6
iba na yung nakaupo,
52:46.4
ano, cover ko po yung tatay niyo.
52:48.3
naka-cover ko po yung anak niyo
52:49.9
Nagpapalit-palit ka.
52:51.4
O, tingnan nyo lang dyan
52:57.3
many parts of the Philippines,
52:59.8
nakatatlong termino na,
53:02.1
papatakbo yung si misis,
53:04.4
siya naman yung magbabise,
53:05.5
tapos si misis yung magme-mayor.
53:07.4
O, minsan yung anak,
53:08.3
Lalayo pa ba tayo?
53:09.9
Tingnan nyo yung ginawa nila
53:10.6
Duterte sa Davao City.
53:12.1
O, di na umalis sa pwesto yun, ah.
53:17.0
diba, nag-vice pa si Digong.
53:18.8
O ngayon, sino mayor?
53:22.9
Hindi talaga papakawalan yung posisyon.
53:24.7
Kasi posisyon yan, eh.
53:31.2
Shout-out kay Edgar Ines.
53:33.8
Ayan, maraming salamat sa'yo.
53:37.0
maraming salamat sa'yo.
53:43.3
maraming salamat sa'yo.
53:44.3
Watching from Dubai.
53:47.0
O, napakaraming dynasties dyan.
53:56.0
Minsan ngayon, diba kayo na, ano,
53:59.2
Diba madalas magbiyayang ating mahal na Pangulong Bongbong Marcos?
54:02.1
O, madalas kasama, diba,
54:03.2
yung Speaker of the House na pinsa niya.
54:08.3
Na mukhang ginugroom for a higher post.
54:10.8
Kaso hindi pa pwedeng tumakbo
54:11.9
sa pagkasenador dahil medyo bata pa, no?
54:15.2
Hindi pa niya mamimit yung
54:16.5
35 years old na age requirement.
54:20.9
Pero alam mo, binibuild up, eh.
54:23.1
Talagang nilalagay dyan sa
54:24.2
national and international stage.
54:30.5
Diba, ano ba kayo napapaisip?
54:32.0
Ano kayo iniisip ng mga namimit nilang mga
54:33.9
foreign leaders sa kanilang foreign trip?
54:35.8
Diba, kunwari, papakilala.
54:37.1
Mr. President, diba?
54:40.2
Kunwari, Ferdinand Bongbong Marcos Jr.
54:43.5
By the way, this is my,
54:45.7
this is our house speaker,
54:48.3
Ferdinand Martin Romualdes.
54:51.7
gire-research naman yung mga kausap nila.
54:54.8
And this is our congressman,
55:01.1
Tapos, diba, bisan, kunwari,
55:02.8
kasama yung anak ng speaker, na congressista rin,
55:07.1
Diba, napapaisip yung mga nakakausap
55:10.2
Ano ito? Family trip?
55:14.2
Siguro naman, pwede i-comment yun, no?
55:15.6
Totoo naman yung sinasabi ko.
55:21.3
Maraming salamat sa inyo.
55:27.5
Shout out from Penang, Malaysia.
55:33.3
eh, salamat sa mahabang
55:39.1
Ako, aminsan, ano,
55:40.4
dami kong sinasabi, no?
55:42.1
Iyo, gusto ko kasi yung topic na ito, ano.
55:44.7
Isa nga, paboran na ako rin sa ano, eh.
55:47.6
ang sinasabi ng iba,
55:49.9
ang dynasty, kunwari, sa isang lugar,
55:52.0
pare pa yung, kunwari,
55:54.8
congressional seat,
55:56.7
magkakapamilya, no?
56:00.1
Okay na nga, for instance,
56:04.7
for a national position,
56:07.1
Tapos, yung isa, siguro, tumatakbo
56:08.6
for a local position.
56:09.7
Ako, agree na ako ron, eh.
56:14.1
makapagsimula somewhere.
56:24.3
Ang suggestion ko na lang, kung sakaling kayo
56:27.2
sa isang elective position in the future,
56:29.5
eh, sana yung mga pinag-uusapan natin dito
56:33.1
huwag niyong gagawin.
56:37.1
gumawa kayo ng tama.
56:45.4
what about the role of media?
56:48.3
Malaki pa yung role ng media
56:55.7
for political and electoral reforms.
56:58.1
Eh, sana lang talaga,
56:59.8
Eh, kasi di naman ganun katinding
57:01.1
pagkakatutok din ng, ah,
57:02.7
ibang mga kasama natin sa media
57:04.1
for issues like this.
57:05.7
Kumaga, pinag-uusapan lang
57:06.6
political dynamics,
57:07.1
usually pag malapit
57:08.3
pag-eleksyon, eh, no?
57:09.3
By the time, too late na, eh.
57:10.9
ano pong magagawa nun?
57:12.4
Kung pinag-uusapan mo yung
57:13.3
pag-reforma sa ating sistema
57:16.4
eh, kung pag-uusapan mo lang siya
57:17.6
pag malapit na sa eleksyon.
57:19.3
At ito pa po, ano,
57:20.7
haba ng aking komentaryo.
57:24.3
yung tinatawag na
57:25.1
political patronage na yan,
57:27.1
eramdam din po yan sa media.
57:30.2
Meron din po kasi tayong
57:31.1
mga kapatid sa media
57:32.7
na pag nag-cover ng politiko,
57:34.9
ang tingin na sa politiko,
57:37.5
Pamihingi na rin ng mga
57:38.4
sangkatutak na pabor,
57:40.5
ilang pagkakataon,
57:44.3
Tapos, talagang halos
57:47.7
yung kanilang kaluluwa
57:49.0
pag nabigyan sila ng pabor.
57:51.9
yung political patronage
57:56.5
in terms of influence,
57:58.6
members of the media.
57:59.8
Nandun din yan, eh.
58:13.2
Hindi ko mind din
58:14.2
yung ibang comment.
58:15.8
Tama, may isang nag-comment dito.
58:18.0
Tama yung sinabi mo.
58:21.7
Yang reporter na yan.
58:23.2
Ganyan talaga yan.
58:26.4
Ayoko nang banggitin.
58:27.1
Nadami pa kaaway ko, eh.
58:30.0
Sige, maraming salamat po
58:32.9
Meron po tayong special guest.
58:34.7
Magkakaroon po tayo
58:35.5
ng special guest.
58:35.8
Magkakaroon po tayo ng special guest.
58:35.9
Magkakaroon po tayo ng special guest.
58:35.9
Magkakaroon po tayo ng special guest.
58:35.9
Magkakaroon po tayo ng special guest.
58:36.0
Magkakaroon po tayo ng special guest.
59:05.9
Magkakaroon po tayo ng special guest.
