KATRAYDURAN NI DUTERTE, IPINALIWANAG NI CARPIO

Home • Forums • Dictionary • Teachers • Reader • Decks • More Tools

Hide Subtitles

Add Custom Study Entry

Tagalog: ` » «

Translation: ( Google ) `

Deck:

Create Chorusing.com Clip »

Click any subtitle word to view Tagalog.com dictionary results.
Computer Shortcuts: Left / Right arrows to jump 2 seconds back or forward. +Enter or Space to toggle Play/Pause button. Full Screen Mode

KATRAYDURAN NI DUTERTE, IPINALIWANAG NI CARPIO

Enzo Recto

Subscribe Mute Like

Run time: 25:04
Has AI Subtitles

Video Transcript / Subtitles:( AI generated. About AI subtitles » )

* AI ("Artificial Intelligence") subtitles on Tagalog.com are generated using "Whisper" by OpenAI (the same company that created ChatGPT and DallE2). Results and accuracy may vary.
* The subtitles do include errors occasionally and should only be used as a tool to help with your listening practice.
* You can request this website to create a transcript for a video if one doesn't already exist by clicking the "Request AI Subtitles" button below a video. Transcribing usually takes 30-40% of the length of a video to complete if there are no other videos in the queue. For example, a 21 minute video will take 7-8 minutes to transcribe.
* Running a super fast cloud GPU server to do these transcriptions does cost money. If you have the desire and financial ability, consider becoming a patron to support these video transcriptions, and the other tools and apps built by Tagalog.com

00:00.0

Thank you for watching!

00:30.0

Thank you for watching!

01:00.0

Thank you for watching!

01:30.0

I checked with President Duterte, walang ganyang gentleman's agreement. Sinungaling si Harry Roque at publicity seeker lang yan.

01:45.9

So for a few days ganyan, pero biglang nagsalita yung foreign ministry ng China, sabi ng foreign ministry spokesperson, totoo meron talagang gentleman's agreement.

02:00.0

Immediately, si President former President Duterte, sabi niya, oh nga, meron. So he confirmed ni President Duterte na merong gentleman's agreement.

02:11.9

At saka sabi niya, yung gentleman's agreement is just status quo. At saka yung status quo, meaning walang magre-repair ng Sierra Madre.

02:30.0

Gagamit ng military activity or military pressure. So ang pwedeng dalayin lang sa Sierra Madre, tubig at pagkain lang. So walang construction material.

02:45.0

Kasi yun daw ang status ko. Yun ang facts. So ang analysis ko ito, yun ba talaga ang status ko?

03:00.0

2017. Tutoo ba na ang dinadala lang natin noon in 2017 ay tubig at pagkain lang? Hindi. Because hindi totoo yan. Hindi yan ang status ko.

03:15.2

Kasi yung 1999, sinagsad natin yung Sierra Madre sa Ayungin Shoal. So yun ang naging outpost natin.

03:30.0

2002, three years later, nagkaroon ng Declaration of Conduct.

03:37.2

Declaration of Conduct by the parties between ASEAN and China. At sabi ng Declaration of Conduct, no country will occupy unoccupied features as of 2002.

03:55.7

Bawal mag-occupy pag unoccupied yan as of 2002.

04:00.0

But if you occupied it as of 2002, you can maintain it. If you have a facility, pwede mo i-repair. Yun ang kasunduan sa 2002 Declaration of Conduct.

04:13.1

Yung Sierra Madre, andu na yan yung 2002. When the Declaration of Conduct was signed in 2002, andu na yung Sierra Madre since 1999, mga three years na.

04:28.7

So,

04:30.0

Yung Sierra Madre, hindi kasama yun sa prohibisyon. We can maintain Sierra Madre, repair it, because that is the status ko when the 2002 Declaration of Conduct was signed.

04:45.1

Claro yan. Kasi yung outpost natin sa Pag-Asa, yung outpost ng Vietnam sa ibang isla nila, outpost ng China sa ibang isla nila, as of 2002,

04:56.4

at 2002, will continue and will be repaired, will be maintained. So, ganyan din yung sa atin sa Ayungin Shoal.

