PANOORIN: MGA BAGONG PAGLILINAW NI RET. SC JUSTICS CARPIO SA ISYU NG WPS AT CHINA AT SI DUTERTE
* AI ("Artificial Intelligence") subtitles on Tagalog.com are generated using "Whisper" by OpenAI (the same company that created ChatGPT and DallE2). Results and accuracy may vary.
* The subtitles do include errors occasionally and should only be used as a tool to help with your listening practice.
* You can request this website to create a transcript for a video if one doesn't already exist by clicking the "Request AI Subtitles" button below a video. Transcribing usually takes 30-40% of the length of a video to complete if there are no other videos in
the queue. For example, a 21 minute video will take 7-8 minutes to transcribe.
* Running a super fast cloud GPU server to do these transcriptions does cost money. If you have the desire and financial ability, consider
becoming a patron
to support these video transcriptions, and the other tools and apps built by Tagalog.com
00:00.0
Thank you for watching!
00:30.0
Well, that started with the New England Times article
00:38.2
quoting a Chinese embassy official that there was a gentleman's agreement
00:43.7
and then Harry Roque confirmed it
00:47.5
but Sal Panelo said that's a lie, sinungaling yan
00:53.6
at publicity seeker lang
00:56.1
because he said he checked with the former President Duterte
01:01.3
and then suddenly Global Times said there is a gentleman's agreement
01:07.4
and bigla nalang bumalik tayo si Duterte
01:09.9
sabi niya yes there is
01:11.4
so mukhang may hawak yung Chinese
01:16.3
kasi pinagdabi niya you cannot get out of this
01:19.6
there was a gentleman's agreement
01:21.0
so he had to confirm
01:22.0
so ano yung gentleman's agreement sabi ni Duterte
01:27.2
it is a status quo agreement
01:30.0
na since we were not supplying already construction materials
01:36.3
to BFB Sierra Madre
01:38.4
we should not continue to
01:40.6
we should not supply anymore
01:42.2
yun darawang status quo
01:44.3
pero that's refuted by everything
01:47.1
first, the Code of Conduct
01:50.6
rather the Declaration of Conduct of 2002
01:53.5
that was long before
01:60.0
2002 Declaration of Conduct
02:03.4
sabi sa Declaration of Conduct
02:05.7
the parties shall not occupy unoccupied features
02:09.8
na-occupy na natin yung insyol
02:12.6
so were that included there
02:14.5
if you previously occupied it
02:16.6
you can't continue
02:17.5
and you can repair whatever you have there
02:22.1
we beached the Sierra Madre
02:26.2
sinagsad natin sa yung insyol
02:30.0
we are covered by the Declaration of Conduct
02:34.9
we are allowed to continue repairing
02:40.1
when the gentleman's agreement was signed
02:42.6
we have been really repairing
02:45.0
because pag hindi mo ni-repair yan
02:49.5
and we will lose our presence
02:51.9
in fact the military has explained it that way
02:54.8
that if we don't repair it
02:59.9
and we will lose our presence
03:01.2
and China will come in
03:02.3
the military said
03:11.6
former Secretary of Defense
03:16.6
even during the later part
03:24.3
of the Duterte administration
03:28.0
of the Duterte administration
03:29.4
they kept on saying that
03:29.7
they kept on sending construction materials
03:35.0
before and after the
03:38.3
the gentleman's agreement
03:41.1
to continue repairing
03:43.5
the facts on the ground
03:49.3
status quo sinasabi ni Duterte
03:52.4
the actual status quo
04:01.3
the Chinese really want to
04:07.5
if we don't repair it
04:09.5
the superstructure is already rusted
04:12.7
it cannot sail anymore
04:14.8
the engine is corroded
04:16.3
there's no way to repair the engine
04:22.7
mali yung premise niya
04:25.0
the status quo is
04:29.2
construction materials
04:37.9
in his press conference
04:41.7
