Close
 


Carpio: Duterte agreement sa China, impeachable sana
Hide Subtitles
Click any subtitle word to view Tagalog.com dictionary results.
Computer Shortcuts: Left / Right arrows to jump 2 seconds back or forward. +Enter or Space to toggle Play/Pause button. Full Screen Mode

Christian Esguerra
  Mute  
Run time: 09:53
Has AI Subtitles



Video Transcript / Subtitles:( AI generated. About AI subtitles » )
00:00.0
First of all, ang sabi ni Harry, status ko.
00:09.2
Hindi yan ang status ko eh.
00:10.7
Ang status ko, at the time that President Duterte came to office,
00:17.7
we were fixing the ano, inaayos na natin, rinirepair na natin yung Sierra Madre.
00:23.3
So, yung nag-agree sila na ang status ko, pagkain at tubig lang papadala,
00:31.4
hindi yun ang status ko. Dehado tayo doon.
00:34.5
Kasi everybody knows na yung BRP Sierra Madre, lulubog na.
00:42.0
Rusty na yan eh. Kinakalawang na yan eh.
00:45.6
So there is really need to retrofit it, to repair it, para at least tumagal tayo dyan.
00:51.6
Kasi pag lumubog yan, wala na tayong presence dyan.
00:56.9
Papasok na yung China.
00:58.9
So, yung pumayag sila na tubig at pagkain lang,
01:03.3
eh, numbered na rin yung days ng ano.
01:06.2
The days of Sierra Madre were numbered already.
01:10.1
Kasi ang rust ko continue, ang dilapidation ko continue.
01:16.8
So, dehado tayo doon.
01:18.9
At saka, secondly,
01:21.6
yung ginawa ni Duterte yan, lumabas na yung
01:25.2
Arbitral Award. Kasi July 12, 2016 eh.
01:28.9
Naging presidente siya, June, noon of June of 2016.
01:34.8
So, may Arbitral Award na.
01:38.2
Ang sinabi ng Arbitral Award, yung Ayungin Shoal,
01:41.4
part of the EEZ, Exclusive Economic Zone of the Philippines.
01:45.1
So, dapat hindi na sila pumayag.
01:48.4
Kasi pag part ng EEZ natin,
01:51.6
gusto tayo all right to put up a structure there.
01:54.7
Eh, ang nangyayari,
01:55.9
pumayag tayo na we will not do anything.
02:00.9
That's against our right as the coastal state
02:04.9
as jurisdiction over the EEZ.
02:07.3
Kasi sabi ng tribunal,
02:10.0
Yung Ayungin Shoal, EEZ ng Pilipinas yan.
02:13.3
That means, we can put up a structure there.
02:16.3
In fact, tayo lang pwede mag-lagay ng structure.
02:19.5
E pumayag yung Duterte demonstration na,
02:21.3
we can put up a structure there. In fact, tiyo lang pwede mag lagay ng structure. E pumayag yung Duterte demonstration na,
02:21.6
wala nang gagawin.
02:24.8
Papadala ng pagkain
02:26.1
at tubig lang. Eh, that's
02:27.8
yung lifespan
02:30.1
ng Sierra Madre, numbered
02:32.2
na. The days of the Sierra Madre
02:34.0
would be numbered kasi talagang
02:36.2
pasira ng
02:37.5
yung structure.
02:40.7
Ito ka pala, Justice
02:42.0
Carpio, kung sakaling lumabas
02:44.0
itong
02:44.7
gentleman's agreement na ito,
02:47.9
na presidente pa si Rodrigo
02:49.9
Duterte, would this have been
02:52.2
an impeachable
02:53.9
offense?
02:55.6
Well, that would be an impeachable offense
02:57.9
kasi wala naman siyang
02:59.0
power to waive our
03:01.8
exclusive economic zone.
03:04.0
We have, claro naman,
03:06.0
sinabi ng Arbitral Award,
03:08.4
part of the exclusive economic
03:09.8
zone of the Philippines, siyong ayung insyol.
03:12.2
The president has no
03:13.3
power, has no authority
03:15.8
to waive that.
03:17.9
Kasi it can only be waived in a treaty.
03:19.9
Hindi pwedeng pamimigay
03:22.0
niya lang, hindi naman sa kanya yung personal.