05:07.4

So, ang status ko as of 2002, we continue to repair, we continue to repair Sierra Madre, at saka we can continue to supply our troops there with water and food.

05:21.3

So, mali yung sinasabi nila na ang status ko.

05:26.4

In 2017, yung nagkaroon sila ng kasunduan verbal with the Presidency, ang status ko in 2017, tubig at pagkailang pinapadala natin sa Sierra Madre.

05:42.5

So, yun ang mali. Anong meaning yan? Pag hindi natin i-repair ang Sierra Madre, kukolaps yan at lulubog yan kasi kinakalawang na yung superstructure.

05:56.4

So, it requires continuous maintenance. Pag hindi natin yung repair, lulubog yan, mawawala tayo, we will lose our outpost, papasok ngayon ng China.

06:09.6

So, pag pumayag ka na hindi na natin i-repair, parang sinasabi mo na, oh, aalis na kami dito, kukunin na ninyo yung Ayungin Shoal.

06:20.4

Yun ang meaning. Pag hindi mo i-repair, parang binibigay mo na yung Ayungin Shoal.

06:26.4

Kasi hindi na tayo tatagal doon sa Sierra Madre.

06:29.8

Second, in 2017, nagkaroon na ng Arbitral Award. Ang Arbitral Award is July 2016.

06:41.3

So, yung pumayag si Duterte sa Gentleman's Agreement, alam niya na na yung Ayungin Shoal, na-declare na na atin yun, part of our EEZ.

06:53.3

Pag part of our EEZ, we have the sole right to put up a structure.

06:59.2

Tayo lang pwedeng tumayo ng struktura doon.

07:02.0

Tayo lang pwedeng mag-exploit, kumuha ng oil, gas, or fish.

07:09.6

Hindi pwede ang China magkaroon ng outpost doon.

07:15.9

Hindi pwede ang Chinese fishermen mangisda doon.

07:18.9

Hindi sila pwede kumuha ng langis doon.

07:21.7

Tayo lang.

07:23.3

Yung economic resources natin lang, at we have the sole right, ito ha,

07:27.4

sole right to put up a structure on Ayungin Shoal.

07:31.3

So, yun, gineam up ni Duterte yun.

07:34.8

Kasi pumayag siya na hindi tayo mag-repair ng, hindi tayo pwede mag-repair ng Sierra Madre.

07:44.1

So, wala tayo. Mawawala yung ating outpost doon.

07:48.1

Yun ang problema.

07:48.9

At saka sabi ni Duterte doon sa press conference niya,

07:53.3

hindi ko nga alam kung ano yung Ayungin Shoal na yan.

07:57.2

I do not know anything about Ayungin Shoal.

08:00.5

So, yung presidente entered into the gentleman's agreement,

08:05.4

pero wala siyang alam ng Ayungin Shoal.

08:07.3

Pero yung Ayungin Shoal is the very essence of the agreement.

08:12.1

Pwede ba tayo to continue there?

08:16.2

Pwede ba tayo, pwede ba natin i-repair yung Sierra Madre

08:19.6

para hindi tayo mapaalis?

08:23.3

Hindi tayo mawala ng outpost sa Ayungin Shoal?

08:27.9

So, for you to enter that gentleman's agreement,

08:31.4

pag pumayag ka doon, dapat alam mo ano yung Ayungin Shoal.

08:35.1

Sabi Duterte, wala akong alam sa Ayungin Shoal.

08:37.3

So, ano klaseng agreement ng pinasukan niya na wala siyang alam sa subject matter of the agreement?

08:45.2

Bakit importante yung Ayungin Shoal?

08:47.0

Kasi yung Ayungin Shoal, mga 20 nautical miles lang yan from Mischief Reef.

08:52.9

Ang Mischief Reef is the largest air and naval base of China.

08:58.1

Pinakamalaking air and naval base ng China sa Spratly.

09:02.6

E pag andyan tayo sa Ayungin Shoal, makikita natin, we can monitor the Chinese.

09:10.2

Kaya ayaw ng Chinese, ayaw nila yung presence natin sa Ayungin Shoal.

09:15.6

At saka yung Ayungin Shoal, that is the gateway.

09:18.7

That's the gateway to re-bank.

09:22.9

After Ayungin Shoal, everything is submerged already.

