TAPOS NA BA ANG KASO SA TVJ VS. TAPE SA COURT OF APPEALS BANAT SA DIVINA LAW
* AI ("Artificial Intelligence") subtitles on Tagalog.com are generated using "Whisper" by OpenAI (the same company that created ChatGPT and DallE2). Results and accuracy may vary.
* The subtitles do include errors occasionally and should only be used as a tool to help with your listening practice.
* You can request this website to create a transcript for a video if one doesn't already exist by clicking the "Request AI Subtitles" button below a video. Transcribing usually takes 30-40% of the length of a video to complete if there are no other videos in
the queue. For example, a 21 minute video will take 7-8 minutes to transcribe.
* Running a super fast cloud GPU server to do these transcriptions does cost money. If you have the desire and financial ability, consider
becoming a patron
to support these video transcriptions, and the other tools and apps built by Tagalog.com
00:01.0
Alright, yan. Magandang araw mga kabatas natin at welcome sa isang namang livestream.
00:06.7
Mga kabatas natin, alam nyo hindi ko rin maintindihan kung ano yung nangyayari dito.
00:13.4
Kasi nga, itong si Harvatera Vlog, okay?
00:19.7
Noong finiture natin kahapon, naghahanap kasi ako ng kaliwanagan tungkol dito.
00:28.6
Gusto ko malaman.
00:30.0
Kasi, yun, krinikritisize niya hindi lang yung TVJ, hindi lang yung IPOFIL, kundi pati yung Divina Law, okay?
00:40.5
Ngayon, mga kabatas natin, siya kasi yung tao na nagsabi na meron siya mga mole.
00:47.1
May mga mole siya, tapos sinabi ng mga mole niya mga kabatas natin,
00:52.4
natalo na daw sa Court of Appeals yung TVJ.
00:56.1
Nanalo daw yung Tape Incorporated.
01:00.0
Ngayon, puntahan nyo daw doon.
01:06.2
Tingnan nyo mga kabatas natin kung anong sinabi niya pa dito.
01:09.4
TVJ and Divina Law, what do you take us for?
01:12.1
Hindi kami tanga, I'm from UP Iloilo and UP Diliman.
01:15.9
O, sabi niya, he's from UP Iloilo and UP Diliman.
01:21.7
Yung UP Iloilo ba, yun yung kanyang undergraduate?
01:25.9
Tsaka sa UP Diliman siya, nag College of Law?
01:30.0
AI ba ito? AI ba ito?
01:33.9
Sa tingin ko, hindi AI ito eh.
01:36.3
Kasi nakikita mo yung ulo niya dito eh.
01:40.0
Diba? O, tingnan nyo kasi yung mga allegations niya dito.
01:42.4
Yung mga taga-USD kayo, pumunta kayo ngayon doon sa Ipofil ng kasabwat nyo at si Judge Tagra na bayad nyo.
01:51.6
Yan o. Ipofil kasabwat daw ng Divina Law.
02:00.0
yung si Judge Tagra,
02:08.3
Doon kayo humingi ng Certificate of Itbulaga ni Joey De Leon dahil hindi marirelease yan sa inyo
02:14.5
because you do not conform to international standards and protocols regarding...
02:19.8
Bakit international standards? Ang gagana dapat local laws eh.
02:26.3
Kasi syempre, this is not an international...
02:30.0
international matter.
02:33.5
Domestic law ang magiging batayan, hindi international law.
02:41.0
... intellectual properties.
02:44.0
Sabi niya, cyber libel plus one siya. Bilangin nyo. Marami akong ipi-play it sa inyo.
02:51.0
Hoder, coño! What do you think of us? Hindi kami nakatapos ng high school na ganito hinunin nyo kami?
02:56.0
Ha? You have caused so much pain, suffering, job losses.
02:59.0
Ha? You have caused so much pain, suffering, job losses.
03:10.5
Well, there are rumors like around na talagang matatalo na si TVJ.
03:15.5
Let's just wait for it no, because the court of appeals has certain ano no, marami siyang protocols.
03:21.5
But somebody told me that ginamit ng Divina Law ang land dispute.
03:31.5
Matatalo sila because land dispute is homogeneous.