03:24.7
The process has to
03:26.0
be followed, that
03:28.0
will need a treaty to be ratified
03:30.2
by the Senate.
03:32.0
So, of course,
03:33.9
ang mangyari niyan, wala namang mag-file sa kanya
03:36.0
o hindi naman mag-prosper
03:38.4
pag finayalan siya
03:39.9
ng impeachment kasi hawak niya naman yung
03:41.8
Congress, hawak niya yung
03:43.4
House at saka Senate at that time.
03:45.8
But, pag ang tanong mo, is that
03:47.9
impeachable? I think it's impeachable.
03:49.9
So, kasi, di ba,
03:52.1
marami pong elements yung
03:53.1
offense that can be considered
03:56.0
impeachable. Mukhang saan po ba yan
03:57.9
babagsak? Culpable violation of the
04:00.0
Constitution?
04:01.2
Culpable violation of the Constitution. Kasi sinabi
04:03.9
ng Constitution, sa ligang batas
04:06.1
natin, the state must protect
04:08.1
its marine wealth in its exclusive
04:09.9
economic zone. Must
04:11.8
protect its marine wealth in its
04:13.8
exclusive economic zone and reserve
04:15.7
its use and enjoyment
04:17.6
exclusively for Filipinos.
04:19.9
Eh, hindi niya
04:22.3
pinaprotektahan.
04:24.2
Kasi pumayag siya na
04:25.7
hindi na aayusin yung
04:27.9
Sierra Madre.
04:30.0
Eh, hindi na tatagal
04:32.1
yung outpost natin doon.
04:34.7
How about yung ano?
04:36.2
How about yung isa po?
04:37.7
Yung betrayal of public trust.
04:39.5
Mas malawak po yun.
04:41.8
Kasi ano yan eh, yung betrayal of public
04:44.0
trust, catch all provision yan eh.
04:46.5
Pwede mo i-bagsak
04:47.9
lahat ng mga reason dyan eh.
04:49.9
So yung dalawang
04:52.2
provision na yun, pwedeng gagamitin yun.
04:55.5
Okay.
04:56.3
Anyway, gusto ko lang po saanang ano yun,
04:57.9
to set the record straight. Kasi nga,
04:59.8
isa po sa mga problema rito,
05:01.8
parang may lusot pa rin eh. Pag sinabi pong
05:03.7
gentleman's agreement, ano ba yun? Verbal?
05:06.1
Nakasulat ba yun? Nag-handshake lang ba yun?
05:08.3
I mean, we don't know. Ang pinangahawakan
05:10.0
lang po natin, yung sinabi ni Harry Roque
05:12.0
at saka yung binabanggit din po ng
05:13.8
China. So, given that
05:15.4
situation or predicament, I mean,
05:17.8
how can we navigate that po?
05:19.9
Well, first of all,
05:22.3
since it's a gentleman's agreement,
05:24.6
that's only an agreement
05:25.7
between the two gentlemen.
05:27.7
Gentlemen kuno sila.
05:29.5
So between President Xi and President
05:31.5
Duterte, it is not binding
05:33.5
to the successor
05:35.5
of Duterte or Xi.
05:38.7
Kaya tama yung ginawa
05:39.7
ni President BBM,
05:41.7
sabi niya, if there is such an agreement,
05:44.0
I rescind it. Kasi delikado
05:46.0
yun. Baka sabi ng China,
05:47.8
you are bound also by that.
05:49.9
Eh, malaking problema yun.
05:52.2
So tama yung ginawa niya. Sinabi niya
05:53.8
kagad, walang agreement, wala namang
05:55.6
kasulatan, walang record
05:57.6
ng DFA, walang record sa Malacanang
06:00.0
na may agreement na ganyan. Pero
06:01.7
kung meron mang ganyan agreement,
06:03.7
I rescind it. Tama yun. That's
06:05.7
the correct thing
06:08.0
to do.
06:09.4
Sabagay. Nalinaw yun. I think it was last year
06:11.8
by President Marcos.
06:13.9
Okay. Ito po kanina, may
06:15.5
balita na lumabas sa Inquirer.net.
06:18.0
Mukha na interview nila si
06:19.6
Atty. Harry Roque. At ang
06:21.6
angulo rito is
06:22.5
according daw kay
06:24.7
Atty. Harry Roque, the Philippines
06:27.7
may lose Ayungin if it continues
06:29.7
to impose yung hardline
06:31.7
stance na yan. I think, isa to sa
06:33.6
mga perspectives na nakikita rin po natin
06:35.6
lumulutang.