09:27.8

Mga reefs don't submerge at low or high tide.

09:31.3

Totally submerged.

09:32.1

Pero yung Ayungin Shoal, pag low tide, makikita mo pa yung mga rocks, no?

09:38.4

It is low tide.

09:39.8

Kasi pag low tide, makikita mo.

09:41.5

High tide, wala.

09:42.7

So, that is the ideal outpost to guard, to monitor re-bank.

09:47.2

Ano yung re-bank?

09:48.3

Re-bank is very rich in gas.

09:51.6

Two or three times.

09:52.9

Well, more gas reserves than Malampaya.

09:56.8

So, napaka-importante na we will be in control of Ayungin Shoal.

10:02.1

So, yun yun.

10:03.9

Pumasok ng kasanduan si Duterte sa Ayungin Shoal without knowing what Ayungin Shoal is.

10:10.0

Sabi niya, hindi ko nga alam yun.

10:11.9

Kaya ano klaseng presidente yun?

10:14.2

So, that is the situation.

10:17.5

Okay.

10:18.5

Sir, direjihin na po natin ang justice.

10:21.3

Unang-una,

10:21.8

itong handshake deal na ito,

10:24.1

na inami naman ni Pangulong Duterte,

10:26.3

was this valid?

10:27.4

And number two,

10:28.3

hindi po ba ito paguhudas o pagdatray door sa interest ng Pilipinas?

10:33.8

Well, definitely, dihado tayo, no?

10:36.5

Pag yung pumayag siya na hindi natin i-repair,

10:39.4

parang sinabi mo na na,

10:40.9

sa inyo na ito, mag-i-tay na lang kayong few more months,

10:44.3

lulubog na itong Sierra Madre.

10:46.1

So, aalis na kami dito.

10:48.5

Yan ang meaning yan.

10:51.2

So, talagang,

10:51.8

talagang, against national interest yan.

10:53.6

Pinamigay niya, in effect, ang ayung insyaol.

10:57.4

Okay.

10:58.1

Nabanggit niya po, Justice, yung 2002 Declaration on the Conduct of Parties

11:03.5

in the South China Sea, no?

11:05.3

So, ang ganda nung pagkakalatag niyo po nun.

11:07.8

Pero, alam po natin hindi po siya legally binding

11:10.4

and mismong China, vinylate po yan, no?

11:13.1

So,

11:14.5

should that still be part of the equation?

11:17.1

Eh lalo,

11:18.2

nanalo na naman tayo against China in 2016.

11:21.0

So, don't you think ang conversation dito,

11:23.6

hindi nga dapat pinag-uusapan dito yung handshake deal or what, eh?

11:26.9

Wala aking karapatan dyan in the first place.

11:29.0

I mean, that's really my opinion there.

11:31.9

Well, so far, the parties are more or less complying, no?

11:35.9

With the Declaration of Conduct.

11:38.0

Kasi makita mo, 2002 yan,

11:41.8

2012, China seized Scarborough Shoal.

11:47.8

Pero hanggang ngayon, hindi sila nagtatayo doon.

11:50.1

They just,

11:51.0

surround it with their

11:52.0

militant militia and

11:53.6

Coast Guard vessel.

11:56.3

Kasi,

11:56.9

they don't want to be seen by the world

11:59.1

na vina-violate nila yung

12:01.2

Declaration of Conduct.

12:03.0

Hanggang ngayon,

12:03.8

ini-invoke pa yun, eh.

12:05.2

So,

12:06.0

it is

12:06.6

a restraint

12:08.2

on China.

12:10.1

So, hindi rin tayo pwede

12:11.4

i-violate yan kasi

12:12.9

sabihin ng China,

12:15.3

o kayo nag-violate.

12:16.4

So,

12:17.2

free for all na ngayon,

12:18.5

mag-violate na lahat.

12:20.0

So,

12:21.0

but it tries to

12:22.4

follow the

12:25.2

Declaration of Conduct.

12:28.8

Kaya lang,

12:29.5

nakalagay doon sa Declaration of Conduct,

12:32.4

the parties shall

12:33.8

resolve the dispute

12:35.4

in accordance with

12:37.1

UNCLOS.