03:35.5
Yan din yung sinabi niya eh. Matatalo na daw sila eh. Homogeneous.
03:39.5
Hindi ko makuha yung ibig sabihin niya sa homogeneous.
03:43.5
Yung arguments diyan ay isa lang tungkol sa land and it's a physical thing.
03:48.5
You know, in intellectual property, there is a trademark and there is a copyright.
03:52.5
They are different things and pinipilit ng Divina Law na pag-isahin yon.
03:56.5
Kasi yan ang ginawa ni Judge Chagra. Pinag-isa niya yung trademark tsaka copyright.
04:03.5
That's why he was able to grant or give a relief. So mali yon.
04:09.5
Mali daw yon. Tapos yun nga sinasabi niya bayad daw.
04:12.5
They will be defeated and everybody will see in the whole world yung pinaggagawa nila na bawal sa international law.
04:21.5
Well, there are rumors like around...
04:22.5
Bawal sa international law?
04:26.5
Ito oh. Bayad ang judge.
04:30.5
Judge Chagra, stop it. Stop it.
04:32.5
Si Judge Chagra daw.
04:33.5
Stop it because you will never survive the Supreme Court.
04:36.5
A trademark is not a copyright and a copyright is not a trademark.
04:41.5
And number two, you cannot grant relief without it being in the complaint.
04:48.5
Those are basic fundamental international laws. Stop it.
04:52.5
Alam nyo, international law siya ng international law eh.
04:56.5
Tapos sasabihin niya na you cannot grant a relief that is not in the complaint.
05:00.5
Actually, pwede. Kasi nga yung batas natin, it seeks justice.
05:06.5
And in every pleading mga kabatas natin, doon sa prayer, meron sa dulo yon mga kabatas natin.
05:11.5
Meron sa dulo nakalagay na other reliefs, just and equitable, are likewise prayed for.
05:21.5
Sabi niya. O kaya basta along that line.
05:25.5
Other reliefs in relation to the fit and blah, blah, blah, blah.
05:33.5
Basta parang ganun. Iba-iba yung terminology.
05:36.5
Pero ang pinaka gist nun mga kabatas natin, other reliefs just inequitable according to the circumstances are likewise, are also prayed for.
05:47.5
Ganun. Kung ano-anong terms. Pero ang ibig sabihin lang nun, kung meron akong hindi nahingi na prayer,
05:53.5
pero karapat dapat yon para doon sa kaso na yon, ika-grant o ibibigay yon ng judge. Okay?
06:01.5
Tapos hindi international law. Bakit siya international law ng international law?
06:06.5
Domestic law dapat because this is a domestic dispute.
06:09.5
Stop quoting Supreme Court decisions and civil law, civil liberties to prove your point na mali.
06:18.5
Because I believe, Judge Tagra, I believe that bayad ka ng Divina Law.
06:22.5
I believe that you are.
06:23.5
Bayad daw ng Divina Law si Judge Tagra.
06:27.5
Bayad ng Divina Law.
06:29.5
So huwag nyo nang ipagpipilit kasi nakakahiyana.
06:32.5
People know. People understand. Hindi kami mga bobo.
06:36.5
Divina Law, you remember that. And ikaw Judge Tagra, you remember that.
06:40.5
It is my opinion na bayad ka. Bayad ka Judge Tagra.
06:44.5
Pero hindi naman pwede na sabihin mo na bayad ng judge tapos opinion mo lang yung basihan mo.
06:52.5
According to my mall, there is no other resort with all of these evidences na matatalo na talaga si Judge Tagra dito sa kaso na ito at yung TVJ, yung Divina Law.
07:08.5
Magugulat lang ang lahat kasi this is what will happen.
07:12.5
They used, according to my mall, they used an example about a certain land dispute na
07:20.5
tinay up nila sa intellectual property.
07:24.5
Now remember that that land dispute is not the same as intellectual property.
07:30.5
Sinabi niya na rin yan eh. Ulit na yan eh.
07:39.5
Ito, Dear Divina Law.
07:43.5
Dear Divina Law and Joel Cloma and Atty. Buko.
07:46.5
You're going to sue, no?
07:49.5
An invalid just because he is expressing his opinion.