the defense secretary
04:43.5
the national security account
04:47.2
pero they all denied
04:50.3
they were consulted
04:52.1
defense secretary
04:54.0
former defense secretary
04:57.3
in the inquirer today
04:59.8
I'm not aware of that
05:02.4
gentleman's agreement
05:05.0
I don't know about that
05:06.2
gentleman's agreement
05:08.1
and there's nobody
05:09.7
in the Department of Foreign Affairs
05:11.7
who's saying that
05:12.9
he knows about the
05:14.3
gentleman's agreement
05:16.1
they don't have any record
05:19.5
yes there is such a
05:20.7
gentleman's agreement
05:22.4
si Duterte lang ito
05:24.8
in his press conference
05:25.9
sinabi niya pa ito
05:26.8
I do not even know about
05:29.1
I do not even know about the IUDC
05:31.7
he doesn't know anything
05:34.3
yet he entered into an agreement
05:36.8
where the subject matter
05:43.4
there is such an agreement
05:44.7
he probably had an agreement
05:47.3
with the President Z
05:48.6
personal agreement
05:49.5
but nobody knew about it
05:51.1
sila sila na nag-uusap
05:52.3
and so it didn't trickle down
05:54.5
to the commanders
05:57.4
so the commanders
05:58.4
continued to talk about it
05:59.7
supply construction materials
06:03.9
mawawala yung presence natin
06:18.9
kahit na hindi niya alam
06:22.3
wala akong alam diyan
06:23.6
he didn't even know
06:24.9
where Ayungin Shoal is
06:29.3
he was too intimidated
06:31.6
with the President Z
06:32.7
na oo nang oo na lang siya
06:41.8
so it's very strange
06:45.4
first he denied it
06:56.1
anything about Ayungin Shoal
06:58.3
but the subject matter
07:00.1
was Ayungin Shoal
07:03.8
we should call for a
07:04.9
congressional inquiry
07:17.4
China is now saying
07:19.8
it's a gentleman's agreement
07:20.9
but it is binding
07:22.4
on the Philippines
07:26.0
they're calling it now
07:27.3
a China-Philippine
07:41.2
the gong is saying
07:46.7
Harry Rock is saying
07:47.7
that it's a personal
07:49.9
bind the successor
07:52.1
interpretation nila eh
07:55.4
it does not exist
07:59.1
about Ayungin Shoal
07:60.0
the more he will look like
08:02.4
entering the agreement
08:04.2
when he doesn't know
08:05.9
what the subject matter is
08:08.8
yung Ayungin Shoal
08:10.0
sa Philippines eh
08:15.7
hindi national interest
08:22.0
mawawalan ako ng negosyo
08:31.0
pero pagdating sa
08:34.3
territorial issue
08:38.1
talagang hardline yan
08:42.7
kahit na hindi niya alam
08:49.9
we have no record
08:58.1
such a gentleman's
09:11.6
and then he will say
09:13.5
I don't even know
09:14.3
about Ayungin Shoal
09:20.5
tama yung ano niya
09:22.1
establish the facts
09:23.4
kung ano talagang
09:30.9
state to state agreement
09:34.2
he must formulate
09:40.0
state to state agreement
09:41.1
but he has to know
09:51.4
it's a state to state
09:53.2
so we have to get
09:57.0
didn't care about
10:01.1
kasi then they will
10:03.2
there's agreement
10:07.3
international law
10:08.2
if the head of state
10:09.9
makes a commitment
10:15.3
internally have not
10:17.2
international law
10:18.0
the head of state
10:20.0
to have the authority
10:44.4
Global Times said
10:45.6
there was an agreement
10:47.1
bumaliktad si Duterte
10:50.5
baka may hawak na
11:02.3
Chinese are holding
11:14.6
they can document it
11:19.2
such a gentleman's
11:33.3
that there is such
11:34.0
a gentleman's agreement
11:37.3
if you look at it
11:38.8
it's very strange
11:41.2
definite that there is
11:42.3
there was no agreement
11:47.4
publicity seeking yan
11:49.4
eh biglang bumaliktad
11:53.2
is very suspicious
11:56.8
eh si Harry Roque
12:08.1
bilib na bilib siya
12:17.8
and in the lower house
12:27.8
by and Muna block
12:35.5
halika na kasama ka
12:40.7
kapag buklot ay may pag-asa
12:43.9
susunbisayas ming danaw
12:48.9
sa bagong Pilipinas