12:38.6

Importante yun.

12:40.1

Okay, walang gagalaw,

12:41.9

restraint,

12:42.6

you cannot occupy

12:43.5

unoccupied features,

12:45.8

pero

12:46.0

you resolve your dispute

12:48.6

in accordance with the UNCLOS.

12:50.1

Ngayon,

12:51.0

we went to UNCLOS

12:52.5

in 2012.

12:54.5

2002 yun,

12:56.1

our

12:56.2

Declaration of Conduct,

12:58.7

2012.

12:59.4

Nanalo tayo.

13:01.0

No?

13:01.3

Sabi ng

13:02.0

tribunal,

13:05.7

yung ayung insyo,

13:06.6

low tide yan,

13:08.0

part of the EEZ.

13:09.9

So,

13:10.8

that dagdag yan sa ating

13:12.3

sa ating

13:14.2

legal right.

13:16.0

No?

13:16.9

Kasi,

13:18.4

when we go to UNCLOS,

13:19.7

that is actually

13:20.4

in accordance with the

13:21.4

Code of Conduct.

13:23.4

Kasi sabi ng

13:24.2

Code of Conduct,

13:25.3

you settle your,

13:26.3

the parties will settle

13:27.4

the disputes

13:28.1

in accordance with UNCLOS.

13:29.9

So, pagpupunta ko sa UNCLOS,

13:31.7

that is

13:32.3

complying with the

13:33.9

Declaration of Conduct.

13:36.6

So, we can cite both.

13:39.0

Both

13:39.4

documents,

13:41.1

no?

13:41.3

Both,

13:42.7

although

13:43.3

Declaration of Conduct

13:45.0

is just

13:45.7

persuasive,

13:47.3

we can still cite it

13:48.3

kasi everybody tries to

13:49.8

follow it eh.

13:52.0

Kasi,

13:52.7

pag

13:52.9

annihilate mo yan,

13:55.4

you will be,

13:58.1

you will lose

13:58.7

the moral high ground.

14:00.1

Even China tries to

14:01.5

keep it, no?

14:03.5

Kaya ako lang po nabanggit

14:04.9

yun, Justice,

14:05.8

kasi nga,

14:06.8

speaking of moral high ground,

14:08.4

I don't know kung merong

14:09.2

ganun ng China ngayon

14:10.2

dahil,

14:11.2

bukod sa pambubuli nila,

14:12.5

they militarize

14:13.8

the occupied features

14:15.0

dito sa South China Sea.

14:17.3

Kasama na po yung

14:17.9

pasok na pasok sa ating

14:18.9

exclusive economic zone.

14:19.8

So, wasn't that also,

14:22.3

yung, yung, yung

14:23.0

artificial island building nila,

14:25.7

weren't those activities

14:27.5

violative of the DOC?

14:29.6

Maski na hindi po siya

14:30.4

legally binding?

14:32.5

Well, yung DOC kasi,

14:34.9

ang pinagbawal,

14:37.1

you,

14:37.5

you occupy

14:38.8

unoccupied.

14:40.2

Ang sinasabi nila,

14:41.7

na-occupy na namin

14:43.0

yung Mississippi

14:43.6

1995 pa eh.

14:45.7

So,

14:46.9

yun, no?

14:47.4

Pwedeng may wiggle room

14:48.8

sila doon.

14:49.8

Ah,

14:51.2

but,

14:52.3

kasi nakalagay doon,

14:54.1

you settle your dispute

14:55.4

in accordance with

14:56.4

UNCLOS.

14:57.1

Again,

14:57.4

ang ginawa natin,

14:58.6

eh, natalo sila sa UNCLOS.

15:00.1

Sabi ng UNCLOS

15:01.1

Tribunal,

15:02.6

yung Mississippi,

15:03.6

hindi sa inyo yan.

15:04.7

Sa Pilipinas yan.

15:05.9

That's part of the EZ.

15:07.4

So, dapat,

15:08.3

doon sila,

15:09.2

dapat,

15:09.6

i-respeto nila yan.

15:11.2

Kasi kasama yan

15:11.9

sa Code of Conduct eh.

15:13.5

Na,

15:13.7

sa Declaration of Conduct.