06:37.2
I think this is
06:38.3
this could really be the case
06:41.8
po. Kung magmatigas ang Pilipinas
06:43.8
dito, baka
06:45.6
ultimately, mawala sa atin
06:47.5
altogether yung Ayungin show po.
06:49.6
Pag
06:50.5
pag
06:52.6
sumunod tayo sa
06:55.5
gentleman's agreement nila,
06:57.7
mawawala yung Ayungin show.
06:59.7
Sigurado yun. Kasi
07:01.0
blulubog yung Sierra Madre,
07:04.0
wala tayong outpost.
07:06.0
So the only way we can keep that
07:07.7
is to continue the outpost.
07:09.7
So dapat magmatigas tayo
07:11.5
to continue the outpost. Dapat yan,
07:13.9
in fact, ang proposal ko
07:15.6
to convert that to a
07:17.8
civilian presence.
07:19.6
Civilian structure. Magtayo tayo ng
07:21.7
lighthouse at saka marine research
07:23.6
center. Pag hinintul
07:25.9
ng China, ang
07:27.4
pagdala natin
07:29.8
ng mga materials sa Ayungin show
07:31.8
to construct the
07:32.9
lighthouse and marine research center.
07:35.8
Then we go to the onklos tribunal
07:37.7
kasi that's part of our
07:39.5
EZ and the onklos, we are the
07:41.7
only one who can put up
07:43.6
a structure there. At saka valid yun.
07:45.5
The purpose is lighthouse
07:47.4
for navigation. At saka yung
07:49.4
research center to manage
07:51.3
to preserve the
07:53.2
fish
07:55.8
and other
07:57.5
other
07:59.5
the giant
08:01.4
clams and other
08:03.2
species there.
08:04.7
So kasi that's allowed
08:07.3
under onklos. You can
08:08.4
put up a structure to preserve
08:11.7
the marine environment.
08:13.3
And that's precisely the
08:14.8
purpose of a marine
08:17.4
research center to preserve the marine
08:19.3
environment and to prevent the Chinese
08:21.5
fishermen. Kasi pag wala tayo
08:23.7
doon, papasok yung mga
08:25.3
Chinese fishermen, sisirain nila
08:27.4
yung reef para makuha nila yung
08:29.1
giant clams. Nangyari
08:31.5
yan recently sa
08:32.7
Skoda Show at
08:34.5
Russell Reef.
08:37.0
That's why we're planning, the DOJ is planning
08:39.4
to file a case for
08:40.8
destruction of the environment.
08:43.5
Hindi nila magawa yan sa Ayungin Show
08:45.1
kasi andun tayo.
08:47.4
Pero pag wala na tayo dyan,
08:49.3
madating na yung mga
08:50.3
Chinese fishermen,
08:53.5
uubosin na nila yun.
08:55.4
Sirain nila yung
08:56.7
coral reef para
08:59.2
they can extract, makuha nila
09:01.5
yung mga giant clams na
09:02.9
patay na. Kasi hindi naman
09:05.3
yung meat ng giant clams
09:07.1
ang gusto nila. Gusto nila
09:09.3
yung shell. Kasi yun, pag kinarve
09:11.5
nila yun, napaka
09:13.1
expensive na yun.
09:14.5
Kung nagustuhan nyo po itong video na ito, pakilike at share
09:17.4
na lang po para mas parang makakita.
09:19.3
At makapanood. Kung gusto nyo po makibalita,
09:22.2
follow nyo na rin po ako sa aking mga
09:23.5
social media accounts na nakasulat po sa
09:25.4
screen. Pwede rin po kayo magpadala
09:27.5
ng super thanks, super likes, super
09:29.3
chat at super stickers sa YouTube
09:31.1
saka Facebook stars po. Alam nyo po
09:33.6
malayo po mararating ito para
09:35.1
makagawa po kami ng mas maraming video
09:37.4
na makatutulong po sa
09:39.1
pagpapakalat ng tamang informasyon para
09:41.3
sa bawat Pilipino. Kada like,
09:43.4
subscribe, follow at share ay pagsuporta
09:45.4
po sa tunay na independent
09:47.3
journalism sa bansa.
09:49.3
Mga maraming salamat po.