07:53.5
And you're one of the biggest and most prestigious law firms, in your opinion, in the whole Philippines.
07:59.5
Ganyan ba kayo? Is that how you operate?
08:01.5
Sige, go ahead and do it so that malaman ang lahat kung ano ang Divina Law.
08:06.5
Dear Divina Law and Joel Cloma and Atty. Buko.
08:19.5
Ang copyright ay hindi trademark at ang trademark ay hindi copyright.
08:24.5
So it is my opinion that binayaran si Judge Tagra.
08:28.5
Siya kaya yung invalid malamang.
08:33.5
O ulitin natin, ulitin natin para makuha natin yung buong kontekstong dito.
08:36.5
Ang copyright ay hindi trademark at ang trademark ay hindi copyright.
08:40.5
So it is my opinion that binayaran si Judge Tagra because his, his decision is very ridiculous.
08:46.5
Pero yun e, di ba? Opinyon. Pwede rin naman nagkamali siya.
08:53.5
Kaya nga may appeal. Di ba?
08:59.5
Even Divina Law quotes about Civil Law, about the Supreme Court, about the Supreme Court.
09:05.5
You know, the devil can quote the scriptures for his ends.
09:12.5
Si Divina Law is quoting laws.
09:15.5
Laws which are, which are being used to justify that nakuha nila yung trademark from copyright.
09:24.5
Opinions are not facts. Yeah.
09:26.5
Still wrong. Because you know, in the court, you can never get a relief without it being in the complaint.
09:35.5
You can say that it's connected. But then, at the end of the day, justice has to be done.
09:40.5
You know, dapat fair yung law natin. Kaya nalampaso sila ng showtime eh.
09:44.5
At saka natalo sila sa labor eh. Kasi alam mo, bayad.
09:48.5
Bayad si Divina Law.
09:50.5
Bayad daw. Ngayon mga kabatas natin, ano ba yung gusto ko mangyari dito?
09:55.5
Ang gusto ko mangyari, sana ako malaman kung abogado ba siya o hindi.
09:58.5
Pero parang lumalabas yata na hindi siya abogado.
10:01.5
Magkikritisize sana. Well, nagkritisize naman ako.
10:04.5
Pero gusto ko kasing palalimin ng konti ito para ipakita sa mga tao yung harmful effects ng social media. Di ba?
10:14.5
Pero mga kabatas natin, I can do that.
10:17.5
Sorry, I cannot do that.
10:20.5
I cannot do that yet unless I know kung abogado ba siya o hindi para I know where he is coming from.
10:31.5
Para malalaman ko kung ano yung atake ko o klase ng atake yung gagawin ko sa pagpapaliwanag.
10:38.5
Di ba? So, tutulungan nyo. Ito kasi mga kabatas natin.
10:43.5
Nung nakita ko kasi, meron naman siyang...
10:45.5
Well, parang yung mga ibang tulfunatics at ampalaya ang galing-galing din naman mag-quote at magsabi ng tama at mali.
10:54.5
Pero pag titignan nyo naman, mali-mali din yung mga ginagawa nila.
10:57.5
At least sila kilala natin at alam na natin how to treat them.
11:02.5
Siya kasi, we don't know him yet.
11:04.5
So, if he is parang spreading misinformation or disinformation, mga kabatas natin, we should at least know siguro how to attack.
11:13.5
Yung kanyang mga pinapalabas.
11:16.5
And I need to know where he is coming from.
11:19.5
Is it from the point of view of a lawyer or a layman?
11:29.5
Yun lang mga kabatas natin.
11:31.5
Hindi ko na rin pahabain. I don't know. I'm still looking.
11:34.5
Nahanap ko yung channel niya.
11:36.5
Tapos tinitignan ko nga at hinahanap ko yung background niya.
11:39.5
Kasi nga siyempre, pinaliwanag ko naman na yung mga mole-mole na ganyan.
11:42.5
Tapos magandang pag-uusapan din kasi ito.
11:45.5
And the dangers of social media.
11:47.5
Okay? Maraming salamat po.
11:49.5
Matulog po tayo ng mahimbing dahil alam natin na yung natutulog ng mahimbing, siya yung laging panalo.
11:53.5
Paalam po, pansaman natin.