15:15.1

Na,

15:16.1

you settle your dispute

15:17.4

in accordance with UNCLOS.

15:19.0

Kaya,

15:19.4

pumunta nga tayo doon.

15:20.8

So,

15:21.1

sabihin natin,

15:22.2

oh,

15:22.5

sabi ng Declaration of Conduct

15:24.0

settled it in accordance

15:25.2

with UNCLOS,

15:26.2

sinettle nga namin,

15:28.1

eh,

15:28.4

China,

15:28.9

you comply.

15:29.8

So,

15:30.0

dagdag yun,

15:31.0

no?

15:32.8

Yun, sir,

15:33.4

yung ano,

15:33.8

yung accountability naman.

15:35.1

Kasi isa rin po yan

15:35.8

sa mga binanggit ni

15:36.8

President Bombo Marcos.

15:39.1

So,

15:39.4

sabi niya,

15:39.9

if it's a bad decision,

15:41.3

you're accountable.

15:42.5

So,

15:42.8

ngayon,

15:43.0

nililino pa nila

15:43.8

from the Duterte administration

15:45.7

ano ba talaga yung

15:46.6

pinasok na agreement.

15:48.2

Pero,

15:48.4

in cases,

15:49.4

like this,

15:50.0

how do we hold

15:51.0

the previous administration,

15:53.2

in particular,

15:53.8

the former president,

15:54.9

accountable po?

15:56.4

Well,

15:57.4

ang tinu,

15:58.2

ang,

15:58.7

ano,

15:59.3

mga kaibigan ko na lawyers din,

16:02.1

pinakita nila

16:03.5

na there is actually

16:04.3

a provision

16:04.9

in the anti-craft law.

16:06.7

Nakalagay doon,

16:08.4

a government official

16:10.2

who causes

16:11.8

injury,

16:15.1

and due injury

16:17.9

to the government.

16:19.4

Causing undue injury

16:21.3

to the government

16:22.0

through manifest partiality

16:24.5

or gross inexcusable negligence

16:26.9

is liable.

16:29.0

At saka,

16:29.4

ang penalty dyan

16:30.2

is 6 years to 10 years,

16:31.6

no?

16:32.4

Imprisonment.

16:33.6

At saka,

16:34.0

20 years

16:34.7

and prescriptive period.

16:36.3

So,

16:37.1

papasok yan.

16:37.8

Kasi yung

16:38.3

gentleman's agreement

16:39.7

talaga will cause

16:40.8

injury to the government.

16:42.3

Kasi,

16:43.1

pinabigay mo yung

16:43.9

ayung insyo ulit.

16:44.8

At saka,

16:46.3

we have the right

16:47.2

to bring

16:48.6

repair materials.

16:51.2

You agreed na hindi tayo

16:52.5

magdala ng

16:53.4

repair materials.

16:54.8

So,

16:55.3

that is

16:55.8

causing undue injury

16:59.3

to the government.

17:00.4

Mawawala sa atin

17:01.5

yung insyo ulit.

17:03.2

So,

17:03.9

pwede pumasok yan dyan.

17:06.5

Okay.

17:07.3

Yung ano po, sir?

17:08.3

Yung

17:08.7

tao dito.

17:10.2

So, may mga pwedeng gawin

17:11.5

to hold the

17:12.3

former president

17:13.1

accountable

17:13.7

pagdating dito.

17:14.9

Pero yung

17:15.6

handshake agreement na yan,

17:17.7

hindi ba

17:18.1

effectively na

17:19.1

rescind na yan

17:19.7

nung sinabi ni

17:20.5

President Marcos

17:21.4

na kung meron man

17:22.6

pinasok yung

17:23.1

previous administration

17:24.1

sa agreement,

17:25.2

I rescind it.

17:26.7

Was that enough, po?

17:28.9

Yeah.

17:29.5

Ang position natin,

17:31.1

kasi yung

17:31.5

secret agreement na yan

17:33.7

was not revealed

17:34.5

to the public.

17:35.3

Walang nakaalam yan eh.

17:36.9

Kahit na si

17:37.8

President Marcos Jr.,

17:39.5

nalaman nyo na lang

17:40.5

yung lumabas yan.

17:41.3

Ako, nalaman ko na lang

17:42.3

yung lumabas yan.

17:44.0

So, wala sa atin

17:45.0

nakaalam na

17:46.4

meron palang

17:47.2

agreement

17:48.1

na ganyan.

17:49.4

Now, if it is not

17:50.6

disclosed,

17:51.4

it's not announced,

17:52.5

it will not bind.

17:54.8

The government,

17:56.3

at saka,

17:57.1

parang agreement lang

17:58.5

between two heads of state

17:60.0

na it will not survive

18:01.7

their term.

18:03.1

Pag natapos na yung

18:04.0

term nila,

18:04.7

hindi na pwedeng

18:05.6

that will bind

18:07.2

the next president

18:08.3

kasi hindi naman

18:09.3

hindi nyo naman

18:10.2

alam yan eh.

18:11.2

Wala naman

18:11.6

nakaalam yan eh.

18:13.0

So, that is our

18:14.1

position.

18:14.8

It was

18:15.3

hidden from

18:17.4

the public,

18:19.1

sila lang

18:19.9

nakaalam,

18:20.7

so it cannot

18:21.4

bind the public,

18:22.4

no?

18:23.1

So, yun ang

18:24.5

position natin.

18:26.1

It will not

18:26.6

bind the

18:27.6

next president.

18:29.8

Tsaka,

18:31.0

sinabi rin

18:31.5

ng next president,

18:32.4

I refuse to be

18:33.3

bound by that.

18:33.9

I rescind that

18:34.6

kung adyan pa yan.

18:36.0

So, that's

18:36.8

the correct way.

18:38.7

And,

18:39.2

ano,

18:39.5

Justice,

18:39.9

how do we

18:40.3

move forward

18:41.0

from this?

18:41.6

Kasi nga,

18:43.4

in China,

18:44.0

pinalutang yung

18:44.6

secret agreement

18:45.4

na yan for a reason,

18:46.3

no?

18:47.0

Nilik nila yan

18:47.7

siguro sa media.

18:49.0

Obviously,

18:49.4

nilik nila.

18:50.3

So, meron silang

18:51.0

target dyan.

18:52.0

And I think

18:52.4

this is part of

18:53.2

their influence

18:54.4

operations.

18:55.3

In the meantime,

18:56.1

habang nang bubuli

18:56.9

sila,

18:57.8

yung mga leader

18:58.3

natin dito sa Manila,

18:59.6

nag-aaway-away.

19:01.0

Nagde-debate tayo.

19:02.5

Ano ba yung laman

19:03.0

ng secret agreement

19:03.8

na yan?

19:04.3

I mean,

19:04.8

how do we move

19:05.5

forward from this?

19:06.4

Hindi ba parang

19:06.9

naiisahan tayo lalo

19:08.1

na napakiyotik

19:09.6

ng domestic

19:10.2

issues natin

19:12.3

dito when it comes

19:13.1

to that agreement?

19:13.9

Nag-aaway yung

19:14.7

dating pangulo

19:15.4

at saka yung

19:15.8

kasalukoy ang pangulo.

19:17.7

In the meantime,

19:17.9

China is still doing

19:19.1

its own thing

19:20.0

dito sa ating

19:21.0

sariling bakuran po.

19:23.4

Well,

19:24.4

tama ka dyan

19:25.9

kasi this is

19:27.3

distracting us

19:28.2

but we have to

19:28.8

face this

19:29.3

kasi alam mo,

19:30.7

sabi niya Duterte,

19:32.6

personal agreement

19:33.5

lang yan namin

19:34.1

ni President Xi.

19:34.9

Pero yung China,

19:36.3

nagsalita sila,

19:37.2

yung foreign ministry

19:38.3

ng China,

19:39.0

nagsalita na

19:40.0

this is

19:40.9

a state-to-state

19:42.3

agreement.

19:43.4

This is an agreement

19:44.3

not between Xi

19:45.3

and Duterte

19:46.0

but between China

19:47.2

and the Philippines.

19:48.1

So, iba yung kanilang

19:49.4

narrative ha.

19:50.9

They want to bind

19:52.0

the Philippines.

19:53.1

So, magkakaroon tayo

19:54.8

ng away dito sa China

19:57.4

whether the agreement

19:58.5

binds the Philippines

19:59.7

or not.

20:00.5

Kasi ang posisyon nila,

20:02.0

binding on the Philippines.

20:03.9

So, we have to face

20:04.7

that problem.

20:06.7

Kasi,

20:07.6

they will tell the world.

20:09.5

Eh, may agreement kami

20:10.4

with the Philippines

20:11.2

na dapat hindi nila

20:12.6

dalayin yung

20:13.1

construction material eh.

20:14.7

We have to explain

20:15.7

to the world that

20:16.5

this is a

20:17.2

is not binding

20:18.2

on the Philippines.

20:19.6

Kasi, it was a secret

20:20.6

agreement between

20:21.6

Duterte and Xi.

20:22.9

Walang nakaalam.

20:23.8

So, we have to face

20:24.7

this.

20:25.9

And we have to

20:26.8

explain why

20:28.1

is not binding

20:29.0

on us.

20:29.9

That was not

20:30.9

declared.

20:31.4

It's not an announcement

20:32.4

to the country

20:33.7

or to the world.

20:35.2

So, it cannot

20:36.2

bind the world.

20:37.3

Walang announcement eh.

20:38.4

Cannot bind

20:39.0

the Filipino people.

20:40.3

Walang announcement eh.

20:42.3

So, we cannot

20:43.4

escape this

20:45.2

because

20:45.5

nakikita ko na

20:47.2

ang posisyon

20:47.7

ng China

20:48.2

ididihin nila ito eh.

20:50.9

Na may agreement

20:52.2

kinonfirm

20:54.1

nun ni Duterte

20:54.9

na mayroon silang

20:56.2

gentleman's agreement.

20:59.3

Ang next step nila

21:00.2

sasabihin nila

21:00.9

that is

21:01.4

agreement between

21:03.0

the state of

21:04.1

China and the state

21:05.2

of the Philippines.

21:06.5

Yun ang next step nila.

21:07.9

Sinabi na nila yan

21:08.8

sa kanilang

21:09.8

press release eh.

21:11.0

This is

21:11.4

the agreement

21:12.9

between China

21:13.8

and the Philippines.

21:16.1

Oo eh.

21:16.8

Parang napaka-active po

21:18.1

kasi ng kanilang narrative

21:19.3

yung kanilang

21:19.9

influence operations

21:21.1

na alam naman nilang mali

21:22.5

pero

21:22.8

ipapakalat nila

21:24.3

at dun magsisimula

21:26.0

yung starting point

21:26.7

ng mga discussion.

21:27.8

Pero

21:27.9

papano po ba natin

21:29.5

itong maganda

21:30.0

i-counter?

21:30.8

Kasi nga unang-una

21:31.5

nanalo na tayo

21:33.1

sa arbitral

21:33.8

ruling

21:35.2

2016 pa lang.

21:37.2

So, sa atin

21:37.7

malinaw yung

21:38.3

ayung insyol

21:39.1

sa low tide elevation.

21:40.9

So,

21:41.6

how do we move

21:43.0

from here po?

21:44.5

Well,

21:45.0

we would continue

21:45.8

to supply

21:46.7

share of matter

21:49.0

with construction materials

21:50.5

kasi we cannot

21:51.4

we cannot say na

21:54.1

hindi na natin

21:55.1

i-supply

21:55.6

kasi that means

21:56.8

sang-ayo na tayo

21:57.7

dun sa narrative

21:58.5

ng China.

21:59.4

We must continue.

22:01.5

At saka

22:01.9

22:04.0

we must think of

22:07.2

putting up

22:07.9

another structure

22:09.2

kasi yung

22:10.9

share of matter talaga

22:12.0

lulubog yan eh.

22:14.1

We can only

22:15.2

repair it up to

22:16.1

a certain extent eh.

22:17.5

So, mag-isip na tayo

22:18.8

anong itatayo natin doon

22:20.8

because as the

22:21.6

as part of the

22:23.1

EEZ of the Philippines

22:24.5

exclusive right natin

22:26.0

na magtayo ng

22:26.8

struktura doon.

22:28.3

So, ang suggestion ko

22:29.3

we put up a lighthouse

22:30.7

a marine research center

22:32.5

at saka substation

22:33.8

ng Coast Guard

22:34.6

para meron tayong

22:36.0

Coast Guard vessel doon.

22:38.3

Pag inatake yun

22:39.2

we can invoke

22:40.7

the mutual defense treaty

22:42.3

with the US.

22:43.2

So, we maintain it

22:44.9

as a

22:46.1

Coast Guard

22:47.0

substation.

22:49.9

Lastly, Justice,

22:51.4

dito sa ginagawa

22:52.6

lagi ang pambubuli

22:53.6

ng China

22:55.1

dito sa ating

22:55.7

resupply missions.

22:57.0

Legally,

22:57.7

ano pa ba yung pwede

22:58.5

nating ruta?

23:01.0

Ano pa ba yung mga

23:01.6

pwede nating puntahan po

23:03.0

na korte for instance

23:04.8

dito sa ginagawa

23:06.2

ng China

23:06.7

na pagganong

23:07.6

yung pangahara

23:08.7

sa ating mga

23:09.3

resupply missions po?

23:11.8

Well,

23:13.0

pag

23:14.1

mag-pagtatayag

23:16.1

tayo ng

23:16.7

civilian structure

23:18.1

like lighthouse,

23:19.2

marine research center

23:20.2

23:20.5

substation ng

23:22.1

Coast Guard

23:22.8

tapos hintuin tayo

23:25.0

ng China

23:25.6

in constructing

23:26.8

those structures

23:27.7

those civilian structures

23:29.3

we can go to

23:30.3

the tribunal

23:31.1

kasi

23:32.1

ngayon

23:33.1

hindi tayo

23:33.6

we cannot go to

23:34.3

the tribunal

23:34.9

kasi it's a

23:35.6

military activity

23:36.6

resupplying

23:38.5

BRT Sierra Madre

23:40.3

is a military activity

23:41.7

kasi naval vessel

23:42.7

yung BRT Sierra Madre

23:44.1

is a military vessel

23:45.5

so,

23:46.1

and

23:46.2

UNCLOS has no jurisdiction

23:48.7

over

23:49.8

military activities

23:52.3

because China

23:53.1

23:54.0

2006

23:57.1

opted out

23:59.6

24:00.2

arbitration

24:01.2

when it involves

24:02.4

military activities

24:03.7

that is allowed

24:04.7

under UNCLOS

24:06.1

so,

24:06.6

we have to find a way

24:07.8

to convert the activity

24:09.1

to a civilian

24:10.1

activity

24:11.2

Like paano po?

24:14.5

Magtayo tayo ng

24:15.6

lighthouse

24:17.0

to be manned by the

24:18.2

Coast Guard

24:19.1

magtayo tayo ng

24:20.1

Marine Research Center

24:21.8

to be operated by

24:23.4

the UP Marine Science Institute

24:25.5

tsaka may substation

24:27.4

ng Coast Guard doon

24:28.3

we can

24:28.8

park there

24:30.0

station there

24:31.1

two small Coast Guard vessels

24:32.7

so that if that will be

24:34.2

attacked

24:34.9

it's still an armed attack

24:36.5

on a public vessel

24:37.6

of the Philippines

24:38.3

covered by the

24:39.9

Mutual Defense Treaty

24:41.7

Nagustuhan nyo ba

24:45.2

ang ganitong pagtalakay?

24:47.1

Mag-follow sa

24:48.0

Informador FB page

24:49.3

at mag-subscribe

24:50.2

sa Informador YouTube channel

24:51.7

Ang Informador

24:53.2

ay nilikha ng mga staff

24:54.5

ni Atty. Ricky Tomotorgo

24:55.8

aka Insurecto

24:57.6

upang lalong lumawak

24:59.0

ang inaabot ng

24:59.8

pagpapalaganap ng katotohanan

25:01.3

at labanan ang fake news

Show More Subtitles »

Exit Full
Screen

Become a patron
We love our supporters! :)

© copyright 2024. Do not copy or reproduce content or audio without prior written authorization. Scraping and republishing our data is a copyright violation. We put a lot of hard work and TLC into this website -- please don't copy or publish our content without permission. Terms & Community Agreement